Contract Interpretation and Enforcement Disputes
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court addressed multiple issues stemming from various agreements and transactions, primarily concerning contract interpretation, validity, and enforcement, often involving complex calculations of damages or obligations under specific provisions. The reasoning across the different matters consistently applied established legal principles to the facts presented; for instance, interpreting contractual language to determine the parties' intent, assessing whether conditions precedent to enforcement were met, or applying statutory rules to calculate remedies, ultimately leading to the affirmance, reversal, or modification of the lower court's judgment based on the correct application of law to the documented evidence and agreements.
Regesto Legislator
UfficialeCONSTRUCTION ET INSTALLATION; RENOVATION; TRAVAUX D'ENTRETIEN; TRAVAUX SOUMIS A AUTORISATION | Les travaux litigieux doivent être considérés comme des travaux de rénovation soumis à la LDTR, en raison notamment de leur coût élevé et du fait qu'aucun travaux n'ont été entrepris lors des années précédentes dans l'appartement considéré. | LDTR.3 al.1; LDTR.3 al.9; LDTR.3 al.25; RLGL.1 al.5
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay the costs of the federal proceeding.
Cited in the dispositive to declare the appeal inadmissible.
Testo completo
!"#$
%&'&(&&)& !"#$%&! &'(%
% '**' * '* '* ' * ( + , ( - *+ &*& & & && &
")*++"
+0 )1 23)..+'40 05 0600740'8&"9:40; 6!06 07 %<'&<% 3&7%=(!0!0 0 00"
0 % 2 &> &9 2& & ?92 < 5&223@'!% "79(0A%<2 & 5(&% +B12) %= 2% & 7 C#/?D...0"'%& C#/D...0"2%&0 2% & E% %2 %A&FAA< C#+B.0" A%A& % (&&% C# ).'?1 %& 2% % C# /D+?.'?1 2%&03&& AA +%(23)..+ & % &3 & 2 &>2%&&>2%&0
#&& & & < % ' &&9' 9< <% &A %9(&&G5(&A&> &%%=% %&%%(3&'&&G &%=%<2 & +2&+--/'%& C#+?DH..0"02% &AF & &5 &% >%=G &0 &&93&% &< &)1 23)..+(%=& G5%< &%>%& &%< >9< <&G %9('3& & %% && & ++ 2%&0 %& 101' & & &A& G57 I & %&% %>' & > 3&' 5 (> G > >2 %(7&< 3&J0
F&AA 10? & & && &3: I7 AA ' (> &( % > 3&75 % &:
"A &%%29 & 2'A% 3%&&K
"%( &% 2&%A%2& 5& &% &GK
"22 3&<%& (3%3&K
"22 5(&&&K
"22 AL3& &&K
"22 <3& &&K
"%$< (& &A& &% %G J0
A&' F&AA 10, (%=& G I%A%22 > 9< < % &A' % (> >G % & && &2 % (% A&5%3E 5 %& &%& 3&06A%( &% % &'&%% &7&2& 3&%% A&3&J0
