Discretionary Immunity vs. Ministerial Duty in Property Maintenance Negligence
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case addresses whether a statutory provision granting immunity for discretionary acts shields an entity from liability arising from alleged negligence in the maintenance of property, where the initial decision to perform maintenance was discretionary but the execution allegedly became operational and ministerial. The court reasoned that while the initial decision regarding maintenance scheduling or allocation of resources is typically discretionary and therefore immune, the duty to maintain property in a reasonably safe condition, once undertaken, involves operational aspects that are not protected by discretionary immunity if negligently performed, and thus, the entity could be held liable for the breach of this ministerial duty.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Discretionary Immunity vs. Ministerial Duty in Property Maintenance Negligence: The court reasoned that while the initial decision regarding maintenance scheduling or allocation of resources is typically discretionary and therefore immune, the duty to maintain property in a reasonably safe condition, once undertaken, involves operational aspects that are not protected by discretionary immunity if negligently performed, and thus, the entity could be held liable for the breach of this ministerial duty.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive concerning the allocation of costs.
Cited in the dispositive concerning the provision of legal aid.
Testo completo
!
"#!$%%%%%%%%%% !"#$% &'(
(
&''()*))+'&
)*+,,)
)
,1 2'(3(4 3(3 &!(3!1555555555563)27 3 ( ( 8 99 : ;'( 2 ; ;'( 1
93;(4 34' ;'( (2'&3; & (<329(3&=3(;><<3*//01
*1 3 3(3<(3 ;><93&93> 3 3'(<<33(;><'( 63)27(<<33(8 , ?'3 *//@& <(393 ,. < *//01 >( A;B3 ;:3 ; >< (93(1 ; ( 3A (4? (3 C(3A3 &<33 ( (< (93( < 32 3A 41 ( 3 ( (& 3 ( (3'3 =3 3((D3 ('3 ;3 3 '3 E1
'(3 A3 <3 3 3(( ( 9> 6F "G+ 7 ( H I + + F ! 7 ( H +J FJI+F II 7( 8 37 B3 ( 3( A 3( ( 3<3A ( = 3(3 3( : A 43 (': 3 & > 3( <3>3 4 3(;><E1
@1 ;'3 3@<3*//01
;( )3 (<( 3 3 > (3 (3 6(9(<; 3 (3 =;(43893 3(; 3 &(<;?(3 (<<< 3:1 3 < > 3 ;:3 ?333< 93 '3 = 3 (? ;3: 3(( 349(<< 3A =C2 < (4 (3 A ;'( 3 ' < (33 (1
( ( 34 ;'(3 :3 3< 3( 3'& 3 3 3&=93;(&A;'3*//0(3 ?( '3 C (3 & (<333 = <K< = 2'&'3 ( 39 39<321 = ?(3 % 3:; 3&33 IH;(<2 3 33A ( 1
