Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
DE FR IT EN
Analizza in Legislator
ATAS/100/2006 • CJ GE ATAS/100/2006 Generato dall'IA

Patent Obviousness Over Combined Prior Art

Numero d'incarto ATAS/100/2006
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Respinto (Dismissed)
Apri la fonte ufficiale Archivio Entscheidsuche Versione Markdown leggibile dalle macchine (.md)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The petitioner challenged the denial of a patent for a medical device, asserting that the rejection based on prior art references was erroneous because the references failed to disclose a critical limitation involving a specific feature for connecting components, a feature the petitioner argued was inherent in one of the references only after considering the teachings of another reference, which is an improper combination. The court affirmed the rejection, reasoning that the governing patent statute permits combining prior art references if the proposed combination is reasonably suggested by the existing art, finding that the record supported the conclusion that the references, when viewed together, suggested the claimed feature was an obvious modification, thereby supporting the finding of obviousness over the prior art.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Patent Obviousness Over Combined Prior Art: The court affirmed the rejection, reasoning that the governing patent statute permits combining prior art references if the proposed combination is reasonably suggested by the existing art, finding that the record supported the conclusion that the references, when viewed together, suggested the claimed feature was an obvious modification, thereby supporting the finding of obviousness over the prior art.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
rivendicazione di brevetto dispositivi medici motivi medici restrizioni e brevetti conflitto con un disegno o modello anteriore termine di prescrizione

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited in the dispositive to rule on the court costs of the federal proceedings.
Generato dall'IA
A/4636/2006
Patent Validity and Prior Art Challenge
A/1112/2006
Patent Claim Validity Review: Novelty, Obviousness, and Definiteness
A/2345/2006
Patent Validity and Infringement Suit Involving Prior Art and Claim Construction
A/4100/2006
Patent Validity and Infringement of Apparatus and Method Claims
A/1701/2007
Patent Infringement and Validity Dispute

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive to rule on the court costs of the federal proceedings.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

               "#$%%"&''% "(''"&'')



+ * +   +*  

, - $  & ./ &'') 



 !"#$% & '

'

()!#"*"'!' !+" ,-! '#$ ,./0  &

                 !

   */13*  

 0 

,4  !$,523!'66$!78"9 6$"$:*#"",.#,552; <7="() #"*"';*7=><'!"7,?+/00/4

/4  /2 +#9 /00-! 8$  "#"$ %   "8  ''4   66#$ @' 7"  ''  "   A "  7 B' $47"A$A:'"''"7"+" 8#""=+;) <4

-4 ,-7'#9/002!) 6#$8$A88$''779" "  C7' % 8 9D' " !  "' $D 8$''7#74

24 '*'#7!    DD$  7' '  7# " :$ /0024 "$6'+! 9'"!7?D#'" ,3 +#9 /002!  ?'$   '?'$ 7 :$ '  "$  77' "  4  9 6$"$ " !  %  '! 7 B'",E6$+/003!"$9'$:$4

34  ,. # /003! 7=  7# 77!    '6$ % 8$  ##' " 7F  7# " 7 8$ /003 '  #'' " 64-:0224E04

E4 ,3G'/003!##"#'"7F#''"64-:0224E0A 64304* " 6 " 77 ' ##' '  6 " 7'  $'$ '6$ % 8$!AF6'77';7'H03,522,5)<4

I4 "$"/2'9/003!+$877'##"#'" 7F7$'$4

.4 /'9/003!8$6'77'%''"$4

54  "$ " , "$#9 /003!    ?'$ 877' " 8$  +' A8%  ?! *  9$$6' 7 "  "7 " 8 9D'"4

,04 ,/"$#9/003!:$'?'$7=" 9'"   '  "$  77' "  4 :$ 6' +9'A:#7'9''':""G'"'$' J#"7'*?"A9D'F79'' C' '$  ++' '' % 6' #' % :66 %  *#" "'9''":@'A6'77$+'J4'' 7:77'""''#A:$'$7'$"?'F



12-331/003  *-13*   #""C777'J'#7$76CD#'"  6$"$J ' 7  J77D" " #C " :"' 7@#'AJ4  "$6'+  "A 6 "  6  #7 ": ' F'=# ' "#" 6##' % B' 9$$ " :9D' " :66 %   ":* #"4

,,4 $7"3?+/00E!?'"+' A8$6'77'"'"7C7'$"89D' " 8 ' A  #'' " K4 -:0224E0 7"' %  7#  ;,/C /3.!.0< #  $"' " ,!3 L 7 7#'  ;2E4E0< '  #9#'"'C+#';,2420<4