*,-.*)../ "/*++"
)0 ( 5 % &%<2 '40(& A& > 2 (> % & (& <2 % 7 & (>% &3& 7F<0
/0 +)2)..)'% &' 5 %"&('% 2& 2 52<2 ' 5G&2 %<2 8&"9: 2 ; %& 3& 7 %= 5(& A&> &% %= && &0 2 & &5&&G& (>AA 3&(& %& G & %=A&> 2 0
B0 +1 2 )..)' 2 & 6 !0 6 0 & %& 3& (%%& & 2 5&& 1 (& )..) & & %M (> AA 2 A& 2& & >"& & % % E & 7 %& 2%& &%' A%2 &% %( &%2&%5F3& &%)1E(&+--?8 N1).;0
10 )? 2 )..)' 6 !0 6 0 & 2 G (> %( &%5 & (7 C#,-D/1-0"05<&& :
" 22 & & ' & %29 % 5 2 = %2&3%&& C#/?DHH.0"K
"%$< (& &A& &%G : C#/D-).0"K
"2&%A%2& & &% &G: C#+BD...0"K
"22 < AL3& &&: C#+/DB+,0"K
" 22 & & & 3&' O ' = %2& %& 22 5(&&&: C#++D+B)0"0
& &G6(%& AA (>G&& %2& 7 &%%G5(& %> (>52<2 5G&2 &&'& >% &F%&>5AA (> 7 A& %22 5 & > %% %& ' 7 (%& %&>% &-% %3)..+ 2!2 0+1 % %3)..+0&& %2 G% & & %&7 % O 2 & %F 7 F%&& 5 AL <' % "(% (&&& & 7F<% &0 "& & 2P2 %& 7 % %(> <2 G&2 && 7%(&2& % <&3&A& 5<&%0
*,-.*)../ "B*++"
+1 % %3 )..+' !2 0 (& 2& 6 !0 6 0 & % %&3&& 5AA (>&G5%F& & A&7A& 5 2 0 (& A& &(3&<%& %F7A&0
?0 %&%22-(&)..)' 2 &<&A&76!0
6 0G (>AA & 2% (> %( &%5 &/&+ 0'5<2 &% %= & ++BQ0
2 %% R E% 5 GP %& &%% &0
,0 (% 5 % & % 40 %& / 2& )..)' &"& % G (>AA 3&5 2 G &% %& %2& 7 0 5 2 & &223 9 & (& & A &%%29 0 (>AA (& 5 &% 0
7F%=' & E &A&5 &%&"&> %=G & GP 2 5 & 2&&3%2 A%%< %&%& A0
A ' &&% % && &% (%& & % & G&0
H0 &&% +1 2& )..)' 2 2& G (> 5( 7 C# ,-D/1-0" %%& 7 C# +)D).-0" &9 G& & %&30%= & C#)D1HB0"7 C#1D1/H0"&9 & & F<2 G& &A5 2 0
' (> & %2& 7 & /. E% 9 &% %& & &2 & 7 %& & % % GP %& &%% &0
-0 2 &'40%% &&%9%22&&% %%2 &9% &%8&"9: ! ;0
+.0 &&% B (& )../' & % E 0 ! &2 G (> AA 3& 5 & (> 5 & % G5& & E &7 %2&7 %& &%%5 &- %&040(& % %& &%% &0
++0 % <AA &3 2&& &A - 2& )../' 40 %% &&%% 7% &% 7G5&%& % G& (>5 & E &7 0
*,-.*)../ "1*++"
+)0 &3& % &G&% 2&A 0
+/0 )/ E& )../ 2 % E % % &% E7>%0
+B0 )B%(23)../'E<< 2& 2 %&5 E<2 )2&)../ &33> %='E<2 G&5 A 5 2 G & &3 (& A&> 7 C# )HD/).0"' F<%%2&'%=5 2 G &%040(& %2723%>% & %"$%=0
+10 E< < A&> % G& & &+123)../065>% &'!2 0 & 0 '!0#0!0& 7A& % 0
E<% G&&'& 2'A% 3%&& (& A& 0 &9 (& & &2A& 2 0 5(&(& F<023&&5 & !2 0 (& & % % A&<%' % &&&9 && G5 ("(&0 < AL (& F< (& = 2 % (P 2 G5&& <9 %>%22(& (&& &2 0
F23'& 3%&&2(& A& & 5(%&F<0G (& (& &A&02&9<'& 3%&&5&& 0
5 F23 %( % & &' & 23& "A%=F2&%& & & F2&A% &%& 0
O (&& ' & (3%7<F5 (& F< & %& 0 > 5(& 2%&A&0 & 2 A% (& A& 2P2 G AP % % & &0( O (& F<2&(%& & 2A&>0
