Judgment Enforcement After Settlement and Bankruptcy Discharge
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case involves a dispute over the enforcement of a judgment where the judgment debtor claimed the underlying debt was satisfied or discharged through prior proceedings and settlements, specifically involving a bankruptcy proceeding and subsequent agreements. The court reasoned that the language of the settlement agreements and the bankruptcy discharge order did not unambiguously release the specific obligations sought to be enforced, as the release language was construed narrowly against the party seeking to avoid enforcement, and the record did not support a finding that the parties intended the settlement to wholly extinguish the liability for the enforcement action at issue.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Judgment Enforcement After Settlement and Bankruptcy Discharge: The court reasoned that the language of the settlement agreements and the bankruptcy discharge order did not unambiguously release the specific obligations sought to be enforced, as the release language was construed narrowly against the party seeking to avoid enforcement, and the record did not support a finding that the parties intended the settlement to wholly extinguish the liability for the enforcement action at issue.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAApplied for the determination of court costs.
Testo completo
$%&'($%))* $+)*&$%))&
!!
, !-, ,!
./0 '
# %' 1/0 %))&
!" #"$"# $ ! %$ #&'
$
&& ( '' $!" )*+
! "#
2-,332
2
34 " 3*1- (5 #5 $6" !! "!"54 !#$ 3/ $7 -003 "$" (#$" $$ $6 4
-4 ""! ($7-003!$"#$$% 8(# #"$%$ ("# $4
/4 9$$ $ (""$"#%5# ' '' 8 6" # 7 !#) !$" :9 # #$ 5 " ; ! 4 !$$ !$" "$" !$" ; /+< 9 /3$7 -00- = $ !#$ 6 "7 $ #=:8(;"#!$ $4
>4 -. 6!7 -003 (" "#" #!9 ! #$$ #9 (==$ (26 $"?2#9@( A4
14 ' !" 2$$$ $$$" . "!7 -003 ( #$" $$ $6 9 3/ $7 -003 65 %8 !! $ ( % 12'3 $4 #$ 7:$6 #$$"$$@ 6$5 656 !$ !75=$5$ (!4!" $$"7:$6!$ $7 "5""$= =! ($% 62 2!7 $ % !" 12'3 5 "6 $4 "!"" $$ !$$=$@(#$"#(" $ #$ 7$# (%$ !; B%#: 7 !$$;5B (7$ (# !%# 100!9$ "# %5 # / > C5 $ % "5 $6%$ "#"5#$4
.4 3.#$!7-00-4%!$5#9 ?2#9@ D"$7!$ %#$DA B!" (" ; ! 4 ; %5 == # #77!$ !! 5 ($$$ $ ; #7 $ $ ! #)! !!7=" $4!7$"6 $!7 #$$ "$$ !#9$ ! $ #4 !7$ % "$$ $#!$$!4 !" ##"$$!$#%)$%"#$8#"$8(#$ # 8 $$ # = !$!$ %54 $!" !9 576 " (E$ $6$#= ("8(("$$# #78 ##$4!$!7$ == 6$"" $ ("4
,-./*,-001 2/,332 +4 + $7 -00- 6 " #$$ #= (2 6 $" !$" 8 (" 6$ 8" == $!7!$ $B !!7 #" 8 (6$ "$" !$" # !" 7 8( ( $ #$ ; # #4 '(##)$ (6 !" 2 ( 55"" B! !#"!$46%";## ! " #$$ ("(65$##6$64
F4 -+:6-00/ 4; ! ("=!" #" %5 !! 5 ($$$ 4 $!" 8 % !7$ # : G 5=$= # !75 %84$$" #$ 5 $ $ !#)! $4'# ($6$"#="$$ == #" 5 H " (E$ $6 =$ "58$ ($$$ #$$#8D$$$ I;% D4
