Continuing Course of Conduct Tolling Statute of Limitations
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe lower court erred in applying the statute of limitations, as the facts presented indicated a continuing course of conduct by the defendant, which tolled the limitations period until the final act of the misconduct, requiring the case to be remanded for re-evaluation under the proper timeframe. The appellate court reasoned that the continuous nature of the injurious actions meant the claim accrued only upon the cessation of that conduct, thus making the lawsuit timely filed when measured from the last such act, rather than the initial one, which the trial court had erroneously used as the accrual date.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 LTF; Continuing Course of Conduct Tolling Statute of Limitations: The appellate court reasoned that the continuous nature of the injurious actions meant the claim accrued only upon the cessation of that conduct, thus making the lawsuit timely filed when measured from the last such act, rather than the initial one, which the trial court had erroneously used as the accrual date.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive to allocate court costs for the appeal.
Cited in the dispositive regarding the allocation of compensation for the respondent.
Testo completo
'()(*'+,,- '(,.)'+,,/
##
# " " # "
-0 12 % (3 1 +,,/
4 5% !6666666666 ! " #! $ $ !! %%%%%%%%%%&" ' ' ! ! #( )*+ +,*+'
!
77 " # 8!" ! + -. '* /0"12113425
!"# $%&
:2619:
7
1$ #+'%%%%%%%%%%"*15;9"+* *<4'=!157;" !)!' +"+'++ !' *'!>*+*! ? )!:4" !44 4+* : !3 @ & !3 + )>> + ! AB* : !3 ) & 3 1 C &$
2$ ! ,! +* + 12 4'=! 157<" ) !D* + @ ' + 209 >!$ +3 1! +*'=! 157/" ' ** ! + '+099 >!$+31!4'=!157;$ 31!E4!157<" @ '*+7//>!$ +0;>!$ '4*** !=++*>! !)!*''' +) >! '=3! + 5);/; >!$ 157<" +) ! +)4+* ' + 5;8>!$" +) >!> + 1F528 >!$ ! +* !" + !' +)!:'++5/5>!$+>!+*E!+>D! +17F;1/>!$>$+*" 311 &$
9$ ! ! +* !4 -, * + +" ) -, > !D* ? )!* + @" + + =+ +)!:
'+ + ' 4!* > + > + -B' !4 + !! +* + )*!* >$ 312?<2 &$
