State Environmental Liability Causation Requirement
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe lower court correctly dismissed a complaint seeking to impose liability for contamination under a state environmental statute, finding that the plaintiff failed to demonstrate that the defendant's disposal activities were the actual cause of the contamination found at the site, as the evidence only established that the defendant disposed of similar, but not identical, materials on the property years before the contamination was discovered and the statutory language required a direct causal link between the defendant's acts and the specific pollutants found.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 al. 2 LTF; State Environmental Liability Causation Requirement: The lower court correctly dismissed a complaint seeking to impose liability for contamination under a state environmental statute, finding that the plaintiff failed to demonstrate that the defendant's disposal activities were the actual cause of the contamination found at the site, as the evidence only established that the defendant disposed of similar, but not identical, materials on the property years before the contamination was discovered and the statutory language required a direct causal link between the defendant's acts and the specific pollutants found.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the final orders concerning the allocation of court costs.
Cited in the final orders regarding the allocation of court costs for the respondent.
Testo completo
#$%&'#(&&) #$&&*#(&&+
!!
, !-, . ,! .-
( / 0 (&&+ )1 /2 0
3333333333 ! " #$ % &&'"(" &""
.44- . 5,!6-7--$ & " "( )*+$,-,,./,0
! "
4-1,04
4-
,5 ,*637,!"8888888888 /"( '"995%:& "($" &/"&(& ,*;*5
-5 ,<$" 7("&"99& &%(&" $":" ( "" '"""(= & /"& ""5
05 .,3$%" (( (799"&%( >?5 ,6$"% 9 ( /" >?5 & % :">( 7 (&" "/" ( 9"702@ 7>>&)(5( (((,+$ ,;",5%> "&?>&&"99%7 &" 7%& "79$,;5
<5 &%A " ( :" & & 0 9(/" ,; 8888888888$ ?">"$ 7 % " & BC $ " '% " ,+$ %( (7 "$&%A"& /"$&&& " "/ & %( >?5 " / &% >"'$&% "4"9 " &%"9" "'""( (&"( % ( (" "5 "& &&4("A ( (&"> "'(5( "" :,+( " & "99 :: " "5 %(/ " 4( " % ( ( ' 9/:5 %" & ' & 9 "/ & : (" >? " (5 ,;$ :"" ( "/ & %( >?( " 9 "" (4: "> 7"%?"D 4$ " ">" & & "' 7 "/47 4 ( (> (/" " E :"" "&%(A:" &5 (&" 7 " &% " )& & (" ?" 4?( & "": " &% "/" ( 9" ' & "995 "( ' %"" ( & /" ( " "'" &>F".0$9< G5
35 ,$ 58888888888 ( ' %( ( " ": &%A "/" ( & "99 F". < G " ' ( ( " ":&%(" "F".-90 G5-H" ,$"%'"9"( & ""F".090 G5