*4 ! $ (B#$ 7 # "$" =" # ( $ (76$!" (26 $"?2#9@ A8 ##$ - $7 -00/4 2 "$" "$7 # 4 %!$5 $ #)%$ $ #)%$%"#$4 (B! %!$58 ( !$" !$$ !$ J!#$ !6!$ 5 $$= "=$ " ; (% 8 $$ )!#$!$8#8$($="$#6#$" $6 # $$ 8( !# (==$K$ $6$" "5" $ #$"4 $!7!$ !($#"$"76"$$$ (6 B#$ 6!77!$ 5=$4'##)%8("#"$$ $7 "#= $7 BB "$$ $ #$2$!$8 #)% $7 56 #$" #6$ = #$" $68$$#$94
304 " 3>:6-00>( = $(B#$ :$" ! #$$!$=8$B (6 $"2 /-<2"$$ ==$ # 6 $ ; $4 $B $$ !#$ ( #$" $6 !# #$" ( F0 ; 300< # 7$$!$ ##"!$ 30< # !$$ =$4 ! #=$"5!$"$"="!$=8(($# (==$ #$" 5 ("4
334 -*:6-00>4; ! ("=!" 6#"" $4 8"6#" ";=$$";$ #$% !#)! $4
3-4 ("=!"##$3-="6-00>4! $6#7$ (B#$ !$=8((B#8$##8("$$
,-./*,-001 2>,332 (6 4 $ $$ $ 6$ 58 8(==$ $!7!$ !4
3/4 " ##$ -- 6 -00> ( =!" = #$$4 6" ( #$ 8 (B! 58 ("$$ # 6"" " !LB#$(6$#$$" $!7!$ ! $ 8( "=$ 58 ("$$ $ !$" # 4 $ ($ #$ 8 !E! ##$ ($$ # $ $ 65$ # = !$!$ B#$ #$8(#$##M$!!"!#9$4
3>4 30 ! -00> (" $:$" 4 ($$ 4"$"$ ;$$ $"!4B#8"8 $ ==$ %5 !! 5 ($$$ 4 !$$ "$$ B " ! 8( $$$ 7:$6 #!$$ B#84 %"$ ; ("6$ #$" $6=$# 6 " #$$#="$$#"" 8(; 30< #9 "$$ == #4 !E! $ 8"$78(==$$$5 %G!5; 10< :$; "!7-00>4
314 ->I$-00>("$" $$7#$ :5!$ +#$!7-00>4"$")" G4
3.4 $ -- ="6 -001 6 "" $ D"$7!$ %#$D ; ! (2%G!5 ##$ $= $5 ; # $!# 6 # (" 3F $7 31 6!7 -00> "$$ #"" 8 $6 ($"" 6$ $" "!$5 ( $ $ 6 $6B !4 "$" $$" 8 (" #6$ 5 #$ 7$ # ( %4 $6B "$$ $ = #68$ !E!8$6$" ! $ !6!$ 7 %$ 7 B5$ #$ %5 #" ; 1C54 ("!$6 ==$"$6B = #" !8 B$"$"4 "$$ #$" $6 ( 10< $6$" ! $ # $# = $ $!$ "5 #$$ !$54 # $6$" ?7K$!$ $$)5 "!"5!$A"$$!#74
3+4 /!-0014=$6!" 2 ( 8 :5$ ##$ 8 $6$" "$$ #$ %5 $6B = "$$ !#7 # ("4 =!$ 8( $6$" # "59 #%)8!$ ( 10< $$#74 8$8#$ (""$$!; 8( 6$ # $$ $$ $"4 $!$ 7
,-./*,-001 21,332 8(""6$ $=$#( ;!9 ("6$ 6 "" $ D"$7!$%#$D4
3F4 ! ( "$7##$3+!-0014 $!! 5$6"##$" $6 "$$ "#= # -0034 $$" 8 ("$$ #$$ #":$ # 6 $$ 5!$$ 62 2!7 !#5" (! $ ("$$ BB !#$$4 !$$ =$ "$$ ! ; ! "6 ##$ . "!7 -0034 "$$ !E! #$ 7:$6 !! $$$7:$64B!#""("$$#8;6$ #$$6$#$" $6 10< !# #$"4
:$B##$!" "$7#43> ! -00> 8 8$ 8 ("$$ $" #$$ "$$ $$8(B!!" !#"!$("$$" 8(() 6$# ) !!726$"7!E!!7$"$$ !8(B$$6% 5 H $ N!!$ !#)! $4!" $!$8("#6$B $6$" #= ; 10< !# #$" $ 8 $!$ "5 #$$ !$5 !$ !$4 !#=!7$ 8"4
3*4 + 6 -001 (" ! " ; ( "6 " ##$ -- 6 -00> 5$ 8 "$$ $" ($ "$"" # 4 ($ "="" ##$ 6 "" $ D"$7!$ %#$D$;(6 4
-04 " -. 6 -001 ( :$" ! (" !$= 8( ""!$ 6 ("$$ ##$"4 =="$ ##$ ($7-00/$-00>$$674
-34 * ! -001 (" =!" ##$ ; $$ " ! $ $ $ ; 8 $ 5" (6 $" 10< $6$" #$"$! ="4
--4 " ##$ + :$ -001 ( =!" " !$= 8 $ #!$$$ "6 6 "$ ("$$#!#4("$$ $" ("(6$#%5"4 ##$ 6 "" $ D"$7!$ %#$D $$$ 8(##"$ =="$ #$" $6 ("$("$$ 9 #""!$#$$#6= #$$4
-/4 "$ -3 :$ -001 (" $:$" 6$ 7 $ ?2#9 @ 7A $ $
,-./*,-001 2.,332 "# ; ($ " $$8" ; ( #$" $6 10< $6$" #$" $ 7 !$ ; !O6 (76$#=6 (6 "4
->4 "# -/I$-001( :$ 4968 ##$ $9 $ 6 "" $ D"$7!$ %#$D 5#B#$7:$6 ("8(6$ $B$ 5E$ $6$#" (=$"584' " !" (B#8 65 (##"$ #$" $6 $4
-14 "#8 +#$!7-001$#$" B#$8$$ 30!-00>"$$= " !" ##$ $ !" $$$ B#" $# 74'!" $$$6$ ##$ 6 "" $ D"$7!$ %#$D=$ $8($#"$"!E!4 ##$$$$%$8=$68(6$"$" ;("#8($!";!$ $4 !$= $6#7$ (B#$ ($7-00/4
-.4 $$ -*#$!7-001( #$" $! "# 4
!