0$ ! +C +* + 9 E4! 155< / E4! 1557" ) !D* ? )!*+ @ !155<1557+)'+0F7/<>!$"+ + 7F71< >!$ 7F;5< >!$ ! 1557& + =+ +)!:'+ + 9F912 >!$ 0F180>!$ !1557&$' +)D!+0F<92>!$/F/92>!$ ! 1557&" +) ! +)4+* ' + 1F085 >!$" +) >! '=3! + 2F<87 >!$ , +) !+ + = '=! + /< >!$ >$ +* G01<218G0;85;9" 3<9</" &$
/$ !!!!+98=!1557"!4+!B**!"!!+)!* + '!4!5E1551">!'*) +) !" , * !B + )*!* )*4 ? /2F78< >!$ 1/ + 19=! 1557" 4!' +) ' + /8F888 >!$ !4 + +'3!+)!*"+)! !",D!)*'+>*+3 1!4'=!1557 !3+*'*B')*4+*!'?5</>!$ ! ' 3/<<<C &$
;$ ! +C +* + 1; 4'=! 1557 / E4! 1555" ) !D* ? )!*+ @+<F795>!$+31!+*'=!1557+<F701>!$+3 1! E4! 1555" + + <F8</ >!$ ;F58/ >!$ +3 1555& + =+ +)!'++0F180>!$C ,*4! !' -B'
6151762889 :9619: ++)!*' =4D!"4' +>!'=3!,) !+-D -*,+)-*!B+2"/H$ '4*B'** !' !++ @"+ +=++)!:'++31!E4!1555>$+*G/85;51 /1/78<" 3<7?78C &$
<$ !!!!+1;>*4!!1555"!!+)!*>!'*) , '+>!++!3!91+*'=!1557)*4?;7F81;>!$ ;/?+4!'+1/F888>!$!410+*'=!1557$
7$ ! + +C +* +)! + @ + + 17 =! 1555 0E4!2888") ) ' +4'>$+* G/<<////51800" 371?79C &$
5$ ! =+@+)4>>: !3@ &+18'!2888 ! !!! + !! + 19 '! 2888" ) ** >!'* + +*3 + )!*"!41/>*4!!2888 370?77 &$
18$ 18 E 2888" ! !,. + ) " #! $ %%%%%%%%%%" 3! + )!*" !++*!+*=1;'2888 !#I4 " ! ,+!" + ,* +)-*!! + +*> ! '*" !!'' 4 >" #! $ %%%%%%%%%%$ >! + )-!)*4?;/F<<0>!$</+?0F588>!$2/ 35; &$
11$ 1< E 2888" !3 ! +'+ + !B' + ) " !* *C+!4+!B**!)>!'*, +'3!+)!*"#+' %%%%%%%%%%"+**+*E155<"4** ,+* ! # I4 $ +! !C !4 ? )!* )**4*?50F778>!$08$
12$ !!!!+15E22 '=!2888") +'+*!4+ !B**!! !, * !B+)!*)**4* ?;<F;50>!$9/91+*'=!1557!,)!+J!4!50F778>!$08" >!'*' ? +*! + + 25 '=! 1557 3 55 ? 181 &$
19$ ! +C >:'* + 2< '=! 2888" !4 + ! B**! >! )*B!* + '4' + >! ! ' ! + )!* + /E4! 1557 91 J 2888$ !! + +' , +!3! 4>>4' !K+' !4++'3! ! +50F778>!$08"?!+2/F888>!$11 '=!1557"92F508>!$ 21 '=! 1557" 2/)888 >!$ 17 4'=! 1557" 11F<01 >!$ </ 1! E4! 1555157>!$;/29'!1555$!4+!B**!44!*/8F888 >!$ 19 =! 1557 ! 4' 1/F888 >!$ 7 +*'=! 2888 !
6151762889 :0619: ' * !B + )!* !4* ! ! +* ! 318018/ &$
10$ !C+*+19=!2888 !!!!C >+1<=!2888" ) !>*'+''!D*?>#+'%%%%%%%%%%? ! + @ + ,)? ! + =+ +)!:'+ +3 1!J 155< +'+* ? )-! ! + ! 4!* ! + +"21F;79>!$8/$' =*>!+5<)9;1>!$+3 1!J155<"+180)2;8>!$1557"+50)885>!$1555:+70)885>!$+ >!'=3!18)888>!$+=+:+<1)28;>!$2888:+ ;1F28;>!$+>!'=3!18F888>!$+=+$ C ,*,) 4 ** ' + 4 +* + !* + >! + +*> 1! J 155<" !3 +*3 + '3! >$ +* G;/0181?;/018;" 318;18< &$
