Residence Permit Continuation After Short Marriage and Miscarriage
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe applicant sought judicial review of a decision concerning their request for residence authorization, which was based on their status as the spouse of a foreign national holding a specific professional residence permit, a right they argued should be maintained even after the dissolution of the marriage due to a miscarriage suffered during the marriage. The administrative court rejected the appeal, reasoning that the regulation granting the right to maintenance of the residence permit following the end of a spousal relationship requires the marriage to have lasted for at least three years, and since the marriage duration was less than this threshold, the applicant was not entitled to the benefit, regardless of the circumstances of the marriage termination.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 33 al. 1 LTF, Art. 93 al. 1 let. a LTF, Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Residence Permit Continuation After Short Marriage and Miscarriage: The administrative court rejected the appeal, reasoning that the regulation granting the right to maintenance of the residence permit following the end of a spousal relationship requires the marriage to have lasted for at least three years, and since the marriage duration was less than this threshold, the applicant was not entitled to the benefit, regardless of the circumstances of the marriage termination.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThis article is implicitly referenced by the decision to declare the appeal inadmissible concerning the main issue.
Cited to declare the appeal inadmissible because it concerns an interlocutory decision (decision on inadmissibility in the lower instance).
Applied to order the appellant to pay court costs.
Testo completo
A/2211/2004 TPE ATA/806/2005
ARRÊT
DU TRIBUNAL ADMINISTRATIF
du 29 novembre 2005
Madame P __________ ! "# $%"&'(
(
D PARTEMENT DE L'AM NAGEMENT, DE L' QUIPEMENT ET DU LOGEMENT
)*+,)
EN FAIT
-0 ""( *, $1 *../& $ 2$3$ & 24"$ (3$ 5")6 7 8 "%"3 $
)(' (" "( $ >"6;6$ 3 ? (@ ('A
) " > $ - 3 B 1%" 2 (" "("0
( & $B$ ""( ($( " ( % "' ( (" "(<"(> $ - 30 ""( $B$C(& (( " "((@? (( ( "(2 $ ;6$ 30
$"" "% ( ""( " 0 >( B (" " $ > (""6" - 32"$$1" "3"> '("%" > '>%EF"$ "(" (3$ 2 (" "( "("0 6 %" '>& '" ( (' $ "4"6< "&4"@"" ' ( %$"0 " ( " "" (( "(" 2(1"3 < 1" 2 " <( """%$"('( "< ('
$1 *../ '(" (" " $ ( ('""((" 0 $( "$" (0
" (" " ( 2"$$10 " 2 ( I %% *J ('$1 *..*& " '" ( 4 > $ '" "& 42 ( '" ($6 $ (' "" 4 3 2"0 ""( 2B F " '" ( "%" H C'" *..G < 2F"
( " -. $ *..G0 *, $1 *..* 5"0& 7 *../8& $ '" "' (" "(( "( "4$ % "( 2 $ ;6$ 3& ( " (" "( 2
< " ()? ( "0 ""( 2'" %" 2(1C 2
+--+*../ )G+,)
(0 $B$ C(& '" % ( (" "( ( " ( "( > $ - 3 '" "%"3&
"6 '" ( 2( $" $ " (" "(0( 2 " <( 2$($ " &'( 3$ <C 0
( C ( < (%"$ "( ( ""(0
/0 -, $1 *../& "1 $"" "% " ( 2"%($ 2 ( 42 '" " )' ($$""( ( ( $ "6 ( "( 5")6 7 ! 823" $42'" (('(""> $ 0