65 &(""&% &,+-222$%(( (":((9"&% ". &I"/"&" ( " &% ( " ($ :&%&>(&%"/"&" (&+2@$/99 ,H",+5
+5 /:-22,$ (&& (/""& ( ( >>( %/"& 588888888887/( ("" (5 &"& & & ,3/"-22- /" / " $ & &". /"" "
1,+231-220 401,04 "&% :-22259"(&"> "((& ( (/( " (& /"("&702@ '"99F".690 G5
;5 &%:/ " 9" ( :" & & 6 &(: -22- 7 " ( ("& & /" & +2@ & "" ("' F+2@&& " ,22@&& & /"(>(G$&"(>$( ("('%(&/" (/" & ?> "" ' /A (( " "9 ""' & /": " %99 ? 5( " ( ("/ J9K>$ " ("'$ " "/"F)(&"$AG$ /"&: "5 ( ( /( ' %( ( " & : " &$ "/ ?)"' FL "$ ("" &" " & > G '% "/ ((: F("$: "$" (7"/& ?("'G"/ " F / " . ":G5 8888888888 9"( ' %( ( " "" ( & %" & : (" 4& & %?"D ""'&/ (( " "9""' &/": " (>".FK>AG5B"$" "( " :""( $&? &"" " "($%(&/" /" /"7" / & &+2@& "/" (& (F".,2$93 G5
*5 ,6&(:-22-$% "'(7%(H &&(""A &'"" 7(" "&%( & ( 7" (& /"&+2@& "/" (& (5 A&%"/"&" (( " &.9"A(7 03$<@$ /" 0*@ A"$ '" %/" &" 7 & " & %4"/"&" (F".6$9, G$
,25 "&-;&(:-22-$%( ( (" "&( & ( "" (%/"&58888888888$'"%/" ((7"'"5
,,5 " '8888888888/" &(H7( ("" ($% %?" ( ( & &&(""9& &-+H/"-220" &. 9" & " & 9(/" -220 " %99 "9 &% (/ " "5
,-5 " & -3 9(/" -220$ %( 9( " " && ( :" &%99 "95
,05 02H"-220$&(""""& " "$% H ('= ( :" &%99 "95
,<5 &("" " " & 0, H" -220$ % 9"( &("" & "& "5
,35 * : -220$ %( " H ( 5 .> ' ' 58888888888( :"%/"/ " & &"?(5
1,+231-220 4<1,04 ' (&"( ( ". (&">(:&%?"/ & & %( & &("" "" " &% " & 5 & ' 5 8888888888 /" "&"'( , ' ( ( " ": &%(" " " " '%.( "&H/" :,$ " &"5 %"&&"$ &" "9" (&"& (&" >((" $ 8888888888$ &% ( "" &% "" ( & /"5 "$ ./ ' "/" ((%99" & "/" (" (( " "/= ' %:/ " 9" &( ( '%" &/" ("( (/" /A(( " "95 9"$' &>(&%"/"&" ($"9" ''% % :( & / & "/"& " ("( ,<$ (& '"( (= & /"& ""5&&' / "/"&" ( " :( %( ,0 ( "( -22-5 7 ' " " &>( &%"/"&" ( & <-$;@ & %"& " 9 ".$&<<@& 5
,65 /" (7$% $&(/"&+ :-220$H & 5 '$ %>" &% (& & (/""$ " /" & 9" '%"( " &&("""" "A " (> 7 %(' & &("" " ">"5 " '% (" " & %( & ( & " / &" &("" & ,+ -222 / / " & > &%:/ " 9" ("(&-, :,+/:-22-$& " ' " (("&& /"&%( &+2@& & (5
,+5 " & ,6 &(: -220$ &" / "9" ( &8888888888 '/ (( " "9&( &/ (: 4"&"'(5
,;5 / "9" (&" & ( & - -22< ( ( &(($ &% "" (& /"5
,*5 " & -3 -22<$ " & !& 8888888888$ ( & %($"9( ":&('" "&" &"/&/ ,2.?:& ": '(&&"//" ( (&& % & &("" ". &%4"/"&" ($ & M ' " & /" " " & " & (/) 9" ( " N >:O&/" = (>(5
-25 "&,2"-22<$ &" / "9" (&" &%"" ( & /"5
-,5 58888888888( ( & ":&(,*P -22<5 "$ " 9"( ' &". /"" & " " -0 : -222 '%" /" & ( :" : & &"5 /""
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
--5 " & ,2 : -22<$ &" " "9" (&"A&8888888888$%(? &/:-2207H" -22<$ ' /""" ( &/ (( " "9 &/ (:" 4"&"'(5
