Royalty Contracts Supersession Dispute
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe dispute centered on whether certain pre-1934 contracts, which had been the subject of prior litigation concerning the payment of royalties based on production, were superseded by a 1934 agreement concerning the division of production proceeds; the court reasoned that the 1934 agreement expressly referred to and incorporated the existing contractual framework, including the royalty provisions, and was intended to operate alongside, rather than entirely replace, the earlier agreements concerning how proceeds were to be shared and accounted for.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Royalty Contracts Supersession Dispute: The dispute centered on whether certain pre-1934 contracts, which had been the subject of prior litigation concerning the payment of royalties based on production, were superseded by a 1934 agreement concerning the division of production proceeds; the court reasoned that the 1934 agreement expressly referred to and incorporated the existing contractual framework, including the royalty provisions, and was intended to operate alongside, rather than entirely replace, the earlier agreements concerning how proceeds were to be shared and accounted for.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe decision imposes costs on the appellant, citing this article.
Testo completo
%&'((%'))* +%(),)%'))*
+
+ "+ " "
"- ( $ , . '))*
! "
"
## $ ! % &'"! "'& " ( ) *+ , -.
! " #$
5 1/6 5
/+
27 $" " %- ( $88 " ( $'% 95 %- : 2 ;" 133* " (&5( &"& ." 8. ( "" (" 03 ; 13367
17 """ < $& $&"" % %&"& , "" . % 23 ;. 1334 , = >! $88 &? ( %'" 95%- : ! % (& ( 2 ; 1334! %& % ( (" , $('"& ( < ; % ($@ ;"8&7
$ % .& < $& ." (&;, 8" $@;" ( (& ( %! $)" % 88"& >> % ($'% & ." %" >A'?! $&"" % %&"& , & ($8'" B ( 2= C" 133*! $D! " )" "'% ' ( '>& ( ". 9 : % %"& ( ". " .'@ " (&'@ 133*!
""8 %( ( "8" '&(7 $ %% % < $& @&&8 ( "-' (&5( ($('"7
07 $& 8'& %%" 13 ; 1334! &?" < EF 8" >" ' < B ' (" (G5. , 2* > % (88&" "A " ; H >?& ($> 9= >:! ; ' 8"
%(7 ; ( (G5.! ; ' %&"& , 2* > %&! ' '$ "(" ( .7 $ &(?& %"" '" ($D <$ @ . ;( , ' >> ( ' ( (&'@E7
*7 (& ( 1I ;" 1334! % &'" ;"& $%%"7 88" (&& < D%" 8 % $& " "" D .@! (- <$ '@" ( " . %& (" "
$> ( (G5.7 ""& <$ 8D" (& ( % , < ;! " ''' %&. % @-' ( B % " '<'"! $ ." %"& %% ( %%""&7
47 $& ";"& 2* %"'@ 1334 " (" (& %%"7
67 &% ( 1= %"'@ 1334! % &'" ;"
( 7
I7 %" " &"& "( 2 .'@ 1334 % @ ( &7 $& (&& < ." % $"" ( 23 ;. 1334 ."
&"& ' % ' %% ($ %&&(" (G5.7 8'& < (" " $> ." &"& "'" (<&! ' &%&"& <$>@"& , J" .<& , 2* >! &"" . (G5. , ""
/0122/1334
5 0/6 5
>5,7 %& 8 . ""& (& ( % ". , ! < "8& ( (&8" ( >> % ($'%7
=7 0 .'@ 1334! $ "'! '' . ( $( ( '%" %! " ( (" ( "" <$." $& . %7 &"! <$." 23 ;. 1334! <" (G5.! " ." &"& 8D& , 2* > " , 23 >7
"" " &"& ''<& , $& % 8'" " &"& ?(& , ;?7
+
27 ?. K?" ;( 9: &"& '(8& " ""&!
