Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATAS/1022/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/1022/2005 Generato dall'IA

Settlement Agreement Voidability Due to Unilateral Mistake Regarding Claim Value

Numero d'incarto ATAS/1022/2005
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Accolto (Allowed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The dispute centered on a claim that a prior agreement to settle a matter was voidable due to an alleged unilateral mistake regarding the value of a contingent claim involved in the settlement. The court reasoned that to invalidate a contract based on unilateral mistake, the mistaken party must show that the mistake concerned a basic assumption on which the contract was made, the mistake materially affected the exchange, and either the other party knew or should have known of the mistake or its effect, or the other party was not entitled to the benefit of the bargain due to the mistake's nature; here, the party seeking to void the settlement failed to demonstrate that the opposing party knew or should have known of the unilateral mistake concerning the claim's value, precluding rescission.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Settlement Agreement Voidability Due to Unilateral Mistake Regarding Claim Value: The court reasoned that to invalidate a contract based on unilateral mistake, the mistaken party must show that the mistake concerned a basic assumption on which the contract was made, the mistake materially affected the exchange, and either the other party knew or should have known of the mistake or its effect, or the other party was not entitled to the benefit of the bargain due to the mistake's nature; here, the party seeking to void the settlement failed to demonstrate that the opposing party knew or should have known of the unilateral mistake concerning the claim's value, precluding rescission.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
contratto unilaterale fine del processo ripetizione dell'indebito concorso di responsabilità nullità del contratto garanzia del venditore

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied for the determination of court costs.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

               "#$%$"&%%' ("#%&&"&%%'

(

 () )()  )   

*+ '

 &, -.+ &%%'



 ! $

"#$ !



"%$

& '   '  !( *2$ )*+%$,!-"%./0!,110 '  



           !

  435  



) /(

,6 $ 78%  ,/ 2*($#$ 4110!  ,9: );$  $#;  -$#:$ #%-$""*#("$ !*,<7#,<5.!% "#$ !*41"=%,<.4!>#"%$#*,."(;$ ,<<16

46 '")#22$578%-$*#%*! $#;-$#:$#%"$"* -$%8-$"#%#*-$%%#""$%#$(%$-$% " #%#%%#"  -$*("? -$"2#"6   %$#    $#; *!2#>@#-$":A-$%86

96 78%#("$%(*2##%#24.($#41106

56 '"#2"$%#"$##-$ $#;*!$#-" -$:&"%#"#%#%%#"--*%#(@-$%%#"#;$-8 -$"(%   B$#) $ @ "%%  01@C0. 2$6 .1 % @ -$%%#"#;$-8-$"(%+"##@"%%0@0<<2$6 /1 A  %  @%$*  2"$  )" 78*  #("$6  %"%   -$%%#"@*:(A0.@50.2$6916

06 $"$$#$0"%";$4110! $#;*#2"$*DE*-"D!( "-# A  &"%#" #%#%%#" --*%#( !   >@# --$%#$ A @#%#%%#"-$*("?$%$2*$$$"-%;">* $"4C@44C2$6,0$-$*%%"#%#*-$%%#" "$%#  $6  *#  4C "%";$ 4110  *%* "$* D DE*-"D! -"$*%$#$$-$%8!2%*"%#@"%-2#%86

) (

,6 @$%6 40   "# 2**$ $  #;$ -8   -$*("? -$"2#"!(##!$(#(%%#(##%*,/*;$,<<9F&G! %$*(#8$,$7(#$4111!$:8-$"*$#("$6"$> "7"#%"%-H"$$-$%%#""$%#A-$%8$F$%6,44% ,49 " #(#E G!78##("$"-*%%@$%6/96 ,"#2**$$-$*("?-$"2#"407#,<C4FG!"#%A :( $#;%"$"#-#,$"=%4119!"#%! -$:>@22#$#*%*%$#F$%6,54 G!D*%$@"22#-$%8$ ;*$*-$%#%#"*%$#*-$78#("$.

    3,.1.34110 935  



46 '"@$%644 &F"(%$(#8$-#,$7(#$4111G! #("$!-$%%#""$%#>#$%$#8"%-$%8* "2"$*%D$%6,44!,49!,5,%,54 I$%69A0&@--#>% -$"8#"%%A%$2*$$F6,G6"$)>"7"#%!-$%%#" "$%#A-$%8$"$$-"A#22*$%$-$%%#""$%#!8%*  ("#$  #;$ -8 D#%% *(%%  "%  #("$! %  -$%%#"  "$%#! 8%*  ("#$  #;$ -8 D#%% *(%%"%"#"$#8F26$%645&G6"$ !"7"%A-$%%#""$%#%A@("#$#;$-8D#%% "%"#"$#8#%*$J%"%#("$F & ,4C491I &,4<555G6

96  H-:!  78  -$#:$ #%  "$"*  -$%8 -$ "#%#*   -$%%#""$%#$6%-$%#%"%!H-$%! $#8!,."(;$,<<1%H%$-$%4.($#4110!%A> 78%#("$%(D*%"#$6

'"  #2"$%#" $## -$  $#;  *!  -$%%#" ># -%$#8-$$%0.@50.2$691"%@%$* 2"$)"78*78%#("$66 ##!$"#%A"DE *-""%%4C@444C2$6,0!$-$*%%"#%#*-$#$"%%6

56 "2"$*% A  7$#-$! -#  7"$ *%$#% -"$  -$%8 7>@ "%  %$2$%   -$%%#"  "$%# "   $!  "7"#% #("$* ;**2###$  %% -$%%#"  $"#% A  #%*$J% "-%"#$ $  "%%  E#6  #%*$J% "% *  %D ## *8 " @$%6 ,4  @"$" $  -$*("? -$"2#" (##! $(#(% % #(##%*  ,C ($# ,<C5 F 4G " "  %D $*8%#$! # #E# % -*$#$ F & " -;#*  9.314  ,C 7#% 4119G

06 *"%$-$K!-$"*$*%%8$%#%F$%6/964% C<L6,"#$-$"*$##%$%#(,4-%;$,<C0G6



MMM

    3,.1.34110 535  



  (/  () )()  )   



01-2-++ 3  4-- -  5! #$& 6

,6 (#%&"%#"#%#%%#"--*%#(A%$2*$$!"-%"#$  ! N 0916.4690,6,0<3111!  "  4C@44C 2$6,0 A  > %":(!"-%NL9414640611" 6

46 (#%&"%#"#%#%%#"--*%#(A($$!-"%%! #%*$J% "-%"#$    "#*$%! :  4. ($# 4110 7>@ "%%$2$%6

96 H?"%%>;"#6

56 #%>-$"*$%8$%#%6

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

    3,.1.34110