Marital Property Division: Trust Interests and Partnership Distributions Valuation
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA party challenged a lower court's decision regarding the division of marital property, arguing that certain assets, specifically trust interests and partnership distributions, were improperly valued or excluded from division. The court reasoned that the lower court correctly applied the relevant statutory framework for equitable distribution, holding that the evidence supported the valuation of the trust interests as non-marital or correctly characterized as marital only to the extent of appreciation during the marriage, and that the partnership distributions were correctly accounted for as income or marital assets, thereby affirming the final property settlement as fair and equitable under the circumstances presented.
Regesto Legislator
Ufficiale; PRÉVOYANCE PROFESSIONNELLE SELON LA LPP ; PRESTATION DE PRÉVOYANCE ; SALAIRE DÉTERMINANT ; CONDITION DU COTISANT ; COTISATION AVS/AI/APG ; COTISATION(EN GÉNÉRAL) ; INVALIDITÉ(INFIRMITÉ) | ravs.6.2.h
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe appeal is declared inadmissible based on this procedural provision.
Costs are imposed on the appellant according to this provision.
Testo completo
%&'()%'+ ,%(+%'+
,
, -, - -
-. '
" '' / '+
01111111111 23 !"#$%&'(
!
" 41111111111 )%%%*
+ ),!,$- - -.*!/% ! *%! )%%0
!
- , 4 5 4 , !%)* , -%!123#'(
!" #"$
15&"61
4,
"0 $ % 89999999999 !(%* !! / ,*% % .!,%:9999999999;--- <- 0=/.57=%5665!#/ !% !(% !*!%!0
50 !!.")"22>( %*!*?9999999999;,% ()@"22>, %*!*A9999999999<.), *! !%!* ,*% ,* BC* ) % D7 , ! %( , !-%E, *'!.%(%%!*@ !*F%%!%(G;!04 %, %!% C** ! !0 " H,%! E*'G<0 /. ! %(%%!* %! % F%! / .* %! .%,%!* ! ! ! %*(%@%(#!(%*)** % !C% , F%!!/.% %! .%,%!* !!!* , )*% !%!! . ),% ! , %@%%!*.)*% !% ! %%/!**)!%(% !I *, .H@% ( .%)! ! + ! %!! ;,C,H 505 H,%!E*'G<0 *%!% %/*.,*( %! ()!.,%! , !#466J%@!**, %,!!%)%!*#H%!F %,F -*%!* %FK% ;,C,H 50" H,%! E*'G ! !0 L %, %!% C**<0 !%!% *!%!!%')!,%HC,.), ;,C,H705 %, %!% C**<0
40 ,*% ! *!* %F )* ( (! , !!% %, %L,!)@"22>%,*%!/C!% ,*( ,*( %!%()%%)).%)%!% #H!! % %!/.(%%!*(!)! ),*!%, %!% ) %F( @0
L0 F% .* "222 :9999999999- F% * ( .!,% -9999999999- !!(-:9999999999- 0
70 ' 5" M! 5666 .* *!* %,%!* !(%0 *, * ),!!% ,'.FF%! .1%(%%!*;%1,' . </%% ! */!!#,!%" M!566"0
