Enforceability of Settlement Agreement Releasing Future Unknown Claims
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case concerns a dispute over the enforceability of a settlement agreement that released future claims, where one party later asserted claims for injuries allegedly caused by the other party's prior negligence, despite the agreement. The court reasoned that the language of the release was broad and clearly intended to cover all claims arising from the underlying incident, including those based on unknown or unanticipated injuries, and thus the settlement agreement barred the subsequent litigation.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Enforceability of Settlement Agreement Releasing Future Unknown Claims: The court reasoned that the language of the release was broad and clearly intended to cover all claims arising from the underlying incident, including those based on unknown or unanticipated injuries, and thus the settlement agreement barred the subsequent litigation.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive for allocating costs to the appellant.
Testo completo
!"
## $%%%%%%%%%% !"#$% &'(
(
&''()*))+'&
)*+,,)
)
,2 3'(4(5 4(4 &!62777777777784)39 4 ( ( : ;; < ='( 3 4 3'44>4' ='( ?( (5*00*@0 A4 *00-2
;4=(5 45' ='( (3'&= AB B4(=C6('65*00-2D4 B64E& = (';(4B4(=C664*0012
*2 4 4(46(4 =C6;4CB (;46 4(=44 4(>44 (6644(=C6 '( 84)39(6644(:.'4*0012
)4( ;4C4 4'(6644(,A'4*00@& 6(4;4,?6*001&4(4 4(<4 =C6;4 ( ;(4 4E<2 C( >=F4 =<4 = C6 (;4(2 = (4>(5A (4 E(4>4 &64 4 ( (6 (;4( 6 43 4> 52(4 ((&4 ( (4'4 B 4 4( (G 4 ('4 =4 4 '4 H2
'(4 >4 64 4 4(( ( ;C 8D "I+ 9 ( J K + + D ! 9 ( J +L DLK+D KK 9( : 49 F4 ( 4( > 4( ( 464> ( B 4(4 4( < > 54 ('< 4 & C 4( 64C4 5 4(=C6H2
@2 ='4 4@64*0012
=( )4 (6( 4 4 C (4 (4 8(;(6= 4 (4 B=(54:;4 4(= 4 &(6=A(4 (666 4<2 4 6 C 4 =<4 A4446 ;4 '4 B 4 (A =4< 4(( 45;(66 4> BE3 6 (5 (4 > ='( 4 ' 6 (44 (2
( ( 45 ='(4 <4 46 4( 4'& 4 4 4 B ;4 =( =' 4 & >= '4 *001 (4 A('4 E (4 &(6444B
+*-./+*001 )@+,,)
6M6B3'&'4 ( 4; 4; 6432 B A(4 % 4< = 4& 44 KJ =(63 4 44> ( 2
-2 ( '&(6644(4 45C4 C (44' 9
)(4N(<4 4(A444('65,O-,8) *01:J
)(4(4'4,0'4,O?/8 P @01:J
)(4;;(6 434'4*-6*0008K(PD*/*:2
(4'4 44>C4 >=4('4 456 4(C64( + ( &4 4(,OOO(*00- E(4C4 &>(6644(642
12 'E&=( 4 45C C <C4' 9
) (' 4( ,. 65 ,O?? ( (6 A444 =C 4(44(6 434'4 (6648 PD02*/*2,,:J
)(4;@( (5*00@;4(&44(& ;(6 4( ; 46(4@( (5*00@8KPD,2@0,:2
4 >4 '4 E(44 64 =4 4( *00- + ( 4(4 4 C &4)4;4 4C2
.2 =444>E&4 64(42
/2 4 54C'(,, ,?64*0012
?2 4 / A4 *001& (6644( (664> B 4 ( C62 '4 (5 ( 4' 9 ' 4 8(;;44 *:9@&*1J'(,9*&*1J'(*9*J6(% '( ( ((<49-&*1&(4 ( ,12D(= 4 @0 4 * 3<6 =4 4( (4 (;4( ='( 1 A4*00*8 'P .,020,:&=C6;4 44 ( (4 <(4B*02=% (5 6(%>4&4 '4 E(2
44( 44>4 '(4 ( (' 2 ;4& ( 4(( 4' 4 (2
O2 ,1 A4 *001 = ( ( 4( ( 4'2 D( (6644(&B (4(&<( C(&('4 (& ( 4 44 > 536 4>2
+*-./+*001 )-+,,)
(4 = 45C4 >4(44 66(4 >4( 4<A(4 =4'(> 2
