Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATA/865/2005 • CJ GE ATA/865/2005 Generato dall'IA

Trust Amendment Validity and Undue Influence

Numero d'incarto ATA/865/2005
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Parzialmente accolto (Partially Allowed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The situation involved a dispute over the validity of several amendments to a trust, challenged by beneficiaries who argued the settlors lacked capacity and were subject to undue influence during the amendment process, specifically citing a significant shift in distribution favoring one beneficiary just before a cognitive decline became severe. The court reasoned that the evidence, including medical testimony regarding the settlors' diminishing capacity and the drastic, unexplained change in the dispositive provisions shortly thereafter, was sufficient to support the finding that the amendments were the product of undue influence and thus were invalidly executed.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Trust Amendment Validity and Undue Influence: The court reasoned that the evidence, including medical testimony regarding the settlors' diminishing capacity and the drastic, unexplained change in the dispositive provisions shortly thereafter, was sufficient to support the finding that the amendments were the product of undue influence and thus were invalidly executed.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
circonvenzione illecita trust validità del testamento mezzi di prova medici rottura del rapporto di fiducia modificazione delle conclusioni

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive regarding the allocation of court costs.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

        

        

  

   











  ! " #$   %$ &#!   '  %( % (   (  







(%   $(   % % ( 



   !"# 

 

'(   ) * $+& ,- ''   ..  /01 - 2 -01))-33-/0,-)-.-)-03 -(  ,.  )-   )  3 4 0561  40 -  7.14082  4 (

  0-33)33..))-339-333.-60-33 33 )  - :  -  /01 .; 4--)-  '+!& 4 0-<-,0/010- 3)36---4--)--0-(

  )333=0'+>') - ?!#&!#@AAA()AB(C(7D(

   )- 3  <64 3.B !%%$1  )0- -   )  B-3  ,,-   (  )1 -= )  -. ); ) 0-1 4 3 .2-.  +% .-1 ; 0-33.3C3(

  9-  3)   1  -  /0  3-3  )3  3.3C.)3 4 056(

!(  ))-01-/0)-)-3.7 ..6-4 &3.B!%%$4BC-53 6---<64---.037-)$+&1- )--E53)-'.'+++-)C)-. ?F(!%  4   -C-- -/  & ).B '+#+ ?9 @ 9#F'(!'D(

$(   0- )B-3   8- E 0- ,,-- ?- )/ G 8 D  !H <0-!%%F1E 065)B-6? ((!$#%D  E.3C. )0--   )  3 E 0561 E53 -   -  )  )  )-.1 -.-3 : +% .-1 0- 5 BC3(

   - C0-  -C B 9-  E --  -35  2 -0))3:))-)-.(  .-   0-  /0  3.-  )30- ,0B 6 :  BC-(

F(  3--'H.-!%%F13:-/014 <3 65E-33&3.B!%%$0)3--.  6-  2 -0 ?>E!&% 037- -..-3 ) 'E>&# ) 

"$%%"!%%& $"# 

=B!E&+H.3-03D1/)0--E.3C. )<3)3 E 056)-B--33-)-. .3C.  7  -. 2-(  3- )3-3 6  3-- 3- )-B     $% < )/   ..--     .-/  - ?- )/G I D1 ,.3.:E-> -E))--3C--,33 ---/'H3.B'+H#?  J'%&D(

&(  3'H<-!%%F3)-3) I !'<-!%%F1 -/0 3--1K!'.-1: -(-0-50;3:4 )64-)53 BC4---..0-C(

   )-  33  )  I   -  .)- )  '' 0.B !%%F(   -1  )3  4   --636-E,,-0-C-4.-/))-) )4)<3,---,143--,-6)< )30;-3-4CC-(

>(  3--!F<0-!%%&1 I 33-0B  4 .- ) -  .)3  -B .---,(   -3363--343-)3C.-,-    4- >  -3 '  ( 9  -)--  ,,1  I   )0- L 6  3C.-   ,- 3-3 )3)3-:>%<3)33C-/.(

  E3-)3--)-)E 'H.-!%%F(  - --)3--E-F-3'-   )3 .---0  '! ).B '+H& ?    & '%D(  ))--  - &>     -  EC-- <---  !! 0.B '+F' ?   ! %&D1   0- 5 .-  -B .---,1 6 3- 30  )3-  <---  .-/ .---0(

#( ( 0-3 :  3.-1 4   3)  !' . !%%&  ) E7--6-(

   )  3 E 056 3-   =  0( ,-1  )-.2-E3-)-0(  B33,---   -- 6-1    E- !F -3 '   - ,33E.3C.--!!<-'+#+?  9#%%DM 3- -B    E- !F -3 !     0- N: E.3C.=0-/2037-)7  ,-N( ,-1  E- !F -3 $  1  - E--3