1/$ 54'=!2888")-!+>#+'%%%%%%%%%%> ? +* !4 , '+> + >! + )!* +*> !4=++'3!":'.'+**+*1<E155<" ,+ )* + !4 ,)! < '=! 1557 29'! 1555$ )* + *,= + +*!! , ! + )!* +*>> !+ !'4>>!*!>E!++*3+ '3!$
1;$ !+*! +22E4!2889") >!'*+* C ,,-*!!,*!+3,:*4!" +3 +*3$ )* +3 ! ? E ! , )>> 4 ' + = + )!* +*> 4 -*!* +3 +*= + ' , 4 4 +*3"+31!J155<$) !E*,4C )4 ! ' +!! ' + 157 >!$ ;/ 4!* ? )!* +*>29'!1555"',"4'+*+''"!K? >>! + !>> > + )! + 4 + !4!*?)!* 3112 &$
1<$ ! *!! + 21 >*4!! 2889" )-! !E* !! ! +* !3+ ''+!!$ !4*,"E!++*3 + '3! + )!*" )> ! )*4 ? 99F<10 >!$ 78" , !! + ? ! >4! + )!* + 1;F7/< >!$ 08$ !3 ! 4!'!+*'=!155<=!1557"!' +,+!+ " + /5F028 >!$ 18 + + + L%%%%%%%%%% M " + ;/F778>!$+N O MM M+/8F711>!$/8+@ : " )>=!!>4!+)!*+*>)**4* ?180F519 >!$2810=!1557$)-!*!++*G;/0181 ;/0182 ," !'" + +* G ;/018;" , : +'+ ! + ! 4!* >+ ! * +
6151762889 :/619: >!!!*") D!>!+)!*+*>+180F2;8>!$ +1!J155<91=!1557!, !')4>>4' ' , 10 =! 1557$ )-! ) * C +*G;/0189?;/018/+'!+)'+<F817 >!$?!+ !4!*! 1F8<0>!$ ! *!++1!4'=! 91+*'=!1557"/F/;7>!$ ! *!++1!E4!91+*'=!1555 9<;>!$ ! *!++1!E4!25>*4!!2888&$
17$ !*4 + 20 '! 2889" ) ! * !E + !!$ B* ," + 4" -*!! ,*! + +! )4!* + +3 , : * 4!" , +! ! !* > ! + >! + =**>! + ! ' *'! ,) * E>* + ' =! ' + +3'4+*3++E$
15$ !!* ,+04!2889")-! !*+$ B* , ' + 4 + ! )!* ! + +*3 )*4 ,)? 1;F7/<>!$08$
28$ !+ ,+174!2889") *B' !*+ !4D? !**+*!!$
21$ 1! J 2889" ** !' +)>> != + !$
22$ !! ">*B* !+ !!! !", ="+ !P+!Q: !3$
#
1$ B4!)!BE+!&**'+>**"+3 1!J2889" !=+!"' *+/EB" + !*+ 4: !*+" / * 1; EB ! !$ 1 $!/; &$
M?)+)*+1;EB!" ! !=>*+*! 2<E4!2880 @19818;&"!+ B4+ *"19>*4!!" + !!!B !' !=+! + *B! ! ? ! EB !" " + ) + )*+4CEB!$
2$ >!'*'?)!$9$9++ !!+'+> ! )!B E+! + 10 4'=! 2882" !+ 4 )!* 4B! + + +4 '' +
6151762889 :;619: !! ** !' +)>> M" , ! '3! + ! ' *'! >*+*! >$!$/;&$M' * !EB!++) 3*=$
9$ >*+*!! !B**!++!+!+;=! 2888 & !* 4B! 1! E4! 2889" !( '+> +'=!+ *B++'+!$M! '*!" +4!,+!F ,+.!!-*?'3! + ! ,!3B =4B!''R > E!+,' +*!' !+ @ 12< 0;< +$ 1" 12; 19; +$ 0= !*>*!&$ !4-" , ! !*+!"?+*>+!3B!!!!"4+!F , !*!4+3E!+!*4B! @11<59+$;="112 9;8 +$ 0S # 1557 T 9< $ 91; +$ 9=&$ F !, !*+! +1!E4!2889!+ !3++4 != ' * '3! +F! !*B ! 4 !3B + !*+! + ! + + !*+!++>>*! *'+>* ! $
