Property Owner Challenge to Waterway Regulation Statute
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA party challenged the constitutionality of a statute that imposes certain duties and liabilities on owners of property adjacent to a public waterway, arguing that the statute was an unconstitutional taking and an undue burden on commerce. The court reasoned that the statute served a legitimate public purpose of protecting water quality and navigation, and since the regulation did not deprive the property owners of all economically viable use of their land or impose a burden on commerce that was clearly excessive in relation to the purported public benefit, the statute was a valid exercise of the police power, not an unconstitutional taking or an impermissible burden on interstate commerce.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Property Owner Challenge to Waterway Regulation Statute: The court reasoned that the statute served a legitimate public purpose of protecting water quality and navigation, and since the regulation did not deprive the property owners of all economically viable use of their land or impose a burden on commerce that was clearly excessive in relation to the purported public benefit, the statute was a valid exercise of the police power, not an unconstitutional taking or an impermissible burden on interstate commerce.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive for ordering the respondent to pay the costs of the proceedings.
Testo completo
#$%&'#())$ #$)'#())%
*
+ ,!+ - + -,
). ())%
$/ 0 1
, ,-2,- 34 2 ,- 5 , -+6 7, 8 !"#$ %&%% %% '! 9999999999 () *(!(*+" ,"' (-(! '! .''&%/ ' (!(011111111112 %&&& 3 4) 5
! "
"&6%/"
2,
%; ' (!( 01111111111 2 (!( (( 2 <= ! ! - ! ' 4 5 % )(= %##8; !! ' (!( = ! *' >! ?' ' ! '!!. @*'! 'A !( != !'*' !*> ! B;C' 1111111111(! ! ! @ !( D' ("-(!E >(() D -! = 4); * < /& ' C5;
&; ' (!( (!( )) ( 2 !*') 'D )((! ' ' F ! *!', 4 C5 < % )(= %##8; 011111111112'(*'!(( <!' )) ! '2 C!G@D' D'H!%###;
/; I! @ ' (!( ' ( )) !( ) < * D(!(%##$E* @<*( '! ! G !2*!>%##$E '! ! 'D'!*(!(*F(( (-,!E*'! ' E'!H ) D'>G!*' !;
7; CD!='! !(*'* !*(2D'! ' (!(EDF!*'>! * !'! ! ' 6 6 !, ( @ '! ! ' (- '! ' ) A (' ! ' *( ( 2 ' (!( (! ! !( = 4); * <%92%$' C5;
8; %:&:::EC' 1111111111D!@ !!(D*! '! ! ' ((!) !)' D!!!! ' *F(! D(%###ED'J! !* !*(!%9&:::4);* < %#2&&E/%' C5;
6%7896&::% "/6%/"