"$%%"!%%& F"# 

)B-6 )0- 5 -3 -  -- )--)   = 3- )3E.).3--.)3)--(

  3-E)/.<-3)0-333.3C3 ,.3.:=0E.)--.)- )3-.--.(

 B(  '& 0- !%%&1  -  /0 4  ))3 : <-   .)3   0 64   < 4 3C.-   ,-163-)- I 640-- 6 4)) :  3-- ,0B )- - )/   I  )- -B.---,(

  -1,4 4453--- -.)*$+&--C00--4-!F  (  -. 40- 33 -3 64 -   )3  )0-(.-,-063)4 :4))-,3- 33)-()1 2 -03-25.. B-3)O-C0--?-1 2 -0!%%%1)O-CI-CD- 2--6-.B-.)))O-C)-03(

 (  <C 33C3  )-3 E   - 0;  53 6- --  -.   )  26  3,3-  65   -  /0&3.B!%%$(E 0;3-B353 )3-3'.'+++16-BC-26--3-3-(

H(  96-133C3:<C(

 ( 

'(   -B .---, 2.- E,,-  .)3 ? "$'>"!%%& !>0-!%%&D(

!(  9E-$-3'!-,33---/ '+ 3.B '+&H1 6E- EC-   -     0-C <6E $' 3.B!%%F00-C)-'<0-!%%&1?  9 #F'(%'D10-3  303-.- -,33.)3)--1-3C ---(

     E-3 F   .5. -)--1 NE -.--  )-)-)053-36E3-))3C 7B-E)73.-/.)BB- )-E-1)3-31,--3C--1)

"$%%"!%%& &"# 

)301)-,-:E2-C-.)3 )--(-1--)5-   )C 3C.3  ,K )3-1 ..   6- E7B--N(

  3---/-.) 30,-EB<E-.---, -B,33?( $ ( F  D  6 )33..   0- 5 )3 0  -,33?($(F D(

   ..  03  6-3 ) - 6  . 7--3--?($(F-,- D(

$(  E- '%# -3 & 91  .5. 6  0 - '%# -3 & 91 )30- 6 NE-  3- E  3C.-   ,-1  ) )  . 6- -  B  -C  .- )-B  --( 6  - 6-  3.-3  3C.-,-.-,-13C.-32.-3 13731BC3)E-3N(

F(   .-,-- )3 3 E))-- -1  -B  3,3,32-)--)3-3/'<0- !%%&1-)--,E;E-)7C3(

&(  3--)-'H.-!%%F)E !F<0-!%%& I ,3E-> 1-3'! 1---B3G

  N3C.-,-3-3)3)3-: >%<3)33C-/.)0,-EB<E)/  I (..-6-3)-(

  3C.-,-)<: )N(

>(  )3)3),E EBC1:65 -/01E53)-'.'+++)3).<- )-) 03).--- 6---N )C037-.B-)-.:)3 E 0561  K .)-  E0 -  7.  E0  82N  BC-  3C.- 3- -0  .)  )C(

   , -- -3  65 )33 : E  )  -  & 3.B !%%$ ..  .  -3-  E53 )3-31 .)    .-,--  - -01 ?-   -)--)0-B-D1E-'%#-3&91

"$%%"!%%& >"# 

  03 ,,-73 )  -  /0   E.3C.   )-   ) ,. :  ,,-  =  0    E-!F-3' 1-0G

 N'(  =  0 .)  - 0 : EC )B-  -33.1--6-.-/M

 !(  -1 --  3,-7.  -- E-  0 : E.3C.  -2  3.  )- -1 )-0.-.-/M

 $( ,-1---)--))313).) 2)-.1 )/ -   ..-- EB-.1 -  - E--3 )B-6  E.).  -.)3)--12)--C-N(

#(  65BC-3C.-,-E)4   0-3 : E- >  -3 '  1 .. E <C3  I ( ,-1   3C.-1 )30 )  - $ -3 F    '%#-3&91-0)0-,-EB<E) ))---+HC+H-EC--<--- ,33'>3.B'+F$?8 9'#$(''%D1.5.-E-> -3!   )30-  -1    - .---, 3 30 0 )/  -B ,33   3--   -/ - (

  C-1-<-,-63C.-)-50 EB) I 1)-373)-B31)-  2)3(

H(     -- 33 -0B  .- ) -  .)3: I (

  E---C1-))KE3..(

PPPPP



$ % (      

3 -0B   -<3  'H <- !%%F )  -  /0 3). .--)  E.3C.1  -    0--    3--4,,-)--'H.-!%%FM

"$%%"!%%& #"# 

.)-.)3:..--.-/ -M

-6E-E))KE3..M

..-6  )3 5 :  -  /0  3). .--)  E.3C.1  -    0-- 1 : 4,,-  )    ----64:..--.-/-(

9-3CG I( ;7/1 )3-1 I. 0;  J-1 I( 73-1 I. 1 <C(

. -B.---,G

C,,-/ <-G  )3-G     (- 9-C- 8(;7/  

)-,.533..-632)-(

 /01  C,,-/G           

"$%%"!%%&