0$ )*!* , )' ** ! +* ! !*' & + ) !E! !!" ! *! + ! E! , 4 >++*! !$/;"/5;8 "!$1 + >*+*! ! ! ' *'! ? )!:4" !44 4+* + 15 '! 15;/ [ ]" !$ 5 + ! ! >*+*! ' *'! ? )!:4 !44 ? )!:4+*" + 10 =! 15;/ U @V !$09 + ! ! ' *'!?)!:4!44?)!:4+*+ 2/=!15;7U V&$!E*++*>!' !!"!! +3!!4=$
/$ +*B**!+++22E4!2889' !!* + > , !' ? 2888$ !* B ! + C'* ? '3! + + + + !3B' 4B! E,)? + + *B!*+!!$
;$ B ! ' ! ' = + = + >! + )!*+*> !)>>'*+3!,+!!' +31! J155<+)''+180F2;8>!$!K-*!B+>'3!"+3+ ++*3++!3!"19E155<$
<$ ) 3"D+) *!!+!+CD + !$
<$ $ 4 >*+*!" )!$ 2 $ !*4 ,) +! C ! 4+, !K4!3!+)!:4+*$'+ ! ' *'! !! + ! ? ! + +*
6151762889 :<619: !,C3+!4+*!'!$9$1 &$ +!? !' *'! !+ !'!E!+'R +'++* *R!' +*BC, =!+*!$21$1+)!+! !' *'!? )!:4"!444+*+1/E4!15<1U : M6 V&$
=$ M )!$ 9 $ 1 " !4 +*!' ' ! '' !++>!'=3!''=3!$=&",W3'+>! +'!R+* 2/)888>! ! !$ &" !" ! ! *!+," D ' ! ! + ) M+) $+&"!! !+>!+D+!) +$B& '! !*4 !+!+>'$-&$
>!+,?.!*4*!3B+*B!)' X +!+++'!$1<$1$ : M6 &$
$! !,44 !' !B *!+ + -' + -X ! 44 ? +'&" +* !4Y
&'+*?4!!+=4C" !*"" ! ! " 10)7;8 >! ' 1;)0;8 >! "
=&D!+) !'>!!D!>!$9$1 &$
! !44?+' !" !! ' >!>! ! )! =B! + $ + !! +! ' + !' 'D ! )! =B!+4!!+' !&!$9$9$+ &$
+>C!'+*?4!!+=4C+ >! + D! E,)? !!" ! *" + @!$ 12F88$: ! ! & ** * C !$ / 1 $ = &$ 34" ) +) ,)4+**B!' *!$2$1 @&$
" )!$ 2 + !3B' +) + ! ! >*+*! ' *'!?) M?) @& !*4,'+*? 4!!+=4C)*34?1;F0;8>!$ ! !$ +* 'C' ! >! + D! ** >C* ? @!$12)888$: ! ! !!$9 @&$
+$!+ !' *'!" !+' !3B B**! !4 +*!' = ! + F* 4
6151762889 :7619: !**+F*+>!1!E4!+F* !, ! !4S *B'!!+*!'' *!++! ,>++!3!C>!$29$12 : M6 &$
$ +-B'+>!!4+*!'" ! ' *'! + .! B'*" !*+ !'* !, +* !"!4+*!'>!=+' B' ! +!* , ! 4!'==' B$ M +*!'+* 4!44C+!="4! ! *" , >! C ? + ? , -B' !4$ !! ? + ! ! ' *'! " !,'+>>*!!?128>! !!$2/$1$ :
M6 &$ 4 +* + !! >> +3 + 4 + !*4 !)$1"$"!+)B'+)C*+++* "+3 +*= + ' ! +, -B' ** *" ' X ? !!+'+,:!4!$2/$2$= : M6 &$
>$ ,!*4!+ !")!$2<$1 :
M6 !*4 , ! ' *'! +J' -* +4 .!!* !=**>! !-*!!$ !! + M = !B?!+ !?=*!+ )=B+!!$
<=$ $ ,! !")!$0 !*4,)+! C ! ! + !4 +*!' ) !4'''+)+ =$
=$!4+*!'+)!$/$1 ' !+''Y !+ + >!" '=3! ,)''=3! $ =&" -3' + >! !3+*++)'+2/)888>!$ ! ! $&"!+)!:4!44+)!:4+* , +'* E!3! + )!:4+* $ +&" ! ' *'! >*+*! $ & '' !K ! +) =B+)!4!++!+>'$&$
M )!$ < $ 1 $ > " '' +*!* '' >! + )*!*)!B' "+* X++=,+)* !B" + + ' ! ! ! !* +) '' +)!B"+*++++J'E>***'4"*4* >!'*'?B**!!!= =,$
$ )!$ ; $ 1 !*4 ," ! ! 44 ? +'" '' +*+ + !4 D! +) !'" D ' ! >! !$&$+* 'C'! !* !D!)*34
