Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATAS/1017/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/1017/2005 Generato dall'IA

Jurisdiction and Breach of Fiduciary Duty Appeal Dismissed

Numero d'incarto ATAS/1017/2005
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Accolto (Allowed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The case primarily addresses the jurisdiction and findings of a lower tribunal concerning various alleged breaches of duty and contractual obligations between the parties over several years, culminating in an award of damages. The court, after reviewing the evidence and prior rulings, determined that the lower body had the jurisdiction to hear the dispute, rejected arguments challenging the finding that a fiduciary duty existed and was breached, and affirmed the factual basis for the financial determinations, concluding that the findings were not plainly wrong, thus dismissing the appeals.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 108 al. 1 let. a LTF, Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Jurisdiction and Breach of Fiduciary Duty Appeal Dismissed: The court, after reviewing the evidence and prior rulings, determined that the lower body had the jurisdiction to hear the dispute, rejected arguments challenging the finding that a fiduciary duty existed and was breached, and affirmed the factual basis for the financial determinations, concluding that the findings were not plainly wrong, thus dismissing the appeals.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
violazione del dovere determinazione della competenza fiduciario risarcimento contrattuale del danno causa dell'obbligazione audizione delle parti

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 108 al. 1 let. a LTF

Used to declare the appeal inadmissible on procedural grounds.

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied for the distribution of court costs.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

               #$%&%#'%%( #$%$)#'%%(



  * *   *

+,  -  " '. /0  '%%( 



 !"#$#%&   $ '($))*($)"

$

++     , --    ! $"( )"()./01 #$234!5355   56

                  !"

   %3758%  

 1

59   :%#; < ,(=! (  56 >? 5/24! ) $$( $!$$)'$$)'($@"$ !$?$)#3A$ 5///"""B?#'$#C - 9

39  53 ?"@ 3883! '(  ?(! )  ) )  $?$( ) "B?!  D )'? 548 E 508 F $ $  *"$ )  )9

69 2)("@3883! !"()$$$)'(!$$$() "@D!D$$D)(G$$H$#$()$? $$);53?"@38839

29 58"3886! !I"$D!)##$"()  ?$ *'  "@ GG$(  ?"@ 3883 ?$ "  (?) ) $; "#$$ ( )(D(($?9  #$$ #($$ ) "@$D DI )  $J$ ) ( )(D(($? (?; " "D)"#)*'J$IDI)(@$$9  #$$  #$ # #? $?9  '. ?$ # ) $$"$ #(G*E##9

49 32"3886! !#($ID!)##$ "()E)"))-KD$)$(!%")#$) D)C - 9;?*L#$$#($!#;#)28 ) $?J ) G! ) ( )(D(($? J$M""$ "#$$ ) $ ) ($D )   "@ * $ $H(  (#) ) "@$D DN  ?"@ 38839 $"$!  '.  # ) .)" ) "  #$  .)" ?$(@ "@ ? $(E'GG$$E$$)@$#D(9 $)$!$$"$ )$$."#$"$*$#$$$"$(?(9'#$() $?  $$ * "B? " #H$ $$ $ )(G$?!  * ) I$ ($$J$M""$ (?( )$?J)G ?GG$ $#$ )) ID9$?)#$(!'$%E%)($$GG$#$)ID #H$JD@!"E$"##$O9

P9 56"3886!'(*)#$$)' 9

09 5>3886! $$$()"@$DDI)$ #$($$"?9

Q9  32 >$ 3886!     )  ##$ "() # '  $$$$)"@$D-5$2DI:);$"$)(G$2DI=! ()(D(($?"@(?;!$()($(J:2DI!



758/873884  %6758%   ")" 4 DI=! J$I DI)(@$$ $)'#$() $? $$9  #$ ($$ "@ $  #$$  #$ # #? $?9

/9  2 #$"@ 3886!      $$$( * '($$ ) $( ($$ $( $$$*'$?$(E48R)#$(D($$#@9

589 33?3882!##$)()#$$#G)'GG$ ) '%?)$( :%#;< ' = ;? *! ? '$$$) ) '(! )"#G$$)*($*'$D  @$$ E  (I9  "  ? )  #$( ) $? ) 48 R @$$ E  )D()'?)$()P3R!"#$$)')()$D@)34R9