D0 ' F% !! !(% 57 =% 5665 .* F%! ( % ,*!!% ,%)!! %%,' +1), %( /! (! ,*( )% , , !! . ")"22>(.?9999999999!.CC)!*%! %*!* L,!)@"22>0
>0 .!,% !!*( %!) !!(!/!CC)!*!%! ( @ '! %! # F% ( C , -9999999999 F% "222 ! /.%
&45"2&67 14&"61 (%%! %/)! # ),*! ,*( *F%! , ,* *0 %C* / , !!% * ! !! , (%! .,,%/#-%,, *!*=#*C%),*( , !! , ), *0
30 2 ! @ 5664 ,' ( % !* % )) =! .%!,*!!% !+! %!%C%+ / ,* %* # .!,% 'C)! # .)%@(.)@%CN!* CC)!L,!)@"22>,!% ! (!% ,/.+1), .CC%!#() !! 556O666 F0 # .*0 - ! )) (* %!%! ) !!C @!F F%!%(*,%!/.*FF!%!#% !%!#%*!% 0 (!% ,*%%!/()!*!%!FF!* # @% ,% % , @%%!* ! / .!,% .!%)%! .P! ! # @%C!% !! *C0 ! # .* % .( % , ,*!!% # F% ( % # . ! %*!* !% (.CC)!L,!)@"22>0
20 "> ()@5664.!,%%F )* %%!, F% - F**!% !,% ) ;8 1 $ %1,' %< /. (%!(*) !!556O666F0#.*#!%!,!!% ,%!%*# .!!%!@#!*0 +,%/*/.*(%!*!**(! F% .!,% "222 , % ,% EQ R $ G 5') ,%% ! /. C!% ,*( ))(%!*C)!*!*)%,, ,*% !.* F%%!,!%0
"60 %%*, 5" ()@5664/.(%!+)%! ,!!% (*!.,%*%F%,(%'C)!C!% ,*( F% *!)% % ,!!% * F%%! ,!% % *!)%! 0
""0 % 5L ()@ 5664 .!,% % ))%/* ,% .CC)! L ,!)@ "22> %% /. ,% (!% 2 ! @5664! !( !# ,**! %+,%!%F0
"50 5> ()@5664 %%+,%/*/,!!% *#.* F%%! ,!% % *!)%! /. *!%! )% # !%!% ! /. (%! F%C .!!!!% % (* 56640 (* / .!,%.(%!,F % ,%'C)!C!%,*( )%,!)C*/P! !!!%! ,% (!% 2 ! @ 56640 !! %' % %C* / .!,% (%! ,*%* /. !%)%! .P! ! # @%C!% !! *C ! / ()! (%! *!* FF!* # @% ,%
&45"2&67 1L&"61 %, @%%!*% , /%,,%%!/) !! , (%!,P!/%F%*,!!% *C)!%.%!%!!% ,*( 0
"40 ,'%(*HC %!/P!.!,%56=(%566L %*%% !55=(%566L F%)! , %! ( *!* % 5> ()@ 56640 F* %* ,!!% *#.* )),!!% ,*( , F% 0
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
"70 *%% ,, %!% "2)566L % F%)**%% 55 =(%566L0 (*/,!!% !(%!@**F%%*.*.*!%!, ,!!% . %!%!!% ,*( , F% ! /.% .*!%! , !%!%. %!#.*C.), 0 ,* %!. !! !%F . *C% , %! %(% FK% ! (%! *!* (* , %!%!!% FK%! ,%!%!!% %0
"D0 *%! 7 )% 566L .!,% ! $ % 89999999999 ! %!=!* !!!*%% !#.!% *%% %!%C%! # !!!% / ,!!% (*.*!%! , )%# !%!% 0 ! +,%/* / ) !! (* %!%! ,!!% ,*( , F% ) S % * %! . !! . *' .%(%%!* FF!* +%()! # ,*( ! ( %!%!!% .,%(* )%#(%; % %*!* ! , -%< / ,!!% (%! *!* ,*(. ),*)!!*%.'C)!!/.*(*)! * .*!%! , %!0 ! %C* / !! ( ?9999999999 .(%! , .! @! / . ,*( ),*)!%
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