-05 " & ; : -22<$ " ( & " & 5 /' &( " & 5 8888888888$ " A (" " & " " " / " ?">" ( "$ ">( /" 9" / & : / ( (>( ' %" " & " /" ?)"'$ ( (H" " "& 5 = & %"" ( &%A ' '% "/" ('" 5
-<5 % $ " & ,2 : -22<$ (> " ( & "5">( '58888888888$")" &=(/ "&%( & (&%($' 9"("
1,+231-220 461,04 "&%:/ "9"&6&(:-22-5 .$" 7 A&%"/"&" ("9("7<2@ 7%A"& &" 7 5 >>. 9" & /" & A"&" &%(7&&(& "&%&9"5
!.-
,5 " >/" %>" " H&""" FG ( ( &"9"( " " ($ &. , P -220$ ": & " F BG$ (&"'H>$& ("& /"4("& $"'( "DH>F 5, 5 36 G5
B" 7% "&%( "&"DH> ":9(&( F QG-+H/"-22<F Q,02,26G$& ">/"& ($ ,09(/"$&"" " " "> F 5,6-G B & "(> $ 7 " H> " "$ & % & %( " & /AH>5
B & &" :"$ Q $ & = & ,H" -22<$9"(' &"" " " " " " " " ( " $&L $9&" 9(&(F Q,02--6G5
-5 " 9(&( " >(( & &" & " & 6 :-222F G ( /"> , H/" -220$ L &"9" "&:&"" "(>&&"& "5 B ("$ " & /" ' &" I"' &" = ?(7".&""'.>": /"> M 9" H"&"' &( " &" F Q,-+<6+"&5,$,-6,06"&5<: (9(G5 /?$ '" (&$ 7 &(9 & .> " " "$ / &" I"' (/ &. H & ( /">F Q ,,+ *0 "&5 6:$ ,,- 062 "&5 <R ! ,; S 0+ 5 0,6 "&50:G5 I '" (& & , H/" -220 " &" . & &/ ": ( ". &I" (>"/.>&(& & &"" "&(& &&"99( "("&"9"( 5
1,+231-220 4+1,04 %$&(""&(/""& &"&H/"-220 9" ' ("5.$&"" "& ": ' 9&5 " '%" " $ 9 ' $ ".$.> H"&":H'%5
05 ": & ( ' $ " H ( " F 5 62 5, G /:95
<5 ( " "> ' " & /" " %"/"&" ( & %( % &"9"(&".7"9&" 5
B% 5<,5, F& /">H'%0,&(:-22-$ ": %.G$ " %"/"&" ( &% :((9""" & &"9" & ". 7 "9 &" 7 $ 4" $ %/"$ > ($ (&" "(5 ?> " & " $ 7 &"9" &>( &%"/"&" ($ & &" 7 $ & " 7 (/""&4"5" &/"" ?> % &" &" = ?( 9" '%"( " &&("" "" " & " (> 7 %(' & &("" " ">" F Q,-306*"&5-R Q,,-0+-"&5-: 0*2"&5,:G5
(>&$H"&("'%"99" 'I" "$&( "?>(I "$" ("( F ,*;+"&5,50;G5 ""$ (" " (&" &"99( & I99 ' I A"> & I( '" /" 'I" : &I99 ( (( & H> & / ( ?> & " F ,*;35003"&5-G5
35 G %.$ " %>" & " " & %( '% ( " ,+-222$& &".&(""$7'"( " " &&(""&(/""$" /-+H/"-2205
" & / ?)"'$ &"> " % ?>(5 7 A" " " ( & /" & %( % ("(5 ( :",3/"-22-5
:G/: & 99 "/ H 7 "5 ""' ./ $"(/. &" "&M" 99"( ' " " /" F" ,2G " " ' ( ( ""F" ,G4& &/" >"' ""'%" ( ": & /"5 " $ (&" "&"'( ' %( /"" 7 02@ ' "99 ' %( " &" " (5 9"$ $ " &" & &" " /" ( :" /"/ " $:&?"/ & A(" 9" >(($ '" % & " 99"
1,+231-220 4;1,04 >& & A"> ( H"& ". & & (&"A "&"("" (& /"&%(5
/" &'""&":(" "&/$ H>(//&".. ">$= "(& .> 95 &" & A" :H "/ ) & /$ ' '% " /$ " &("& " & 7 &"" " & H> /:&" " ">"A5B" (&"A &" "$" ?%99"(" %:&/ "&"'"'"9& ""(&" T '% F Q,-303,G5