559 #()' )6"3882$E'$)')"%$)53 ?"@ 3886  65 )("@ 3886 # )' $%*$ ) $ G)(   )D()'?)$()P3R9

539 )J)()58A$3882!' $.(E'()"%$) 5?"@388665)("@3886*')"%$"#("$ # >$ $ );  5 >? 3882  $%*$ ) $!  *' $% *$)$"#("$#>$9

569 54?"@3882! ($E )#(?.) $$*'($$($()$$*#$$?$*')"% $  *  )D( )'?)$( )" # '  ($$ ) P3 R 9  $ ) PPR($$##I)($(9

529  5Q ?"@ 3882! '(  G$ ##$ J )( ) '  ) 58 A$ 3882  #($ *'E  $ )  )( )     )?$ II  "# # @? E  @ ?$J  * ($$ "#@ "#$$)($$9

549 #;%?@)' )53>?3884!;?*'(G"? S)()' A$3882$?G$##$#$)* ?$D(*'$*"$)$E$)48R9

5P9  3Q >? 3884!     ($ E '  *! @>$?"$!  #$$  #D$ ) #  # " *'@>$?"$   $$ # ) ID"$###$J)D$)($32>$38869

509  58"3884!'  G"('(*'(J"$)? '))?>)*9

5Q9 54"3884!'(($E' *'($$E588R?)9



758/873884  %2758%   5/9  50 " 3884! '   >$( '##$ ) '(  ?$ *  "()%$$$G"$*''.?$#)ID"$)'($$)$( )#)()' )58A$38829

389  53 ? 3884! '(   $  )(  ##$ ) '  #;) @$)?$*'I$$ $ ?  "() * '?$ J"(!  ?$ $ %"M" # )$ )  D?$( )   !   "()!   ($$ ( "")'#)/89

359 58"3884!' >$)##$*'$"$ )'#$()$?)48RG)$'##($)  E*'($$(?"())' 9'##$($$$)?" '?$##M$?*(G$)#?)$G$))() 58A$38829

339  P > 3884!  @ ) (  $  ) ) "#$ #)#$$)'*M$)* ($( $)9

$)((<LS$)48R!$G92889%#"9 '$?()$4ITC - """B?$#)$32 IT  (D"$"""B?9 ?"@3883!>'?( D?;D)548E508F!'?#$(54";$!>'  $)  *"$ )  )9 # ! > ' ( )'? ) ) )  )9    "' )$ * >'?  ) )' #)/89'#$?()#""$U>'))9 $">(>"#";#$>G#GE"D#"G *3P$*$(D"$E' 9)'"#$#G9) #) # ""$ # ) "()"$ "  "' ) ) )D$?9'$"$#?$()$?' "')("(  )$ ) ##($ )GG($ E " (D)9 '$" * > # $?E48R"G)$??$(!*>'#) '$$$))' 9I$M$J"(#"())' O9

' )((<L' $"#$)'?)"()$$$!* #$  "#$ $$  #$ ) '(9 'J#$  - $ *"$)())$)'?"()J$)$!$ "$#G?@J(*'?)"()$$$O9

    )((< L9  $  $$"$ IT " )#2%4#)"@D%$D!'$%E%))))@ ))$>"@9'D$))D$))#$I!)$I!'$%E%) ) '$I )  )* $?$(@J9  ' "%"M" )(    9- $$$$$@9 $$"$#)D($)



758/873884  %4758%   #I.$I(#$)$D*9'#?"$"(('($$)$(9 $?$()@V$"$"#H$"#@#"#$$9 ?I! $?$(#$)ID?)$)(#"$"#H$"#$@9  )') ? '##($ )    )   )' $?$( #@ (D; J( E 48 R9 '>$ * 9  ' # )'$ G"$*)"B?)@V$"$!"#H$)GG*'# J$$?$(9!"$?$$")$#J $?$(#G9.D"#H$)GGO9

369  52 > 3884!  % &   ,$ $$( #  )(G ) $(M$)$$*)(#"#($9

P>$!68A$$3/#$"@3884!$(#D$))( #($(9

54?"@3884!&  "#($(?$*,(  ?$  G ),$ * "B? $ *, .D ($$ )#$(!  ),$$ *  ($$ ,($$ )(D)(   # #.I*  * ,"#MI$ $$"$ ) $?9  (*!  ?$ )$ E  $ ),?)$( $;9

329 $$($($($"E,$"(#G"$$D)(E>D9



 