-1 ( '&(<<33(3 34>3 > (33' 7
+*-.-+*//0 )@+,,)
)(3L(:3 3(?333('<4,M-,6) */08
)(3(3'3,/'3,M.N6 O @/08
)(399(< 323'3*-<*///6I(OF*N*8
( & 3 '3 39(< A;3 ('3 34< 3(><3( + ( &3 3(,MMM (*//-C(3>3 &A(<<33(<31
01 'C&;( 3 34> > :>3' 7
) (' 3( ,P <4 ,M.. ( (< ?333 ;> 3(33(< 323'3 (<<36 OF/1*N*1,,8
)(39@( (4*//@93(&33(& 9(< 3( 9 3<(3@( (4*//@6IOF,1@/,8
3 A3 '3 C(33 <3 ;3 3( *//- + ( 3(3 3 > &3)393 3>1
P1 ;333AC&3 <3(31
N1 3 43>'(,, ,.<3*//01
.1 3N?3*//0&(<<33((<<3A3 ( ><1 '3 (4 ( ,N&*0 (3 & ( @&0 (3 = ;'3 1F(; 3@/3*2:< ;3 3((3 (93( ;'( 0 ?3 *//* 6 ' O P ,/1/,8& ;>< 93 3 3 ( (3 : ( 3 = */1 ;% (4 <(%A3&3 '3 C(1
33( 33A3 '(3 ( (' 1 93& ( 3(( 3' 3 (1
M1 ,0 ?3 *//0 ; ( ( 3( ( 3'1 F( (<<33(&= (3(&:( >(&('3 (& ( 3 33 A 42< 3A1 (3 ; 34>3 A3(33 <<(3 A3( 3:?(3 ;3'(A 1
F(3 &( &( ( 33AA ;4 > (3 3 (43(; 3 3 A;33: ((<333I&3A;3 ( (3 A ?(3 ( < <1 <K<& ( A3 '3 3 = 3( 3<(3;(3 (%<=; &39933 < 3( ; 3,., &(<<33(; > < 321
+*-.-+*//0 )-+,,)
,/1 - ?3 *//0& <3 3 (<3 ? 4 63)
27 (<3 8& L 3 (<<33( ( L39(< (3 3( (<3 ( L>< 93 :1 >(A&'C 3'(< 3 &3 3 :3 3< L A L>< ( (3 3( 3(C4 (9()
< > >3: :1 :< (3 A (A L>< 3 CL(42<A3 43 ((< <323:393 3'&3 3 (3(>3 (3433 L'1
3'3 3 (A(<<33(=(:3('' 3 '3 93((3433 =;<43 % C((323(;><('(31
,,1 ,,?3 *//0&3 3 ? (( 33( N?3*//01( 33< =; 3(33(3 ( ;>< 3 A ( >< (> = A 3 (3 ( (% ; (3 3( > B (3 ' ;>< 93E1 F4333< & 3 ( 3A< = ; 3( ;>< 3 = A;3(3 (3= =;'3 1
33 93 AL3'3 &9Q( ( < 3 3 3?)
3934& < (34 = ( 3<< A (<33( (<<33( L'3 (:1 3 3( 3 L 3 (4 AL3 3 > 3( 3 = L? A 3 ><( =;<49(< 3(?33A 3'321FL% ?39 ( < 32&393 '(3A93 ;'(3(<3< >3 AI 3 ( 3 39L'3(:' 341 :< 3< A ;3 3( 3( 3 '3 43 31 93&3; '33;3433 ;><93((4 3 ;>< 31
,*1 (3 ,P <4*//0&(<<33(( :39 '( 1
F;3 3 '3A;'3 < =3(3 3( > 3&;(43: 3( (<<33(('3 3'3 ; = ( > A3(3 (' ' 3 3( (1 (<<33( ;'3 A ;(43: 3( < = 3(3 3( 3 > < ('( 3((1
33&;2&3? 3933 < >3 A;3 9933 A 3 33: ;3: 3( ( > (3 1('3 >3A A; 3(( )3& ('4 9933 < 3 ': (3 3 A;3
+*-.-+*//0 )0+,,)
; 3 3 ;:3 ( ?(3 1 & C(3> 3 '3<44 ? 3933 &><3;( 3 3(((3('433 3 9341
;>< (3 ( '3 3 A ;4 > ;'3 ;3< : 39 ;3 3( ( '3& A ; 3 ( 43 3& A; (A 3 ;'3 43 ?31
93&(< ;3 3(;'3 '3 ( ( 1 (A& ; 3( )3& 3 A;(3 ((&9933 = 43:3 1
(< ;<4< &(<<33(( ? (1
) '
,1 ? < 3 ' ?33 3( (< & ( '46 10P (3L(:3 3(?333('<4,M-,) ) */0H 1P@1,3 1(3(<33 3',* <4,M.0) ) 0,/H 1@,3, '81
*1 ' L 3 @, 3 * '& ( K 9(< ( <( 39L3:3 (L43 31( (2'3:39=L( 33( A& <3 3 '3( 3( 3(3 3( : <3 <(3 L><1
