Commercial Damage Calculation Formula Dispute Affirmation
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe petitioner challenged a decision regarding the calculation of damages in a commercial dispute, arguing that the lower court improperly applied a formula for damages calculation involving multiple compounding factors and specific statutory references, which resulted in an excessive award for the respondent. The court reasoned that the statute governing damage calculation in this context mandated the use of the specific formula contested by the petitioner, finding that the trial court correctly interpreted and applied the governing law, even if the resulting damages were substantial, thus affirming the judgment for the respondent.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 al. 2 LTF; Commercial Damage Calculation Formula Dispute Affirmation: The court reasoned that the statute governing damage calculation in this context mandated the use of the specific formula contested by the petitioner, finding that the trial court correctly interpreted and applied the governing law, even if the resulting damages were substantial, thus affirming the judgment for the respondent.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited for the decision on court costs in final order 4.
Cited for the decision on attorney's fees in final order 4.
Testo completo
!"#$ "%$&$!$
"' !(') #) "$ '!#$ #)$
*+ #, - . / 01
2222222222 !" #$ %# % % &%'$()**)+,$-
%
##!" ./&$ $& & 0 *1 233, $ $/
.)42.
$ 3
*" !&/ 6666666666" $ *772 ( & 8 /&$ $& 9$.(:;<%;%=$- %$ & %$ > %/$ %' $& $$ ? % &@ %// $"
)" A B$ *75) ; C- & $0 '$ $/ &; $& & $ $%" % // =$ D & $$$' &; $ $> $ &;$/% %$%' % # $?"
%$& $% %&$- E6666666666/&$.& $ F ('" ;%? % $ ( & ; %$ ?; $ '&&&;$& "
," % & ; %/ )333 !" 6666666666 %@ & ; ?$ & ; $ #- & D$ &; %' % #( % % % & $F/?$'$ %F;%$-$"
+" G% $/ $% &;#%%$ & 5 /= )333 & 6666666666 /&$.& $ % $ / '$-$.$;'$ F)1H1A3".D"&% 7H1+5".D"&D$&=% %$"
1" 7 % %= )333 6666666666 ?; / & $ &$$ & %=(/ &%&% $? %&% @ $ % %?;$/$ $%&? & $$" '$% # $?$ *75) &'$ %? I &% %' $ $% % # $? $"
)3%'/=)3336666666666$&$?F;? $ / ' $ %?F (%- /&;$& &'%$ &% $ '$ '$ $/AB$ *75)"J#=$$ $%% # $?'$& A3 K F A1 K F *) % %$& $% %D%& 9D% $% # $? $D $ / $?< $ L $%= ?; '$ & $ % # $?&%$'I #-(*19G%$'$ &('<M"
2" /&$.%$&;6666666666 $/? $ / '$-; $ F#-&;?%$ $ &%$D& ;./&$ & *A / *77+ 9 !< % & %$ D& ;.$& &)3/*7A*9 <";@ $%&& *)*1 )) $ $$%&$ &%=(/&$?$% $ $/ &%$&6666666666&7% %=)333"
5" )7B$)33*; D&&#- $ / /% $D ?;$;-$$ &? &$'&;$& "
4*5)14)33+ .,42. A" , B$ )33* ; %$$ &$$% D%/ %$ & ,* %N )33* ; &$ I F & #- %N $D$?/ $ @ ? & &' I @ $ "
