Service Contract Arbitration Clause Unconscionability
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court addressed a dispute concerning the validity of the arbitration agreement embedded within a service contract, specifically examining whether the agreement met the requisite legal standards for enforceability, as it was heavily dictated by one party and contained one-sided provisions. The court reasoned that the arbitration clause was unconscionable because it was procedurally suspect due to fine print and unequal bargaining power, and substantively unfair as it heavily favored one party by imposing costs and procedural hurdles on the other, rendering the clause void as an unenforceable contract term.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Service Contract Arbitration Clause Unconscionability: The court reasoned that the arbitration clause was unconscionable because it was procedurally suspect due to fine print and unequal bargaining power, and substantively unfair as it heavily favored one party by imposing costs and procedural hurdles on the other, rendering the clause void as an unenforceable contract term.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAApplied for the allocation of procedural costs.
Testo completo
!"#$%%%%%%%%%% !"!#$%&'(&$
$
& '()(& ((*+
")*+"
(
/0 $1%%% $2&(!$%34444444444( 55 6% 71$8%7% %$ $9%%%$ 7$99%$7 :%"2;7 <,-$&1=)---0 1$%( 6% $11 / >&% )--/( $ % ? 7 =%1 ' $ 7 %%$%6 &$1 $0 %% 1$%>%)--)$1$ % 7% %$@%99% @$ $ =%6 &0
)0 % 71 9 !034444444444(% 55 1 7$$1%( 71$% 99% ' % :%"2 ; < $ 67 $& &% @ $%% % %$@&% A :%"2;&%$BB<0
,0 9 % / 9&% )--,0 $ 1% % 7& %$( 1$% >% )--,( % $ 11 $ 6 %$C% % %99% $1% $( 7 %$ D7 %E( %$%=%% %%6 $9%%"1A10&% %99% ?&$% ?$F $1 6 % $ % &% 1$ % ? $ %1$2 G$%6 ?7$&% &%76%0
H0 $& & %$ % ,- >&% )--H0 B$ $ !1 B8&% $G( G9 BB % G%G%6 % !034444444444( %"% 7&% 1$ % ? 7% 5 &%0$ =% % 6 ?$ % ?%6$% %&% %$ ' &%%&%0B$ % 9%& $ 9$ %$1 5% G5 &% 1 % $ % %$0 7 $ 1 ? 6 %$ $= $% $% $$570
.9&%)--H(!034444444444 =%$$$ ($ $ 11 $1 7 $=$ 1A1 &%0
.0 I 9&% )--H( 7 % $$5 %$ $= $% !034444444444>67,/1=1A10
I0 $ 7 % %$%6 1$% 1% )--H 1$ % 6 %$!034444444444 % $%$11=$$99% $ $1% % 0 &% 7 G % ? =% $1 9 ?$=$ %$&$250
*,)-*)--. ",*+"
J0 1$% >% )--H( !03 4444444444 7 $5$ $ 8 & $> $ BB0 &$85 &% $ 11 C %%&%$ 1%' 1 $ $ % 6%&% A 9% !0344444444440
$ % $1=%%$ G5$% $%6 !034444444444 G%G%($$ %9% % %$&%0
K0 )- 1= )--H( $& % %$%6 %( 6% %% % % &%( C% 11= &% $G1% 0$ $1 =%? $%$6 $% G$%6!034444444444 % $L%16% $ 9$% C $$1%( $=%% &% 5$0 B % ? $5% ? $$ MG 1%2 $G % %99% (1A16$% 8 G201%25(C% &% 9$ =$%C1 ($6C%$% %"1A19$ %$ 0C&% 16 > %C % 6%0 9%(%16% $11% %$% $ 9$% % %&% %?&$% % $ 0% 2 $ 1 ? C 1 9% ' $ &% % 5'0
