Dispute Over Benefit Calculation Methodology
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAAn individual challenged a decision concerning the calculation of a benefit or allowance related to their professional status, specifically disputing the method used to determine the applicable index or basis for the calculation as applied by the administrative department. The court reasoned that the applicable legal text provided a clear, unambiguous reference point for the calculation, and since the initial decision correctly applied this mandated reference, the grounds for contesting the calculation methodology were unsubstantiated, leading to the dismissal of the appeal on its merits.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 93 LTF, Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Dispute Over Benefit Calculation Methodology: The court reasoned that the applicable legal text provided a clear, unambiguous reference point for the calculation, and since the initial decision correctly applied this mandated reference, the grounds for contesting the calculation methodology were unsubstantiated, leading to the dismissal of the appeal on its merits.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive to declare the appeal inadmissible regarding the procedural aspect (inadmissibility on formal grounds).
Cited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay the procedural costs.
Testo completo
A/3836/2005 JPT ATA/82/2006
ARRÊT
DU TRIBUNAL ADMINISTRATIF
du 9 février 2006
Monsieur B__________
D PARTEMENT DES INSTITUTIONS
!"#
EN FAIT
)* + )#(% ,---+ . /- 0000000000 1- 234/*00000000005++-+6728- 9:+-+2-++;0000000000;62+--+2, ---1- 234<-,+2,=-.2- +-+5 !' , !''$* >+ -- ? +-@+ 6 9-++ 2+-?9--@A=?9)#,!''B*
!* !%=-!''(.-++0000000000;6.-@-- -++ ;0000000000 ;6. ,+ 9-- 9:: /* 0000000000,,:+-+*
$* )(C!''(.2-1- 2342- @-59+*/*0000000000+--+2 ,-8-@4
* )%2,A)##&.-@-++,+2@-9=: 9--,2+62-9,-9,2-,@-2 ?-87-.9+8-,9-:22-7 DE%)'* ,:-F8-2,,,2 9 -. + 2+-+ ?. 9-@. 9-++ @- -3,+,,:+@--,*
A* )) 2,A !''). /* 0000000000 @- ++ -,2-?+ - @ 22-+- G- ,,-* @- ,+62,.,,-A>* 23@-++ 9A= 9-. /* 0000000000 @- 2-@- 2 9@- ,H-+ 2GF-?,* -@- 2 =: 9-- ,2+ 2 +- 2 -,2. - @- A++8--+ 9 -. @--, @- -+2-.---,2-A2-2+.
* )' @- !''!. ? /* 0000000000 2+- I 2:9@+G-,2:-22A-00000000001- 234 00000000005 - @- 6 @ ,H-+ 2:3 ?9- @- 2?+* -9+-@+A:23-?,-@- -*!#=@-!''$. -A9- -A@- @-8-,+9 -)%+,A!''!2=: 9-- ,2+ ,-8 ? 2:3 + @- ,2, :-8 ? 9: +-+ +- 3 +:--,+ 6 8- :82GF-?2,2-,--.?---,2-A 2G+6/*0000000000*
