Appeals on Contractual Liability, Indemnity, and Warranty Claims (2550-2553)
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court reviewed several appeals concerning liability for damages arising from various transactions and events occurring between 2550 and 2553, often involving indemnity and warranty claims based on prior agreements and assignments. The court reasoned by examining the specific contractual terms, statutory provisions, and factual findings from lower proceedings, ultimately concluding whether the appellant or appellee was responsible for the resulting losses; key determinations included assessing the scope of indemnification obligations, the validity of warranties related to asset transfers, and whether certain claims were time-barred or properly assigned according to the applicable legal framework and evidence presented in the record.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Appeals on Contractual Liability, Indemnity, and Warranty Claims (2550-2553): The court reasoned by examining the specific contractual terms, statutory provisions, and factual findings from lower proceedings, ultimately concluding whether the appellant or appellee was responsible for the resulting losses; key determinations included assessing the scope of indemnification obligations, the validity of warranties related to asset transfers, and whether certain claims were time-barred or properly assigned according to the applicable legal framework and evidence presented in the record.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in order 1 for the allocation of court costs.
Cited in order 2 regarding the granting of legal aid.
Testo completo
$%&&'$%(() $'()$%((*
+, -.,! !! + ,! -
/0 & 1( 23 %((*
!!!"# $%&' % %& "&! !!("&)&% * *%!
&%
++ ( ,, - ! % !&!" . /0
!! " #
-2142-
! -
46 ( %!7!8! !!!&%%!'",!4/9: ;&%'!"%!%!&%$%!7&! < %&&& =$"!!&%8"!&!= %$%"&&(>% ?%!&!= $ %!%49(355<%6"&"!!"'<<&:5$&>% 25546
26 %$$ %& @ A!& 2554 % "! -8!%%7! 8&$ &, &&&"#(&&&! (%%$%&7!($ .% !$!&" &%'! & & (!&"%" %! ( .% B! - "$%!< %"&! & >7! % &% > &&!= '%&">%#$% >C&%'! >>!7&%76