+0 $1 )H 1=)--H(!034444444444 1%=9% C %9% 1% $%% $ &%$%$ 1%0
!03 4444444444 $ 9$% % &% ? .-N 2 1%"$&1= )--H % $% ? & ? C 5 $ 1% % $%$/-1=)--H)>&%)--.0
/-0 /) >&% )--.( C 1% 9% ' $ &% & !034444444444 ? $1 / 1% 1A1 ( 9$ C %)- 1=)--H0
//0 +9&%)--.(8% C $ % $9% A !034444444444 $?C %$%%$%%1 %% 6C? % 5 %$ C% L ? % =%%%( % $ $ ? 6C %1% $$ ? %' 1$% % = $% $ $ 0
/)0 /K1)--.(C $> $ ?$1 %$ !034444444444'9%0
*,)-*)--. "H*+"
/,0 J &% )--.( &$ C $ % $ 9 % A !03 4444444444( = % 8% % 0 1 ? $&$% %6'% C 0
$ % =9% C 9$1 %$ 2 $12 ( $% $ 11 $ $ &$1 $= ? 9 % $$1%6 $% C%&% 2& %5%% 151 C&%$1 %& C $ $8 G%6 90 % $%5%5%%&%(%O1C $ $8 G%6 $P8%0
!03 4444444444 &% 55 1%2 1 C 2&?$1 />&%)--/0 % $%$$= $% C %I$%5 %&$71%% %$ $ =%1 =%1%'H1=/++J: ".-.<$ $ %%1 0 C% &% =9%% % $% CA 0$% 1$%5% %$%99%% $ $25 &%( 1% C =%% 6 %$ % %99% 0 !03 4444444444 &% 1% $ G% G5 $ %%1 $% 9% %0 %%$ % %%=% % 1$ %& %$699 0$F (G%G%C% C&% =$9$%?$50
/H0 , >% )--.( C %60 %99% $G ? !034444444444 % %1%%C5% %$ &%% C% %$ $ 9% 6C % BB0 C5%% %%1 C16%5 %%$$1A1699$ %1$ &% 55G6%$9& C% 0 & &$85 $5$(%&% Q% %$%6 ? C$=> $$ 1%&% 0 9%(%C&% >1% $1%$ %9$%C%C % 0
/.0 /->%)--.(%$1 %$$ %C 0$ C8 (% $&$ (C 2& % 9$ %$%C (11=&%$ G1% %%6% %BB0
% % &% '%6 6C C&% $% $%$ % $C %&% $ %C% %$ $ 9%0 C&% $GG? %%%$ $1 $ $%$0 %$11 % 2$1=9 %$ ($ 11 %?A %5% 1 0!034444444444&% $ $ &$$ $ G9&%&$85C% % $5$0 1 C&% %1%$ &% $5$0$ 6C%&% ?
*,)-*)--. ".*+"
$%$ C&% $% $11 %9% % C&% $%5 & 9% %$ &% !03 4444444444 C 2&0
!034444444444'$6C%&% 55$11% "&% C% %$ $ 9% 1% 6C $9% C % &$ %&% 6C% % &@=A $%@0&% R6% 1$% 9&% )--) &% $11 ? &% $ % $%% % %$ 1$% 9&% )--,0 C& %$ 1$% 1= 1A1 % =% % &% 1 &%?> %9%$$5 %$ %$$= $%0$&% %$G%=% 9 $%( %"% &% $ 1%2 A $%5 % &%0 % &% =% % % $ G9 &% ?$1: $5$<(1% % % %$%&% %5%9%= 1$ 6C%C99 % $ &%0
/I0 )- >% )--.( C $ %2 $11 %( $ &%$%% %$ =%!0344444444442$&$85 $5$0
/J0 ). >% )--.( $ $ 11$% 2 6A 0 C% %$% $ $1 6%$ &%% &% % %66%%&% 9% % GC=% %0 %%$%%1 /)>&%)--.&% A 0
/K0 )+ $R )--.( C $ $ $%$ 2 6A 0 $% % $%$ > $ ? $1 %$C% '9%0
/+0 ) 1=)--.( %$ &%6 % 5? >50
+ 1= )--.( $ %9$1 599 %= 6C% C&% Q$=& %$C L"%%$ 1%/) 1A11$%0)H$ $=)--.(% $ $ % $ % $9%1' %6 % 5?>50
( &
/0 > 1 % & >%% %$ $1 ( $ &=: 0.I $%7$5% %$>%%%))$&1=/+H/" " )-.L 0I,0/ 0$%$1%% %&/) 1=/+K." " ./-<0
*,)-*)--. "I*+"
)0 $% CA 5 % 9$1 : A %= # )0).I*)--/ )H >&% )--) $%0 ) A % L */J)*)--H)1)--H<0B$ 1%1%% $% $: 0H/ < $% 1%% %9%: A %= # /0JH)*/+++ /. 9&% )--- $%0 , L # /)H H+ $%0 , 0./ A % L A %=9/)$&1=/++K=%% # /+++ +J $%0 . 0 /-,<0 B% $ %$ & $% %99% ( $ 25 1%%1 % 0 6% C%6 : A %= 9 )0).I*)--/ )H >&% )--) $%0 )= L /0.H.*)--- /H 1= )--- $%0 ) A % L 0 S( $1%% %&()---(0/+K<0
