Statutory Interpretation and Prohibited Conduct
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case involves a dispute over the application of a statutory provision to a set of established facts concerning the parties' conduct, which required the court to interpret the scope and intent of the relevant legislation. The court reasoned that the plain language of the statute, in conjunction with legislative history and prior judicial interpretations, clearly indicated that the specific actions undertaken by one party fell within the prohibited conduct, thus warranting the determination reached by the lower tribunal regarding liability.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Statutory Interpretation and Prohibited Conduct: The court reasoned that the plain language of the statute, in conjunction with legislative history and prior judicial interpretations, clearly indicated that the specific actions undertaken by one party fell within the prohibited conduct, thus warranting the determination reached by the lower tribunal regarding liability.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court explicitly orders the appellant to pay the costs of the proceedings.
Testo completo
!
""########## ! "#$%
%
$% && &'$() )&& & $
""##########
&'()&
&
./ .0++1.002#!34444444444#%355516$#% % %!4444444444#35& 5 75&68!3!44444444449/
'/ 5 .+ .0 :$5 .00;# <5 35 !3 !4444444444 3<5%/ %5 % % $ % 3=/ >% !3 !4444444444# %5 !3 4444444444 :55 5?&5/
*/ 2 3<',,.#!344444444443#@5 355 % %5# 1 !3 !4444444444# 5 3 % %5 35# %3 5%="5 35 5/
3"@55$5 @%%33= 5 A @%% 1 % %$ 35& 5 # % 4444444444# 5% % B !3 4444444444 $5 <%5 %3 56 @ 5 5%$ @5 $ 5% 55/
2/ %5 . % %< ',,. '0 C$5 ',,'# %5 !34444444444 !3 !4444444444 B5 3 5 %C% %%5351&5/!3!4444444444C 5:5 :5 B%5!34444444444#!5<#$5 5 B@5D$5 %:5 @5 A /!34444444444$5 %"= %5 5 %35 !E 5F<<5 5::/
-/ %@ 5 "%5B*.C$5',,'#!3!4444444444 5:%3%$%5!34444444444B@5 3 % %5 1 56/ %5%# !3 !4444444444 5 B@@$5 :5 35 5!34444444444/
;/ ==3 5 # %5 !3 4444444444 6!3!4444444444%5.-:$5',,'/
)/ .' 3 ',,'# %5 !3 4444444444 5:%3 !3 !4444444444%5 5%55 3 @ 5%%5 7$5% 3 @%%35 G5&68 3 9/
+/ %5 35# !3 !4444444444 % %5 !34444444444B5%="5 5$1%5 5 5 %5%# @$5 = 35 56%3=3 .00;/
(*)+(',,- &*()&
0/ %5''3',,'#%5!34444444444$B !3!4444444444 % 55 # 55B @<% @$%5 C35 :5 @35 55 #5 $%5 5 %% 3=3 /%5!344444444443=3 1!3 !4444444444 5 :%5 %3 "55 % <% %5 B5 $5 :: 35 5/
.,/ '- $5 ',,'# @D %C% H %3 5:%3 5% B5#!34444444444%#@ 35%%5#5 6 3 # B 35 % 1 %3355% $5%:5% 75&68%3355%9%5% %3 /
../ < # !3 4444444444 5=5 5:%3 5% % 5 %5%!3!4444444444 :5 B@5$5 35% %%535#5 %3<3/
.'/ %5*35',,'#%3355%% %D1!3!4444444444 5 * C5 ',,' % 35 5 % !3 4444444444/
.*/ ', 35 ',,'# !3 !4444444444 %<$ 5% 1 %3355%/ !3 4444444444 $5 5 .0++ 1 .00'/ > 35 5$5 5 6 55 5%#B5 5 %:5%/ %5=5 B "55 5 =5 3%635 B@555 B<% %5D :: 35 1@%B$5 5$5 /
.2/ '.:$5',,*#!3!4444444444 35B@::535 A %5%535%5!34444444444/
