Review of Demurrer Sustained Without Leave for Failure to Plead Fiduciary Duty in Investment Advice Case
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA party sought a review of a ruling that sustained a demurrer without leave to amend against their complaint alleging causes of action including professional negligence and breach of fiduciary duty related to investment management and advice. The court reasoned that the complaint failed to state a cause of action because the pleaded allegations, even if taken as true, did not establish the requisite duty owed by the defendant to the plaintiff, noting that a broad contractual relationship alone does not automatically create a fiduciary duty, and the facts alleged did not rise to the level of an attorney-client or other recognized fiduciary relationship sufficient to support the claims asserted.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Review of Demurrer Sustained Without Leave for Failure to Plead Fiduciary Duty in Investment Advice Case: The court reasoned that the complaint failed to state a cause of action because the pleaded allegations, even if taken as true, did not establish the requisite duty owed by the defendant to the plaintiff, noting that a broad contractual relationship alone does not automatically create a fiduciary duty, and the facts alleged did not rise to the level of an attorney-client or other recognized fiduciary relationship sufficient to support the claims asserted.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive to regulate court costs.
Testo completo
#$%&$#'(($ )#$(#'((%
*)
) )+ +
" ' , - '((%
$. / -
01111111111 2"
+00 )+ 3 45) !" #!##$ #%
!" "
#$%&$#'(($ $!&'$
0)
) *+,-)........../01+0,2#3 '+450!%64 #31()78$,4+00+0#654#339)+044+!!654#339/ 4 5+4 + ,4 4 :0 5 ;; # 654 #339+55)
*+, -).......... +00 !! ,2 #331 < + =;;4 + =$454+40 >4$< = ? +,+ 54 @ =4 += +=454+40) = 4 +A0 +=454+40 + #((B + # 64 %( 5,2 #333/ 4 + "(B >;) 0 + 1 654 !((#?)+044+!954!((#/*+,-)..........00,4200;4 += 4</ 0 040 C +4 @ 4< @ , + # +0,2#333/2+A0+=454+40+"(B/+D;4C= E44+55)
) 4 5+4 + ,4 0+0 @ F + +4 040 C +44 +=4 += + 55 =04040,4) +</+044+!1,2!((#/ 4;,0=400C +554044,0C +404 0+4@+,4$+=454+40+4#2!((#) 4040C + +044 + 44 45 8 4 50 @ 4 4 +004,)
) *+,-)..........460!12+4 +044/+0C
G6 ,+ C4 6 4;4 +44 4C=@ =0C + , ,4A 5 A45;/6=54!(6=40504+ ++H+,44;4C454#%& 1 9 540 @ ;, 4) 7 4 ,0+46,4+04+0+C46=54E48 +=I 0 + + 4 , ;4 0
&#% #&!((# $%&'$
,E:4CC40424+0040/+6;; 6+=E4 / 4C= +,4$ ,= 00 +0J
054 + ## 654 !((!/ 4 6 + 6C=G0+0C=0200;4+4,0,4/ ,4+=24A4+454,22,I+0J)
+)
;,K
460 < + ,,44 + 7$ ,4/>41 7'3 ?52)
00,4+=;;40 42;,0,@ =4 %/ ) % + 4 + # 5,2 !((! ,+4;4 4 =A44 6+444>?)
;+K
#) +044 + !9 54 !((#/ *+, -).......... 54 I ,4 200;4 += 4< +=454+40 ;,0, @ =4 % ) # /8,+C455L5;E4+44,0,@ + 545 + M$544 545 @ + M$454+40/4200;44+=+=454+404<) = 050C450)
&#% #&!((# $ &'$
!) +044 + !1 ,2 !((#/ 4 44,0 + 4+00 C =0 ,44 040 +44 +=4 += +554+<4,0+4@4<+=454+40)
;;/4*+,-)..........=+4@+55/ =4+=+,4$I54A0+<#+0,2#333/+@, +C+A0+=454+40+"(B400)
%) 7=4!% 7K
N555;+4@4/+0<+ 64/44;)N
N74,408;+55+5;K
) ;+64+00+0C4/++0</5454 ,0A ,, 5 55 5; C4 44545/+M4!"/%40O
2) ; 44 + M4 !"/ % 40/ C4/ ++0</5454,0A,,555 5;C4+064545)N
N +4 @ + 55 + 5; + 4 ,4 6 + ,4 C4 4 +0< + 64 / CM ; 44 +0 ;,0, ! 40/2/,46+,445M+4)N
) =4! 74CK
N +450 4,40 @ 55 @ 5;K
) 744;C,4A+0 ,4+48O 2) 74,4A+0,4+484+454 <C+4504 "05O 74+#105<C+450 4 "05)N
&#% #&!((# $"&'$
-+C=+=;C= =54 "05++450!%64#31() =44 +4@+550CI,4200;4+ =4 %)# ),;+0)
&#% #&!((# $'&'$
+)0 ) )+ +
"
6 7 #) P4O " 7
#) 6O !) ;,4+CM5;,0I + +04 + %( 6 +< 4;44 4 ,,+0 +0 42;0+0+/7EQ4HE;C4'/'(( /4 8,4) ,0,4 +4 K ? 4+4C 8, C +044 +04244++044C0O2?8 C,4;4,54+,++044O? 4A++0) 74,0,44 400,0,00?2??4$+/ 42;0+0 +,4<CM4+5+0 452) ,0,4 + ,4 ,: + 5/ C4 64 ,0,4 M4 MA4 + 4< 4 + ) 7 0A, 64 ,0,4 +044 C0 M5 + C0080+40>)#%!/#('#(1?)
A;;4<K 04+K *4$4 R 4S
0I,,4C04;448444C=@=;;4;0+0 +4A;;
&#% #&!((#