"$%$&"!''( $"#
J* B2,A!''!./*0000000000@-6@++-,2-?+ ---,--.8--2+*
(* )) A !''!. /* 0000000000 @- 8- 9A= 9 ?-3, -28--,--?-9+-2-6 -. =: 9-- ,2+ F -++ ? 9?> 9@- 2+@++9--@-*
&* )'A!''$./* 0000000000@-++,>+ 6-- 9F - 6 ,H- 2:. +@+, F + - 6 @ - =: 9-- ,2+ )! =@-!''(.2-:9++-++9--*
/*0000000000+,---?9-,?-:@,@- 8- -- -. 2 --. ,, F - I 2: 2 2A-* ,H-- 22,, 2,F2,,K@A,L2:-@*
G ,-+. 9-@- 9-++ @- 2@?+ @-* - 9-- - 3 ,22-+:8-*
B* !# 2,A !''(. 8+ 9- -++ 0000000000 ;66::/*0000000000,,:+-+,-8?9-@-++ ,+ )% 2,A )##& 2 ?- 87 - ?9- +-+8@A,@-2-@-*
%* !%A!''(./*0000000000+--2+-+* - , 8- 9 ,- )% 2,A )##&. ?- ,- 6 # * @- +=6 A 9-- --+9728-9:+-+--2-6 8- G:, - - ,2F. -++ ;0000000000;6+@-++0000000000;6* 8-.--@- +++-@+!#@-!''$2,-29,68--?!%=- !''J.2,-29,2AM-?8*
2- ) =@- !''$. - 7N- 8- I 00000000002--@-8-9A=@-+AG+ =:,8@*
#* !+,A!''(.+26=. ,-8?-@-/*0000000000+-62@? +- @- -* ;- 9-+ --,+ @- . !''$. 8- 72+ 2 2- @-. 9- 2 +-@+ 9--69-++*
"$%$&"!''( J"#
)'* )$ =@- !''&. 2- ++ - ,2-24
* /* 0000000000 72+ ?9- +- -- 9 -8- 8++ 2-+ AG- G-* @- 7+ ,+- =?96 8- +2,-@-CG:2-+*@-++ -@,G88.2-@-* @-,,+67-@-+ ,-+-+)#%J63@* )#%B.-+-+@- 9 ,, :- 2-. 28- ?9- @- 7+ 2 )' . @ @- ?- - ,- ?- - @-++-8-:+)##&2?-87-*
@- 2- -@-+ ,, : +-+ @- N -- 2 )##$ )### 3@* ;9:-.-@-++-+672-+:,.- )##B 9 !'''. 8, 9-- 2@-- 000000000023 -A,---8@-*
= 9-. - @-- ,, G88 A ,, I ,+ 23 0000000000* 9:-- 6 9 -@-+ 28-62-,2,---+,-2-@2+ 2+. - ,2- @- ,- +-+ G--*;,2F+-G-9@--+6 7-@-+-*
@-- 2- 9 !''' 2 0000000000* 2-?- @- J''I2,-*?--+-2G+9+-++ ?9- @- ++ ::+ 2 2 2- 22, - I 0000000000* @- 9- ++ :+ - ,>, 6 7 2-*;9:-9--?-9@-22+622-+- G-,,-))2,A!'').72+ ?9-+---A@,H G-?9-@-=:+-,--A?9 822 -, ,, 22-+- 9@- 8-* - 8,, @- 2-@- 2* 6 9- F - 6 9> -A 9- !# =@- !''$. - - +, ?@--,.?-@--:+.@-2A-,A*
+,+.-->:7@-*
A* 2+ 9-+ --,+ 72+ ? G 2G+ . 2- -+,. 9+- 2 3 :@* @G. +2+--8+?.--?-22-+-9-++ @-,++2,62+--?+*
"$%$&"!''( ("#
++-@-+6+2-,2F 2-++-8,+?96+2--3.-:+6 =:*
))* )(=@-!''(./*0000000000--A9- ,2F ? - @-- ,, KI - 2L 2- ) =@- !''$ 6 )''O* /* 0000000000 ,- MG ?- - +- 8-+ @ A2 -@F @- - -3 -8- 6 ,2F* +- -+ 6 7 -@-+-+,++?9:+-+*
EN DROIT
)* =+ ,2 - @ =--- ,2+. @A1*(& -P:--=---!!@,A)#J) ! '(< * &$ * ) * - 2+ ,---@ )! 2,A)#%( ()'5*
!* G+2+--?+.?-+2:-* -A ,---8 ,- ?-+ 88- ,AA. ? 9,2F 9@- 2 1 "$$B"!''( )' ,- !''(< "#B!"!''J )J +,A !''J< "&%&"!''J $) C !''J< "&)$"!''J(C!''J "!!#"!''J)&,!''J5*