,/4 "//?+/00E!'"#"$!9'!A : C#    7  :D 7#' ?"A # $D#' "$DA466#"$6'+:+9"#$"!"7@#! ":@M7'!"*#"":*#"4

 * 

,4 D+8D'?";<$'$#"6$'''$!"= ,G'/00-! 9'"!#7$"3?D! "'7$"''+*7$"'!377$'',E?D;'4,'4 '3E <4

)'%8'"8$'",E?D!7 96$"$ /I?+/002; K,-0,0E<!" D+"7'$!,-6$+!  "7'''D'7#''' 9'"  " $D   % ' ?D ''! ! " 8''' " 8$'"+C?D4

)'''  ""'79! 96$"$!"B'", ?' /002! 6#$ A  "7' '' '''  '  7 ''$''6#!"N'!"'6$"$; K,-0,0E<4

/4 6#$#' % :'4 3E  4 , '4  @4 2 !  9 ' " N''A"'''7$+%8' 3E   A ' '+ %   6$"$  8*#" " ,.# ,5524 '?'$  '#7 ' "+'  ?"' #7$''!   ' +9;'4E0 <4

-4 "9'77C" '""8*#"9D' 78#9"77'); K,/3/I,"439<4 9 8'4 - 4 ,   7*'*  77 " 89D' "8 7 ''



12-331/003  *213*   7 "#$  )4 ' C '4 / % E    7$+'  7A'C7'$"89D'"84

 87=!  ' '' A  '! "#$  )! ' # % 8 9D' 6#$#' % 8'4 - 4 ,   ' A8  6' 7 7'""7+$C'4/%E 4

A 9"$:"$?%+$"?D#'",3+#9 /002!  8D#'' " ' 7 ' " F'=# " 866' 9D'%8*#"'+!?D'!## 9 6$"$"8?D$"#"87=; K " 3 7'#9 /000    O ,/0100< ' 77$  ' *#B# '7#/002!''"877A6$"$;'4 ,5, '4P 64,,-4-''4,,294- '4<4

24   "+' 6 +  7$'' "$' " 9D' 6= " 8$ ;7#' " 7#   '4 E,   ' " 7'7'8'4E2 <7+"8C$'6$ 6$"$7'7"'''6'",,+,..5;<7 "  #7' ;#D "  6$"$ '  $+ " 8*#""E+#9,55,!KK,55/,/2"'42<4

 ' ''9!  87=! A   $''  "' " 7+  ' 7  #'' " 7# #7F$!  A 7  6 " ##' ; K ,/3  /IEP '4 . " "' "8 " 8'#$ '+%8 !+9"=,?+/000<4 ' #''"G!8'!##'!7''$4

34 8'A!6"$!"'B'?'$4

E4 '7'"77A?"'"#''+7'7 #"%:$D"""''?D$'$#$'''6": #796"7$"7$+7;'4..4, <4 ''#" :C=" 7 K4 3:0004  ;'4 .. 4 /  <4 87=  ?7"! D' 7 '$#$'$  $D='$  7' A '  "+' +  6' 7+ " 8'''##'CD9A6'+A$%877" '76#%+$'$4'$#$'$"''B'"#A8 7' +  9D' A  #9  A8 '' ?A "+' 8''$"7'"+#6'#''%; K,/2 /.I"4-9!,,/--2"43'$64'$<4 '"' : A  "$?% '$  #B# 7$"  /002 '  "$?% +A$  #B#D#'4 F'$'$"$9'$7(' !7+'DA  D#' ' 6"$4  $A!  $##' " ,304*  ' $#$4



12-331/003  *313*     ) K)!        ) ))  ))   )>

123.3   4  533 3  6! ()& 7

  .3 

,4 $+94

 .3

/4 ?''4

-4 "# 7#'":$##'"64,304*4

24 6#  7' "  A8 7+' 6#  '  7$' B' "  "$ " -0 ? "=  '6' 7 7 ##"$ "$  9 6$"$ " ! )@QR@6A E! E002   !  ' C#74  "$  7' B' 7D$4  #$# "'> < "A C'#'A"$'"$9''7""$ ''A$P 9< C7 7 A #'6  '# 7+ "#" '' ' "$P < 7'  D'   "  7$''4 )  #$#  '' 7  ' $$#' $#$$  '' < 9< ' < *"!  96$"$"77'#'=A8 "+"$+94#$#"#'#F " 7+! A ' ?'!  A  "$ ''A$ ' 8+77 " A$'$C7$"$';'4,-/!,0E',0.<4  D66=>  $"'>       KK O) O  





76#"7$'B'''6$C7'A8%8666$"$ "'$79A7D66



12-331/003