Sovereign Boundary Fixation Over Prior Land Grants
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA litigant sued a government entity concerning a boundary dispute involving submerged lands, asserting title based on a prior grant and challenging the current configuration of a shoreline boundary established by a statute and subsequent regulatory actions. The court reasoned that the legislative act establishing the boundary was a clear and unambiguous statement of sovereign intent to fix the limit of the submerged lands, and under the relevant legal framework, such legislative declarations are controlling over claims based on historical grants or subsequent erosion/accretion, thus affirming the boundary as set by the statute and denying relief to the claimant.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Sovereign Boundary Fixation Over Prior Land Grants: The court reasoned that the legislative act establishing the boundary was a clear and unambiguous statement of sovereign intent to fix the limit of the submerged lands, and under the relevant legal framework, such legislative declarations are controlling over claims based on historical grants or subsequent erosion/accretion, thus affirming the boundary as set by the statute and denying relief to the claimant.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThis article is cited in the final dispositive section concerning the allocation of court costs.
Testo completo
!"#$%!"&&' !(&##!"&&'
)*)*
+ )+* *,* +* ,)
'- ./ 0 (& . 0 "&&'
1 2222222222 ! " # !! ! $ !%%&'('!%''
!
,33) *,* 4+*5)*6)) % '!'( )*+,-
4/.34
* 3)
5# "' 67777777777(5*80!''!(%! -'!!%'05 9-' /22/ % :, % 4:' # %(( %% % !!'%$ 4'-'%'!(%!%5+ /220#
/# $ !%;'%'%') '<'- ! %'%'!(9 ', %,5 %(: /22/ :%%== !' (%' $ !'& (!:' 7777777777 ! $! )>'! '& <<!( # "7777777777# $ ( !!( - :! %%'! = !' ! (% ! !! %! %-! ':%( .581/./220#
0# %(''%/0 /223$<<'!%$ 4'-'%'!(?'4 , $ @ 9!( %% % !!' !'< & $= !' >!;'&(!:' 7777777777-: /22/'!& ! : %(;(( !'< >'%' %( ( 9!'<''! A! % ! -' ;(!&'!(%! -'%$'!( ((!'!!', %' !'-'!(%><%$(&'#
3# $'!'%$ ( (!( "#!! (!( 9!( %(''%$ %5*!: /223#
8# 5B -: /223 $ ( '! 9!( , % ': % ( ! (:! C ' % $'! !' % (! 9&$C% '!9;(% .581/./220#
1# (%1%(: /223$ $!(C'#
* ,)
5# ';-' $ ;'!'9%''' ?@(!(%'<'(!'!'!(%, 5 D!/220 ':!% '(%89; %! ('%!!-'4 ('%!8(!!519; ? !#5!# !81 @#
6'!C$!'%$(!'%519; ':<(%( /+9-' /223? E502521@ % ';-'%!(50<(- ' %''!'! '!' ;! !!! ':!% ' % '(; C ! ' 9; !'!' % $!!! % $(!'%-=9; #
./0+1./223 40.34 /# ':%(F!'!'&%!!!' !'-C' <(%( $ 4'-'%'!(%5*9'5*8*G ? !#81@#
6(! 9; %%$,!''(!:'#
0# = ! % $ !# 53 % ' ;-' (% %''! !'- % 5/ !: 5*B8 ? @ (% ! A! % & ! %(% % !' %$ &!' % ! '-' ( %''! !'- %! %-!! ! '!(9&$C% '! &!'#
< !' ''!4': &%=!%!%-! A9 '%'!'#
3# $,''%% - & (% %!% .581/./220 %-! ':%( :9!%%(! ' '= !'(!:' 7777777777!"7777777777!- :!%'!% 9 ' %# H$'!'($!<%( A= !' < !! !!' ! ' 9!'<' % % (! (% 9&$C% '!#
,)3 )+* *,* +* ,)
7.181 9 :11 1 4 (%" ,;
5# 6% I'! '!' % $ !# 53 9&$C % '! % (% .581/./220J
/# ( -'!% (% J
0# < !' % &$ -! < ! (! A! % %(' % 52 9 %, !'<'!' ' %( % ( ': <(%( % 6>K'L ><&' 1 1223 ! ' =' # %(' ! A! ;(# (' %'!M @ '%'& =!! & %('' ! %(' :!' ' ! %
./0+1./223 43.34 %(''!!&(J:@= &!'<'!'-' %% !! ! %(''J@ ! ';! % (!!#6'(' !'! ! ' ((! (( ( !! @ :@ ! @ '4% ':<(%( % ! !', &$' %- %( ' -:#(' % !' ) % - &' ! 9'! '' & %('' !!&( ! $- % &(!(=(%'( !? !#50/521!52B@# ; <<' M ('%!M N'% " '
'< % (! A!!!'<'(= !'''&$C$<<'<(%( % ; <<
./0+1./223