Damages Calculation Post-Contract Termination
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA party challenged the calculation of damages awarded in a previous decision, arguing that the lower court erred in applying the established rate to a specific period, as the underlying contract had been terminated prior to that time. The court reasoned that while the contract's express terms governed the relationship, the established rate continued to apply post-termination based on implied agreement or unjust enrichment until the matter was resolved, finding no reversible error in the lower court's methodology for calculating the final award.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 al. 2 LTF; Damages Calculation Post-Contract Termination: The court reasoned that while the contract's express terms governed the relationship, the established rate continued to apply post-termination based on implied agreement or unjust enrichment until the matter was resolved, finding no reversible error in the lower court's methodology for calculating the final award.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe final order includes the taxation of court costs, citing this provision.
The final order determines that the losing party must pay the costs to the opposing party, citing this provision.
Testo completo
!"#$%!"%%& !'%"&!"%%&
( )*( + ( +)
,-. '
'/ 0-. "%%& !"""#$ !%&'( &!&' #'"!!"")#'*'&+ , '' !'& ++ ) ,, - "& "'"# .!/0$
-2177-
1)
78 #7/3/ )!&"9"%!&'9" '(," :#(&"& 7/468 '&("# %&; !"#'# < , ! %!.#)'&'"%"7&="'7//38 #'!''"("'#&'"( %"0:#(&"&255>%!&&"!'#8
28 #%!#%&;)::"'!)&-"(""'#?"- %&;) @2/!'!A&255> ("'$)!'&!")&')"(""'# !'": B)!::&"'C"%!&'''!'!&% )%DE'!&"&! &'&!9'%D%!"'"! "9&" (&'"9')9& :'"98
>8 &%%!&'&#$) /=("&255F & #" '&"'' ""B# B %'"' !::&"' ) #%&"! =& &#"'' '&"'' %" 7//0 ) :"A&!.9" "("' '&!A ''"B ' #9##&'":&E" '.&!'&%"A"'#&?!%#&#$9E@8 !";&!#''"%A'&("&$755G%"0:#(&"&255> #''%&#"#B)'&'!')#''#%&":%&"''B"!"'' 'A""B8
F8 & =!"'$!&%%!&'!&&"&B"("'&#& %#""'+H&E'!!9" 70!'!A&2552 C'& B )&# %&#'"' 'A :"A&!.9" ( B'!&I %!"' !!&C & "C-E"' !::&"' )"!" ' ) #'' #%&": JB" %&*' #("'J8 & ""B"' B)" ("' #'# :&%%# %& "9 !'#!%E.'"& '&; &B# (""A & &"!9&%E" !! !& #(!B' , H B" %!&&"' C%"B& %&# !& (&'#A& "A C '"-":'!"& " &'"' % )A 'A ""B8
38 & #"%.E"'&'&"'' !&%%!&'22=("& 255F %!# "9!'" )#%"! #%&": =& &#""! ' :"A&!.9"8'")"%"'#'&("$35G #''%&#"#B)#'''# )#"!&8&;('!':!"B%'"'!";&B)%'%'&("& '!'8
68 & %#""' +H %.E"'&" '# %& "- ")&# H , #'A"&%%!&')C%&'"26"255F8 #" &' B !& )'&'" )C%&'" )&# %&#'"' % .%'K #%&": #'"' #' !&"' ' %A &"& '!' "' (!"& !& ":: L !A"& &(" A& &!"'MN " "" !"#&# B)" JC"' ":'' C9#&'"! %&' A='"( '"! !!&8 ##:" !"& "%!&'' ( :" B"