3&% &(& & '(5%<&' %( O 0 (& 2 3&<%& & 3&<%& 7G&(& E%& 3&%F0(P 2 2 & EG5A% (P 2 3&<%& & <9%22 > &&0 (P 2 2P2 G 5& &% O 2 &'%F 53&<%&<G%% <&(& &F<% &0
%' && (& % & F 5< &902%& >0& (& %5& &&7
*,-.*)../ "?*++"
&A0 3%&& % &% % &9 E (& & % G & %3 0 2 & &9 % 5 (& & <2 && F<0 A%(& A& 0 %(& %0<%%2 & (&&306%&R ! " &&5(& F< F % "AP A%0
!2 0 ( G (> & 2& %G5 (& & %&%5 2 0
&9( 3 % ! "'A% 3%&& (& & G (& &A&0%3% % 9 7 R( & %2 % G % & A2 &0 % & = %( ' F % 5 & A& 0 6%!0!0'F& %A&%'2&%A%2& 5 && (& & A& G5& 5= (& & % 5 2 0
% & &(& %3 2%2 &% 3&5 <&% G5&5=(& 5 &%%> % <&A&2% & EG5 2 0
&&&5=(& ( & &%0AP %& % & &5&2232&"& & %( 5(&90 " &&&9 %(& 3&3%F5 &%2&5 & %0
A %& %%& > (>=3&0
& %7!2 0%G5A%&A % (> "(G5(& ="2P20
+?0 +B E(& )..B' !2 0 A& (& E< < I%2 &A> (>"(J=%& % C# 1D.,/'B.&&G5% 5 2 0
+,0 &9% 2&> & & &2 &% 2&0 +) A(& )..B' 40 0 &&G 5(%& 5%3( &% 7 A%2 & 2%%0
)1A(&)..B' 2 % G%M &F< % & %& "( G& 5(& 7 P & 2% (> & 3&0 & &&% 2& &%0
+H0 6G%&' <7E<0
*,-.*)../ ",*++"
*
+0 E 2 & ( E&& &% %2 ' % (38 01? %&D%<& &%E&&&))%(23+-B+" " ) .1 K 0 ?/ 0 + & 0 %& 6 % 2&& &( +) 23 +-H1 " " 1 +.;0 % & % & &% 5 & ,+ & &% E&&G &3 5P 2%&A&&&%% %0
)0 0 6% 5 & / & + & ) ' % G&A& A%2 &% (>G&% %%3E %( &%'5 "7"&2& ' 2P2 &' % % & 5 2&% 5F3& &%' 2&% %A% >& 2%&A& & &3 &% %<2 ' % ( G5& 5<& (>5 &0 &'%E &7 '% (> % 5 & A& & A& 5>%& &% %&& 5 2&% 5F3& &%0 (> &%3 5 & <& % %& %22 (> A%2 &%' % G5& 5< 2&% &%%A% >& 0
30 % (> <& &A = 2%&A& &% &%& &% <' (&< +? % %3 +---' G %& && ' % &2& & (> %2& % %2& 7 %&' G %& & %2 %M & && %=' %22(E&8!2%& %&+----*+++.,?;0 2&%& %& (& %% % 5 & / & ) ' & G (> 5 & G& (& & (& G57 F%& &' % 22 2&7A5 2 F<2 % &' 5 & E & 7 8!2%& +--- -*++ < ++??;0 % >&92 3 % %E 2%&A& &% ' 9 %23>22 % %2& %&2&%& '% 22 &&'75 &/'&+ 'G(& P %& %22 (>%( &%>% %M % <& <2 &% %=).Q8!2%&+----*++)++;0 22 A' % %22&(& 7&G2&7A5 2 F<2 % &5 & E &7%&8!2%&+---+.*++<+B+1;0
0 ' % &% A%2 &% 5 & 5% $ %( A&& &%' % G E& 7 < % 5& %( % & 8 *?HH*)..) +) %(23 )..)K *)++*+--, *)+)*+--,H(&+--,K *1))*)..BHE& )..B;0
*,-.*)../ "H*++"
/0 E& % ' & 2&' 5<& & & &% (> D & %( &% 8% A%2 &%; % 7 5 & / ' &&%2 > 2'7(%&:
" 53% >2& &' ' (> 9( 5 & %' % &' %& (> %( &%0 %%<2 & & &%' E& 2& G (> 5 & % &3 53% & 7 %( &% % 7 A%2 &% %2&7 %G'5= > &%&G2 %% &% % %< 5>& 5&223' % % G5& 5% > % %23'2 &%'2P2 %2 5> &% &%%22 <%2 '%A9 && % 7 < F<2 &< 5&223