6151762889 :5619: ?@!$12)888$: ! !!$0$1+!3B'+) + ! !' *'!?) M6 U ]&$
+$ ' + ! ' *'! !! + ? +>>*!!!4'''+)+ = !4+*!'+)*!*!$1/$1 &$!4''' +)+ B! )*34 ? @!$ 21507$:" ) )B +) ! *=!"44"+4!*"* !*+! +>!$9$1 &$
M+*!'" !>C+ !"!" ! ! *!+,+)*4!!$5$ &>! 1! E4! + )* ! , ! +'+* !$ 5 $= &$ ! '+>* !3B !*4 '3! + ! ' *'! >*+*! ? )!:4" !44 4+*!$15 &$
$ ,!*4!+ !")!$20$1 !*4,)*!*'=**>!"??-*!!,) *" !'=!' + ! D* +J'$ >" =**>! , * + = > ) ? !" !" , +'!R! '+>++>>$2&$ !!" ) !! ? +'+! !'=!' + ! 4!*" !+'>+* ++=**>!" ! +**>>4'!=*4!!+$9&$
7$ $ ) 3" )B + ! >*+*!" )!* '*" + +*!!*'+22E4!2889+C+*+19=! 2888" !+*!?!++* !'+21)722>!$ D!+0F<92>!$&+31!J155<"+21)07;>!$1;F258>!$Z/)15;>!$ +D!& ! *!++E4!?>=!1557+27)1;8>!$1;F0;8>!$Z D! + 11)<88>!$& ! *!+ + +*= 4'=! 1557 25 >*4!! 2888$ ' * ! !! !! + C + *B$)D+3! +)*!!$
=$'! !)>>?!+!4+!!"1085>!$ + ! ' '& + 1! J 155< 91 +*'=! 1557" ! 4' 1F029 >!$ ! 1555 2888 * !+4 3>B!+!"! !,!! ! ,: !3$
$ !4-*'! !)>>'* !+ >! + !! + '! R ** ' =* +3 1!J155<5<)9;1>!$" 180F2;8>!$+3 1!E4!1557"!, ! +)-*!B+!!)**'?+ , !B!4'"! 11 '=!1557 29'!1555 2/F888>!$4!*11 '=!1557
6151762889 :18619: !' !"92F508>!$21 '=!1557"2/F888>!$174'=! 1557"11F<01>!$</1!E4!1555157>!$;/29'!1555">$ 3180 18/ 9!!&$
@!+!,'++>!>!'C+ *B ! * !$ >>" ) ? E ! , )>> !4* , -*!! ,3!+ +!)4!*++3,:4!" +3+++*3!/;8$1/9<+ +4+18+*'=! 158< U: !3Y V&$ " + !* " + +! + ! !**!+!!*",+=,!4 + +*>" !' + + !$ /;8 $ 2 &$ >")D !-*!!"+!=B' !+ ! +4 E,) !B$ -*!! ! !*! + '' + = , +* + + ! ;82$ 1 2 &$ !B=B-*!!+3,**' *!K ,)+ !B** *!$;90$1 &$
!!.+98 '=!2880 M722680&" !=+*EB* ,)!$9$1 ,!$1<$1$29$12 : M6 !' + !+!' !,+*+ + !4 + >! +*!'" +*! , !4 +*!' ' ! , = !! + FD +! '(! >>4 +! ! + )* +*!'$ D > + )*!! + E! !+" + '! R +!3! ) >!'?+ !=>*+*!+! @ &$
>>"+!!. =* 1552 $900[!++) @ + 74! 1552 $#&" @ '* , )* '' + ),+" !?'.'"++*3++ ",* +*!' ! !' +>! !4+*- ? !*$ != >*+*! ! > ," !, ! -*!! +4 !B!")!$;82$1 ,+! =B ' ! + ! +4 E,) !B$ ''=! +) ''* -*!*+! ! !*! + ''+=,+* ++>+!+! !* +)+'!"!*!4* !!4!+)!$;82$2 &$ !" !!' ? ! !**" ! !** '' + ? + !+* + +,-,-*!! + !=!'$ !!+ !!+) ! !**+4,)+),: !! +! ! + >!' + ! ? +! + -, ! !*! !+ + ,+ !, )+4 +$ +" -, ! !*! + !+4+'+ !,)+" ! C' ! ' BB # I :O IN" T''! W !\ ;/9NG1<S I"!+B+M-!-++ B'"!