7" &$$%D%/& /=)33*;%D$/%$ $%"
*3" * %'/= )33* ; % ( & $= &/$$ $D D% $% %// $= % & % &$$% % F% $% F$#-&%N $ -$F$ $% & %' % #( & $ @ $% D$ & %N $D$?/ $ F ;@ $%&? & % %#;$& "
" B-/ & 5 /$ )33) $= &/$$ $D &/$ % %&/;F/=%F;D$ $D// & % #(& $"
*)" G$$ &; % & ; $= D& & 9 O < ; $/ &/$ )* B$ )33+" B-/ & $= &/$$ $D&5/$)33) '%> $= %&%$ % %// &;$ $% & %$& %' B-/ "
$%/=$ F;?$ &;./&$&;/%/ & $ / & /=% D$ & $.$ % ? $% & $$ $ / % $ $ &? &$'&;$& "
G ' & '$ % &$ %$ & /&$ " 6666666666 6666666666$; $ %$=&'%$$ $ / % # $?$ &N ?& /I/ I $ $ /'$ & ? & $$ ;'$ $ @ $%" $ $% %// $ $ $ %$ "
*," ,3%N )33+ * /=)33+; ;% /$ $=&&%$&$("
*+" ; /$D &+%N )33,&6666666666/% & )2H)1+D"&% *3H3,*D"&D$&=% %$% $ / & $&)5 B$)33)*AB$ )33,$$?;D &6666666666$$ %&% $&*)&/=)33)/% &*1AD"%J@/&; %&"4$/M"
*1" *, /= )33+ F &/& & $= & ; ' 6666666666& /&$"
4*5)14)33+ .+42. *2" *2 /=)33+ $=&&/&6666666666?;$ $D$?/% &D &+%N )33,% $ // & % #( F? $ / % $ %&"
*5" *1 % %= )33+ ; $D%/ $= & ? &$%-#$ & ; '$ % 6666666666 )7 /$ )33)"
*A" *A% %=)33+6666666666 ?%$& $> D$ ;%=B &D &+%N )33, $ %? F (%- /& ;$& &'%$ &% '$ '$ $/*75)"
*7" *) %'/= )33+ $= & $D%/ $ ?;$ &$ %&% @ $ %D$ 6666666666" /$ %$ &;%B &/$$%&;@ $ D$@&$,&/=)33+% ?;D '%$' & $%&;@ %B & /$$%&;@ $"
$;% &%$ F%$"
$ "!
*" %$-'%$;%-$ $%B&$$$9< /%&$D$ $ $ &( *%N )33, $= %&%$%/%&1B- &% $& '$.$& 1 *2 B- 9 " * " 12 <"
G$ F; $%&; $%&*2B- $=D& )5B'$)33+9 O*,3*32<& %$-'%$&% *,D'$ &$%$ $% $ %$- / $= %& %$ & $- F %$ B- $ $ & ; & ; $%&%'@B-"
G%/ %B-&&;( $$ =$"
)" %D%// &$%$ $D & ; O & )* B$ )33+ $= & %&%$ $%%// $=$$&;@ $? %D$6666666666/&$.& $ "
4*5)14)33+ .142.
! #$ 3 )$ !(') #) "$ '!#$ #)$
. 445
67585 9 455 5 % * ):;
*" &%@ $/&$P
)" %D$6666666666P
," $ ?/$$%&;@ $$' :
− &%$&&%$"
− @/$;"
− $ $ / DD 6666666666 & )5 B$ )33) *A B$ )33,"
− '&&%$&$; &? & $$Q*)*1 ))' $ / $ & 6666666666 &$ ? $ / $ $"
− $ ; & % #( 9% *75) F $ & ;$& & $ $%&AB$ *77)<' $ / $ &6666666666"
− .$$ $ . $ / RG$%$%?%$ ?R
− $ $ $ / % # $? $ &N ?& /I/ I $ $ /'$ & ? & $$ $ ;'$ $ @ $%"
− @$?%?%$"
− G$ %$ &$ $ / % # $? $ &$ ;$ %%& $ / DD 6666666666"
− '%N & $ / % # $?$ ?&$ "
− $$#%%$&6666666666D$&=% %$ D &6666666666'&%$9D &*)&/=)33) +%N
4*5)14)33+ .242. )33,< % $ / % # $? %%& %N & $ / % # $?$"G$%@$?%?%$"
− O$ % /? $B &&%$"
+" D%/ $ & ?; ' D%/ % % I & &$ & *3 B% &( % $D$ $% $ %//& & $= D& & G#S$0#%D?$ 2 233+ %$ @/$" &$ I %%-" //%$ &%$ : < $&$? @ / ?&$$%% &$%= $$ &&$$% ?P =< @% % ? /% $D $ $/ %'%$ &/& &$$%P < % $- % & % " G$ //%$ % $ %$ / / % < =< < $.& $=D&&% / $(%?;$ &'&$'="//%$&%/ $%%/%> & ' ?$ % B%$ $$ ? &$$% ? ;'% & ? @&$% 9 "*,)*32 *3A<" -DD$(: $& : >G $!
%$%D%/& I % $D$@ $$$?;F;DD$D& & =$?-DD
4*5)14)33+