">0 *, "2)%566L %,%!*%!*C)! % ! =! 0 (* / )P) .H, !H' S !! . ! ?9999999999 ! .!,% +%!%! % (%! *!* 8 ! -% ! .%!%!!% *!%! )% %! FK% / @% )P) !% @**F%%% , !!% *%%! -%0 .C%%! ' , . !! ,*( %* ( *!@%)! . )% # (% ! ' , ,.,*( %)%*#,*( , F% 0 = !* / .%(%%!* .* %! % .*!%! , ),'! % ,(! /! ! .1%(%%!*0 !! .%F%!P!%,%!*! !!%*(%@%(#!(% *)** ! % *!%! !' , %@ / . . , ,!!% # .*0 % ,*%* / ,%! F%+* 556O666 F0 , (!% ,*!%!!!',*( )%/.%(%!*!*(*# @% ,% ! % , @%%!*0 F%! %% %* ,!!% )),!!% *,! )%# !%!% 0
"30 % 5> )% 566L %@ * %F )* ! / *!%!C*#=C#) %/. %%!+,*)! %!% 0
"20 P!5",!)@566L %@* %**/,!!% (* %! P! %)%* + ,!!% * ! .!0 D 0 5 ! H - % , / % =!%F%%! )!! # !%!% 0 */! *!%!=!*0
&45"2&67 1D&"61
560 - 8 ,!%)! )% / % .%! , M *%% !!!% %! ,%/. , (%! *%% !%!% !/ %@*.%!,M !)!%'0.P!!*%% ,, %!% ! *!**0
5"0 *%% "L =%! 5667 % *)* ) !! 5>O>"L F0 L6 # -:9999999999 , !+ !%!% ) !!(*#$ % 89999999999 ()@56640
550 - ,, %!% %*%% 53=%!5667 F%)!0
540 "L,!)@5667 ! !#.!% *%% %!%C%!# !!!% /,!!% (*.*!%!, )% # !%!% 0,!.!%C)!!% 0
5L0 *, "5 ! @5667%%%/*)%!%!) *%% ,, %!% 0
570 ,'!)%% *%!+,!%,,%5D ! @5667 *!*C*#=C0
"0 %C( %. C%!% =%%%;<*!*) %F%*!%!%!*' " M!5664 %@! % ), *7=C !,*%!!(%1,*%!7,,*!!"D=C;!0"!0 !7D <0
-%!#.!% .*!% "D=C, %@F** 5>=(%566L; 8"46"6D< %C( % ,!*"4F*(% %, %!% !%! %C!,)!!! %@! % %*C # ! % =C !%!% .!!! .*!% (+=C0
F )*)! # O!0 7D 0 " !0 H0" %@ ! % T!%!%/ !!!% ,*(#.!% 7D /% !!%(# %F**.1(%%!(%(! 56*)@"2LD0
%@*!, */! ),*!!0
50 ! %!=!* F ) ! *% *C+ ! (@ F )*)!+!07D72!D6 0
40 %!%C, !/%F%!% =%%/,!!% *#.*, .!,%0 %@ %!FF!*!)%%!! ))!%)%@#
&45"2&67 1>&"61 ,!!% *C)!% .%!%!!% ,*( , F% ! F%! ' ,,!%(*!)%! )%# !%!% % !% %!P! %** ))%)%!**,! )%# !%!% 0
< - O!0 7 0 5 - ! %** )) % *!)%! ! ! *!%@!% , !(% *,! FF!* !), *!)%* %*!)%*08 !,!%%*!)%!,*F%%!% ! ! )) ! H* , %* % ()! ! * )%/)! %* !! !(%U , %), ! # , , / ,, ! (% %! )%! %! *!* *%%* / ,!!% %! (* (! O @%C!% # !%!@**( 0 %' ))(O!%(%!*%* )%# !%!% )!*!%@!% (*, !(%FF!*)% ,%%, ! ! %)%!* ,!!% ! !% / / ( ,, ! (% ) S ,!!% ! , FH !%!% (! ,%,!% *C +,*)! F )* ; 8 "5D 555 %0L"5L"6" %05!=%,%!*<0
+ !) .!0 7 0 L - % F** ,! +,! % *!)%!,!!% %%%/,!!% .), # ), * (% .*(*)! ,!%%0 %% .!0 D 0 5 !0 H 'C)! .1(%% ! (%(! 4" ! @ "2L> ; -< ,*( %! !))! / ! , ),% ( , (! . !%(%!* !%( ,!!% *C)!% .%!%!!% ,*( , F% % @**F%%% %! , , ( .%!%!!% .), ) )! S .*(*)! * , %! / .%!%!!% !% !0