:6 %$$ %&45$&>%2554%$"!!&"! !&%#(%%$%&7!($ .%!&%'"=(%">! $!% 8%C& $.8 7!= &%$%! =! & $% ' =" B%>&! % !' >!% !'! %$!& ( "&& B! - "$%!<6 $ " # <<%!% ( $% >C & B! ! != & B "!& $ % = &" (-D !=&% &!= .&>""<!!"(!'!$.8 7!=6 % ( "%!& E !$!' & 7%!' # (% !& !$ .%6&!"$!& >A&!'&A&!<!"&&%!&& "=&6(!$!&"&%'!"&!&< "6
F6 (%"<!&( >A&(B$%&!$.8!&%!=&25<"'%!%2552$% %6% %& &&%$$ %&=(%"$%! && '&%$"!!"$%!8%7$&!&.&>! >>!7 =(<!>% .7!&! $&8!!$ %&&3-,4'!&"&"!7 &!=" $% % & =( "&" 8 $!&!" $& &% ! ! # !!= & $ % $$%% # '!'% ' <!>% .7!6 %& (&%&! ' (B$%& '!& G '% & & B # &% ! !& $$ %&& $ $ !&! ! '!& &&!& E " &%&!' =& # %A>%8!&!'&D&& &B$%!&' &8&!!&" "$ !% & &%!&6 $%"&!& $ &% > (&&&! &%&! " !%6, (B$%&
1233412550 -:142-
(B$%& !7 &!=" &% > "$%!< %"%%& "$! & "'C% .$&H$.8 &!=&.% %B & < %$%!&&6 $%!% &&"=("' &! !B%!% !"&!&> %&=(! A !& (B$%&!" # '!7% %$%! $% 7%!' &%'! # 23 & 35 I & & %'& = %"&& (&! A&! =( '!& &" # ( &% ! $ .% $ %%!& D&% ""& "8& % '% 7"%! ! =(! $ %%!& "7& %< %% $% !!&% != -A&6
36 %&!<!& "! F % 2552 % &&&" "&& "$%!<7%'&<!>% .7!= &"&"$% ' ="$%7%"&& &%J%<&!7J%'& !&! &%'!!<<!!6$&!& <<%!& & A % ( 7% "&& ("$!& 7""% ( <%7!!&" %' & < %& %$ .%&!!%6
@6 % %K 49 % 2552 (!&"%" %=! $%&&! (!'!!&"'( >&&! (%&6
06 %$$ %& 0 A! 2552 # (&&&! ( % <!%" !7 &! & !!=" (B # %$$ %& = (&!'!&" B%"A=( %("&!&$B!7!>!&%6
96 (%""&"!>""<!(%&&!C%(!'!!&"C4%'%!2552 $%"!! 43'%!255:6
/6 % ( $% "% %"'!! %& (!'!!&" % "! &%!&& &&&" 4/ ! 2553 = ("&& &" $&!&"&!&&&! !%=($%"&!&& A %"&&"$%!<$%!&&& <<%!& % & & %&!&! %& =( $ '!& $ %&%'!%6 $%!%<!&"&&(!&>!!&"("&&$8.!=&$.8!= =!$%&&!&$<!%$% A&('!%6
456 %$.8!&%&$.8 &8"%$&(%"&&&"2:A! 2553 = ("&& &" -! "&!& %&" &&! !% ' !% ("&!& 77%'" $& %!% ! !% $&!& & =(! (. '!& $ 87& !7 &! $.8!&%!=6 ('!& $& $ &" &% 4% & >% 255F & 40 A! 25536 , !!&&! !&!& '&%&!%8%8 &&$ &%&7!= ! %"$%!<&!" !% %&=%&!!&= $!&" &%'! "&!& & & &!'!&" %&!' & & %'& > %&%(B!!=&$!&B$%!"6
1233412550 -F142-