1234512556 ->177- )'!& ' #("'' &'!&& ! %&!:"! !" :(!&A B%&%#J8!";&B)&#%''&("&$755G$!%'&7& ="255F8
08 & #""! 76 & 2553 )::" '! )%!" #&# )&# "%'%''""#&!"'C%&''"!)&-EK9; >=("&25538
48 )&# #'# !" $ C A"""%""& &E'!-%.E"'&"B ,&(" #" 	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
%!"'(%.E"'&"B ")!A&('%"#%&"(=& ''B""#%':"A&!.9"8)#'')&#'!%'"A ('&!AC"C'#%&":E&!":"#!'#(#&"'#)''"'%9&# )"#%&"(=&D9&##9&8
!"! )&# %&#' % )"%"'# '&(" " & % !'"B"&%%.E"'&"B '%'C&&'"("'#$755G8
/8 &#""!77(&"2556 ) ":!&#)&#B&' #'"'&='#8
758 )&# &%&#'# %& *'& '' + , :!&# !%%!"'"!8 !'$)!'&!")&''";&)"(""'#$!%'&>5!'!A&255>8
%&!"' &'":"' & E"&&9" #" '&"'' '# 74"2556 C'&BL
J%"("&!"C!" =!'''%#=!&'"!!#'' (74%!"' :"A&!.9"%!"'":'#''#%&":#(;& &'#&"#%&(")"!&
1234512556 -F177- 'B)"'#9&'"!("!"!'!':!&8'&"'' ::'# &' E&' ""'# $ %&" )'"#%&& %E."!'E#&%" ::'# ) ' %&" ) , !%9# .!&C' ' !":;&8 E&' &#'' &' "'":"' ' "#("'A' !::& #9' )"'&'"! #"' ?#'!&"' (&'"9 ' # '!' =!&#@8 ,! #'' %.E"B ' &"'"# #(!'"! %!"A & % 'E#&%'"B8 '' !' !& ' ! #'' %.E"B B" !'"'' ""''"!%E."B%!&::'&'&("B!B'$!(" ''!''"%'$::'&'"("'#%E."B!"''J8
(& #9' $ %&!#& !&&"& D =!& !"& 8 %.E!'E#&%' '''' "(& )&# %" =" 255F %!&#''#%&":"%!&''8
778 & #""! & !%%!"'"! 73 =" 2556 ) !:"&# B )&# %&#'"'%)::'"!"("') '%!("'""%&#'&$ )!'&!"%&''"! 8
728 72="'2556 )&#"'&='#&!&!'&"'#""!8,:!'& )''''"!!"&8 74"2556 ""B&&%%!&' & 74 " 2556 ::"& !::&"& ) #'' #%&": #(;& ' %&#'& &'&"' !" '!' ":''"! ("8 !";& B & % %.E"B '&!A C"C ' #%&": )#'' % &#""!%&'" 9&":&%%"'#'&("8 % .%'!'!!9"#%&"().' '!" %"%& &"';&&'": $)#E'&"''!:!&C&;9)&'(&"'D'&&' %"B) (!"' %&&"& 	";&' !(C '&"''8 !' ; !& $ )!'&!")&''";&(::'>5!(A&255>8
7>8 !!&&"&73!O'2556 ) %&#("&='&!&8
7F8 & #"'&"''%"0!'!A&255F #'#' 70!'!A&%& &"A#8'&&!9#&%!"A"'"!%&' %'"' #"#&#B)J"'!(!"&&!"&!%'"' !&B)" ("' !'& %&8 ! C%#&" %&!:"! "' B)" :' %&& #&"C %"' %'"' ' %&!#& C "('"9'"!#"&8)&#=%%B%"' !"' C9#&#J8 C%"B# &"A B)" C"'"' %"& 9&# :"A&!.9" 'B!''''"')&#)%DE'&("& D$ '%%&'" %&B)J)'%%A:!&"&)::!&'#"&J8& %&"&!:"&#B)"#'"')!&("9!'"#'A" %&&E'!!9,8
738 ,&#'#9&#$=9&8
1234512556 -3177-
+)
78 !"9(!"&P!&9"'"!="""&?@#'#!":"#'"'"'# ; 7&!O'255> &"A'!&!" !%!#3=9 !' %&#"' ' ("-%&#"' 3 %%#' ' 76 =9 & ?&'8 7 '8&'36 @8
,"'$P'"!P#'"!76=9& %& &"A:##& 20=("&255F? +7>5756@ & !"9(!"!%'# 7>:#(&"& "%!"'"!'&"'!"&&9'%&''' &"A'!& !" "#9& & $ '&!" =9 '"'"& P''' P#'"!!(C=9&8
28 !:!&#' $ )&'8 36 8 7 '8 E8 2 &"A '! &!"!*'"'"B!'''"!%&#($P&'836 !"&%&'"9##&&!"'&!"6!'!A&2555 ? @B"!'&'"($!"&P&-"(""'#7/="7/3/? @8 ,!%#'%!&=9&)%;'""#'A"8
