Contract Breach Prejudgment Interest Rate Determination
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe petitioner challenged the application of statutory penalty interest rates, arguing that the lower court misinterpreted the relevant statutory provisions when calculating prejudgment interest following a breach of contract, leading to an excessive award based on the timing of the breach and the statute's effective dates. The court reasoned that the statutory interest rate applicable is determined by the date the breach occurred, as the statute in question was intended to apply prospectively, and therefore the penalty interest should be calculated based on the rate in effect at that time, not the rate in effect later when the judgment was entered, necessitating a recalculation of the damages.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 93 al. 1 let. a LTF; Contract Breach Prejudgment Interest Rate Determination: The court reasoned that the statutory interest rate applicable is determined by the date the breach occurred, as the statute in question was intended to apply prospectively, and therefore the penalty interest should be calculated based on the rate in effect at that time, not the rate in effect later when the judgment was entered, necessitating a recalculation of the damages.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited for the imposition of court costs on the appellant.
Cited as the procedural basis for declaring the appeal inadmissible.
Testo completo
!"
## $%&&&&&&&&&& !"#$% &'(
(
'$$()*))+$'
)*+,,)
)
,2 3'(4(5 4(4 &!62777777777784)39 4 ( ( : ;; < ='( 3 = ='( *0>4*00*?0 65*00-2
;4=(5 45' ='( (3'&= >@ @4(=A6('65*00-2B4 @64C& = (';(4@4(=A664*0012
*2 4 4(46(4 =A6;4A@ (;46 4(=44 4(D44 (6644(=A6 '( 84)39(6644(:/'4*0012
)4( ;4A4 4'(6644(,>'4*00?& 6(4;4,.6*001&4(4 4(<4 =A6;4 ( ;(4 4C<2 A( D=E4 =<4 = A6 (;4(2 = (4D(5> (4 C(4D4 &64 4 ( (6 (;4( 6 43 4D 52(4 ((&4 ( (4'4 @ 4 4( (F 4 ('4 =4 4 '4 G2
'(4 D4 64 4 4(( ( ;A 8B "H+ 9 ( I J + + B ! 9 ( I +K BKJ+B JJ 9( : 49 E4 ( 4( D 4( ( 464D ( @ 4(4 4( < D 54 ('< 4 & A 4( 64A4 5 4(=A6G2
?2 ='4 4?64*0012
=( )4 (6( 4 4 A (4 (4 8(;(6= 4 (4 @=(54:;4 4(= 4 &(6=>(4 (666 4<2 4 6 A 4 =<4 >4446 ;4 '4 @ 4 (> =4< 4(( 45;(66 4D @C3 6 (5 (4 D ='( 4 ' 6 (44 (2
( ( 45 ='(4 <4 46 4( 4'& 4 4 4&@;4=(&D='4*001(4 >( '4 C (4 & (6444 @ 6L6 @ 3'&'4 ( 4; 4;6432 @