(- 2 C" 1330! @ " ( ! '%& ( 4 ;?! (" %&(" " .5%&("! 4 %%&" " 26 ;? 9"7 2 "7 " 46 :7
B" , K" ( K&" ( 26 ;? ! % @ 8&(& 1I ;. 133* 9 # 203 236:! ( ?. (%"&! 20 8&.! (%" "" ?" %'""" @ " ( ( &? , " ;? ""! ! ( K""" ( K&" ( .D ;? 7
17 8'&'" , $"7 46 7 2 "7 >7 = ! @ " ( L" " < ( """ %&. , K"7 46 ( 8&(& ( 6 "@ 1333 %" ?&& ( (" ( 0 : < " ". , 8&(& K5 >A'? @?" " K('"& (K.@"& ( 14 ; 2+=1 9 :7
B '%&" % ;? ( (K%- " &"@7
07 ! ";"& "'% "! " .@ 9" 46 " 63 :7
*7 D "' ( $"7 2I ! K& < 8" . ( %"" (K ("! . K" ( K88 ( ". '%&""! "%( "" <K %" @'" D? ( % &." >A'? K@&?7 '@! %"! ( >> ( ".! @ (> ( %8 <K DF" %&&(''"7 (" %. %%" %. ( 88" <K 87
/0122/1334
5 */6 5
K& " " (K%" "" ". .@ < " %%&7 K@?"! < K""& '%&"" ;"! ( %"% M 7 D ' ". '>& ( ". %% , '& %""( %'"N @7 D "" ( ! D & (K8'" " D "" %&& .& , K7 4N 7 ( 8 ('" %'""" ( ;? K " %" %'" ". %%& " .@ # " ( "" < $& $" % %&"& , $"" 23 ;. 1334 , = >7
47 $"7 03 %&." < (" , $('"& " %( < $& K@. % %%" ( "A ( >A'? "" ( K""& '%&""! "''" 8 ". .@! %&" % , ' ( '>& ( ". K"'%" '"8 .@! '%'" '%J>! % '%"'"! (&'" ( ' &" ( @"7
% (&"' ($%- ?."& ( 8"! '%" " ( (" % ( $&7 '%" $ ( %( (&" "" " %% ($%-! "''" '@ " '%"'" "& ( $"&& 9B ! 327+1 >88 1*I:7
(& ( % < (" J" %%" , ?."& ( 8" "
( 2 , 24 ; ( 8" &?-! ( 26 , 03 ; ( 8" ( ?."& ') " ( 02 , 63 ; ( 8" ?. 9"7 03 7 0 " *4 7 1 "7 ! @! ( $( $5>A'? 5 :7
B &"@ @-' ( % < $& %&" % @ ( %&" D .@ , $"" ( " ( "A , ;& ($8'"! % %'- 8 % ( (" , $('"& ( 4 , = ; " %&N $ $?" ( ( 8 ( + , 24 ;7
"8! <$ & '< % "" ' <$ %. % '%"'" ?&& <$ %( @?" ( >A' " ( @&&8 ( %"" "- &D! $) % ( %( ( (" , $('"& % '%"'" (&<" 9 1333 %7 232:7
67 $%-! 8(" @-' " ". , $('"& ( >A'?! 1330/ 1I1! D "' ( < $& @ ( %&" , "" ( " ( "A " <$%- $ J" ( '%"! ""(
/0122/1334
5 4/6 5
"" '%'" ($J" .<& % $D " ;"8! '%"'"
'&" ($J" "&! $ %( (" ( $& %(" 4 ;7
I7 $& D%<& . 8( > " $J" ( (G5. , 2* > ( = >7
! %&"&! $) % ( %( (" , $('"& ( $& < ( , "" ( " ( "A ; ." (G5.! <$ -? ?&& 8" %. ( %""&7
) ( . < "! $& $" % %&"& , $"" , $> .! " ""8 . 'J' ;! " ''&("'" &(?& '" ($D! D%<" 8 <$ ." 8" " >7 @ ( & "" , " &?( < <" (G5.! " ." 88" &"& 8D& , 2* >7 ;"8 (- ($ " '%"7
" . %(" < '%"'" $" % &%>@N % (& ( % " &"& "8&7 D %&( " ( " %(" (." @ ( &7 ) &< % ($ %! ' ($ &( (& , (D ;7
/0122/1334
5 6/6 5
" +/ + "+ " "
$
0.1 2 3 45 (,' #6
1
27 & .@7
$ 1
17 ('" %"'" " &(" (& ( % , (D ;7
07 " < %&( " ?""7
*7 8' %" ( <K %." 8' " %&" J"
( (& ( 03 ; (- "8" % % ''(& (& @ 8&(& ( ! B>OG>8< 6! 633* ! " D'%7 (& %" J" %?&7 '&' (" M : (< D"'" < (& " (& @" " % ( (& ""<&N @: D% % < '"8 "' %. ('( "" " (&N : %" ?" ( %&""7 B '&' "" % " &&'" &'&& "" : @: " : 5(! @ 8&(& ( % % " '"- <K (. (& .@7 '&' ( '" ') ( %.! < " ;"! < (& ""<& " K.%% ( < &"& D%&(& " 9"7 201! 236 " 23= :7
?88- &(" M
5 P Q
% 8' ( %&" J" " "8& D %" " B&"" (K "" , K&' % ?88
/0122/1334