>8 ' '&# ("9& 7& =("& 255> '&*' !":"'"! #9"'"( !'' &!"' )&-"(""'#8 %!"' ( '%!& !'%&""%%%"A&;9&!"'("9&!'!Q :"' =&""B' #'&"' !' %&!"' ' =9 & !":!%&""% %!&%%&#"& &)#'':"'&#"#$ '#'&"'#""!&!%%!"'"!"'"9"? +72/F!"8782N 76/!"87N>36!"87'&&D'"'#@8 B"!&%&!#&' $#:'&;9'&"'!"&!'&"& '!!&!)%%"'"! )%%"B' &#&( ; =!& & '&# ("9& ? + 770 /> !"86AN772>65!"8FN 7//4R>0%8>76!"8>A@8
F8 #%!# :!& ' #" %&#( %& !" %&#' &!& ' &(A ?&'865 @8
38 "'"9 %!&' & %!"' (!"& " )''"' $ '# !' !::& )&# %&' " &!*'& 'C )"(""'# ::"' %!& ='":"& )!'&!" %&''"! 8
68 P&'8F87 #:""'P"(""'#!#''""'"!%"'# 9" %&##%&'!!9&# B"&#'P''"'$'# %E."B !'%&!('P":"&"'#!9#"' P"!P "'8
1234512556 -6177-
08 C'&P&'82487 P&#&!"'$&'P"-'"("$ 6621>G!" $"-&'P"-'"("$35G!" !$ B&'&'P"-'"("$F5G!"8
48 &" ''"' $ '# %.E"B B" %(' ! ''"' %E."B %&!(!B&"(""'#P&'8F87 !!"''"!& S $ %&' " ' %&!%&' "' S !" %.E"B B" #B"('$"8!";&%!!#BP#'' %.E"B ": ! % ! ::'"! $ %&& E&9 %& P&-"(""'# ""'"! %"'# 9" B P&# %!&&"' %DE&:"'%&(A!(!!'#N&B"'C"9"A!"' D'& #'&"# " !A='"(' B %!"A !:!&#' $ !'&" #"? +752763N,2557%822F!"82A'&#:#&N:8" +7202/4!"8F":"@8
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
1234512556 -0177- #(#&"'#B )%!"'(!A='": "(&%"'#'&(" %' %&'"B' -!&#&("'"!!)C9#&'"!?, 255> ! 7 %8 2 !"8 >A1AAN (!"& " T - , !%8 "'8 %8 4> %#840(8@-%&"!A'D'&C"9#)&# !B)&"'D "%%!&'A%!&!"#'#? +752763N,2557%822F(8!"82A' &#:#&N + 7>5 >32!"8 2828> ' &&D' "'#N :8 " + 7202/4!"8F":"@8
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
; !& B) )A &#'' & % !'"B "9!'" '&!A !'!:!& !!&C ::"' % %!& ='":"& &!"' $ %&''"!)&!" ""!A$)C%&'%.E"'& &&9 !C )""B&$)""'&'"!?'=9"'"9@"' B&&#"%!&!&%.E"BB"-#9	' C &"';& '"!# %& =&"%& - " %&''' &!'& !&8 )9"' %!& " )#'A"& ";& !A='"( " !%' ' !'"''"! %.E"B )&# %' C&& '"("'# & &E# '&(" 9&#!&B)"&'? +7>5>32!"82828F8'&&D'"'#@8
%&" %!"'"! #" & '# %.E"B ' & &!& !' "%! )&# !'"'' A ""%A %!& '&E& B'"! ?=&""B@(!"&"'B&!%'C"9&"-"B)"'' !(&'!'(!!'#%!&&!'&!&'&#"'#9&& ! '&("8 & "A& %%&#"'"! !' " "%!' ?&'8 F5 + ""! ( )&'8 7/ N &'8 /3 8 2 ""! ( 77> ' 7>2 N , 2557 %8754 !"8 >@ )""'&'"! ' =9 &"' " "9!&& !'''"! :"' #" " :"& & '"'"! ' !"! #"&'"($%"'#?&#"@'&(" %&!#&$C %&#A&%&'"%!"'(&!"'&!"8
1234512556 -4177- )"%! %&'""& !&B )C%&' ''' ""''"! %"'# '&(":!#"B'&"9!'"'&!A!'!:!&!!&C8 ' "%%&'"'C'!&"'#""'&'"('="""&)C"& ('!'!"#"&")'"'"!#")"%"'#'&("%& !"#&'"!#9'##'#'&9&$)"(""'#?%&'""& :'&%.E!!"C'!"!-'&@B"!'%%&'"'%!"'( &!"? +7202//!"83N,2555%87F/!"8>@ ! " ""''"! ?%&'" ! '!'@ %"'# '&(" ' ='":"# %& &"';&=&""B#'&"'? +7>5>32!"828283@8
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
B"!&(&%&!A'P&%%!&'#" B"'#'&"' P' B %!"' "'"9"C "' :"' P!A=' P #' "&!'"# B &%%!&' :! & C !%' BP" %& #9' !"#&'"!%"'C%&"#%&%&!C"# BP""'#'##'A" %" !" P; B &"%'"! !'C' #" ' P%%&#"'"!"''"!#"!"'"&':"B!"! PC%&' !"' O' !'"(#8 &' P##' #'&"' %!& (& %&!A' P' " P!&"9" !. %&( " #"9'"! ! &%%!&' ! ! C%&'" " A ' A" ! !' ? + 723 >32 !"8> 722765!"87'&#:#&@8