%(( &(""9 / : &% "9" (&" % " ">""9" '%"" &(">( A "(&"$ ": :" 5 '" &( " $% '" " ">"A " " 9" %:H &%( &9"($' 9&& A $ '%" (> "&( " " A"($'%"" ( (( :"""&&"F.G$' &" " & A (&" " " 9"$ ' " & %A " :" "/(F Q,--,62"&5, (95G5%A "&" = 9&( & " . & &"> " ("$ = >U 7 &"" /" & " ( & ( A? "/ ('"/' A ' " ( F5 ! $ %A "(&"B"J "9" 4AA">&'" ( V$ " B?W"D"? "?>D" ?"9 $ 6+1,$ 5 0+G5 = $ X A '% A " &" = . ' A 9" $ 7 " A ( A ' " (5 &" = (?":$ ? & " & &" FYX $ W >&"? &B?/ Z&">$" ,536+G5
& 5 8888888888 (& "9 7 " .5 % ' Q H>('% (&"( :""' : &I &" I/" & / : ' ' "4" " 99" &I(" " (&" '"$ $ 9& A &I(F Q -0012-&,<H"-22<"&505,R ! -22, [<0;50<3$,*;;[3650+2"&53:G5 % %.5
A A" " &( 9 & &" "$ &%( :" 7 ' A " ( & /" & %(./&("J./"A"'('%( & ( " "" & M N" %( " ( ("(O$ " (&( '% (/ "( " &=" /&"&".( "5 " & '" (& /"& '"99 E '" % ( E ' " "/" ( 4"&"'(5
1,+231-220 4*1,04 (&" H" " " & A '" (&( 7 %:/ " 9" & %(J " L ' &" &" (/" / (( " "9$ ?> / ? 5
G /" 7 ( & ? / : & %:/ " 9"7'( ("%(5 99 $ "9" (&"A 7 "> & (/ " ( & >"5 I"/"&" ( ( " ("' (&"$ " . (&"4 ?("' '" &( " $ " (" & I " 7 (" (&>"F95>"$ ! ,,,02 5-+-"&50:R/"" Q,,<0,<"&50G5 "" A&I"/"&" ( 9& (" / A &I"" ( 9 " &( "( (&"R (' ("' :H "/ & I"" (9 "'I"" &I(/F Q,,2-+3"&5<G5
" " " & %4"/"&" ( & 9 " & ( &((&"A" . &' I( 7=& /" (& /" & >" ?(& /"F/"$7&T& I(/ " &I"/"&" (JI" "&":"" (&>"&( & $ 4&&I(&,2/:,*;*(A:. &IA "(&" 9"$ ,253*RS $ &%\" I "/" ( & &I:/ " 9" & I ] ^R _` 01-22< 5 6<R Q :"( --212< & -2 : -22<$ "&5<5-G5
%$ 9" %:H &% ( & 9&"$ "( '"%/.9A('"" H"& "5%)&. "&%( &"&A $'%(" A7+2@ "/" (& (&9K>$ " ("'$ " "/" /" & : "5 "/" ( ((( & A "" " & %( & M &% %""' & ?>$ & / (( " "9$ & /": " (>".%"&:("4&&%?"D 5 " &/$9 & '%(" " " /& %( &%($'( " / &%"" ( &%A'' "/" ('" 5)"7( &&( "('& (" "" (&>"5
65 GB%>" &/&"/"&$% % :()& / ("( ,0 ,<$ ( "( %( -22- 7 %"& & %"&" " & "A 7 " F:((9" ,0J Q5 <*I3-<54$ " $( "(-22-JQ530I;035a :((9" ,<JQ50;I<6254" $
1,+231-220 4,21,04 ( "(-22-JQ5<,I<3654R95".*$93 G$: " ""7 /&"/"&&Q5<+I6<3565/" &'% " 7 ( ,3 ' %( % / L "" " A&%"/"&" (&+2@7 &,H/",65
5./'%,<$"( (= & /" & "" &&'/"/"&" (" :(%( ,0 ( "(-22-5
:G B H"&$ / ?) ?( "' ' I( " : " " 7 ( &" = &( "( " . ' ":$ & '%"&(&" ""&"("(&""%(/ "/"&" ( FB -222 "&5 0 5 02;G5 " & ( 7 I(/ " & " "A & :? &I "/" ( 7 & &( " I(/ "&I"/"&" (FB-222"&5-50,0G5
G%> & " 5L H "9"(&:' %( ,0$ & M " /(( '%" ( ( " " "" ( & /" & %( ,<5 . $ / & "/"&$ ( "(-22-$&" = 9"A(748 ')9*)'868
+5 G I>" 7 ( & &( " " ' I ": &&I(/ " 7 (5/&%"/"&&" = (/( / 9 "&" "9". &%" ((5 9"$H"&& ":"" (&(9(7&" & :A " "'R" ""'$&"/& I " 7 ($ I( I " &I "/" ( "/ & " I "/" ( ' I ": & & " F Q,-6 5 +6 "&50:1 ::RB-22-56;"&50:$B-222"&5-5;<R/ 7 I" " & " & " ] ^ ,, 5 00-1000 "&50R ,*;*500-"&50:G5 Q (9.$&",<$7I '= " &"F BBG$:"( &A5 &( " / F(&"G & " "' & " : &&"( F Q,-<0-0"&50:1::RB,5,;-G5