59 D?'D$>):=($(")G($$$(!); 5A$3886! @$)!"#()4>D! )$#()$$?%#()$!4##($$5P>D:$95$9 $4P =9

-$E'$)'($)5P>D!# @G()( 30>?3882: +56858P=!) D?)#$(!56G(?!  )#$$$D$#"$$$ @$)  ) (D   E $ >D $$! ! ) '$$$ ) '($)?J>D9

-"#($#>D))'#;$($@

39 G()(#$D(())$))P$@ 3888: =$$(?D5>?3886!$H$")G$ )"@)#$(D))")9- #"$(!#$)?*)$,##*)$M$$I(E"; )##*;D##@$?D""$U



758/873884  %P758%   G$>)*"$)($"$$#)$: +568368)95951 664)95931 +53/2)95931 +5302P0)95!53P56P )92@$(G(=9;D)#()*$E,##*$ (?);>)$(?D: +550/6)9P@!5536P8 )9 21    5//Q W 60 #9 65P )9 6@=9 ;  * '#$( ) $?E'D)'?)$()(@$(53?"@3883$'$#D(  $$ '( 3886!  .   )')"$$ *    '##*   )'#;9$)"M"!);5>?3882!))#$)? )35"3886")G$G()(,?)$()5/>5/4/ % :2;"(?=!);*)(##$($()50" 3884!$*)$)#$$$(?D5>?3882: + ) 53 #$"@ 3884!  462782=! ($$ #(( *  ## )(?##( >*, 65 )("@ 3883 #  >#)  "$; )(?$ ) ,?)$(?$?)$(!*$,"#) ) 2;"(?) : +568624)9692=9

69 $>$(  $"# $ )?$  >)$ "#($$!   $ ?@ :$94P95$9I93$P8 =9

29  *$)?@$( )'##$) '(! G"(5Q?"@ 3882E'$))()'$"()58A$3882#$$?$!? ')$D9

49 J$")$9PEQ !$(#$(#$()$?$$#$!$$  #$! ) '#$$) ) '( E "# )  #G   )" )'$?$(  $? * #$ @"$ M$ JD( ) !  $$ #$ ($ )' $$$ E  $( #I.*! "$  #.I*9   )'#$( ) $? ) D )(! '$?$( * #$ M$ JD( )  #$ ?)'$#G)'$)")'$?$(:$9P=9

$(#$(#$()D$$)"$)'"@)'#$) #@$()D)'("I()$?(*@())" )'$?$(!$$)"$($)'$$$E$(#I.*!"$ #.I* $ *' #$ #;  $$"$ $  " ) ()#$$ JD@:$90=9

$ (#$( ?)$( '#$( ) D $$  #$ * $ #("( #"$)D)(:95=9("$?$($? $(#$(?)'#($$$$$E$(#I.*!"$ #.I* * #?* #@@"$  #$( ) D $$  #$ :9 3=9  ( "> * 'JS$ # )'$?$( $? ? )'M$ $$$)$(#I.*!"$#.I*$)$#$M$JD( *'J$$(#$(?)'$$$"#MI)'"# $?JI@$:96X$9Q=9



758/873884  %0758%   P9 - '$9 3Q 9 5 )   G()(  , ?)$( ) 5/ > 5/4/ : =)$?D>*'65)("@3886!'()$E $$;'$?)EPP376R"!E)"%$'$?) E48R"!E*$)$'$?)E28R"1) #(@!'(#$!)'#;'$93Q95@ !#($))"%$ '$?)E28R"9

-'$93Q95 !)$?D);5>?3882!'( )$E*$)$'$?)E28R"!E)"%$,$ ?)E48R"!E$%*$)$,$?)EP8R"$E $$;,$$?)E08R"9

(?$J)'?)$(!?*'($#@$''($$ #?)$"#(?*'#$@$JS$'$?$(* #$ @"$ M$ JD( )  #;  $$"$ $  " ) ()#$$!"I()$?(*@(:$95P =9

-  >#)!  $ )'?)$(!   ) )$ )  ! $  $ ("* $  "()1  $  (* ("*@>$?)'#$(G$*'"#$)'(?: + 558  304 )9 2! 584  380 )9 3=9 *'  ) '$?$( ) '(!  )( ("* G$ )(G$!  .   )  G)   )()')"()!)"U#"$$$)'(?#$( ) $? ) '$(( ) ) $?$( @"$ JD@ : + 554  566)93!58454Q)95=9

 "# ) ? 'GG$!  ;D D((!  IGG$  J$"$*#@"$$))J?$G$$' ? '$!  )GG( #"$$$ )   $J )'?)$(9   "U?#?$M$IGG(J$"$!)?$M$$"( )'#;(("$)#$!#;*'"#$ ?##J"$?@$:"($I)D(()"# )?1 +53Q68)951 +58256P)93$3@=9