1234512556 -/177- 758 )%; ''#"'&"''B#",!'"9!'"B# :"A&!.9"8 & !"! B' $ %"'# '&(" &(E "(&9'8& '!";&'::'B& %'"' %' % C&& )'"("'# &'"( & B) %' $ 35G !& B & ' + ::"&' B )&# %&#' "%"'# '&(" " & % !'"B"&%%.E"'&"B8
."&%%&$'B!&B)"%%&#"&%%!&'#'A"%& #"'&"'' =9%''!"''"&!%':"'B !)C%#&" #" '&"'' ' 9##&' " !' $ %&& %&'" %!& ! %'"' &"! &'"! !:" B" )"' $ &"&8 "" =&"%&!&%%!"C!'''"!:"'%&%#""'B)$ )%%&#"'"!)"%"'#'&("%&#":"? +723>3> !"8>A1'&#:#& 7//3 %8FFN 7/44%835F!"82@8
&% )9"' & E"&&9" " . " &%%& B)%.E"'&'%$D%&!!&&)"%"'#'&("B '&!A !'!:!& !!&C ! :"A&!.9" !' %'"A )'&*&8
)CA"""%""&!"'%&#",&%!&#' !"& #" ' &"!!9"B8 :! & C ""B !%' ' %& #9' !"#&'"! %"' C%&"# %& &!&'8 &%%!&' %& "& #'# #'A" %" !" );8 &"%'"!"''"!#"'!%%&#"'"!!'"&8#" !'C%&"#&)#(!'"!)#'''#""B&%"'#'&(" C"9"A ' !' O' !'"(# & %!"' (8 & !"! !' !E#&' ' !("' !&' B &%%!&' #" &%"' '!' !"'"! =&"%&'" %&''' " &!*'& %" :!& %&!A'8
778 &+)"9!'"B#'&!A%!"'(%.E"'&"B8 & !&%%!&'22=("&255F B'$"&' #%"! #%&": =& '!' &(' B)" #'"' &#""!8 ' #%"! #%&":&"';!&D'&!'"''":)!!&A""'#%.E"'&"B =&"%&8 !" B)" !"' + '" B #'' #%&": !'"'' ":''"! &#'"( )!%9' '&!A !'!:!& !& !&' B)" &"' :"& )!A=' ) "9!'" #%&#? +7>5>36 !"8>8>87@8
728 , %! ; !& B'"! #(' '& &"';& #'A" %& =&"%&8.$'#9&")C"&")&#&#"'%"&
1234512556 -75177- %&! ";& ::"' &B# B" :!&"' %&!!'" #:(!&AB"!&)C"9"A""'#)&%&")'"("'#%&!:"!8
&"';&&'":C::'"!!&%!&E&!"B?7@%%&*'!&#"# )&#!::&'%"%"&#'&!A''"B'#9##&'": &E"8
A"' &(E % %&' P"'#9&'"! !" '!' ":''"!("?2@8&+$'#9&&(#B))#'"' %"!# #'''&;'!&#%&:"8
."!''&B!& !#''#%&":'(!" &#""!8 "&"'-!%&&")#''%.E"B&"'"#")#E '&"'' ?> ' F@8 %%&*' "" B )&# ) % #%"# '!' &!&%''"(8
(B"%&#; :!&'!''&B'&!A%.E"B ":'' % ( ' #(#&"'# B ) %!"' ( !A='": " C' '!' " (& %"'# '&("8 !'&"& " . " )''& &';& C"9"A ) ::!&' (!!'# %&' ( &!'&!&'&#"#&&%&!'&("8 )A !!&A""'#%.E"'&"B )"%"'#'&("&#''''&!A)#( ::' $ ";& &"';& =&"%&'" ' ! % &9& !"!#"!'"';!&%!"A)#&'&8
)"'B&!& :!# !"'D'&&='#8
1234512556 -77177-
+)1 )*( + ( +)
23 4 -- 5 6 7 68 9 '&" +:
6 4 -
78 #&&!&&(A8
4
28 &=''8
>8 )#!' :"C#$255:&8 '"$E&9&!&'8
F8 :!& %&'" BP %(' :!&& &!& !'& %&#' &&D' #" >5 =!& ; !'":"'"! %& %" &!# &# &"A :##& & ,EZ"I&E!:B" 6 655F '&!" C%"&8 #" %' D'& %&!!9#8 #!"& !"'L @ ""B& C''B#""!&!&'#"&!A'"&"'%#""! ''B#N A@ C%!& %!& B !'": " '" %!(!"& & '' '& #""!N @ %!&'& "9'& ! ! &%&#''8 ," #!"& !'"' % '&!" ##' ##&# ! ''& @ A@ ' @ "- &"A:##&&%!&&%'&&'";&&&!&BP" (&#&&"&&(A8#!"&&!&'"!&!&!. %&( B" &!' =!"' "" B #""! ''B# ' P(!%% B#'#C%#"#&!&'?&'87>2 756'754@8 9&::";& &#"' &"-!" [ !&"\
!%"!:!&%&#'&&D''!'":"#C%&'"""BP$P::":##& &!"%&9&::
1234512556