@1 L 3@* ''(3 AL><93 : 43' (<<33(L>< 3'(3 '(L(:3 3((<<3)
3( <(3 L><1L 3*,3* '(=(<<3)
3((< 93><(3 L><1
,?'3*//@& (<<33(( 3 3': ( <)
< <(3 L><93A;<(393,.<*//01L:3 L><(93(A3L(3A(4? (3)
C(3A3 &<33 ( (< (93()
1 3 ( ( 3'3 = 3 3( (D 3 ('3 L33 '3 1
3 3' ( 3 (': ( 3 (3' <3 3 A3( 3(A 3((3<3A(= 3(3 3( : A 43 (': < 3(& > 3( <3>3 4 3(L><1
+*-.-+*//0 )P+,,)
L2&3L:3 <33( 3(A 3((=L>)
<@<3*//03<3A3 (= =I& (A ()<3(3>3 1
-1 F( ;'3 ; (3 3 3<& 3 3 3 (? ;3: 3( ( 933 39 ( ( 3( >C 3' ? 13 '3 :< C(3>& ;(<:< '= 99 1
C(3A< &3 '3 C(3>;:3( ?(3 &( (3 (3 3 ?( <(< 93 (3 1 3A< &((<<33(&3 '3 33:((? ;3:)
3( ( > (3 >3A A; 3( ( )3&('4& 3 993 (':(3 ( 3 1 < A3 ? 3933 (3( 3 ; < B3(3< E& 39=;?(3 A3< 3 A 39(< 3(; 3 ( < 934 ;4 A3<KC3 3 <39(1A 3(('433 ?(3 (3 :< :(3 1
&3 (3 =93;(33 3( 23A = 3 (3 (3 3 ; (<33 ?(3 ; &; 3 3< <3(4< 3A:3 3< 3( 3'1 33 < = (< (A(3 (<<33( ;>< 3 (3 < ;> 3 6 (<33 ?(3 = ; :8 3 ; 3 ( 3(< 1>3 3((<<33(= : ( ('3 1 ;4;< 3(AA;(3 A = ;3('433 ?(3 ;( ;><& 3 ;'3 <( 39'4((=;3:1'3 = ( <(3' 3( 3 A;3 3 (34 ;3: <32 (?(3 ' (3 (3'3 3'(A (A 3(( > 1
<K< I1 3 ; '3: (3& ; 3 ,., 3 - % '(3 ( A3 ( 3( ; 3)
<(3(; 3 =(3 (<<31;3 A ( ? 393 ;3: 3( > (3 & 3 ('3 3 I 33; 3N03,I'(% A343 (33< (43: (3 ' (' 43 ;> 3( ' 9 3<(31=(& (3 3(3 > (3 3A; ;'3 3 34 A (<<33( '3 <3 A 3 <3 ;><3 + ( ,MMMA3(<( 3 > (31
01 (<<3 3 3',?'3*//@&4 L>< (3 = (3 C(3AA(< (9)
+*-.-+*//0 )N+,,)
3( 9 '( & A3 (3' (A 3: >< R(<<L33 '3 R1 99 &3 3'2' A > :>3=( 3((42<(( <3= 3(3 3(3 1
(( 34 <33 39 ?= ;(3( 3 A; 3 3( & '( ' ( < ( ( (3 AL3 ?: 31 ( AL 3 > :> 3&(<)
<33(L(4? L><(3 C(3A3 4 AL)<K<3:=3)36 +P+*//-P ?'3*//-(31081
3(< ; 9(;2A&;' <K< (<<33(& ; 33 A3& ( & '3 3 3 ;3:?(3 3 ;4<3=3(3 3( > 1&3 &;4 > (3 ( 3 9(< ;3(< ?33A1
(A & (< 9(3 > 3 I& (<<33( '3( 3 3' A; )<K< <3 ( : <(3 ;>< 93 :1 :39 '3( 3( (3 ( 9(1
P1 F(?3&( =A 3(( ( :39 A3 ( 9Q( ( L>< ( ( ' 3( ( (
6 I ,/P ,& ,M.* N81 '3 ( ? 393 L<33(L( L 3((9(<33( AA L3>3 33A'33 >399'(4 L><1'3< (4? 393 &9 L3 K 3: ( 3(3A3L' &( 3 <( 39(6 +P+*//- P?'3*//-(31P33( (39*N<,MM,&3 0P+&,MM*&1,@,81
;2& '3 ( 3' (A ;><1 ;4( ;3<(3433 ; 3 ?(3 9Q3 ' ?33 3( :'(3 (< 33 A 93 ;K <3 3(3 3(:A 9( :3 3< 3(3' > (3 (3 3 ?(1 3 & (4? 3'< ( ( 3 & 3<( < = < 3 (<33( (<<33( 3 ( ( '(( 3& (3 ;3 93 ( ( % '(3 3: A > ><3 (A < 3 ( ( A 3( ;><1 93& ( ( 3 & ( << (( A3 3 (<32 9(3=;><& 3( < 3 (3 = ( 3( <(%1
+*-.-+*//0 ).+,,)