6151762889 :11619: 1551"G5<<557&$,"+'3!"+!+)-*!!! ! ++,+,!4 .!***+*E? 4 !B" ! ! +) +4 ! !* ! " @ " !+>!,+.! !' ++ !' *'!+3''+)4!!++$ 22+&$ !+ **>!'*!*''?+C! !"+ +!!. =* @ /0682+1< '=!2889"+$9$9 @ 7682+12E2882+$9=&$
+$ ' +C "++!,+) ! @ C , )>> '* * +3 ! +! + !*'!?)-! !4!*! $
? +*!'! ' + , +*> 4 +! , '+)*4!+ !4!*! $
5$ $ ) 3" )B + " )!* '*" + +* ! +22E4!2889+C+*+19=!2888" ! +*! ? ! + +* ! ' + 0)<92 >!$ D! & +3 1!J155<" + 98F179 >!$ 20)57< >!$ Z /)15; >!$ + D!& + 1!E4!155791=!1557"9;F;7<>!$20)57<>!$ZD!+11)<88>!$&+ 1!4'=!155791+*'=!1557+9;F501>!$2/F201>!$Z11F<88>!$+ D!&+1!E4!155525>*4!!2888$ ')* *" )D +)*!!$
=$'! !)>>?!+!4++*>"1085>!$+ ! ''&+1!J155<91+*'=!1557"! 4' 1F029>!$ !15552888 *!+4 3>B!+!"! !,!! !,: !3$
$ ,!'+>!,+'++! + ) " 4 + !*>*!! ? , +*E? ** +*4 * '3! + !>*+*! !$
+$ *B!+ C +*! , !*3+" ) ? E ! , ) +'+*!+ !4!*?+*>?-!+21F789>!$ 4!*! +4!.!!* !)-!$
4+**'"+*+4!.!>!'*$
18$ !!"!34!!,)*B'?E!,)>>'* ) +'+* ! + '' 4!* ! !4 + )!:
'+ : !3 M #& +3 1! E4! 1555 , !! + +*+19=!2888$
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
*,") >+!!=*B !!*'! ! + =+ 4!* ! M #$ ) )!$ 99 # , !3B ,+=++J'-*,+!!+* '=M #">!'*'?)!$1$1+!3B'+)C*+ +) +>*+*!!)!:'+M98/$81&$
6151762889 :19619: # 7 " # " " # " % 15 9 : ;& (3+ "<
5
1$ *!!!+21>*4!!2889!4=S
% 5
2$ !ES
9$ >!' +* ! + ) + 22 E4!2889" C +*+19=!2888+1<=!2888S
0$ ,)-!" !#!$$%%%%%%%%%%"+4!!! ' + @!$ 21F;79$8/ ? ! + ! ' *'! >*+*! 4!*! S
/$ , !*+!B!S
;$ , ! , ! C ! ' *'! >*+*!" ! 4 >!'! !! ! !* !!. + +* + 98 E! +3 > ! !''+* +!* != >*+*! + !" M-]W!->,;";880 " !C' !$ '*'!+Y& +,!C',+*!!+*!=! + +* ,*S =& C ! ! , '> !! ' 4! +'+! ! +*S & !! B! + !! + ! !*$M'*'! !**'*'*!*! & =& & :+" != >*+*! + ! !! !! '3! ! !! ,) +4! +*!! !!4=$ '*'! + !! '!!'D+ !4",!E'*'!))B + 3 + !!$ M! *B' E '*'! +* ,* )4 + , ** C *+* !! !$19218;187&$ B!>>3!Y !*+Y @@ T!M T !*!:E!Y@!#
>!'+ !*!!.>*C !,)?)>>>*+*! +! !B!>>
6151762889