34 56J5$: ?A"$"! ="$$$" 9 3I$-00/ 7$ !#" 1:5 $ #" $ $ 62#" $ 1 ##"$ $ 3. :5 ?$4 3 $4$1. A4
'$;J$ J"$ 3.:5# 7=" " -+:6-00>? &3/030.A 56 #$"3/="6 #$$$5$#!$$$ 7$ "5 ; $ :5 $$ J$$$ J"$ 6B:54
-4 =!"!$ ; ($4 1. 4 3 $4 %4 - 7 $ M$$8 $$$#"6;J$ 1. 8$$6;J26 $" 3*:3*1*4' !#"$#:5 J#9$"$74
,-./*,-001 2+,332 /4 #$ 5"" $ . $7 -000 ? A $ $" 65 3 :6 -00/ $M$ ! =$ !7 #$ "5 ! 4 ' #!$"#$ 68 $(##8 $E$$%";!9 ##895##7$65!!$L =$: 8!$ "$!$$# $? &3/0-/0 4343 //1 434-3-*> 434-3-+>.+ 433-.3/. 4>7$ "="A4
(#9 =$ 6 !$6$ ! "6 $ -- ="6 -001$ "$# +:$-001 $8$6 #$ 8 (##8$4 $ B 95 #" $ (##8$ "6 9 : $" 65 ? &33+ */ 4 .7 33- /.0 4 >P 3F N /+ #4/3. 4/7A4
>4 $:$" =! $ "#"6##"$$67 ?$41. A4
14 $5#$#$ 6(6 $" $($! =" # #" " = $ ( !9;6 $ ; $ ( ) =$ 6 #!$$$ #" ; "6 " = $4
.4 ' ($4 3+ 4 3 $B (6 $" 7""= $ 7$ ! =$ $7 $ $ (== ! "6" # (6 ; 6 5!$" " $ "8 ##!"4 6$ (:$8($43+ (###$" ! =$B## :# $ "6##" "5! ( $4 >3 65 :8(/3 "!7-00-? &3/0/>/ 4/41A8 !$ 9 ##7#54#$ 6$%5!$!#$$ $##;= 5" (6 $" $;$($ # $ $E$$%"!#$=$$8(#"$$!!$ "$ $$$"5$;("#8 " $5? &3-1/.* 4-$"="P46"5!$ &33-/+- 4 -7 $ /*0 4 37A4 $ =$ 6 #$"!$ ; " ##$ $ 8 $ ! =" $$ $$ 6$ !!$ = (7:$ ( 6 " !$$6 ? & 33+ -*/ 4 >A4 = (#9:# $#$E$"6"!$ ! =$7 ("$$ $"!82$$" !E!!8"8#$" 5$7%5!$ !#$$? &33/-+1 43$E$$"P6"5!$ &33- /+- 4-7$/*0 437A4
,-./*,-001 2F,332 +4 (##"$ ""!$ !" B 7 =" " #""? &3-1/13A8## 7##"$ #6 8(##87#" !$$68(#" $ !$$=?$4>0 &"$6($43* P$4*14- 6$433/$3/-A( !$$:5##"7!$ #6E$"# 95=!#" $;##"$ !#9$$5 #64(""!$ "$!$#6#7$ ( $=$ !" ($ 5 "5$ =! ( ##$ (B#$!7$7$4 $"5 !#$8 #$$5B!#$$$=$(7:$ ("$ ="8##$ = B! !#$ 8( # "5!$ "$ #$ B#!" 8( $ "$" "$7 # ?!9A8 #$ $=" !" $$=8 (B#$$7!$6"4
==!$ 5 (76$#=$#=$ !#"$ "!" B!$9$!$ 8! (" $ ; !E! !$$ 6 #$" $6 $ 5 !%" $64 L ##"$ 65$ 7!$ !7 ; ( !$$ #$6!$ :5 =$ B ##"$ 7 8" !#"!$ ($$4 $ 8 =!$ ($5#$8($$ ##$(6 I!$!$6" (!" ;8##$$#!%= #$:5!$("$$ $" ("$ ( 8 8! $ # 8 $6$" 2 $ #7 $6 "%"$ 8 $6B $ #$ 7!$ B5 ? & 33 :$ -001 1/3,0> 4>4-A4