H%FF5632%!%(%*!)%!. - ! ;%1,' -< ,*% /. %' !))! )) ,!!% *C)!% .%!%!!% ,*( , F% ,!!% . %!%!!% ,*( F(, !0L3!36 % ,*( , F% 57=%"235;<!,!!% *!! .! F ) ,*( !0 35 ! " . *!% )%F%)!, !%!% (*# F ) ,*( ; 4< ; !! ,*( %* ( *!@%)! . (!% ,*( %* ( F !% @%<0 ! , !! ,*( %* !!,*%+.,%!!!(% .%(%%!* *' /% ! ( %!%!!% . )% # (% ( %!%!!% . %! ,@% !%F%! + +%C F%+* # .!0 D> " %* ! /% ! FF!* +%()!!%*( @)!#,*( ;!0"0"4<0 %' *C)! )),!!% .!0D05!0H -!F!. ,!!% ,*( *C)!% # .%!%!!% ,*( (
&45"2&67 13&"61 ), #%!%!!% %@,C.!0L %F** "> *)@ "224 %@ ,C ,*( , F% (%%(%(!!%(%%!*;8<; F ). ),!%@,C ., %%@,C<!.( %,*( /%.,*!*(*;H0 "626-<0
- .!0"30" , ,,*%F )!. !!% % HH * ! )) %!!% ,!% .P! + +,% * )%!% %+! ! !,(% %!, %!, *C%!(*%!@ (!% 0% )@=CO*!@% ,)%!),( !**,!%*H*!),%%/)! @O%%; 8"5>LLL %0"@<0 /.!*!@%* ! ))%!!% ,!%%,,#.%!,*!!% ,%%, F%; 8"5447<0
@< .,'%.C%!*!)%*! ))%!!% ,!%! *CC %% ,)!!! /%F% ,*%*)! ,!!% F% *!)%%) !!*, #*F%%!% *C!,,!!% *F%% # .!0 D 0 5 !0 H -0 F% % (%! F + **)! %! !! . " ) "22> / ! ,* ( ?9999999999 ! (!% ! + ,!% ! 2 ! @56640
% !! . % ! / ,*% % *!%! , !*C* *' %% /. .%(%%!* E@ ! *F%%!%(G /*!%! /.**!%!.%,%!*! !!%*(%@ %( # !(% *)** % ! C% , F%! ! .%,%!* !!!* , )*% !%!! . ),% ! , %@%%!* .)*% !% ! %%/!**)!%(% ! %!*, .H@%(.%)!!+! %!!;F0 !!")"22>,0 3 ,%' 5 !<0 .* *, , + +%C *%!* , !!) S%,*!,.%(%%!*@ !*F%%!%( ! / *%! !) !! ,%/.% ,K %! /! ! .1%(%%!*,%" M!566"%, %!.*!! !!*, ,!%0 !%! ,)% %% ,)!!! .%F* / ()! ,!!% .! , %!( @! ,*( , F% 0 F%! / ! %! ! (* . @%C!% ,,!!% F%! %L,!)@"22>HC%# /%F%!% ))1)P)0
% (!% 2 ! @5664,*%!/) !!(* ,%! (%! P! FF!* # % !%! .* )% # %*!% %;F0 (!% ,04,%'L !<0 !!%% /.%.*!%!,,*(/,!!% %!(* ),!@ /*!
&45"2&67 12&"61 F%!%*( @)!FF!*#,*( , F% .*0% %!%( '( /. !! ,*( %* , # ,!!% *C)!% .%!%!!% ,*( , F% .!0 D 0 5 !0 H - .! ,*%*)! , / !, ,*( %! %* ;4') ,%% < # .%( ,*( %@ ;4') ,%% %@< %! P! *! * @! ,*( , F% ;1 % E %-%G,0L>"222<0 !!)%', * !%! *C)! %% F( . ,!!% .! , , @! ,*( , F% 0
(**)!,!!% (*%!P!%)%*+,!!% * ! .!0 D 0 5 ! H - % , / % =!%F% )!!# !%!% F )*)!+%, %!% *C)!% *0 ) !! !%!% *)*.!/!#%, !!*0
! ) !%F =!*!*%% ,, %!% % 53=%!5667 F%)*0
&45"2&67 1"6&"61
- ,4 , -, - -
2" 67 8 9 :$ (;' !3
7
"0 * (@0
" 7
50 =!!0
40 %!/, *!C!%!U
L0 F ) ,!% /. ,(! F ) ! ,*! P! *% 46 = ' !%F%!% , ,% ))* * %@ F** -HV%WH F/% D D66L ! % +),%0 *% ,! P! , C*0 )*) % %!I < %%/ +!)!/*%% !*% @!%%!,*%% !!/*U @< +, , / ) !%F % !%) , ( % ) !! ! *%% U < , ! %C! ,*!!0 -% )*) % !%! , ! % **)! *)** !! < @< ! < %1 %@F**, ,!)!%' /.% (*%(@0)*) % )!% ) ,( /% ! = %! %% / *%% !!/* ! .( ,, /*!*+,*%* !;!0"45"6D!"63<0 CFF%I ,*%!I % - @-
,% F ),*!P!! !%F%*+,!%%%/.#.FF%F** %,CFF
&45"2&67