+*-./+*001 )?+,,)
>(4 % 4<= 4&44 JI=(63 4 44D ( 2
-2 ( '&(6644(4 45A4 A (44' 9
)(4M(<4 4(>444('65,N-,8) *01:
)(4(4'4,0'4,N.O8 P ?01:
)(4;;(6 434'4*-6*0008J(PB*O*:
(4'4 44DA4 D=4('4 456 4(A64( + ( &4 4(,NNN(*00- C(4A4 &D(6644(642
12 'C&=( 4 45A A <A4' 9
) (' 4( ,/ 65 ,N.. ( (6 >444 =A 4(44(6 434'4 (6648 PB02*O*2,,:
)(4;?( (5*00?;4(&44(& ;(6 4( ; 46(4?( (5*00?8JPB,2?0,:2
4 D4 '4 C(44 64 =4 4( *00- + ( 4(4 4 A &4)4;4 4A2
/2 =444DC&4 64(42
O2 4 54A'(,, ,.64*0012
.2 4 O >4 *001& (6644( (664D @ 4 ( A62 '4 (5 ( 4' 9 ' 4 8(;;44 *:9 -&00I ' ( ,9 *&*1I ' ( *9 ?&00I 6(% '( ( ((<49-&10&(4 ( ,O&O12B( = 4?04*3<6 =4 4((4(;4(='( 1 >4 *00* 8 ' P / ,020,:& =A6 ;4 4 4 ( (4 < ( 4 @ *02 =% (5 6(% D4& 4 '4 C(2
44( 44D4 '(4 ( (' 2 ;4& ( 4(( 4' 4 (2
N2 ,1 >4 *001 = ( ( 4( ( 4'2 B( (6644(&@ (4(&<( A(&('4 (& ( 4 44 D 536 4D2
+*-./+*001 )-+,,)
(4 = 45A4 D4(44 66(4 D4( 4<>(4 =4'(D 2
B(4 &( &( ( 44DD =5 A (4 4 (54(= 4 4 D=44< ((6444J&4D=4 ( (4 D >(4 ( 6 62 6L6& ( D4 '4 4 @ 4( 46(4=(4 (%6@= &4;;44 6 4( = 4,., &(6644(= A 6 432
,02 - >4 *001& 64 4 (64 > 5 84)
39 (64 :& M 4 (6644( ( M4;(6 (4 4( (64 ( MA6 ;4 <2 A(D&'C 4'(6 4 &4 4 <4 46 M D MA6 ( (4 4( 4(C5 (;()
6 A A4< <2 <6 (4 D (D MA6 4 CM(536D4 54 ((6 6434<4;4 4'&4 4 (4(A4 (4544 M'2
4'4 4 (D(6644(@(<4('' 4 '4 ;4((4544 @=654 % C((434(=A6('(42
,,2 ,,>4 *001&4 4 > (( 44( O>4*0012 ( 446 @= 4(44(4 (=A64 D(A6(A @D4(4 ( (% = (4 4( @= 4=A6;42B54446 & ( 4D6 @= 4(=A64 @D=(4 (4@ @='4 2
44 ;4 DM '4 & ;Q( ( 6 4 4 4> 4;45& 6 (45 @ ( 466 D (644( (6644( M'4 (<2 4 4( 4 M 4 (5 DM 4 A 4( 4 @ M> D 4 3 A6 D4 ( 4 4 A436 4'2 BM% >4 ; ( 6 43& ;4 '(4D;4 ='(4(646 A4 D J 4 ( 4 4; M '4 ( <' 4<452 <6 46 D =4 4( 4( 4 '4 54 42 ;4& = ' 44 =4544 =A6 ;4 ( (5 4 =A6 42
,*2 (4 ,/ 65*001&(6644(( <4; '( 2
+*-./+*001 )1+,,)
B=4 4 '4D='4 6 @4(4 4( A 4&=(54< 4( (6644(('4 4'4 = @ ( A D4(4 (' ' 4 4( (2 (6644( ='4 D =(54< 4( 6 @ 4(4 4( 4 A 6 ('( 4((2
44&=3&4> 4;44 6 A4 D=4 ;;44 D 4 44< =4< 4( ( A (4 2('4 A4D D= 4(( )4& ('5 ;;44 6 4 '< (4 4 D=4 = 4 4 =<4 ( >(4 2 & C(4A 4 '4655 > 4;44 &A64=( 4 4(((4('544 4 ;452
=A6(4( '4 4D=5 A ='4 =46 < 4; =4 4( ( '4& D= 4 (54 4& D=(D='4 54 >42
;4&(6 =4 4(='4 '4 ( ( 2 (D& = 4( )4& 4 D=(4 ((&;;44 @ 54<4 2
(6 =656 &(6644(( > (2
)$
,2 > 6 4 ' >44 4( (6 & ( '58 21/ (4M(<4 4(>444('65,N-,) ) *01I 2/?2,4 2(4(644 4',* 65,N.1) ) 1,0I 2?,4, ':2
*2 ' M 4 ?, 4 * '& ( L ;(6 ( 6( 4;M4<4 (M54 42( (3'4<4;@M( 44( D& 64 4 '4( 4( 4(4 4( < 64 6(4 MA62
