Modification of Temporary Restraining Order
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA dispute arose over the scope of a temporary restraining order previously issued in the case. The court considered the arguments regarding the need for the order to remain in effect and the potential prejudice to the parties should it be maintained or dissolved. The court reasoned that given the ongoing litigation and the balancing of potential harms, the temporary restraining order should be modified, but not entirely dissolved, to ensure the preservation of the status quo and protect the interests of the parties pending further proceedings.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Modification of Temporary Restraining Order: The court considered the arguments regarding the need for the order to remain in effect and the potential prejudice to the parties should it be maintained or dissolved. The court reasoned that given the ongoing litigation and the balancing of potential harms, the temporary restraining order should be modified, but not entirely dissolved, to ensure the preservation of the status quo and protect the interests of the parties pending further proceedings.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThis provision is cited in the dispositive section regarding the order for court costs.
Testo completo
"#$%"&%%$ '"#%%("&%%$
'
' )'! ) !)
)*+ , # -+ &%%$
!"#$#% & ( !'()"( !*"( +(
(
&'((,- '(,#./00$1 (!"
!
3$2%3
.'
#4 " #%5/ ( " '6 73 '6 ! 8 ' * 9:( ; ' ) !'"!( 7) ( <'(( # )')"84
$4 *" ; ()( ((=: (=( ' !'( *('>? "(""'@A($0054
B4 ! !" ((( *""(" !C D"(9!(<'(D .B0(9$0054D"(9!(<'(D "(9@((( #E*0#/@4
54 ## (9 $005 ! @!" ( ; "F 6 . (9 $005 ((!( ) ( ) ")"!( G "!"" C *(4 #E ( !'"!( * 7 8 * !'"!( *<'(( 4 "; '(( '( H( ' <: !'"!( ( ' <: !( G '( ": * 9:( ( BII @4 ' F ' ( * 9:( A( * <!9 !! ( !(D"(9!(<'(D4
.4 ? #B (9 $005 " ' 4 '=<(3'=<(<"'( J& C ; D"(9!( <'(D !" 3 ! '(( "(" <'(" * (9 * '(( "( !G( G ( "') :" != C ")6 (G( !(4 (9"((' <:'=<(;<'(6:4 )( *('(9""@ ''=")(9("4
/4 $B)!9$005! "(9 "!'(G(! ; !(( '(( I*EII@4*9:( '('( *"*"6)C/E%@4(#0K '('('#0@4' F *<'((4
E4 *(!" *" ! " C ! ' #/@")$00. ;!(@ @ '<: (((" @( *<'((4
I4 $#@")$00.! @()! ( *"; @"((@ " (!'"!( *<'(( ;'")(*G ('(('((!(("F
2#/02$00/ 3B2%3 ;'=<(; *9 : ('"@( * !" !( ; * ! <;4 ? :!( 9(*<'((((!()() ")"!( G ' ; '('( *"6) C I*EII @4 ' (@@(!! D"(9!(<'(D4
%4 $I)$00.*"(("'( ! !(@;* (G(;*)('96! *3*"((''' <'(( ';* @@( * '=")( G L(" ) "( !G( G ( "')4 G';" ;* )( ) (( ()9;!(""'@A($005;*"((M:" .%(*( (( (( ( ( '@ "' ;* "(" !" '(!( C !! * ) G64 ((( ; *<'(( "(( * @( :) '( )( H( "" !!'! .(9$0054 ! (C! ) '( ( ' <: (":!( "F C D"(9!(<'(D4 ')((! C "!'!( !! /E%@4';);(9 (!'(4