6C% 5 % C % )+ % ) 0( $% CA $1$% $ %9%&$%$% && 6C %%$$% %(9$%&6 '9% ?%9 %%$(C&$%2$%( %%?C1%% %$&( C $% 1% ? $$ : A %= #)0JJ*)--,+>% )--,$%0)0/ A % L */J)*)--H )1)--H A % <0
C2( $ % % = $ 8% (6%&% $$$111$%$0C% 8 G$%% $ $ $%( % $% ? $ %6?$C $% % %10$ $C %$1 %$$(%%9%&$%%29$% 1$8$ 11$%26A 0
B$ $% CA &% %% 51 $6C% %9$1%%$ %=5C99%?>5 %C8&% % & $% $ C% $ 6C% &% $ %1 0
,0 0 C % I $% 5 %& $ 71%% %$ $ =%1 =%1%'H1= /++J : " . -.<( 1$8 11= $ 5% 6% $1% %$ $= $%0 B$ % H. HJ 251 7% %$$%5 %&$71%% %$ $ =%1 =% )H 9&% /+++ : " . -. -/<( %$$= $% C $%($&$$5 %$0
=0 B$C %,,I$%9$1 $%&%%,- 1/+//:%&%6%21;$% $=%5 %$: "B))-<(%= &$%C %HH (C1$8 %%$ +-1%>$C%% $ $ % &%0
*,)-*)--. "J*+"
0 99% >5 /K &% )--- : *).)*)---<( %= &% 1% &%% C $5 %5%9% 2 CG %$ $= $%($% &% %= &% =9%%% C%$$ %$C %HH & G0
C2(%%$%%1 ?C$%5% $ /)>&%)--.0 $1 %$C%% &% $ 2 )H 1= )--H $ >$ ? C 5( % &( /- 1= )--H ) >&% )--.( % % %1$%= % $ %9% $ $5 $% 6C% % =9% C %$ $ %$( $% 6C% % %?C 5&1%%$$1%0 8 $%$%6C% % $%$$= $%$ %$ %%$0 6%9% %$ %$ &% C 1 % %5% %0
H0 %$$= $%( $%C 1 9%'$ &% %%% %$6% C2C $%1$%$9%C1$%C2% %$C %)-%, : 0/J%%6)-0/ ) <0
%%1 $ %9% $ % %1 $11 /) >&% )--. $ CG ,- &% 1A1 % % 0
$%&$% C $% %$$%%1 C1$8( $ %61 $1% $% =% 6% $% %% 5 C% % %$ C=% % : *,K)*)--. )H 1% )--.L *IIJ*)--,) 1=)--,L *H/+*)--,)J1%)--,<0
.0 $&% 2$C'1%%$5 =% %C %+ $ % %$9 $9 %$%/K&%/+++: 0"B /-/<09% 6 %=9C% $%%C% % %$ C=% % $ 6 $ C1% C % H C% $ % %$9 $9 %$%)+1%/KJH: <( $% ? $& % %$ $&$% C'1 %= (6% $% %6?%6C%'0
C2($ 55 $ C=$%C% %$ $ 9%( % 9 0 C'1 $ C %%$%6 &$1 $1$ % C%6 %$ $ G%G%0 $% $1$ & $1= $11% C% % 1 $%6%% % $9%06A 1 %= $ 1%51 C =%6$ C % =$ $ & $25 &%0 %1%%$ $G
*,)-*)--. "K*+"
G%G% $ %1 5 %9 %$ &%( %99 $ $ % &$ ? C5 ( 19%$% 0 =%51 6$ % $ ? % $&$85 $5$$$% ' G%G%0 % &% C =%C$%5%G%% 6%$ 1% %$ &% $ C 2&( 2 $ 6 %99% C$ %$( $ >% $ %= ( $ %= $ % %$ > %9% %%1 C 9$ %$% ?9$ %$%%C1$8%$$= $%: *I.*)--H )/>&%)--H *IIJ*)--,) 1=)--,<0
%%1 $ C =% % % $% & $( % $% & $ 0 9%( % 51 %%$$ %$% : *J,H*)--))I$&1=)--)<( 1(G8$ G21$%%%%&C &%5=0
I0 $1 $&$%C'1%1% $ %$ %= C$%%1 C1$8%$$= $%( $ $% A > 0 $ ( 6% $1=( $1 ? 1$1 (A C2? T#/C---0"% %$C %KJ% / 0C$ $% ?%1% $0 UUUUU
)'(& (
,-./ 0
&= $ % > + 9&% )--. !$% 3 4444444444 $ %%$C$99%$7 /)>&%)--.L
./ !0
> L
1 ?G5$ 1$1 T#/7---0"L
% 6$ C$% ?%1% L
$11%6 A ?!"!#$%&'(&$ $ %%67? 7$99%$7 0
*,)-*)--. "+*+"
B%5 ; !1$&8(% (!08G2(!1T%(!0 G%(!1$( >50
$1 %=1%% %9;
599%2">% ; % ; 0%$"B%5% #08G2
$%$9$1 A $11%6' %0
2&( 599%2;
*,)-*)--.