("(6)'12"($ "(( "4" 2 " /$*..;' ! 0
J0 -G $" *..;& "1 $"" "% ( " "( 2 " -/ (" ( $"" "' -* $1-HD;5 ) ;-.80
H(K *..;&( "%($ "1422 " (%($ < 2( $" & (1C ( (& 42 '" " '>"'""(2 $ "4"642'" &$"6 <2$3<(' $ (""6 > "60
( " '(1C 42"'"" <( 2( $" "2 $ " "3">0 'F&"('" &23" 2$4""'" "%"30
H $1*..;& " 233$ ( (%($ < 2( $" 42" '" " 42"
2$& ( 4)" " '%"" "'0
,0 6 "' & ( ( , ('$1 *..; ($$ '" 4"&(" (""6 "(%"0 ( $ "' 7
'1 :( 1
*..* 58 9:*..2/G,0) 9:G2,/D2;G;0)
+--+*../ )/+,)
*..G 56'8 9:*D.2//.0) 9:G2;-G2JJD0)
*../ 56'8 9:*-G2G..0) 9:/2D;-2H;*0)
D0 -/('$1*..;& "( "%($4 " 3 <C30
EN DROIT
-0 C $ " ' C"" "( ($ & ( '1(" '5 0;J ("L(3" "(C""" ('$1 -H/- ) ) * .;A 0 JG 0 - 0 (" ( $"" "'-* $1-HD;) ) ;-.80
*0 ('" L " 2(1C ' "%% " "3 4" ( (( ( <2$"" "(" "$0
0 " (F<2" 2'("('(" $ > "6 ;6$ 3 2'(" " > $ "'$ > (""6(( " "4"6- 3( "$$10
10 '> (' "( 2 $ > "6 @ %"$ ("& " %( %" 2(1C 2 ( )' "1 0 #23" "( > $ & )" % ! ( " (%($ < 2( $" 4" " ( ""( *, $1*../0
( "$ %"<4("6 $ &"% $ 4 ( " ( ( $ 2( $" 4 2 %"$ ($"& $" 3$ 2$ 2 $( 9:;...0)4""'" "%"30
(('""(1C 4"(2$0
G0 0 "12$$"" "' 9:-..0)< 9:J.L...0) ( ( ' <(" (( "( " "("'-/ '" -HDD5 0 -G, 0- 80 $( $>"$$ 2$ 9:*.L...0)(42( "(&" "(( ( ('3 " (" "(&$"4 '>( (%($>" "( 3 5 0 -G, 0* 80 ($ %"> "( $( 2$33'" 2"% "(&""' ("($$ "( 33' 5 0-G,0G 80
+--+*../ );+,)
10 $ $"" "' ( & " 6 $ " "3"$ $(""5 +D-G+*..-/ $1*..-A0!&(" $"" "%7 ( I& ($ *& *..*& F0 -0/0;0; 0 -GH)-/-A 0 #0 9# & #FM"N"F # %F 7 3$" ( N3 # %1O" & & J6$ " "(& P"F *../& 0G,80 L " 4 4( " " $"" "'(" B %"> ($ ""3>3" (" 5 +GJD+*..; */ $" *..; % " 80 ' L " - " * (" 3'(" *. $1 -H/- 5) / .;8& " @ " %" " "( "(" "( 3 ( ("*-$1-HG,5 #)#G--0.8&( $$ L "JG #&('> "('3" (<L "*/ 0
2 (" 4"(($$"" "'@ 62 "((" %"" "(63( <2 "JD (4 (" &$B$$"" ( " "(5 :- -D* A -*- *; -*. 1 ;,80 2$ "" "%"3 ( " "$ ($$ "(""4"" B (( "($ 5 +,-*+*..; *; ( (1 *..; +J/H+*..; / ( (1 *..;80
0 %""4( ' " ($$"% &%K )( %($L"$3"30#(""4"L( $" &L$"" "((" %"''" %"L (" 5 0 # & " (" $"" "%& '(0 *& FQ & -HD/& 0 J/J)J/DA 0 *. $1 -HH/8 C(" L 3 ('(" L" "(("%"3$5 +-,;+*../*$*../("0D % " 80 C"" "( 4L L>6
5 +-G-+-HH,-D%'"-HH,("0;80
26&% ( '&)"@ 2" (' (42 % < 2( $" $ - 3& 4" " '" ( "%" & ( 4 1")%( "("%"3<( 2 " "3">0'$B$ '> " (" "(1;6$ 3$" "%" "$ $ &<(" "( " >"'(@0
0 L$(" ""(( "(" &4"3(' ( "( "45 +GJD+*..;C<" %80 "" ($ & %"> "( $( L$& 3 3'" L"% "( " "(( 0
26& ( ($$" " '"( "( 3" "( " $ "6 ( "(0 '> 42 '" "
+--+*../ )J+,)
2 " &( "& ("1& ( 4$( $>"$$ 9:J.2...0)2 "-G,"- "10
%"33( 1"" "((%($(" " '" "(2$( ( '24" &"2( 6 "(0 $ %' 2" "" 212 0 %"&" "(%""6"$ ( "( " "3"0 ($ 2$1 $ & $ B < 9:;2...0)&(" <(N"6$$ $>"$$3 ""(( "(" 0
/0 ( "" C 0 $($ 9: -2...0) $" < F3( 4"($15 0D, 80 RRRRR
PAR CES MOTIFS LE TRIBUNAL ADMINISTRATIF
à la forme :
( ""( $ L$3$ &L4"$ (3$ *, $1*../A
au fond :
C A
$ <F3( $($ 9:-L...0)A
($$"4 B < ! " # $%"& '( ( "" 4L $ L$3$ &L4"$ (3$ 0
#"3 7 !$('@&" &!0@F6&!$9"&!0 F"&!$(& C30
($ "1$"" "%7
3%%"6)C" C07 '")" 7
+--+*../ ),+,)
!0 ((" 0('@
("(%($ B ($$"4> "0
6'& 3%%"67
+--+*../