9; G-!%/(>%###E*> (+ KG= &:::E > * < ! (*> @ ! !' <= *''( ) ! 01111111111 2 4); * < # ' C5; # )(= &:::E* ' @ ! '(!(*> (+ 4);* <%:' C5; ) E!/% &:::ED)) ) ! )'( C@ ) ! = ! (!( L!( * ()! D! ) ' G-! 7 = &::: 4); * <%%' C5;
K; C *' ! ( ) ! 01111111111 2 *' '!! KM87KE9: ); 4); * < 8 2 K ' C5; '!! '*' , '! ! ' * ! ! '! >! ' ! < D'! ' ) !( *F( *( ' )(= E = 2 'H! %### ! '*(! G= 2 (> %##$E F ) !! ) ! *' !E!,'! '! !(N!'!' '! ! '! N!(G'G-!) !;
$; ( ' %& G= &::%E C '! ) ( 2 C' 1111111111(*! ''-*''!!KM87KE9: );4);* <%' C5;
#; K )(= &::%E C' 1111111111 )'( '' ! ' 2 ( ' * D !( +" 4); * < / ' C5E '! ) @ ' (!( D= ! = '( * *! '' ! <!!! < !! ''* (- --=;
%:; ! & &::%E C @ =( D'' ! ' )'( * C' 1111111111E ' (! @D @ !( -(! >(() D -! = E *'> !( (! ! --( D! 8& ;' CEC' 1111111111= !DN! = - !'!* !'! ! '' E.!*! !@ ' (!(= ! )) !() <;
6%7896&::% "76%/"
%%; %$ = &::%E C' 1111111111 '!!( =' ' = '! ' !! ''(- --=D! 8& ! '2D => !(D! ' C;
%&; !) !'!* E!!@>' E*! ? ' !B*(!N!;
-,
: 1
'= ! *( @ ' )(( *! -(( ' ! ' 9 '!'> &::: 4 A $/:;%5 ! !( = - % G= &::/E !I! ' ) ! ' '> *' ! ' (-' D"= != =!;*(!! (' (- * *' ! ' = - G@D /% (> &::&E(-* *'@<- >'!= - '!'J) !G @!(! !'!*' !4 +%&879K ' ; %5; '!E G- ( (- !( ( ' !!@(E <- -((E D*< D(!! ) ! , !! '! 'J ( ' ! - (!( 4); +%&%/99' ;%>5;
6%7896&::% "86%/"
;
, ! D! $& ( % <-! D = != =!/%'!'>%#7KE!/%(>&::&4 5E ' ! (*! ' * ! '@ '*! ' ) !*=' *( '(*! '( D(2'*! '! 'J ' '- !E !'! E 2 D,* ! ' D ( @2'*!) !'->;
'! !2!!! *' ! 'E D- !D' D( *(*! '2' (D')) 4); +%%&$E' ;7A %#$9E*;7#/5;'@' !( =D!* >' *'*( 2 ( * *! ' * '- (E ( ! > 4! $& (& 5;
> )(( 4 + 5 *'( * * @D '*! ' ?' '-B *' ! ' *( !(E 2*! '!'J' !'I!E F*N!!D!!! '@D' !' !D!!D!!!'*!*! @E@ '! *!!! * '= '! ! 'E *' ! G! ) '> -! '(*'-4); +%%9K8E' ;/>A%%/%$%E' ; &A%%&$E' ;7A %#$/E*;%:$5;) !(! !!''!! @D DF ? '! ' * ! *') !E 2 ! >B 4); + O P ?.>! >- Q'R E , < ( ! ' *- %%&5E D'J (! *!( ;
) ! ' ''! * >' D! )E D * ( ! ' '- '! ! 'J *! '! !> ! >! ' ! ('*! ) (!> * D)) ) !' @ !E'2!2@S' !!()!> ; ))!E @ > ! *! ) ! ' *'(
6%7896&::% "96%/"
''! !=! !!! ''-! !(N!E-((E' *! @! >,E(G2)) !' '-E'! 'J ''! '( !'! ) (E'2 'JD(!! ''! '! D =! '!(!((*'(!*=!N!'!(; '!"2E( !E'= !N!-((E'I!D(!!! )E''! ' (! = *'>>4); +%%9%9%E' ;7A %##: *-7%8A %#$KE*;9:K5;
' G *E '- ! (*!( = '@ '! ! '*=!*N!*SE*''! )G @ ') ! 4); %#$/E *; 7KKA %#$$E *; %/K5; '@ '! ! ' ! *F( 'D '=> !(D*'F4*''5E'- ! (*!( = '! 'J ( '! ! ' '! ('=>E D!"2" '!'JE(-2D '=> !(D*'FE'! ! ' *=! * N! *S ' *'( ' ; 4); C .T U .'U = .-. !E='*;9#5;