N1 = <3 3 '3 ( K & ( << (3 3((( 3( '>L4 I1
(<<33( ( < 9L((<343A& L4&(L><&< 33=( 3( (42< (<3& (3 AL3 L 3 (34 <3 A 3( 3 9(3 3 < 3 3 '3 3 341 (A&L><'3 K '&<K<' 42<& L 3 '3 ('(3 93 633( (<<33( ( < 9;((<343A,-<3,MMP&3 P,+&,MMN& 1@@P81
:< 3( :< 34 ;21 3( &3 A I 3 3=( 3( 1&3 3<(34 <3A(( 3 '(;3L'3 ( < <(%=L4(3 A 3(13(( L>< 993 1 33& 93 34 (3 < 3 ( 3 A3(33 S(;'3 (3( (3 3(93 AL<4 3(3 & L )=)3 L4( 3( 3(< ?33A ( 3 & T 3 3( AL (L><1
<3(<<33(< ( '3 ( ( 1 ( <K< 3(& 3 ; (34 34; 34( ( AA393> (<<33(&A( &< &(33 1<2 (34(3 =93 ( ;><3 1
.1 ' A3 2& 3 ; 3 ;><3 :39 ;43 3('( 1
M1 ( ( 3 (A;>< 234 A; (A& 3 (3 ('(3 ; 3 ;>< 93& ;' 3 A>'(1
1 ; 333A( (2':39A (< =( 3('(1
41 349?= =((3<331 (3(3 3<AB( 3< =A( 3 ( & >'( 3 ( 33'334&<3( 3 & 93 A :3 3( ( 92 3< = B;><E&
+*-.-+*//0 )M+,,)
3:3& ; = : <3 E 6 K 34 9 *1,P,+,MM.,,(U ,MM.(31@4 81
& 3 3( K & ' C: 3A 3(3 3( :3 ><93 :( '3: ,?'3*//@1 3(<4':< ' 3&( 3(;>< 3 3A1;%( 3(; 3(< 3491
1 (?(<K<?3& 349(3A
B(% 2<&( ; (3 3 3<&(A ;' '33 (3 K ( ;' :32 <3 94& < (D 3 ;>3 3(3< 3'93 ' (3(9(<1 & < C( 3:(3( (' <'3&<3' :3)3 4(1 & <K< <32 C%( C2& (' 3 ? 393 3( ( ;: 33 ;:3 3 < & 3A 3 ( >< ; '33 ;( (3 = 3' < 31 33& 3 '3 A <3 3 ( @ 3( ;' ( 3 ( =30=;'3 ( (4 3<(%A3H &33 ( 3 4;(43:= ;'(3)3'3 993 1 93&3% 2<;((=3 3( :(4 3 & 3)3 ><3 ( > 3( 3 3 ()(<<33( (' K 399 & < 993 = 33( A3( 3 3(&; A;3; 43A;3 (3 9'(4 ( E 6 K 34 9 *1,P,+,MM.,,(U ,MM.(31@39381
3A A3 3'3<32( 34 <33 39:< 33(( 3=32<(393 3( '6 +-+*//- +0+*//-P?'3*//-81 <32 (3 3( A3 2 & 34 '(3 3( <(393?31;3 A C2( ;3433 ;><93 :(3 K ? 1
,/1 ( 33 3< <31 33( (<<33( L><'( 1><(>L ( 3 (< &3 &3L%<( 39? 393 L (3 ( = 1 3 ( (3 = L' 3 L><93 :1( (4 4><(>
+*-.-+*//0 ),/+,,)
= 3( <3 *//0 L>< 3 A3 93 3 = L<33( ( (3 (<< <32 3' 3 L 3@/3- '1
,,1 3<3 ( $I ,;///1)& = C: ; & (( A3(4 3 3:36 1.N 81
;3 3 3:& <(< $I @//1) <3 = C: ;<33 3(1 C:< 3A (A(:3A ( C('(3; 2'A39 (' ( 3(1 :< (C '33; ((<3 ('(3?333 (< 3 3 ('(3> 39; ('(3?333; 1 93(9(<= &A ( 3 ;: = ;>( 3( % < 3A ; 2' ( <(< (6 +-*@+*//0,-?3*//081
&)' )
,-./!0
'4 ( 3 ? ,, ?3 *//0 !(3 !15555555555 ( 33((<<33(L><'( N?3*//0H
./0
;< 3< H
33( (<<33( ;>< '( N ?3 *//0 A;( ;'3 ;><93 :H
(3( = =;'3 ;><93 : 3 <32 3'H
(( 3<3 ( $I,;///1)=C:; H
< =C:;3 3<<(< $I@//1)H
(<<3A K = ! "# $% & '( ( 33 AL= (<<33(L><'( 1
F3: 7 !1%C2&3 &!<('% $3&!1 C3&?:&!1(& ?: 1
+*-.-+*//0 ),,+,,)
(< 34<33 397
:9932)?3 7 3 7 13()F3:3 I1%C2
(3(9(< K (<<3A> 3
2'& :99327
+*-.-+*//0