Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATAS/1055/2004 • CJ GE ATAS/1055/2004 Generato dall'IA

Negligent Left Turn and Failure to Yield

Numero d'incarto ATAS/1055/2004
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Respinto (Dismissed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

A party sought damages following a collision that occurred when the defendant failed to yield the right-of-way while making a left turn across the plaintiff's lane of travel. The court reasoned that the evidence supported a finding that the defendant was negligent in executing the turn without ensuring the way was clear, thus causing the accident, and affirmed the judgment in favor of the plaintiff, upholding the finding of liability based on the defendant's failure to maintain a proper lookout and yield.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Negligent Left Turn and Failure to Yield: The court reasoned that the evidence supported a finding that the defendant was negligent in executing the turn without ensuring the way was clear, thus causing the accident, and affirmed the judgment in favor of the plaintiff, upholding the finding of liability based on the defendant's failure to maintain a proper lookout and yield.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
diritto di passo risarcimento dei danni da incidente stradale tamponamento infrazione commessa per negligenza sorpasso non consentito grado di colpa

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision is cited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay the costs of the federal proceedings.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

     

   

%&'((%())* +%&),,%())*

+

 + "+   "  "

&- ./  $ &* .  ())*

  

  0000000000    ! " #$ %%&

&%

11" "+        %&  & ! '( )* " #$

          ! "  #$

0 .+) 0

 1+

,1 2 23333333333 !  ,-4/ 55%   6#& %!  &78  8% 9  !  &% &&  &% 3333333333  $ & 8%% &   $%  %!:  8! 5 91   !&!    6!!5  ; & 0%!:    ,<) 5%1 8   ,% % ,--=1

.1 % !    .)  .//* ;55  &  8% >:! ? 08%#   @ ; 5%! 9;8%# $ %     % "  ! 0   &% A3333333333  $ & &&! 9;  %8  & 8   &  ;&%   & & 0%!:  &  88% ! 0 $ 55& ! &1

41 ; &!%!  5%! 88 &   .=  .//*1

*1 % !   % 88 &   .* B& .//* ;   5 %!  88%   % & " ;& 0%!:  %88& 9  &% A3333333333 %86    $     !&!& 9 &  &% &   ;AC8 & &  #$ $ & %!8 "  9&   $ %   %!:   & % !& &     ;%!  86   &    $    %   6#&   & D E  %&!% & 9 8%  8  %!:   6!& 9 &  %!8%& %  8%   & % %&  '% ;!$  5  ;!$ &%  8  :7! 9  %! %  5%&   8  9  &78 &%! ?:%   @1 ;&% %  !&!& 9 & 8&    % 5&  & 5 9  !&6 1  !9  %!:   & % ;& 8  86   &    $  F1  !  $ & G&! 9  %!:   & % ;&%H &  !8 88!& % 8% %88%& "   &&  %& ?51 8%   8 &   ,/  .//*@1

)1 ; &!%!  &%G&! %%  ,= 8&6% .//* &%  & !  1   : 9  &% A3333333333  ;  &  I ! 9  !  &% &&  &% 3333333333 ; 8 !&! &  8 9  ;6%$&  &% & ; %!:  ;& 8&0(&% 8  86   &    $  " %& &%  ;& 8%  7 &  : &% 9 ;& 0 %!:  ! 8% ;  & &  &% 6&  8%&& 8%  9   8 ;&% %$ 9 I  ; J &  ;&  8!& %1  & "  9 ;55& 8 5  8%!& %%   & %! "  9; I8%& !8&  & ! :! $     ;&%   9  !  &% && & 9  !    ;   & !1

=1 $ &! "  !&% % ;     %G&  %%1

<1    !&! :%! " G:%1

+,-..+.//*

0 4+) 0

  +

,1   :$  % ;%: &  G   % ?@  !&!  5 ! &  & &! #  ,% B& .//4  % 6 &  %   8!  )

