Discovery Dispute Over Privileged Documents and Burden of Proof
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA party sought to compel the production of documents from the opposing party, relating to the subject matter of the litigation, but the opposing party resisted, asserting various privileges, including work product and attorney-client privilege. The court addressed numerous specific objections to the production requests, generally holding that general boilerplate objections are insufficient and that the opposing party bore the burden of demonstrating with specificity how each withheld document fell under a claimed privilege. The court ordered the production of many documents, requiring a detailed privilege log for those withheld, emphasizing that the work product doctrine does not shield documents merely because they were reviewed by counsel, and that boilerplate assertions of privilege are inadequate to meet the required showing for protection.
Regesto Legislator
UfficialeIMPOT; FORTUNE; INTERPRETATION | Examen et définition de ce qu'il faut entendre par les termes "chauffe-eau individuel (cumulus)" d'une part et "service général" d'autre part pour l'alimentation en eau chaude. | LIFD.21 al.1 litt.b; LIFD.21 al.2
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAApplied for the allocation of court costs.
Testo completo
!"! "
! ! """! " """# $% "" "!
&'&&&
!"#
"
'( )( *( ( +( ,,-.- / 0- 11 /*1 2 /%%%3/*1(
!( .-,/-1,45..-6- ,78+9'::: !%%%3 -;;1-.110-0;-2< *+ ''='#'( , /. '::# *+ '>=?'@( , /. '::>(0-1,;1-2 *+#>=@$'( (
&( !'.1;!%%%3/1---5-6- ,78/ + 9 -5-.-;;;/+,,.-A-'::: !%%% .0-1,; *+'%&=$%%( (/-1,4/.0--- 2 *+$=&%&( (
$( '#B0-!%%'3)(( +(.0..1-(-.--1,-; -0-1,;5-C;(.--/ + .--55-111-0.-,1-,0.-5-A-D-- 0-...(
@( !: B0- !%%'3 / + . -;; ,7 0; A--,,ED/0--C.,'::#'::>0-0 ,.-.,,,<A.2 *+!&=>>:( (
?( .,- 13 -;; ..- 2 / + ! 5.0- !%%'1.-1(,3---D-D/'::#3- 0-,.,11--./-11;3/1--...( '::>3-0-,.@"#711-3!"#71..(
--0.<C,3-,,D0 -0D/ + /0-.5-5/-11; !%%1!(3-;;0-1,-D----DD 5 .- '#%3'> 1!( ,7 0- . 5 5- --- F /-03 - 0- D 5 <;-; .- 7 A1'@:3:&1!(-;;0--,,-D.55-- %3:@G,A-355--D/ + 0-1./55- 2 '( 3 -;; --D- D - C- /*13 AH11;I7%@<&%(5-1---.1-(
#( '! 01; !%%!3 / + ,-1 1- .1- , -1,/5;--11;--'?%1!1- 5-( 0<3/ + C1.0/-11;,- 1, /1.C1 A ;- - /( 0 -0,/.5-'::>/.;----2 *+'&=##:( ,
"!$%$"!%%& &"#
':::2 *+':=:?:( (;-5--5.'@01;!%%!,- 0 -1,; *+ :?=@%%( 3 /+ .1. /.0 2 *+!=@:!( ,.(
>( '@01;!%%!3)(( +(.--,7 11--1-7/+6- ,7811--9(
/ + 0-,.:2'%1;,-/1.C1 1--,.A;-(3A1- -- <55C3 - 0- . D/- 0- --D. , D /<.-5-,0-C..D/--,-D/ <55 (1-D1;,-/1.C1 1--1.'%2:,1-5D55--, -1.'3',-2'3%,-(