$* 2-+-+)%A)##&1!)(5++ ,-8-+ 2 @- 2 +@-- . $ =- !''$ 1- 234 @-5* - 2+. )) =- !''J. - ,-8--!+,A)###1- !)J5* 7- -9 6G+6@-*- -2-- --. ? 2+ ,---@ =--- 2 6 9+ @-: @- +:- 2 @-*
++ +2+ !% A !''(< 2+ -3,+:-2@-2--*
J* ?9@@--8-+--!#2,A!''(. @--+=6,,:+-+2-)##B 2-)###-3@*+:,?-?8- 8 8 @ 9-- @- ?-+ 9: +-+ +- - @, 2. -@!',!''$*
"$%$&"!''( &"#
(* @-3+,--P-+--,+2@--. -- +?-@ 6 +@-. P-- P7 28- 9:+-+?P@-+-@+*
* ; =-2 - 1 "!BB"!''J $' , !''J -/.-,---84,---8I. !''!. !3, +--. 2* !$& Q!J$5. +-- ,---@ -+. ,-8-A -+,* +-- -@ > 8, 6 P=--?* P,--+2P22 6,-8--P +-- -+:. 8 P- -,A- 6 P-+ 8- -@-:- +- ?P-- ,>,A8-*
? +@- - 2-A GF2G3. - F - P7,- P-+> 2A- 2 2--2 22--+ 1> -+.2*$$'.$$)5*
A* 9-+> -@-+ 2A-? 6 ? : +-+ - -+2GA + 9- # -+ ) * 2 ?- @ 7 28- - 88-. 2 ++. 2 ,2,3.:-9GA--+2G3 9-@-+@-:+* -A+22+--88+,,-- 2?-7+=6-@-+9:+-+?-8 2* @- 9A@ 2 ?9 2 7 +=6 9-@-+28-+??92.9-6 -A+ +,-? 9-++ + 2 : 1 "#B!"!''J )J +,A!''J "&%&"!''J$)C!''J5*
* 2--2 22--+ :@ -@-+ +-? 22--P-$&-+$ --8++ 8++- -)%@-)###1 *8+* ;)')5* ,,?--6 - 8, ,,. P23. -A+ :- 2 P- !B * 8+*-22-+A@-+*
923. @- 2G+ - -@97-28-9:+-+*+2++ :2+-.?--++,+8@.,>, -G.2--+,929::@-+*- @G-,2,-2?-87- -@ )##&. +: : ,2 ++ 6 9A +--@ : 2 9-++* F - 922+- ,2,?9:+-+:-@-+I 2 - 9 2- -@- @- 2 2--222--+.,2 92.+2+-- +2-@-.92.:@-+-@.,2++. -:, 8- 2 ,2F 8- 9- 6 -A+
"$%$&"!''( B"#
+,-? ? 2+-. +G+. 9--- 97-@-+-*
&* ; 9- )$ . 9-+ ?- + 9-- - - ? -- +2 2 7 -- 8-7+. - 923 9A ,-. -7 2++ ?>. 2 -,2-A@2G39-@-+28-@-:+1*#*)* )$*)5* 8-.69-)$-+$. 9-+ ,---@ 2 +:, 2 @-, 2-9--96-7,-* -3-2--2,-- - ,?, 7 3: 8-7+ 2 - -9--* @972-2--29--- 97 28- 2,- -+ ,>, - 22 ? 9,--+ @- 6 +-2-. 9 6 - - , 9,1 "$$B"!''()',-!''( "B)("!''J$)C!''J5*
923. 9 2 2- 2- - -,- 2@-?I-2.?--,--? 6 7 -,2 -F 8: +-* GG - 6 ,--,-8-.2,2I2--?9-=? 28-+-+* @G.,2F+A-A-8- @--8,?A -7.
-A. F 2-. 8- ?- @-- ? -22-,--,-?--,26 :+-+9-,2+-+-+,-8-,2,8- +- ,-7 - ?9 2- -@-+ 2 :++. @ 97 6 @* --. =--- + -3 ?9 2-9--2+-7,-.-,7-,,9- )$-+$.,2-A@2--222--+* @G.+--8!#2,A!''(.?-+?-@6+@- +9--+-+A-.,:+G:,9,2F*
-A,2-,*
B* 2-,-*;.?-9A-2,:- . ,+ 6 2- 8- 2+. >+ 923 6 DE!('* . ?- ,A +:, 2-,. @ 9?- ,>,,1*%B 5* RRRRR
"$%$&"!''( %"#
PAR CES MOTIFS LE TRIBUNAL ADMINISTRATIF
à la forme :
+ @A -=+ !# A !''( 2 /- 0000000000 +--!#2,A!''(+2,---< au fond :
9,2-,<
+--!#2,A!''(<
+A-9--9::,?-+9:+-+<
2 2 + -7 ,- 6 ,2 +2- 2+ ><
,6G:+,, DE!('* <
,6G:+2,---+,, DE!('* <
,,-? 2+ > 6 /- 0000000000 +2, ---*
;-+:4 /,@F./*FG3./,D-./* G+-./,.=:*
, -A,---84
+- =-4 @- 2+-4 ;*DS *@F
"$%$&"!''( #"#
2-8,>++,,-?+72-*
3@. :88-34
"$%$&"!''(