D'=! ) ! *! *! *E 2 E =' (! ('=>; E'@ @ ! ') !(!( *)!D! )E'-!(*!(=2'!"24 +%:/ %&&E' ;7A %#K$E*;&9:5;D- !'!'JE <')) E ) !(!((( )!4); %#K/E*;K$E' ;&5; !(-E* *'!@D!)'@ '! !D''* ' @ ! ' ) !!!) 2 !!*'(; !( )) !@E*''S! !!EG-(!> !D>> 2 @ ! 2 ! >, ( !@D D !*!('! ! ' 4); + %:$8&E' ;8A %#$/E*;%:#5;
D*<E* ') !' (!((!(*> ( !#)(= &:::+ ; D!'2'!"2@ ' ) !@D @ !> '-;<'E*'! ' '! ) (2C' 1111111111%&G= &::%E*!(( D ')'(!2D! $&;% ;
6%7896&::% "K6%/"
() )'( '' ! ' /: G' 2 '*! '! ) ! '( '4! $%;& 5;
(*'!!!@N! =(&&::%E C- !*! E'!@D!=>2)'4! $% (/ 5;
E ' -=' D'- ! ' G && '=>%#7%4A &;:85(!(' ) (! >!' (!( ! !( < % 'H! &::/E !!! ! @E '!! '!!! ' ! = 2 ' )(( D"= ! = =! 4); ! %E!;!89=E;%E!;E. ))%5;
(!(' D')) *(! >E')'(!2 D! /E ; /E ' %7 '=> &::& ' ) ! ' D'- ! ' G 45E@ !<''*(!!*'G-D*<;
;
,!D! 8& 4!= -/%(> &::&5ED*'F' !'= '-@D (= '!* *! ' !! '!'*(- --=; @!! ! *' ! '*( 4 %#$#E*;%%K5;
D*<E '- ' ! *! ( '! ! '> * C) !' (!(011111111112*' '!! KM87KE9: );E *(!! '! ! ' * ! @ '! >! ' ! < D'! ' ) !( *F( *( ' )(= E= 2'H!%###!'*(! G= 2(>%##$EF'*
6%7896&::% "$6%/"
) !! )!*' !E!,'! ' @ !(N! '!' '! ! 'N!(G'G-!) !;
D! %7 ; % E '(! ' = ! /7 ! =! E * ! D'> -! ' *' D*'F ( .@ '! ! ' (!=" 2 '*! '=*'* '! ! '; *'F' =!='F , E*( ' @!E* < '*!> '! =( 2 (E < 2 @ '! ! '* ! * !N!(!) D'>G!( ';
> )(( )) ( ,*(! @ D'> -! '(-(*'-' !N!'@'J '- ! H 2 = '! ' !! ' ' * (- - -=E * D*'FE * *! ' (- ! D 4 %#K$E *; &8#A %#K&E *;9$K5; '*! '@ '!!@D> '-* ! ''>=! '* *! '*!!!@D*'F= '("
!! '!'' *(- --=E'J D, ! *D ) !' 2(- ! !(''*'!!'2D>D )!4 %#$/E*;%:%5;
'@D*'F!*''E'-(*'! ' !E2! !> E'-(* " E'!!@ *' ' D, ! * '! 'J *'> !( ! --( 4); . ))9::/ ! =D+ **! ''! ! '"A + %%7K#' ;/A %#$$E*;%/9' ;/ A %#$8E*;97#' ;&5;
?'-BE )!!!'!*'*.F @@ *(! *' ' 2 D,!( ' @ *! , ) ( = '*'!! " 4); . )) 9::7 5; '@D ! D ' (!( 'FE + D! !'G' ()(( 2 D! K87E * (E '(! ' = D! K8#E * ( ; ')'(! 2 ! E !'! *' .-( D !! 'E -! ' '!LE (*'!2D(-' (!(EN@D=.@! ' '(
6%7896&::% "#6%/"
' E '- @D @! !! '! ' * (- -2=' !*'@ (*'!DN'-'! !' !;'!(*!(.-(D !! '-! ' D! K89 ?'!'-( '( -(,*(! '!E (-!*'@ *!))! =!( ' =!'-E'@ !-! '*'*! !F! *! *(*'(! 2 )'! ' =''!( ' (!(B 4); + %:K /8/E' ;8A +%%&%#$85;
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
D'E ' D,! ! - ! 'E () (! ! ! @ !( D' ( -(!E >(() D -! = E* %)(= %##8!!!'!*( ''J'! ! ' D'! * (!( *F(; = ! =' * (! @ , D *
6%7896&::% "%:6%/"
' ( ! *'> !( *! ' N! --(; ! 2 , D, ! D(- --=*!* *! '(- !D E(!! E =' E@()D*- !! '!;
G *'!!E + '@D F= !(- - -= '@ D*'F ')' ! * 2 @ *'= ! N! '>!, -(!'!*'*> ! !! ' ! @!N '!4); %#K&E*;9#:5; @D'!' !D, -2!(-E' !'N!(=(D*<@D' *! ' ! !!E ! < '*!> !( ! -! 'E D *'FN!(-' @D !((;
