Petitioner v. State Regarding Retroactive Application of Retirement Law Change
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe petitioner challenged the rejection of their early retirement request, which was based on having accrued the requisite service time under a prior regulation, arguing that subsequent legislative changes should not retroactively apply to nullify their acquired right. The court reasoned that while the petitioner had met the conditions for early retirement under the law in effect at the time they filed their initial request, the subsequent legislation, which abolished the specific early retirement provision relied upon, was applicable as it was a purely procedural or immediate effect law, and the administrative decision to reject the claim correctly applied the prevailing law at the time of the decision, thereby dismissing the appeal.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Petitioner v. State Regarding Retroactive Application of Retirement Law Change: The court reasoned that while the petitioner had met the conditions for early retirement under the law in effect at the time they filed their initial request, the subsequent legislation, which abolished the specific early retirement provision relied upon, was applicable as it was a purely procedural or immediate effect law, and the administrative decision to reject the claim correctly applied the prevailing law at the time of the decision, thereby dismissing the appeal.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThis provision is cited in the dispositive to rule on the costs of the appeal.
Testo completo
A/3750/2005 JPT ATA/88/2006
ARRÊT
DU TRIBUNAL ADMINISTRATIF
du 14 février 2006
Monsieur X__________ !"#$%&'#
#
D PARTEMENT DES INSTITUTIONS
()*+(
EN FAIT
01 - 2 )//0& #$ 3 ## 45 $$$$ 6 3# !#$ 78888888888 9$(: ; !1 78888888888 # 2<& $2 2$$ 8888888888& $ == >##"$3$=#2 $#9$(:; <&4$$ # >$3 9$(:; >$<1
45 $$$$ #=$ 6 $ 2"$ #'#$ ?$$$1 #))'$)//,2$3# #$3 & #$ ## 3 ' $2 $ '#2 &#=$2$$# >$3 )-2$)//@1
)1 2 "2 =$ 3#A? 3 # & # 3$ $# #$ # )+ ='$ )//,& ## #$ (#22$4$ $# 4" $##%$ 5 A$1))# #A)//@&#"# )-?'$)//.& >2A3 $####($2# $=43$ 3%'$ ' $#==$ 3$= $#B $).0 ,0@ # $)02A0C,-9 (D,001<&$#$ $#$ $# 42'$ $1 >2A3 $##$4 !1788888888883'$ "$$###6 $ ' " $$$ & # 4 #$ $# A? $' 3 $,0@ 3 $ $1
,1 @ '$ )//.& #$ 2 A$ # =$ 3>##$ 3 2# # EF +)3//-&0/ # # $'$ G ?$ )//002)//.10C2522#$&$3=$ '$ 2 $ $ $# 9$(:; H $2 ; 2 ? $& #$ $ <1
@1 0. 2A )//.& = >" # & 2# $= 4 =$ #$# # & #'$ & > &5 $>"3 4$#A# '$'$ 2$ $& $ $:2 IA>$I ? $1 B =$ 3$ 3 # 2$$ $'& $ 3 $ 2A#43$'$ =$ #$ 632A#$## '$1&3: $ 2$ $#$$$$1
.1 )/ # #A )//.& !1 78888888888 # : $A 2$$ $=2$2 EF+)3//-&0/'$ 5 6.J: )'$)//0# 3 1# # 63# $#3$2$ # 6#2 $#=B=$1
*,-./*)//. (,*+(
+1 ) 2A )//.& # 6 2 # ? ($ 6 #2 $# 2 B =$ 1 !1 78888888888 '$ # 2 #2# $# $$1 # 4 2 #$ 'A& $# 43 #2# $ '$ 5 =# #$ A$ #1 & 2 $#$ 6 $35 A$9D)//)@)-<B 24 $A 2$$ $= '$ ## 2A#2 =$ 3'# B# 2"$ 3# ?$$$1 ?$ #'$ 3$4 21 # 3A#&$($3 $ 2"$ &2$=# $#$1 !52 3$ #'$ =$ 3#A? $# #22 ?"& $ #'$ #2 3$>$>$&4$3 2"$ 1#K & #$ # 23'$ 63$$ $ $'#'#$ ?$$$$(25213"$$ ## " 4 $1 =$&2#'$ '#$#$#A$$ L #22)@='$0CGC9 M )@/<1