Q 9" ("( 'I" 9" " & 9" ' " & ($ '" ?&"( = & I" & /AA"""(>$ &(/ >(& (( " 7& /"""&" ( & /" 9" 7 = >>($ 'I &"/ >(( : " " " (/( FB -222 5 ;<5 "&5-:RB,5,;3"&50:RB,533"&50:1::R Q,,< 0,2 "&5 <: :"(R B ,; 5 ,;, "&50G5 (?( $ " /"& & & (& 7 (& " & " " "'$
1,+231-220 4,,1,04 & %: & " 9" & "" F"" " "( ?&"$ U>$ ( & /"$ "" (1 (>" &% " " & (H A &% "5 (& " ( &%(/ "&"" &/"&%(" "5 9"$ &/&(>: -3@$ & 9 ">& F Q,-6+;"&53RB-22250-,"&53:1G5 $&" = ((&9K>(( ) ( "'5) T "&%A"$ & " & $" &'/?) ?( "''%(" : "&" = (&" &9K( "5 A $(& ""9("7-3@ /">:FB-22250,*5"&531::RB-2225;<5"&5-:R B,5,;3"&50:RB,;5,;,"&0G5
:GB%>" &/&%"/"&$% &Q502I++*56 : /'%(" ?("' ("-22-& %"& " 9 ". F95 BB -222$ : , -222$ ,340+$ "/ &% "/" (<JQ5<I6,;54A,-$" Q5<I;0+54A,-?"&<,$*? bQ53;I2<;54$" $."&A "-22-JQ53;I6-+544G5(> &% &"" " & & & 02@ F&" 7 / & Q5<,I20*544G &% (& " ( " & -3@ " & %U>&%( &"&" "&%"&(& 5
% (&( 7 & & &" & F95 BB-222$ : ,-222$62JQ5<I06,54A,-$" Q5<I36;54A,- ?" & <,$* ? b Q53<I;,;54$ " $ . "&A " -22-J Q533I06<54G5(> &%&"" "&& &02@ F&" 7 / & Q50;I+33544G &% (& " ( " & -3@5/&%"/"&"": %(./7Q5-*I266545
G (> /&%"/"& 5.>' "/" ( ( " (( " "/ = ' %:/ " 9"&( ('%"&/" ("( (/" /A(( " "95
&G 9" ' / &I"/"& " ( ( &( "( (9( " : F/ G$ 'I"( &I '= " & " F BBG & "/" ( " (( " "/$ & '" "99 "/& I( (/: " 5 "/" ( >( "/ & '"9" " < &(" N" (( " "/O " ">"9" '% '". & '"9" " 9" "".5 & ' & &" & /"$ A$ & " $ : " 9" & "" " (/( $ 9 A " &&"4"5 >&&>(/ "&I "/" ("'/ &/"$&" /"'I:">"9" "9& "/" (
1,+231-220 4,-1,04 (>. & ( ?&" & %(5 $ 9" ' (( " & " :((9"" & "/" ( "/ / = A">( & "$ $ ""$ "9(" A " '" /"& ("'M"" = ($ = ""&( ":""&I: F"" (7-3@G5
GB"%&(9("'%" ("-22- & & /" F95 , BB -22-$ & /" 324*0$ "/<G$7/" &Q5<I-26544$: " & Q5 <I<235;2 <,$* ?$ " Q5 3-%;6*5<2 ($ " $ 7 +2@$ Q50+%22;5625 B" "' 7 (& " & -3@ " $""'%9" % " (" "($&%U>& &9" '%" ( " 9" "&(& $ 9" '%" &" 7 ( /" 7 "$ : " 7 / &%"/"& & Q5 -+%+365<3$ '" ( A&%"/"&" (&<;5<<@$/ &" 7' & 5. $ " &"5
1,+231-220 4,01,04
! .-4 !-, . ,! .-
:/; < = 58 $>( .?
;
,5 (/:R
;
-5 %& " '!"8888888888&" 7' & R
05 &(""&-+H/" 0,H" -220 /"7% & R
<5 & %" "( 7 / & Q5,%322$44 7 " & "" "79" &(R
35 7% &&&%A"&" &%(7& &(& "&%&9" "/"9"R
65 9 " & '% / 9 ( = & &(" & 02 H &. "9" " " &( &( ": 9(&( & $ B?W"D?9'" 6$ 622< $ " A"5 &(" = >(5 (" &" J G "&"' A '&("" &(": "" &&("" '(R :G A ' "9 " " /" && &(""R G "> & ( 5 B" (" " " (( ((( G :G G "4&$ ":9(&(& ".'%" &/&("/:5("& ") & /$ '" H" $ "" ' &("" '( %/ & '( (A(&"( F 5,0-$,26 ,2;G5 >99".J ("& J "QQ S"B S "9&( = "9"(A """'%7%99"9(&( &">99
1,+231-220