.-/ %5;3',,*#%5!3444444444431 %3355% @5 $5 :5 B !3 !4444444444 %5 @ 5 %535!34444444444/
.;/ '-3',,*#!3!4444444444:5 $55%="5 %5!34444444444/
.)/ %5 .) % %< ',,*# %3355% 3 1 !3 !4444444444 %5 5%="5 B@ ::535 $%5 5 .' 3 .00; @% $ 3<5%= % ::535 $%5 $5 53.00;/
.+/ '*% %<',,*#!3!4444444444 351%3355%%5 5 B@$5 %:$5.00;%3<5%=/
(*)+(',,- &2()&
C% 5 %B5%="5 5 $5 1 %%5%5%33'-3',,*/
.0/ 0 3< ',,2# %3355% $5/ !3 !4444444444$5 35%%<5= 5%=%5 1 3 %5 % %5 35 1 5 # 1 3/ %3355% %%5 %%55%% 51$%D%535/
',/ .+C$5',,-# 3 55%% B 355% %5 35 1 5 35 6 3 % 5 5 5 </5C% 5%%$ % :%5 <5 %5 5 # 3 %5 5B3 1 % 5% B !3!4444444444$5 355%%5/ 3 $5 $ 5% % =53 5% # 5B !3 4444444444#%5 5#@$5 B5 5 %/
'./ .) :$5 ',,-# !3 !4444444444 5 C % &$ 5<% 55%/ < #!3!4444444444% 5 B 55% 3 5 @ <53 5% :5 # I 3$55 5%%5 /B@1:5',,*#$5 5% 3 %5 35 1 5 # @<% 5% @ %:5 @5 A $%5!34444444444#5B@$5 C=B %55 @ 55 %&5# :5B@15 3<5%=% $5 $5 53:$5.00;#%5@ 5 % %3 / '- 3 ',,*# %5 5335 3 6 B %3355% @5 C%5 :5# !3 !4444444444 $5 35 @ 5 %5 35 5 %5% $5 % % %<5= 5% =/ $5 % B@ < = :5?5 5 B 55$5 @%<5= 5% 3 %5 5 B5 :55 3 =5 % $5% 5% 55 =5 / !3 !4444444444 5$%B5 % :5 B 3 @ 5 %5 1 55% % %5# 55% .+ C$5 ',,- 3 $5 A # $ 5 :5 % !34444444444/
''/ .0 $5 ',,-# 3 % % % 1 %:53 5%55%.+C$5',,-/
'*/ '; 3< ',,-# 6 $%5 5$5 1 :%3 %<$ 5% 5<#!34444444444%:53%5 5%%B !3!4444444444$5 :5 %< 5%1 355%%%5/
& )
(*)+(',,- &-()&
./ C 3 5 $ C55 5% %3 # % $<7 /-; %5J%=5 5%C555''%$3<.02.& & ' ,- G / ;* / . 5 / %5 % 355 5$ .' 3<.0+-& & -.,9/
'/ 55% % 5% % 5$ % % %<C % @?5 #@5?5 %@ %5 %@%<5= 5%7 /2/.5 /< 9/ @% @:: :%3 # 535 1 %:53 5 5% ?5 % :% C55B 1 % / 3 553 ? 355 @A :5? :H% 5 %5 %<5= 5% % @?5 @ % / 55% B 55%3%K% 5B % 1 35%%535%3 1!34444444444/
*/ @ 5'%5 %% % 33< %:5% 5 ;3<.0+)7!>&E.+,9#:55 % %53555B%5<6/$%5 B3 %5 :55 /
2/ @6# % $5 % 356 :%5 5 !34444444444B@$%5 $%5%5%%535 2 3<',,./
3" % 55 53 5 5% @ %:5 @5 A =/ 3A"3 = C$5 ',,' 5B@ %$ %5 @ % 5 % : 5 A !3 4444444444/ % 55 ::53 B@ 3 5 %5 1 5 %@ 5 "%5B*.C$5',,'/ @ ==3 /
% C 5:5 % :# %3<? 3%5# % 3563 B@ @ 5 %5% 3%= 5# 5B@ %$5 #%5@ 5 1C% 15 @3<5%=5 $; L #%:53 5 5 555B B3%=@$5 =/
% =3 ::53B!34444444444@$5 % <%5 % %5 % 3" % B@ $%5 % % 5 / B %:5% # % $5 % %I @ 3A3 %5 1 % 5% % %5# %5 B5 3 @ ? 5:%3 5% 55%%535#53 $%5C 5:5@5 A B%B7/! #%5 5 :135% 3%5# M#.000#=.2,9/
(*)+(',,- &;()&
-/ $%D 3" <% 5#!3 4444444444 % 5 %5 $5',,'6 3 / @ B@1@5 %#%5 :$5',,*#B% 35%5% %5 1 5 / 5%="5 5 % :%5 % 3B # % B!34444444444N3 B@5% $%D '-3',,*/
;/ 3563 5 355%%36 % %5#5@ %@#3A35@% 5 %3 5::5 5 %:5 @5 A =!3!4444444444/
)/ 5 @ < @ : @ 5 %:5%/ @ 1C 5 B %3355%B 3 % % B!3!4444444444$5 355%%5 5 /
+/ 6 % B@ 5% @ 1 @% !3 !4444444444#5@D5@ 3 56 /
0/ 3%3 OF.J,,,/&351"=!3!4444444444 B5%3<7 /+) 9/
PPPPP
%(& ) &
*+",-!.
$< % 5 C .) :$5 ',,- !3 !4444444444 % 55% 3 @%%35 .+C$5',,-G
",-/.
C G
3 1"=% 3%3 OF.J,,,/&G
%335B A 1 ! "# $% % # 3 @%%35 55B@1!34444444444/
>5= 8 !/D"6#5 #!3O5#!/ "5#!3%#C=# !/=#C= /
(*)+(',,- &)()&
%3 5<355 5:8 =::56&C5 C/8 5 8 !/ %%5 F/D"6
%5%:%3 A %335B? 5/
6$# =::568
(*)+(',,-