-1 +2A)//.& $# $=#24 $ "6 ?"1
EN DROIT
01 $A 2$$ $= B2$ 3#==$ $A2 'A$$ ##29 1001) H *0)@*)//.G2)//.<1
)1 ?$$ $# L #$ $ #$$ # 2 $: 2$$ $'9 1.+ 10#$L#"$ $#?$$$))#'2A 0C@0 ( ( )/.<1 # #' # $$# #$ ?$$ $#2$$ $'& $@&.&+$0& .- #$ # 2$$ $' 0) 2A 0CG. 9 ( .0/<& = B $#'#$9 1.+ 1)<1
,1 D# #$#22$$#L $@$0 & 2 $$'$ #: $ L #$ L: =##$ A$=& # % ##A? #$ & 2#$=$ # L #$ # #A$" $# 9 1 <& #$ # LB$ &L$B$ #L #$ &L#A$" $##=$ 9 1A<&#$ #? #$'A2 6 & 2#$=$& # # #$ # #A$" $# 9 1 <1 '>& $# 4 #$ ? # $'#4 $#6=$'#$'#$L $#?$$$&L #$#22 $$#9 1@1, <1
@1 B 2 L $ .+F & $# $$ ' $A 2$$ $= #' # $# $' 6 $#
*,-./*)//. (@*+(
$$ =# #$ A$ # 4$ ' =$ L#A? L$$#L $.+ &$) 4$# # L & #22& ## $# A$2 #$ A$ " A$9$0 <1
.1 1 D# $# $$& L (6($ $A " &4$ $ 2 6L# #$#22:&# 22 $2 $ 2 & L# $#& L$2$ # $# L1 $ "#$#$ 4$# #$ 2 $ 6 # ?$$4 $A " 1 $A 2$$ $= $$ #2 # 2$2 $#=$$: ' " 4 =# $#$ A$ $# L $$$ $ 2 # L L""2 9 F E1 )C ?'$ 0CG-<& # #2 '2 L# $##22 $'$>:
9 *)+/*0CCC@2$0CCCH 1)+#'2A0C-@<1
A1 # &'>& $# $$4$# $ 6 $#& 6 L A$2 6 $$ $# # '$& 6 L#A $# L #2# $# # L '2 & B '& 6 #$ L $N2& 6 $ " $# =# $# $ 6 L' $# # 6 ' $# L =# $#& # $#$ B#A? &L$$ L $== 1 #22 L $$ L $A L5 ?" 2$: $ L #A? #4L #$ >$>$4$#L $ #'#$L$ $#&#$ #B$"L4L# $# # L# #$ $ 6 $ $#1 & $2# =$$ $' 4 $ $" A#> L# $# L #22 L" & ($ $ #22#$9 *+,/*)//0C# #A)//0<1
L:& #$# $ 2 '$ 6 $ >"3 >##$3'# 43$2 #= #$$4345 $$$$#' 6## 1 '$ $2 3#223" #$' 5 #$#22 $# $$1#43 $#$$#$ 'A&$ = #4 $##$ =##$ A$ #1 #'$ :# 2$$2 $$ #$ 2 $ >"=$1
+1 #'$ $ $"3' $$ $#3 $' % #;
1 2=$ 3#A? 2$$3#$$$$ $ $# $ )- #$ " $' # L2$$ $# # A$2 A$2$B@2A 0CC- 9 ( . /.<1 $ 0+ $ 0 ,/ &
*,-./*)//. (.*+(
' $2 # AO2& $# ## >= '$& $A#' >= 2 1
3:& 2 =$ 3#A? 3 ' $2 4$ ##>='$&$#=$2 >$1
##' 63# 2 $ $$? $=$ =$ 43#$ 2$##$$$$$2#$A2#$ $$ $#3 6$>"=$=21
A1 D3"$ #&($ #' 3#==$63# 2 3 2$###($## >2A 3 $#1 # $2 B =$ A$ # 2 ' & $ 3 # B #$ $ 3 =$ # 3#A? 3 $ 1 3## #($ >2A #$ $ 6 # " $? $=$13#$2 #A$" $#3 >" =$ = 3 =# $#$& = 3 A "B1
1 D# # $& 3 #A$" $# # $# '$(6('$ # #& 4$ #$ #2 #22 $2 3 $ ,)G #$ = #2 # $'$ $ ,/ 2 0C00 9$' $4$:2 ; #$ #A$" $# ( ( D ))/<& 2$ N #22 $ '#$ =$$ 3" A$ '$(6('$ 3 1 # $'$ #$ $$ # " #$ =# $#$& # 22 " $ $#6'&6 2$A&$2 #$ 2 $ & 2$ 3$ # " # >:2 B1 #$ "2 # " # 4 $? $=$ 9F1 & PQ> #" R '#2 )-1 D 2A 0CCG $ 1 E 1 &#> S== $>$ &&0CCC&1-,<1
# $## 4$? $=$$"$=$# 4 # $'$ A$4 #$ #'#$ B =$ = 3 =# $#$ # 4 $ $# #' 1 ?#3>$ $ $"$B 3 == $3" A$4$$ ' 4$? 2 $A 3==$A$3 $#3 1 3:& #$ # "$ =$ 3$ =$ 4$ $$ A 3$ $# 5 # $ $= " $# #% $ 5 A$1 & #3 2$#($1 $# 3 # =#$ 6=##A$" $#3 2A#=$3'# # 21
#$ # '#$ #$A$$ 3 $ >" 3 =$ = 3 =# $#$ #$'$ 3#==$ 4
*,-./*)//. (+*+(
$ "$ # $ 4$=$& # $ '#% # #A$" $#1
-1 2#$ #5 $'A1D# &4$#2A& #2B=$#5 3:6 EF03///1(1 TTTTT
PAR CES MOTIFS LE TRIBUNAL ADMINISTRATIF
$'A 2 =$ )/ # #A )//. !#$ 78888888888 # 2 $ $ $#
2 6>"22#2 EF0L///1(H
#22$4 5 6 ! "#$ %& '# 2 $$ 43 2 $ $ $#1
D$" ; !1%>:&$ &!2#'% E$&!1 >$&?"& !1E# $&?" 1
#2 $A2$$ $=;
"==$:(?$ ; $ ; 1$#(D$"$ F1%>:
#$#=#2 5 #22$4B $1
:'& "==$:;
*,-./*)//.