446 , (B$%&! % $.8!&% 20 % 2550 <<&" # 45<<! & (% (!'!!&" L!-$%C M N (%" <<%($&8 7!'%"$%! %$!&"&%'! &!7 &!&% >"$%!<%"%%&"$! &"7%.% &!= & .% %B & < % $%!&& ('!& $ %"$%! % $!&" &%'!6 (B$%& %'" (> ("'"& "'!& .& $ !&%<"%% $% % ! $ $% !&"&(""&<'%$%"(<%7!!&"$.8!=6( $ >A&!'" %&!& $.8 &% & &% > &%&! 6 (B$%&!" "&!& $!&!' & $ %&& 7!= L ">!& # $!% %$%! $!CN6 , "%&! (!&!&" % $ '!&'%!%(A %#(&%#&$ !&=(!!%%!'!&$$ ' !%<!% & !&&!D'%6&!&!&!'!&8 &'!-#-'!&% (&& $ = &% &%'! "&!& '% < &6 , (B$%& !!&! ("%7! "&!& & &< ! %<& !!&! >!!&" %"!&6 %"&! ("%7! ( %!7! $%& $.8!= '"%!<!!&$#(."% &= &!!L$%"$!%&!'!&" $& A %" & = & !&& . 7 B%! $8.!= >= $ & %E-' $% =%&!% &%'! !!&%&!< %$ $%! # (B&"%!% % &% != & % &!= . % &% (! &""'!! N6 (%" ! '!& B$!=" $%!% &$ =( &!&#D%$!&&(B%% !$% <! $!("&!& %'!"!&""$8 &B8%$%C(&%&!6%('!& $% !% $ 8!&" $% % % ("' &! ("&& &" $&!&6,%$&%!&&$.8!&%!=(B$%& !"%"=$!&" &%'! "&!& && & & & =(! (7!!& ( !&! %> (><&&! !7!<!&!'D!(%"'!&"%"= "&& $.8!= ("&!& $&H& 77%'"6 (B$%& &% &!" = (%" $%"&!& $ - %>!!&" $.8!&%!= !'!& &% > & < % %B6 >!!& $ $ $%& (!&"7%&! ! & $%"&!& $ (<<&! %$ % 8% != $ '& B$!=% ($% $!& (> &% > &" -%&!!% !7!<!&!< & >A&!<6 '!& & &< ! (&&% = &%!&& < % B %C7 (%& ("&!& &%" !<<!6 & # $%" ( "&& $.8!= %!&!" (B$%& %'" = ("'&! ( & "&& "$!& % ( B$%&!6 !% &! #$!&"&%'!& &(%" (!&!'!&"6&$%!%&! "&&B$%&!=(%"& >""<!(%&$%!'"9(555<%6&=(&&&"#%! 35(555 <%6
426 , ('!"!4:'%!2550,%'!"!%"7! ,! % L!-$%CM,N(B$%&!% "&>!&'%&!&= (%"$%"&&&&% >"$%!<%"%%&"$! &"7%
1233412550 -3142- .% &!= !! =( &% > & < % %B $%!&& %"$%! %$!&"&%'!6&("! %&! && &< ! !$ !>#$%"!%6 '!&(&&% !$!&"&%'!& & C2@%25506
4:6 49'%!2550( <!&$%&#(%" $% A&$$%!%%&6
4F6 % %%!%2F!2550(%"" %!>&&"!%! %& ' &!% 7&! &! & J(! &&" (% !&&! ! & <!!C% A=(# $%"& ! A ! " %! <!% < # $% >C !B = A (%%!' $ # 7"%% L$% A& $! %& 66 $% (<<! & ( 66 %&% $!& <&% "! !$." &NJ6 "7& !!=" = "&& &" ("&!& "7%" $!( $% A&$$%! %&6
436 %&,,%'!$.8!&%!&&% &8"%$! >%C' L N &! & %&!<!" 23 ! 2550 = (%" <<%!& ( ! $.8!= =! ($D8!& 7"%% <<!% ! & <!!C%& & %'&$!&"!%&6
4@6 %"!! DA %( $$%!"% !&#%&(!'!!&"&!C% C $%!% A % B!C ! =! !& &!<!&! "!! & %&!%"(<<&$!<#"'&% % &%&&"!! 6
406 % %& <!& ( >A& ( !&%& !' &!% "$%&& $.8!&%!*H$!&B!'%!&!%C'L*N&2@!25506
496 , %$$ %&2@A!2550"$%&&(%""&"8 $!&!" %! ( > "!&B # '!" !!!%6 '!& 7&" $! ">& ! ! 2550 &! >E !E"$! & &%!&& &7!= # $ !& ; &&!& 7%'& 7%6 45 !2550("&!&<%&%"$ !7&% !&$% >>&8&!&# &! >!' "!&6 ('!& 7%" '!% &!&6B!$&%"&!&%&% '"8E$%! !<<!!&%"'!>& !&B%7*6$! %%!'"# (8H$!& B!"&" !' "&!& >%'" = $D8!& $&!& < &! %6 "&!& %$!" % -D $!& A% $%&! &$ 8"8>%&$!7!&&!$ %6$%!!&$ $ "'!& = $% >C $%!!$ "&!& &% > B!B =! $!=!&(.$& & 7!"$%!'&7&!& %6