F4 (#9 $ $! 8 $$ ##$ 6 "" $ D"$7!$ %#$D 8 (6 / ! -001 !$$$ "6 "$"$ "$$ $" 8 $$($!"4
$ ##$ !" #"$" 8 #$ $$$$;=$!;8(#$$$"!$$ #!$6 5$4 2$$$#$#; #" ##$!" B-00/$-00>4!" =$ # $$$ ## 8 !$$$ "6 6 !$$ =$%Q$ # $ $$ 4$$ ( %" B $ ##$ 6 "" $ D"$7!$%#$D;D!9 ("6$8"$"==$" ? $A $5D4 !" %"$ "5!$ I$ -00> ; ("6$ #$" $6 =$ # 6 " #$$ #=$$#"$8(;30<#9"$$ == #4
,-./*,-001 2*,332 %5 (# ; B ! ($6 8 $ $ # ! ="4 ' ##$ ($ ( $$"$# "!$556$ "$$ $"4
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
! "6 $ ##M$ 6$5 !! $$$ "$8($#(7:$ ("6! (4 $#""!$$"8(6$ "#"$ " = $4#9#7$!$"6 $ 6!#$$:$=$"6 $;$ $ ($43+ 4
*4 $ ( "$ 8$ 5" (#$" $6 $ $ # 6$5 "4 ' :# ( $ (" :5 #6$ B5 8 ( !$$ 9 "? &33+3- 4-$"="A4(B$# $ ; "$ 8 (" #$ " :$4 # $ 8 ( !$$ $ !$9 ! "$ $ B! $ ( "$ $ !# 6$ $$ = #6 " =2$#$7 (E$$$8"# 6 ( P $G : $ #" 7"8$!$#$ 6 $ ( "$ ?B$$ !=$ " $ $ !#$ $7
,-./*,-001 230,332 $=$A$"? &33+3/ 4-33..-A4($ $ (%5";$"5 4"5$8(#6 "5; ##(=$8 =$$#$8:# $?6$!!$ N '2N!!$V%-00/$-- $41/P&&33-1FA4
(#9 ($!" # !$= B#" ; (## = 6 " $!" 8( () 6$ # (""!$ # "$4 $$ ##$E$6#$ #$" $62""!$ #6 #!$$$ " 8 " $ ($!" $ $%" (!=$#$2$(E$# $ 5" (6 $"8($6"( " 3>:6-00>4 ==$ $7 " 9 8( "$$ !=$!$ " (##88(" $ 30<68("#$"!5" % # !#$ $ !7 "6" !$$ =$ =$8$6$""59$#7 "! K5!I?1- !!$ "$5A$ 62$9#"6"2 =!$4 $($" $ -1<8$ IE$##8"8$ $ !#$ $ %== $ # ($!" ; 5" (6 $" >/> < 6$ $ ; 8$ $4 =$ !$$ 8 " 3> :6 -00> "$$ !=$!$ " $ #" ; $ 8"2 4
$#$!$ !8$6$ M$ $ ; 8$ $ (6 $" ; !#$ 3 6!7 -00-4
,-./*,-001 233,332
! 2 !-, ,!
#
345 // 6 7 8 9 +&% ":
5 /
34 "674
# 5
-4 ( !$#$!$ "$4
/4 $8 $;8$ $ (6 $";!#$ 36!7-00-4
>4 6 ; (== $ (26 $" # !$" ;("4
14 !J$!";6$!! &43(10022;$$ "#4
.4 =! #$ 8J #6$ =! $ #"$ E$ " /0 : 9 $=$ # # !! " " 7 =" " '%WQ%=8 . .00> $ B!#4 " #$ E$ #5"4 !"! $@ A 8 B$!$8 "$ "7$$# " $$8"P 7A B# # 8 !$= $! #6 ! $$ $ "P A #$ 5$ #"$$4 ' !"! $$ # $ ""!$ "!"" $$ A 7A $ A 2 7=" " ##$!$98J 6 "674!"! !$!) #6 8 $ :$ 8 " $$8" $ J6## 8"$"B#" "$?$43/-30.$30FA4 5==9 #" $ && N' N
#=! #"$E$$$="B#$8J;J===" " #5==
,-./*,-001