#04 #0F$00.*"@(')C! (@("(9$/ !$00.' G(! ;<'((: *" @( ( C *!'9(" !< * '=")( :N4 (@(!((;*""(( "'@ '$00B( * '( C '(( :(;" C (( "'; ( *( '( C !( $005 ; *"(( ' '"'" ( ; )( 9( C !!( *4
##4 ) #5F$00.!" 3 ! 6); ''( D"(9!(<'(D*9 *( " ' ) 5 !4 (( " ;* = "FC '" * '(< ( !(( '" ; 9' ' :4 *9 * (+ *G '(( ')"4 *( ' " ; *! ( '' ' !!( '(( ')" O @@( "FC4 #5F(.F($00.! @!" @4
#$4 *" *"(( ' ;((" !(( /E% @4 ! @( (@" #/ F $00. !! !( '= '( 4 0. #/B#E5 ;@!"''(4
#B4 " #E A( $00. ! )" *''( @!" C '( C !(( /E% @4 ' $0 @4 @ '' ( .0@4 @ *G"( '(4
2#/02$00/ 352%3 #54 #B '(!9 $00. *" @!" ''( ''( ; '"( " ! "( * "!'( ( !(( I*EII @4 ( ' <: !(( :9 #E*0#/ @4 ;* )( (("4@()@@(; *G*'';(' 6 ;* *)( ' "(" <'(" ' 9 *4 ;( ;* ( ( "!!(( I*$$I@4
#.4 " #B "!9$00.! F("*''(!(@ ; *" (( ) !! /E% @4 ' @ '' ( '((;:!((()C(((!(6 * !'"!('(C9:( ( H((4
#/4 ( #/F)$00/*"(F((((( "4!( *G '(( (( * !'"!( ((;! ((C9:( '= !(( I*$$I @4 6 ; *9 * *"(( ' '!6 *<'((4@()!'( 6; G'((C @"6( "9(* *((; G" ( G:94 ( C !( ! '!( !(( E*.5%@4)("H(C.K 6$#@")$00.4
#E4 "' #. ! $00/ ! ( F( 4 6);*(4#E4# 6:!(()C*9:( '(!''((' ")*"*" *=( ( !'(4 ?*:( '"(( ( !(6 *!'"!("@6C (:"" * ( C ( !'"!( *3<'(( ;'!((( *G'<: @'(( (9 "( *9 9(4!" *: (9 )G "' ( C "@( '=")( ( C << )(! ');" ' !!( ":6 ( G) *4 *( 6CF(((;*@()*G4
#I4 ("';" ( .)$00/''(;!!( *!" *"(";"; (9;*(!" C 9 ) G6 ( ; '' *<'(( "(( 9 (9 '=<;4 6) ' ; '=")( '( H( *: ; '( ":!( H( *: 9"(; !" !( "( *(4?*:( !'( !(') G' !'( C *( " "(( * 9:( 4 +( ) !(( /E% @4 ! ( )(!( '!( ' ! !(( I*$$I @4 )("H(C.K 6$#@")$00.4
2#/02$00/ 3.2%3 #%4 "( $I)$00/! (F( 4 ((;**('";*!(''' @ '((4!" !H!'96! '=")( *(''9 *<'(('"(((( ! @("::9 !P!" ((( ;";*" )( "(" <'(" : ( C *!'9(" !< "(( * '=")(:N4
$04 "( ( "(" !!;" ( B ! $00/ ( !C '('((F;*$/!$00/4
$#4 ( ;"(": "CF:4
!'
#4 :)Q:(F 78"("! @"(((" 6 #A($00B 9( !'" .F: ('" (()3'" (.''"((#/F:7(4#(4 (./ 84
?(CQ( Q"( #/F:' 9@" " $EF)$0057 J#B0#0/8 :) '("#B@") '(((:('!((( 9( ": C ( F: (( Q((( Q"( )GF:4
$4 @!"!( C *(4 ./ 4 # (4 <4 5 9 ( +((; ((('")CQ(4./ @" ":"" ( /(9$000 7 8;(()C@" "Q3! #I!#%%5 7 84
+( ":!( (: (@ G !'"!( C *3! '") ' ( C *3 ( 9:( '") ' @" " * ( $0 ! #%I# 7 -@4(4./4#(4884 ;( ( ()G '"'((("@!)C!"(( "; (: ) ')" '(( '(( !'"!( C Q3! 9:( C Q3 ( 9:( ')( "!(9 7@4 "! $00#3
2#/02$00/ 3/2%3 $00$'4%I(@CQ(4./4#(4: 'F( I/B/ )Q(4 ./4#(484
?!'"('F: Q'6("(94
B4 (F(" @! ( " '( ( )9 7(4 ./ ( /0 -(4I% 84
54 9 "(('"9!(;(((' ) '=!(( /E%@4 A(( '('(G@ *<'((C D"(9!( <'(D * 9:( ( ;* "CG' !'(4
(' ()(!('!('*(!" !(( I*$$I @4 A (( !'"!( ' "F C D"(9!(<'(D .B0(9$0054
.4 !'"!('(;"'3! (! (')"(":'@" " $)#%0I(( *3 7(4#$4$(B 84
*(!"*'''!( !(("!"'((!(; *<'(( "(( " !( C *"(( '=<; ! ":!( C '=")( !!9@""; *9 *;(+ *G '(( ')" ( :"" *