4/6 % & 29 A! 2550 (%" %$%"&" $% ! % %& &% "!! 23!2550( &$%">&#%&!&&! (<<& $!< & $%!!$& # (&! "!! &&=" $%C (!&! !'%&" !6,(7!&%&!&&! (<<&$!<<!&
1233412550 -@142- ' !%=(&!$>&%'!%&=(77%'&! "&&&"& G&&&&"$% "!&! &$% !& %%!%2@ !2550%"!%&%*6C7"7&= $%!'&! %&(!'!!&"&C %$%&!$>&&! %' ! %!& && 7 !$% $ %&! " $% %$$ %& # (!&"%D&(!&!"#(!"!&&"(B"&! 6
256 "&%!&! 4@ A!& 2550 (!&!" & %A& % %6 %&(<<&$!<!<!&' !%=8C% % $%!&$"'!&#$%!C%'"!! "&&< "%(B$%&! % =(!&!"=!<!$%&!!C%&< !"&%7&"6 " $&! &!&<!& '=!>$&H&D&%%"&! & $%&$ !<!%($$%"!&! $!&"&%'!6 !&! (!&"%D& (!!&%&! # (B"&! !"!& "!! !& ($ %&% %!(%"#$%' !%%&%&$% "%6
246 % %%D& !!& 23 A!& 2550 %!> " "% % % %'>%"&>!&(<<&$!<& (!&!"$!&#% %& (!!&"355<%6#&!&%"$6% %(!&!" &%&%%D& &"%"!%%'>$%%%D& %!><""%2: & >%25506
226 , ('! "! 20 G& 2550 , (77%'&! ("&& &" "7"$%% %& &!&"'"& '=!(!<!%%! ! (B$%&! % C % = && "&"%! %&! $ %%!& D&% %"&! # "!! $$%! %&6 " ! %'! & =(! B!& !$!&" &%'! & & $! 2@ ! 2550 $ % %" % !"&%!"6 $& ("&& &" % %& ("&&'!!>&$&>!!"!&$%"&%"$% %%$!&" &%'!#&%6
2:6 ,%>&'!"!(!&!" &%A&% %6
2F6 %"%!&%40 & >%2550 !% %&!< % %!> " = && %!C% <!& ( >A& ( !&%& ' &!% # !!= $.8!&%!=* $!2:$&>% 25506 $% !& $! %%!% = ! & %" % O & % & 43 & >% 25506 "! . !!=& = ">& (8 $!&!&! !7 &!("$! "$%!<"'C%.$&H$.8 &!="&"$ "6% !&% %&$%"&""&&!B&' &(""%&! $"! 8"%! %&"&&(B&%D!%%!&>!!&"=!<# $&!&<%&%&! $'&"8%%!(& -&(8"&"% -7%!'!&"6 "$! &%& ' & "$%! !$ %&&6 $&!& "&" $" !! 8.$ &!& & <%"6 >""<!! ( &%!&& "!&B ' % $&!= &8. %"7&% 8.$ &!=
1233412550 -0142- B! .&!= & &7!=6 "! %&!& A %(8! &% > <<&!<>!$ !%"$! &!B&6%&!<!&$%!%!$!&" &%'!& &6
236 %"%!&%9 '>%2550(!&!"$%!& ! 6%C' =(!<&&&%=% %&$%"&&&& &!$!&" &%'! %& $ ! (B$%&! % 6
2@6 4: '>% 2550 % %& $% (!&%"!!% &!% &%& %!>"( % %!>&&"!%4% '>% 2550$%=!-!$% %&' &!%6
206 % %%!%4@ '>%2550 !% %&C7 && =%"'!! ! !"%"%&-! "=7%'=! %!&$D&%&%7!=6
296 ,%"&"7%"#A7%6
! +-
46 ( >A& !&!7 & =&! ' !% ! ("&& &" % %& (& "! %"$ !&!$%&&%% '%%$!&"&%'!&A&!<!& !! $$%! %& (!'!!&" =! ! "&" %" C 4% '%! 25526
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