8 0! '%( <E&'& #+--?0 /+B E&& ;K
" & ' 5 F 7 52 ' ' %M & (> 7 &% 2% %=' 9 % G5& %& F<2 DAA &%G& &A%<2 '&% > 3%& % % &% 8 */?1*)..+ )- 2& )..+' *)?+*)..+)B(&)..+ A& ;0
&3 2&& &A && % 22 %& %22 ( D &D& &%%(>& &'D<2 &&'2& %A%2& D& &% &G' % %(> (P 2 % %&'&&G (>& &8 *+?)*)../)1 2& )../K */?1*)..+ *)?+*)..+ & A & ;0 && % A%&P 'GD&%(& &%2 <2 &% G (> & %2& % 22 2 &% &% D A D & % 3S &2 %
8 *?1-*)..B )B %M )..BK *?HH*)..) +) %(23 )..)K */B*+--H),E(&+--H;0
B0 0 %22(&"'D>2 (>& P % A%& & 9 7 %& &% % 2& & & ( &% %F 7%&0 "&( &2 GD % &3 D3% & 7 F<2 G& &A D&2230 2P2' D<2 &%%=% &(7 (> (%&%AA D T F<2 DAA &% G& &A %<2 8 *H.)*)..+ B 23 )..+;0
30 2 %U %& (& &&2 7 2& & F3& %% '% 22 %D<%%2&G'>3%&% % &%' & A (& G (> % %2& 7 %& %& 7 %<7%&%& F3& 0 D 2'%&FF7%2
*,-.*)../ "-*++"
% R D & <%& (> ( < A% &% &G GD&A% 93%3%<2 GDA% &% = (> >"2P2 80 6 C ' #0 V C ' W E& &3 2&& &A % 9( 2 &9 D & &223W & # +--H 0 /?H;0 D& D<& %2 <&2 A%2 &% & (>D &%'2<D3<& ' &2& (>7 A%2 &%'& 9&&A %%M %G 9 3%3 %<2 80 6 C ' #0 V C '%0& 0'0/?-;0
10 59'&A & &< (>AA 2 3& 5 > AA % & 5 ' 2& 5( 79 C#H.D...0" %2% 7 C#1D...0"(&%0 (A %& % &' 2 7E & % & %& )1 A(& )..B G %22 GG C#1D...0" 5(& 7 P & 2% (> & %& &&G5&5<&& ( % "(%2 &>G % & %F& & &AA > F%&& 3&' && 5 > 3&<%&0
2% (>7%& 3&& C#,-D/1-0"% 22 & & ' & %29 5 2 ' %$< (& &A& &% G ' 2& %A%2& & &% &G'22 < AL3& &&&&G22 && &0
#% 52 G (>AA %& &% G 2 5 A& 5%3E ' % ' 5 & <&%& G& &% &G>25% 2& %A%2& 0
% (>% & 2&A 2 (>5 &&AAG& %&( P %& %22 (> A%2 &% & &% 5 &/&) % &%0A& G (>& % 22 & &2&9&2A& 5 59 & 0
?0 9 ' &3 2&G%( &% 5 2 G &9 = %M %22 C#)1D,+H0" %%& 7 (>5 &% 5%M &%3'%%2&7 8 *1)1*)..B H E& )..B;0 ' 59 E%5F& & &<& T%M 3%(% 2 0
,0 % G& 9 G (> & &<&> %&( P %& %22 (>%( &% G9%'&% %2&7 0
*,-.*)../ "+.*++"
H0 %2 &2 '& & 2 A&> %=2>&229 (> &%2 2% =% & A&> & G% % % R %= && & ' 5 ' %A%22 && A% %< %& %& A' G &"& %2 &3(E<2 %% &33> %=% &50
-0 %&&E 0(%= 2 %& 0
5&& &<'2%2 C#)D...0"2&7F< % 0%5&2& %08 0H, ;0
XXXXX
' * ,
./012$"3
(3 % & E - 2& )../ 40 0 5 0 0 00 % &&% 2 D2<2 'DG&2 %<2 B(&)../ K
01243
E K
2 7F<% 2%2 C#)D...0"K
& G5&5 %5&2& K
(%& 2 52<2 '5G&2 %<2 % A&>%=%& K
%22&G P 7 ! "#$%& ! &' (% % ' 2 D2<2 'DG&2 %<2 '7%22&&% % %2 &9% &%&&G57!000"0 !0 0'0
56704!3
*,-.*)../ "++*++"
!06F&'& '!0=F9'!2%(='!2C&'!0 F&'E<0
%2 &3 2&& &A:
<AA&9"E& E0: E<& : !0 %%& 06F&
%&%A%2 P %22&G> &0
9(' <AA&9:
*,-.*)../