(?D),?)!.!G"("$E>#)@ ($@! )  (G( J )( $$$* : *M$    $$ )  Y --Z= * ,( , # # ),$?$( $? : + 53P 0P )96@7$@@1-3883#9PQ)96@=9

*?),?)$(?(@)$$$* ".! $ "#MI"$ ## E  # ) ,?) :"$$ (  I)#! VD! ( ) ?! $$(7$(D ),$$ ) (> $ $J ),#$= JD$ * , ()  "$$ )   @$ : + 53P  0/ )9 4@7=9  $ ()$  )?$ # M$ GG$( ) "; I("$*! " )?$ $ "#$ ) ,"@ )



758/873884  %Q758%   $ )  #$! $  )  @$ ) )($"! E #$ ) )($$$*!?),?)*#($"J"? ("*JD@)$?$("#$@?#$()$?() ),$((: +53PQ8)94@7@@=9)()$D@"J"") 34 R    $$$* #"$ ) $ "#$ ) )GG($ (("$ * #?$G?),$?$($?: +53PQ8)94@71 -3883#9P2=9

09 '#;!$"()$($E'J$)'#$() $? ()$ ) '(! )  $?$( (D;9 !    $$$  32 " 3886 *  $ #$ J  $? )#$(! E $"# #$!($$GG$#$)ID92#$"@3886!  "$*'$?$(E48R)#$(D $#@9 G! $)  )  P > 3884 #  @ ) (!  "()% $$$ ) $!     ##?( '##($ )     ?$ *' $?$(  #$ ) ID ? ) $ )(#"$($$"#$@!$$#($*'#$)GG* #$$! "#$ $ )  G"$ ) "B? $  "$?$ ()$ E $?!#("$J$$?$(9

Q9 ?)*#(;)!.)*$$"()"$ #$ E $? E 48 R )  $?$( (D;!  #$ ) ID! ? ) $)(#"$$($$GG$9

/9 -'D$ ) '$"$ ) )D( )'?)$(!   GG$( # '$"(! )'$$(#$!#$*'M$G"();*'$$ "#$)'$?$("#$(#($$?J(E48R3886!# )G93Q,/269%*)()$D@"J")34R ($(#((!@$$E???)$()G935,0809%9 "#(    *  $ $ DD(  3886 ) G9 4P,6QP9% % $ G932!54)'I3886X)D()'?)$($)P5!4R!)EP3R9

589 '$E>$$$*' $.($$E48R)5 ?"@ 3886  65 )("@ 3886   @ ) '$9 3Q 9 5   )  $ ?D>*'65)("@3886$$%*$)$ );5 >?3882!##$)?$)'$93Q !?D); 5>?38829

559 G!  $ ;D! )  ); ($! *  ($$ ) $(! $""$   # #.I*!  $ DD?( $ *, $ )  G$ $$"$#@)$?9 $(D)!,$950 #(?$*$J )'?)$()@((G)$@$")G$$@!$$! )'GG   )")! (?( # '?! E ? D"$(  ()$  (*!   ##"( :9 5=9  "M"! $$ #$$ )@



758/873884  %/758%   )(  ?$ )' )( $(  G $! )'GG   )")! D"$(  ()$  (*!   ##"(   $ )$)(#)$$ID$$@"$:93=9

"@);$!,$"*)$),(?) $),?)$($((!),$$($"(),$)")9  GG$!  ")G$ ) ,($$ ) $( ? #$("$ E  )( $$*(!#$M$#"#$# @)(9

539 $$!#$*'M$>$(9



758/873884  %58758%  

  1 *  * *   *

"

23/4/   5  6// /  78 $+' *!9

  4/ 

59 (?@9

" 4/

39 >$$9

69 G"  #$ )  *' #?$ G"  $  #($ M$ )  )( ) 68 > );  $G$ # # "")( )(  @ G()( ) ! -IKTIG* P! P882   !  $ J"#9  )(  #$ M$ #D(9  "(" )$< = )* J$"$*)($)(@$$#))( $$*(1 @= J# # * "$G  $" #? )") $$ $ )(1 = #$  D$   )  #($$9 -  "("  $$ #  $ (("$ ("((  $$ = @= $ = %)!  @G()()##$"$;*' )?)(?@9"(")"$". ) #?! * $ >$!  *  )( $$*( $ '?## ) *($(J#()($:$9563!58P$58Q=9  DGG;<  #()$<   .- ( 

#G")#($M$$$G(J#$*'E'GGG()( )#DGG



758/873884