1233412550 -9142- !<!&! B $%!!$ A%!$%&! "' $$" %"7! (! %&6 F4 '!7% A=(:4">%2552L +4:5:F: !6:63P ' !% ! %&6 90 & 99 %C7& % (%-!'!!&" 40 A'!% 4/@4- N6
B&%(%&69964%C7&%(%-!'!!&"40A'!% 4/@4L N("! %&! ("&&&"(%"87& $$%!& & $%&!%&=! $&(&&%#=("! %&! &&" !&! %& E 7 $"%! 6 ' D ! 87&"A#%"&% ! !!&%%$&! &>$ %&&=( $!&! $% 8! !&#%!%6
'%&(%&699>!62&6 !!&! $$%! %& $% <<& $ &H& 4% A % B!C ! =! !& &!<!&! "!! 6
:6 &%"$&"!'!!&"(!$!&"7!& & $%&!$%""$%& 7 %" %"&& ( !<!%!&" 7"!& ( ! ( !& L%&6 9 6 4 & F 6 4 N6 & %"$&" !$!&" 7! & & !!&! (> ($%&!$ !>!!&"7!(%"% %8" &%'! "=!!>%" =! &% !"%&! ! && !!&! %"& (&&!&#&"$8.!= &&=($%!&$%C&%!&& &%%"$&&! B!7!>L%&60 N6
< %"& # Q%&6 29 6 4 &% '!7% C 4% A'!% 255F Q%" % !& # %& &!C% Q! & !'! # 05 I ! # &% !-=%& %& (! & !'! # @5 I ! # ! %& Q! & !'!#35I ! #=%&%&Q!&!'!#F5I !6
F6 &&!&#&"$.8!=$'& &&!&$8.!=&%)% !'!!&" (%&6 F 6 4 !! ' (%&6 9 6 !C% $ "= ( "&& $.8!= !< $ <<&! # $%% 8%7 $% (%-!'!!&" !!&! $!&"7!=(%"$ %%!&$D8%<!&$%' > ' &"P % =! & B!7!> !& D&% "&%!" ! >A&!'& = $ !> L + 452 4@3P , 2554 $6 22F !6 2> & %"<"%P<6! +4202/9 !6F!<!N6
% !(B!&&% > & < % %B$%!&& $$ (> % $%" ( !7 &! "& ( B$%& L$.8!&%N & ($$.& 7 %&! % %!&C% ( .&C !<!&! % L + 4:5:/96 !636:& !6@N6 $ %& &&%&&!&# &"$.8!=!7 &!&% > & < % %B$%!&& &!& $ % > <<!& $ % % # !'!!&"6 &%!%!B!&$%" $&! =&% > & < % %B
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
36 % $ ' !% % 7%" (!'!!&" A7 > ! & = "!"'&&!(&%$"!!& !'&!< %!%6&S8 "! !&#$ %&%A7&%("&&&"&#!!=%= % & $ % = &!'!&" (%" & !$> &%'!%6 &% " "! &!&& ""& &! $ % "&%!% = &%'B $& %%! >&B!7%(%"L +4232@4 !6F443 4:F !6244F:4F !6:453439 !64N6
$&&!<<!&"&!C%$%'#"&>!%(B!& % !$ $!& >A&!' (%" <<!& $ $ % A&!<!% !'!!&"L&!C% $%&!N6%(B% !&B$%&&! (% ! ("7&! % !& D&% <!%" $% >%'&! "! &#"<& = !$$%"!&! % !& B$%&&! $& D&%%"!C% < % #("7!&"&%!&& %"&D&%%$ %&"#!7 &!$ "%(!<!&! % L +4:5:3: !626262P + :5 '>%255F@5515: !6:62N6
( >!7&! $ %(%"!!% 7&$%!!$7""%% !& % !L +42/F@: !6F6242:2:: !6:440 209 !62>F55&%%D&!&"N6 A7 $&$< %!$&
1233412550 -45142- %&%'!=(%"< %! (&!!-D$>< %!%$! ">& !$!&" &%'! ! $ % "'!&% = % %& !& &&" (!<%# $% <!&7%" !'!!&"L +45@9@ !62$690N6
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