G: &  8%! & &  $ 08%! & ) 88!& & ,= G: % ?%&1 , &1 % & )= @1

J & " ;&   ;!&   ,= G: % 8%  % 6 5!!%  .< G$ % .//* ? K ,4/  ,/=@  %   :$   8&!  ,4 5!$% %   8 &  &% & % %:& 8%&&&  % 6 &  %     !:%  % " &%  G: & & %   ;&&&  ;!&   $I G: %1

.1 5%!& " L%&1 )=  1 . &1    % 6 &  %   H&  &&&  8%!$ " ;%&  *4    & %  8%&&  & 8!& % " ;%0$   & %$ $& & "

;%0 $  &!  .) &6% ,-=M   9;" ;%&  )=  9 & %& $ "   5!!% %  8%&&  8!& % " ;%0 $   %$ $& & $  &!  ,- % ,-=)1

J 8!& 8% G:%   ;8# &   !&6 1

41  %% &%G&!  &8 &  & %$6 "  5% ?%&1 M    %  8%&&  5!!% 8!& % " ; J N & %&1 *.    %  8%&&  & 8!& % N O@1

*1  7  8%!6&    &&% 9 ;55& 8 5  %% ; 8 !&!

%& %! 8% ;  1    %!&6 &  & 55& 8 5 &    6G&1

)1 I &%  ;%&1 -  ;% %& $  %6%&  5%     &  5%  %!&&  ; $  &!  & #%  8%&&  8!& % ?2 @ D E  5%  88!& % B& !&6   ! 8%  %!:   & % 8%% & 8%  !  &  86 "  %$    8% %! &  !%!  5%       & 8%  $ &    '    'C8 &1  &&  5%5 & %  .L,// 5%1 & %6%! F1

=1  ;8# ;%! 55%   6#&1 J !  &% &&   # % 8%% &  %!:  8! 5 91 ;        ;%!  &% A3333333333 9   $   ,/  .//*  !%! ; 8%& 9  %!:   & % ;!& & 8  86   &    $  & ;&% 8%& 9;  ;&%H & 8  !8 88!& % 8% %88%& "   &&  %&1

+,-..+.//*

0 *+) 0

<1 J ;  &%&    G:  5& %  88%! &      8%$ 5%  8%  $& :&  I9   $& 8%!% ;55  & $  9 %&  5 & 8%!&&  :%!  $% 6 8%!8!%& & 9 ;&% % 8%6& %  8%% & 8  5 % && 88%! &   & 8%5 ;  &%% ;&% 8%$ ?88%! &  &  8!  8%$ P Q %  %R&:$%5'%  % JS $% '%:

81 .,. T *)/ P QUS+AV% %R&:$%5'%  %R&:%'&85:   . !1 81 4- T ,,, & 81 ,,< T 4./ P 7:  $%R&:%'&85: . !1 81 .<* P 51  K ,..  *=-  1 * ,..  ..4  1 4 ,./ 6 ..-  1 .6 ,,-  4  1 4 &  %!5!%@1  &  #%  8%!%  $  8  % & ;(&% &  ;%&1 .- 1 . &1 ?J .//,  T ,/ 81 .M  1 *6@  G% 8% %  ;8 %  ;%&1 *  &1 !&& &G% $6 ? K ,.*  -*  1 *6 ,..  ,=.  1 , & ;%%(&  &!@1

M1  % 6  ! && 9 9;    & 9 9 6  (  %%&  & ;&% % "  6 :&   & %  %    !&&  &! 0 ;:%& " ;!$  8  B& 88!& % 8% %88%& "  8% 6  8%&&   % W  ;: & 8%  8&  ; &% " '% %!: #%1

-1    G& 5  8    &  ;&%  !  &% &&  ;%%  I8%&   5 & !&& !&6 1

,/1 K%   &  5 %%  88%   ;& 0%!:  &  %G&%  %%1

+,-..+.//*

0 )+) 0

 " +1  + "+   "  "

$

2.3   4  5   67 &8(  #9

  3 

,1 !%  %% %$61

$ 3

.1  %G&&1

41  & 9  8%!% & :%& &1

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

 :%55 #%D  %! & D

2% 0   X %  Y   

 8  5%  8%!& %%(& & & 5 ! I 8%&    9;" ;55  5!!%  %   8%  :%55 

+,-..+.//*