7 8()G!'"!( 4
?*(4BB '(;!(;"*()9; G( *(")"!( !6'"(";);4 ?)( ((!' ( "(! *'6 :""!( " ::(G(! ("4 *:( ' *( *!9"C('@)9C*"4
(( ' 6: *('"(( ((4 *(4 #00 ) 9:('((;6:'3!H! (;F' !(6 (((''94*'63 ( :"" @( '( (":( (( ( )( H( ('"(" !H! '' ; ( '( (( 7 J #$$ ##I 4 $- ##E /0% 4 / '4 /$#84 !! ' ( (( ;)("(!( ( '('(H("(9)( << )(" '"!" ('"(( "( '' @ !'( ( *!9 ( ;("(""!7 J#$$##I 4$(H(("84@( <<;'(')(( )( 6: 9 @ C !@(( )(" "';4 ( ":
2#/02$00/ 3E2%3 F' "("'';= C 6: *('"(( ;!( (! * '" ( '( ( ' ( ( ' 4 '( ": '' ;* '" * (G( DD ( G *!9" C *( != Q('"((4 ( *(4#I ; *(G(!H!*( '@"!( "(!((;*('"(('!((("(( '<9"4H!( *(('+(C'!6) '( "( *( ( (( 9( ') ' '( *( ( ; (G( ( (( ' G(!( * 7 J#$E 555 4#984 (G *('"( !6 " ) ""!( (( <; (( )( H(('"("C'( (( !97 J##E/0% 4/299 '4 /$$84 *G )( ( H( ('"(" (()!(
7 J ##I B5$ 4 # '4 B5.84 @ '' 9 ( ('(! !9:N ( (( '"@!" ( (C('"( "@) '(;" :"7 J#$5 #.. 4#9-#$$##I 4$84
/4 *'6 *(4 BB4# !'"!( 7" 4 #%%E8 '")( ; D( G * ! ( ( )( ( ) !!( : ('"@( ( *( 9( (G!:6 ; *9 * ( !" !(D4 ( C *(4 #E4$ ( !'"!( * 7 " 4 #%%E8 3 <'(('")(;D**('((' ((!( ( "F <L'(G ' : ( ; '=<(; * 9 : ('"@( * !" !(; *! <;4D
?(*(!"(); *G(@ ) '(( 6 ; *(4 #E4$ ) P *<'(("( *@(:)!'(9C*"4*<'(( "(( C'=")(9(":N;*C"(!G(G( "')4 (( ; *9 * *"(( ' C *: * "(( ! @!9";4
"( ''( "(9 . (9 $005 ; '(('"(( @@("C!< *'=")( G L(" 9 *" )( ) @(:9(" (9 !! ( <! "'!"4)(( C*(3!" ; ');(!C * * @ *") *(<" ( "<'' C "("4 ( *"9( (9 * '(( ) "( !G( G ( "') :"!=C")6 '( *9F(@"(( 9( *C* *)'=<(;('"@;' * ((!(!" !(G4#B(9$005 '""C
2#/02$00/ 3I2%3 *((( !" 3 *(!";'''; '(( ( <'(" ( 9 (9 * '(( ; "(( ' <: '=<(; <'(6 :4 ?*= F(( '=")( 9(" ' ; !" !(G ( '<=(<"'(;"(("4
@!" ' '( ; *<'(( : (@((C*!'9(" !< *'=")(:N '(("(( ' "'@ '$00B4
) ;'"6 @( ((;*<'(("(( !()" !( ' *"(( "'@ ! 9 ( (( ' '=")( 9(" :N ; "(( '"@;4 *9F(@ (<"'(;)(":!( (C*9(= * !(( ;*<'((9()9 *'; '(( ( G'"!( G *(4 BB4# ( #E4$ 7@4 J # (9 $005 . 4 #B52$00584 !'( C ( ": ; *9 * ( "; * "(( ! @ "(( '"" ; (: @( !( "@" (!( C ; (( (C( @(4 ; 9@" "*''" :: ( *: 9@ * 9( "@( !! "(( G@ !! "" !) 7@4 ( 9(8 "@" G ( )(" @(7@4 J #5)$005. 4$/2$00584
*( "; C F( (( ; *(!" @" ' <: *<'(((( '((!'"!(4
E4 @ "'(;*H(F("4
RRR
2#/02$00/ 3%2%3 ) /!'. ' )'! ) !)
012++ 3 4 56 #$& ! 7
2+
#4 "( ! )()94
2
$4 F((4
B4 !)" *''( @!" !! !( '= '(40.#/B#E54
54 F(( ! )(4
.4 (;'" (:((4
/4 @! '( ;Q ')( @! ( '"( H( " B0 F 6 (@( ' ' !! " " 9 @" " ?<S,<@; / /005 ( G!'4 " '( H( ':"4 !"! (T 8 ; G(!(; "( "9((' " ((;"- 98 G' ' ; !(@ (! ') ! (( ( "- 8 '( :( '"((4 ? !"! (( ' ( ""!( "!"" (( 8 98 ( 8 3 9@" " ''(!(6;Q ) ")94!"! !(!= ') ; ( F( ; " ((;" ( Q)'' ;"("G'" "(7(4#B$#0/(#0I84 :@@ " (T U
'@! '"(H(((@"G'(;QCQ@@@" " ("'9;':@@
2#/02$00/