,%&&%$%!!$!>%$$%"!&! $%' %!> <""%%$ "!7!%&%!=! %!C% ($$%"!% %&! &.$ (B$%&! %$$ %& "!B6 !! %=( & $% "% !!&%&!' B$%&! <!" # "! !"$& & "&>! $% $"!!& % % > ( >%'&! $$% < ! & (!'&!7&! $C& !! =( $! ! !% & = (B$%& > &!& # %"&& '!& A7 %!& "%&%! 7&$=(!! %&$%& &%%>!- < "L +423:34 !6:>1N6
06 ($C (!&!" (& < " % (B$%&! % $ % &&% "! %&! ("&&&"6, &B$%&% %&$%"&!&$ =( &% > "$%!< %"%%& "$! "7% & .% %B & < %$%!&& &(B$%&!6A7"=.$& & 7! "$%!'!!!&$$!&"&%'!6 & !7 &!! %$!!& $ !&! A%!$%&! $ % ! % )&% %&C% !'!&6
'!&& &< !(&&%=!7 &!&% >"$%!<%"%%&L+:: !<!&! !&%&! ! -45N !$!= $%" $" ( ! "$! "$%!< "7% . "'C% .& $%!&" !B!&"$%"("$! &$%$"%! (
1233412550 -44142- ! B ! $%&%>&! !7!<!&!' (8% L -45 $7 0/N6 !! % % )& = % %& $%"& "&& &" $.8!=<&&$ &!7 &!&% >"$%!<%"%%&6 !&! ! $%)& "!& (&&% &>!!&! ("&& $.8!= & (B% $!&! $% 8!&=$%%!&(%&69964 6
& & "&& "'"& C "!! $$%! %& &%!&($$%"!&! (B$%& =(%"$%"&%>& $!&"&%'!& &&=(!(.$<&&! !7!<!&!'6<<& $! ! ! 2550 ("&& $.8!= % %& & 7%'& " $" "!&& 8 $!&!&! !&" <%" # (8H$!& $.8!&%!=6
%&& ! $& =(D&% &&" = "$!& ! &%!% % &&!& # &" $.8!= % %& & $ "! %" %&=$$%! %&&!A&!<!"6
96 %&'%!&& &"&&"7&D&% &% ."#% %& $$!&! (%&69962 =!(!$!&"7!(77%' 87& % )& "8"& % !& (%" B $%&&! C =(! %" &% ! ! !&%%$&! &>6 (%&6 2/>! & $$!> $% 7!6 B &% && !$ !&! ! %& "&" $$%!" <!& (>!& 7%" (!'!!&" & = (%" &% ! =! !'& $%"&# '7%"(!'!!&" '%&% !&#%&%! ( !$!&"&%'! D %!7!!&"!&$"%! (&&&=! !$ %!&(%&62/64 L"N=!$%"""$%!% &% !6
( %% ("&& &" % %& (& 77%'" $! $ &% ! !6 % "=& '%& !$ !&! "7 $%"!&" '%!& D&% ! # ' >""<! ( %& (!'!!&" &!C% $%= !&%%$&! C$$%! %&6
/6 '=!$%"C% %%!6
456 % %& >&&7!!!&"2(555<%6!& %"# &!&%"$6
446 (" &A&!<!B"#255<%6&!#8%7(!&!"6
1233412550 -42142-
- -.,! !! + ,! -
46 &% %6
26 "!! 23!2550(!&!"6
:6 (!&!" # '%% # % %& !!&" 2(555 <%6 # &!&% "$6
F6 &" &A&!255<%6#8%7(!&!"6
36 < % $%&! =Q $'& < %% % % &% $%"& %%D& "! :5 A % C &!<!&! $%C %!> <""% L,8T!E%8 <=!@@55F N$%' !% %&!C%% !& $>! < %"&B%&692 !<""%% %!><""%40 A! 2553 L +NP " !% % % !& !!=% ! &!< & .$%'&$ %&%!7&%% %& &!%P! !& D&% %" %!> <""% $% ' ! $ & $% ' ! "&% != B !&! (%&6 F2 +6 $%"& %%D& & $!C $ ! % %&!' =" .$%' !'&D&%A !&#(' !6 7%<<!C% %"!& !% * , .
$! < %$%"&%%D&& &!<!"B$%&!!!=Q#Q<<!<""% % !$%7%<<
1233412550