*! =@D!!*F!'! ! 'ED*'F *= 2 ! ' !* = E * ,* ' D * ( ! !(' ' !! -! = )' ; '= ! *!E*'@D!'*'!!!'>*!( !''* D!; 8& E @ D' * !! @ D*'F = ! ' ( !'>G! =*@D *'= !2'!!='!* ! D@ !! !! ( '>E (= !! !! < @D '-' !(2 '*! 'E @D,!( ; ! '!E(- --= (END(. D !4); %#$8E*;9:&5;
D! !'!)' * D'E @D = DN! ('!( "';
() ) ! =' @D ' @! < ! ! %##$E ' (!(> E'*'*E> *'!!!!E! ! *'!!F!( (.-*!! = !.' '= -*> !(;<-=' ( !!(- !*' ! F!*!!*!>!! !<E!= * @! '! 'E*(!' E*(**'G!*'!! ' ! '; *( @))'! !!= '!* (((
6%7896&::% "%%6%/"
)!!! E=' ' E=!@' (!('!!(*! ( ';E'!= D*>'! E'!@D D*>; () =' ('))(2 C*') !' ! *(! =' !'G' )=' ( * ! .- ' ; ! (-E ) !=' D=' G ! (D-!'! ! '' *'*F D!)' ;
'!* <) -!' @E!(%##9! %##KE()*'F(E@G= 2= %##$E !!( (' (!(;'=*'(!(--(% %##$E (!( ( /% '!'> %##$; ! ' '!!> @D F > (! ' *'E @ D *(=! ()E ! )) ' (@D D- !2DD !!<)) D*<;
> <= @D ! %& (> %##KE () '( K:M9&9);*'D(%##$E@ '*' !2 ' E!@!'.(*=!; D!@D' %###E '@D*'F' @(2 CD!!!! ' *F(! D(%##$E@D !@D*!E = !-!('*'* 2 K$M8%#E9: ); ! @ D! *!E = ! =( /:M::: ); '= *'F(E ' ! =! ) ! ! %:$M8%#E9: );; !! ( ! ' '( *' D( %##$ ! D> ! ) ! )*!D*'F!*! '!!I('*(! '! ! '2.!8M8$/E/:);*) !!,!F! )47%%);5; F '!!@! (('! !D! ( C;
E'D)) () "NE )!E!* ' E =' ' *'('= !<;+'! (!,*( E' !*!' ! *'!!2'E () H! H N! * = - !E .! D,!N )) !( @D ! 2 '! ! '= !<; () *'= ! * @ 2 (! ! ' *! > DN! ( '>; ! !
6%7896&::% "%&6%/"
H!H*!L! *I!'!(!' ='(2D(.E'!@ <-! '! ! ' (( D ! * H N! ))((; ' ' -@D!) %###!@(*L!> (!((*'(E'@D '! !(G2 > @2(! !!!(;
'I!E >'!!@E!( !2D(%##$E C(- <!H(* <'*!>) D(!> '!! '! ! ' ; '! (-! ' C @E < D( %##9 (G2E '! ! ' D(!! * =( ( (-,E * ! D !(N!'!' !D(!(((!*'(*' !'! (!( !(; < *( ' ! ! G ! 2 *!> %##$E ! '! ! ' *F( '! H ) ' ! D'>G! *' !E (' ! ' *( !E ) !E D * ! *(; > <= * @ D! ! 2 ! (*L! !! * ! *' '!! ' '! ! 'E @ () D! ) ! @ !!( D *! '! ! ' ((E' !'!!8D%:/EK8);E'*'!*( (! 2*!*(;*I!<' )) D!!@()?!'G' )=' (* !.-' B;
E ' -@()E@ ' ! *) !! !! ') < )) @' (!(D!!'=(< D(!( %##$E D ! ) ! =' !! -! 2 (- * ' !( D! '!*( @ !* *;
' 'E=@ *(<E >(' < @()D*E@ !(-(!E* '> -! '(-@ '> !=!'! -@D'*'= !!! ; ) !E ) ! *= (- - -= D! 8& ! ' ! (*' '-> * C) !' (!(;
6%7896&::% "%/6%/"
-,2 ,!+ - + -,
<; = : 3< $'( -
;
%; S' !A
;
&; <=D'' ! ')'(*C' 1111111111A
/; )'*! @M*=!)'''!*(!N! ( /: G' < '! ) ! ' * * '( ( >)((E.T U.')@ 9E9::7 E!' ,* ; ( *! N! *''-(; (' ' ! P 5 @ ,!! @ ( ' '! ( '>! ! * ( '!!@(A>5,*'*'@'! ) ! *'=' !! !( 'A5*'! -!''*(!!; (' '! !*!' ((!((('!!5>5!5 "E > )(( *' * ! ! < ' @M =( =>;(' '! '' 'F*=E@ '!G' !E @( '!!@(!M=' @(!(,*( (()4!;%/&E%:9!%:$5;
-)) <P *( !P C "' 3 ' W
(! "G !P ,
'* ')'*(!N!!'! ) (,*! @M2M')) )(( ' *-))
6%7896&::%