?2 M 4?* ''(4 DMA6;4 < 54' (6644( MA6 4 '(4 ' ( M(<4 4( (6644( 6(4 MA62M 4*,4* '(@ (6644((6 ;4A6(4 MA62
+*-./+*001 )/+,,)
, >'4 *00?& (6644( ( 4 4' < ( 66 6(4 MA6;4D=6(4;4,.6*0012 M<4 M A6 (;4( D4 M ( 4D (5> (4 C(4D 4 & 64 4 ( (6 (;4(24 ( (4'4 @4 4((F 4 ('4 M44 '4 2
4 4' ( 4 ('< ( 4 (4' 64 4 D4( 4(D 4((464D(@ 4(4 4( < D 54 ('< 6 4(& A 4( 64A4 5 4(MA62
M3&4M<4 644( 4(D 4((@MA)
6?64*001464D4 (@ @J& (D =(644(64(4A4 2
-2 B( ='4 = (4 4 46& 4 4 4 (> =4< 4( ( ;44 4; ( ( 4( AC 4' > 24 '4 <6 C(4A& =(6<6 '@ ;; 2
C(4D6 &4 '4 C(4A=<4( >(4 &( (4 (4 4 >( 6(6 ;4 (4 2 4D6 & ( (6644(& 4 '4 44< ( (> =4< 4( ( A (4 A4D D= 4( ( )4&('5& 4 ;;4 ('<(4 ( 4 2 6 D4 > 4;44 (4( 4 = 6E4(46 G& 4;@=>(4 D46 4 D 4;(6 4( = 4 ( 6 ;45 =5 D4 6LC4 4 64 ;(2 D 4( ('544 >(4 (4 <6 <(4 2
&4 (4 @;4=(44 4( 34D @ 4 (4 (4 4 = (644 >(4 = &= 4 46 64(56 4D<4 46 4( 4'2 44 6 @ (6 (D(4 (6644( =A6 4 (4 6 =A 4 8 (644 >(4 @ = <: 4 = 4 ( 4(6 2A4 4((6644(@ < ( ('4 2 =5=6 4(DD=(4 D @ =4('544 >(4 =( =A6& 4 ='4 6( 4;'5((@=4<2'4 @ ( 6(4' 4( 4 D=4 4 (45 =4< 643 (>(4 ' (4 (4'4 4'(D (D 4(( A 2
+*-./+*001 )O+,,)
6L6 J2 4 = '4< (4& = 4 ,., 4 - % '(4 ( D4 ( 4( = 46(4 ( = 4 @ (4 (6642 =4 D(> 4;4=4< 4(A(4 &4('4 4 J 44 = 4 O1 4 , J '(% D 4 54 (446 (54< (4'('54 =A 4( ' ; 46(42@(& ( 4 4(4 A (4 4D= ='4 4 45 D (6644( '4 64 D 4 64 =A64 + ( ,NNN D4 (6( 4 A (42
12 (664 4 4',>'4*00?&5 MA6 (4 @ (4 C(4DD(6 (;)
4( ; '( & D4 (4' (D 4< A6 R(66M44 '4 R2 ;; &4 4'3' D A <A4@( 4((536(( 64@ 4(4 4(4 2
(( 45 644 4; >@ =(4( 4 D= 4 4( & '( ' ( 6 ( ( (4 DM4 >< 42 ( DM 4 A <A 4& (6644( M(5> MA6 (4 C(4D 4 5 DM )6L6 4< @ 4)4
8 +/+*00-/>'4*00-(421:2
4(6 = ;(=3D&=' 6L6 (6644(& = 44 D4& ( & '4 4 4 =4<>(4 4 =564@4(4 4( A 2&4 &=5 A (4 ( 4 ;(6 =4(6 >44D2
(D&(6 ;(4A4 J& (6644( '4( 4 4' D= )6L6 64 ( < 6(4 =A6 ;4 <2 <4; '4( 4( (4 ( ;(2
/2 B(>4&( @D 4(( ( <4; D4 ( ;Q( ( MA6 ( ( ' 4( ( (
8 J ,0/ ,& ,N.* O:2 '4 ( > 4;4 M644(M( M 4((;(644( DD M4A4 44D'44 A4;;'(5 MA62'46 (5> 4;4 &; M4 L 4< ( 4(4D4M' &( 4 6( 4;(8 +/+*00-
+*-./+*001 ).+,,)
/>'4*00-(42/44( (4;*O6,NN,&4 1/+&,NN*&2,?,:2
=3& '4 ( 4' (D =A62 =5( =46(4544 = 4 >(4 ;Q4 ' >44 4( <'(4 (6 44 D ;4 =L 64 4(4 4(<D ;( <4 46 4(4' A (4 (4 4 >(2 4 & (5> 4'6 ( ( 4 & 46( 6 @ 6 4 (644( (6644( 4 ( ( '(( 4& (4 =4 ;4 ( ( % '(4 4< D A A64 (D 6 4 ( ( D 4( =A62 ;4& ( ( 4 & ( 66 (( D4 4 (A436;(4@=A6& 4( 6 4 (4 @ ( 4( 6(%2