-1,.1-'1-!%%&3-;;,.-. D<55 .--. 3D/--':>$-,-/ ,-.'##-(1-1,D/;-C-3 - ;- ,1- , , , / ;- -7 /-0,-<(
:( / + .,?1-!%%&B(
--C,-0-0;--11;--3, ,--71 55-- -5 2 /1.C1 /-11; --;-/<(
,- ,.- A- + '::@ '::?3 -;; 0- 1,- 51- ,.-5-D 5- /.0 1-A 0 -0 <D-11;-( 0.-.1-.5 <;-;3,-,..1,I,/<;--3/1.C1 /-11;30..3---C..,-02 0-0;( / + ,.--.-55--'% !%G/JC;J-1(
D--D.5.-/ + 5-C-<-55&--. K1.C1/-11;L1,2;-DK<LA 1-3-8
<55 --0-619
0-C..(
/,73 -;; 0- <. ;-D K<55 --0-L.D-02%,-D0-C...-.; 0-',-(
"!$%$"!%%& $"#
M / + 3 -;; 0- 1 1,- 1 0- C.. /<(13-5-K<,0 / 1 ,. C1 --; / < ,-7(,,--30-/<-.-20- <55 619 2 <D -0. /3 - /.0- --3 ;-C-3(L(
/,73 0- 0- .. - ':>@ -,- /I71--;-C../<3N/-/ + 3 K- < ,0 / 1 ,. C1 --;/<,-7L(
'%( .,-D3 -;; 1- A,-- / + .2,-D(
''( .-- '! 01; !%%&3 11-- 1- 0I.-2/ + ,0.--(
'!( .,. '? .1; !%%& ,7 -; 1---53 / + .-- 2 - 2 5-1-,,.--'!01;!%%!(
M 3 11-- 1.C- - --;- C..-. / < 1I / ,,- -D 0 ,-. - ,,-(/-,.--0-C../<;-C-2 A1-,<D,,-.-0--<55 <---,1- -5-;-<3D-.--1,-;(5-1 D-12D/0-1-11--3-;;-,-; ;-/<55 <55-<55 --;- / < 1-7 C..-. -- A ;-<0-(
'&( 11----D.D.--0-...,-.,/ + !?01;!%%&(
'$( )( ( +( B / + 2 5-1- -1 11--3 5. -,.- - <55 --0-0-C..--DC11- 1(
'@( / + .2.,-D(
'?( MD-3..C.2BC(
"
"!$%$"!%%& @"#
'( B. 1, - 0 B--- 1,.3 0;6(@? -=C--B---!!01;':$' !%@O(?&('-(-,.1---0'! ,1;':>@ @'%9(
!( --C,,D55--1.'3'2'3%,-, 11-- 1-5 D / < ,- -11; / 1-7--0-,1,,0-C..(
2 - -0 2 5-1- .-- ---/ + (
&( /- !' -. ' ; - 5.. /-1,4 5.. - 6+ P M ?$!(''9 ,.0- D/ -1,; 1 5 -11;--7 ,-- K;9 0 -0 -11; ,- /-11; -;; .0 /C - - ,,-../-B-;2-C-L(
2 /-. ! 1H1 -,--3 - ,.0- D K 0 -0 .1-. 1, -- /--- 55-0C11---;;L(
5-,--3/ + .;-D---. A,,-.-/,,10-3-D---, --0--/I01-0(
,--0CD/-5,1K<55 --0- 619L / , K0- C..L / , , /-1-<(
-.311--1-D/0- C../ <,1-/0--1--!$<!$/< D-. D- /.- , / <55 --0- 1( <55 / ,-. ':% - -, )( ( +( 0 2 -1 -- A ;- < ,1 , --;-!$<!$3-0- C../< 0-,,,--/,7(
D-,-.<55 )(( +(3-. -,-5--D.0-/,.2<-7 D/,1,,1--;/<<3;-C- -- D 1H1 - -- , -11; 1,1;AC1/-1,<1-!$ <!$3-51D/,2-K0-C.. /<LN// + (
"!$%$"!%%& ?"#
@( .D31-(
?( .--11--.(
#( .11 *+ >%%( 1- 2 <C )( ( +(3 D- 1;6(># 9(
QQQQQ
$!" ( "
)*+,-.
.0;-B.'?.1;!%%&,/1---5- C0- .-- 11-- 1-7/-1,45..-'!01;!%%&O
+,-/.
/1O
.--11--1-7/-1,45.. -O
12<C/--1..11 *+>%%( O
- D 51.1 A - :# -0 - 5.. =C-- B---3,.H,H,.3,0--1---53 B 7 -5--3 , 0 -; 5.. O 1.1- ---D-31-51I,0,-C 1- O - . - A1,- 1- -; 5..3 '%%% '$ O ,. H ,-7 ,- 3-0D.111I,03-0HB-2=0-(
11-D ,. H 2 /1--- 5- 3 2 11-- 1-7 /-1,4 5.. -3 2 )( *( ( +( -- D/2 /1---5..-;-(
M-.C8 )10I3,.-3)(I<73)1*-3)( <.-3)13 BC(
"!$%$"!%%& #"#
1 -;1---58
C55-7 B-B(8 0- ,.-8 )( - (0I
,-51H..11-D.A,-(
703 C55-78
"!$%$"!%%&