O2 @ 64 4 '4 ( L & ( 66 (4 4((( 4( 'AM5 J2
(6644( ( 6 ;M((6454D& M5&(MA6&6 44@( 4( (536 (64& (4 DM4 M 4 (45 64 D 4( 4 ;(4 4 6 4 4 '4 4 452 (D&MA6'4 L '&6L6' 536& M 4 '4 ('(4 ;4 844( (6644( ( 6 ;M((6454D,-64,NN/&4 /,+&,NNO& 2??/:2
<6 4( <6 45 =32 4( &4 D J 4 4@( 4( 2&4 46(45 64D(( 4 '(4M'4 ( 6 6(%@M5 4 (42 4 ( ( MA6 ;;4 2 44& ;4 45 (4 6 4 ( 4 D4 (44 S ( ='4 (4 ((4 4(;4 DM65 4( 4 & M )@)4 M5( 4( 4(6 >44D ( 4 & T 44( DM (MA62
64(6644(6 ( '4 ( ( 2 ( 6L6 4(& 4 = (45 45= 45@( ( DD4;4A (6644(& D ( & 6 & (44 2 63(45(4 @;4 ( =A64 2
+*-./+*001 )N+,,)
.2 ' D4 3& 4 = 4 =A64 <4; =54 4('( 2
N2 ( ( 4 ( D =A6 3 45 D= (D& (4 ('(4 = 4 =A6 ;4& ='4 DA'(2
2 = 444D( (3'<4;D (6 @( 4('(2
52 45;>@ @((46442 (4(4 46DE( 46 @D( 4 ( & A'( 4 ( 44'445&64( 4 & ;4 D <4 4( ( ;3 46 @ E=A6G& 4<4& = @ < 64 G 8 L 45 ; *2,/,+,NN.,,(U ,NN.(42?5 :2
& 4 4( L ' C< 4D 4(4 4( <4 A6;4 <( '4< ,>'4*00?2 4(65'<6 ' 4&( 4(=A6 4 4D2=%( 4(= 4(6 45;2
2 (>(6L6>4& 45;(4D
E ( % 36& ( = (4 4 46& ( D =' '44 (4 L ( =' <43 64 ;5& 6 (F 4 =A4 4(46 4';4 ' (4(;(62 & 6 C( 4<(4( (' 6'4&64' <4)4 5(2 & 6L6 643 C%( C3& (' 4 > 4;4 4( ( =< 44 =<4 4 6 & 4D 4 ( A6 = '44 =( (4 @ 4' 6 42 44& 4 '4 D 64 4 ( ? 4( =' ( 4 ( @41@='4 ( (5 46(%D4I &44 ( 4 5=(54<@ ='(4)4'4 ;;4 2 ;4&4% 36=((@4 4( <(5 4 & 4)4 A64 ( A 4( 4 4 ()(6644( (' L 4;; & 6 ;;4 @ 44( D4( 4 4(&= D=4= 54D=4
+*-./+*001 ),0+,,)
(4 ;'(5 ( G 8 L 45 ; *2,/,+,NN.,,(U ,NN.(42?4;4:2
4D D4 4'4643( 45 644 4;<6 44(( 4@436(4;4 4( '8 +-+*00- +1+*00-/>'4*00-:2 643 (4 4( D4 3 & 45 '(4 4( 6(4;4 >42 =4 D C3 ( =4544 =A6;4 <(4 L > 2
,02 ( 44 46 64 44( (6644( MA6'( 2A6(AM ( 4 (6 &4 &4M% 6( 4;> 4;4 M (4 ( @ 2 43 ( (4 @ M' 4 MA6 ;4 <2 ( (5 5 A6 (A @ 4( 64 *001 MA6 4 D4 ;4 4 @M644( ( (4(66A436 4'4 M 4?04- '2
,,2 464 ( $J ,=0002)& @ C< = & (@( D4(5 4 4<48 2.O :2
=4 4 4<& 6(6 $J ?002) 64 @ C< =644 4(2 C<6 4D (D(<4D ( C('(4= 3'D4; (' ( 4(2 <6 (C '44= ((64 ('(4>444 (6 4 4 ('(4A 4;= ('(4>444= 2 ;4(;(6@ &D ( 4 =< @ =A( 4( % 6 4D = 3' ( 6(6 (8 +-*?+*001,->4*001:2
')$ )
,-#." /
'5 ( 4 > ,, >4 *001 !6 27777777777 ( 44((6644(MA6'( O>4*001I
#./
=6 46 I
+*-./+*001 ),,+,,)
44( (6644( =A6 '( O >4 *001 D=( ='4 =A6;4 <I
(4( @ @='4 =A6;4 <
4 A436 4'I
(@( 464 ( $J,=0002)@C<= I
6 @C<=4 466(6 $J?002)I
(664D L @ ! "# $% & '( ( 44 DM@ (6644(MA6'( 2
B4< 9 !2%C3&4 &!6('% $4&!2 C4&><&!2(& >< 2
(6 45644 4;9
<;;43)>4 9 4 9 24()B4<4 J2%C3
(4(;(6 L (664DA 42
3'& <;;439
+*-./+*001