D(4 &( &( ( 44>> =5 C (4 4 (54(= 4 4 >=44< ((6444K&4>=4 ( (4 > A(4 ( 6 62 6M6& ( >4 '4 4 B 4( 46(4=(4 (%6B= &4;;44 6 4( = 4,?, &(6644(= C 6 432
,02 - A4 *001& 64 4 (64 A 5 84)
39 (64 :& N 4 (6644( ( N4;(6 (4 4( (64 ( NC6 ;4 <2 C(>&'E 4'(6 4 &4 4 <4 46 N > NC6 ( (4 4( 4(E5 (;()
6 C C4< <2 <6 (4 > (> NC6 4 EN(536>4 54 ((6 6434<4;4 4'&4 4 (4(C4 (4544 N'2
4'4 4 (>(6644(B(<4('' 4 '4 ;4((4544 B=654 % E((434(=C6('(42
,,2 ,,A4 *001&4 4 A (( 44( /A4*0012 ( 446 B= 4(44(4 (=C64 >(C6(C B>4(4 ( (% = (4 4( B= 4=C6;42D54446 & ( 4>6 B= 4(=C64 B>=(4 (4B B='4 2
44 ;4 >N '4 & ;Q( ( 6 4 4 4A 4;45& 6 (45 B ( 466 > (644( (6644( N'4 (<2 4 4( 4 N 4 (5 >N 4 C 4( 4 B NA > 4 3 C6 >4 ( 4 4 C436 4'2 DN% A4 ; ( 6 43& ;4 '(4>;4 ='(4(646 C4 > K 4 ( 4 4; N '4 ( <' 4<452 <6 46 > =4 4( 4( 4 '4 54 42 ;4& = ' 44 =4544 =C6 ;4 ( (5 4 =C6 42
,*2 (4 ,. 65*001&(6644(( <4; '( 2
+*-./+*001 )1+,,)
D=4 4 '4>='4 6 B4(4 4( C 4&=(54< 4( (6644(('4 4'4 = B ( C 45 (' ' 4 4( (2 (6644( ='4 > =(54< 4( 6 B 4(4 4( 4 C 6 ('( 4((2
44&=3&4A 4;44 6 C4 >=4 ;;44 > 4 44< =4< 4( ( C (4 2('4 C4> >= 4(( )4& ('5 ;;44 6 4 '< (4 4 >=4 = 4 4 =<4 ( A(4 2 & E(4C 4 '4655 A 4;44 &C64=( 4 4(((4('544 4 ;452
=C6(4( '4 4>=5 C ='4 =46 < 4; =4 4( ( '4& >= 4 (54 4& >=(>='4 54 A42
;4&(6 =4 4(='4 '4 ( ( 2 (>& = 4( )4& 4 >=(4 ((&;;44 B 54<4 2
(6 =656 &(6644(( A (2
) '
,2 A 6 4 ' A44 4( (6 & ( '58 21. (4N(<4 4(A444('65,O-,) ) *01J 2.@2,4 2(4(644 4',* 65,O?1) ) 1,0J 2@,4, ':2
*2 ' N 4 @, 4 * '& ( M ;(6 ( 6( 4;N4<4 (N54 42( (3'4<4;BN( 44( >& 64 4 '4( 4( 4(4 4( < 64 6(4 NC62
@2 N 4@* ''(4 >NC6;4 < 54' (6644( NC6 4 '(4 ' ( N(<4 4( (6644( 6(4 NC62N 4*,4* '(B (6644((6 ;4C6(4 NC62
+*-./+*001 ).+,,)
, A'4 *00@& (6644( ( 4 4' < ( 66 6(4 NC6;4>=6(4;4,?6*0012 N<4 N C6 (;4( >4 N ( 4> (5A (4 E(4> 4 & 64 4 ( (6 (;4(24 ( (4'4 B4 4((G 4 ('4 N44 '4 2
4 4' ( 4 ('< ( 4 (4' 64 4 >4( 4(> 4((464>(B 4(4 4( < > 54 ('< 6 4(& C 4( 64C4 5 4(NC62
N3&4N<4 644( 4(> 4((BNC)
6@64*001464>4 (B BK& (> ()64(4C4 2
-2 D( ='4 = (4 4 46& 4 4 4 (A =4< 4( ( ;44 4; ( ( 4( CE 4' A 24 '4 <6 E(4C& =(6<6 'B ;; 2
E(4>6 &4 '4 E(4C=<4( A(4 &( (4 (4 4 A( 6(6 ;4 (4 2 4>6 & ( (6644(& 4 '4 44< ( (A =4< 4( ( C (4 C4> >= 4( ( )4&('5& 4 ;;4 ('<(4 ( 4 2 6 >4 A 4;44 (4( 4 = 6F4(46 H& 4;B=A(4 >46 4 > 4;(6 4( = 4 ( 6 ;45 =5 >4 6ME4 4 64 ;(2 > 4( ('544 A(4 (4 <6 <(4 2
&4 (4 B;4=(44 4( 34> B 4 (4 (4 4 = (644 A(4 = &= 4 46 64(56 4><4 46 4( 4'2 44 6 B (6 (>(4 (6644( =C6 4 (4 6 =C 4 8 (644 A(4 B = <: 4 = 4 ( 4(6 2C4 4((6644(B < ( ('4 2 =5=6 4(>>=(4 > B =4('544 A(4 =( =C6& 4 ='4 6( 4;'5((B=4<2'4 B ( 6(4' 4( 4 >=4 4 (45 =4< 643 (A(4 ' (4 (4'4 4'(> (> 4(( C 2
+*-./+*001 )/+,,)
6M6 K2 4 = '4< (4& = 4 ,?, 4 - % '(4 ( >4 ( 4( = 46(4 ( = 4 B (4 (6642 =4 >(A 4;4=4< 4(C(4 &4('4 4 K 44 = 4 /1 4 , K '(% > 4 54 (446 (54< (4'('54 =C 4( ' ; 46(42B(& ( 4 4(4 C (4 4>= ='4 4 45 > (6644( '4 64 > 4 64 =C64 + ( ,OOO >4 (6( 4 C (42
12 (664 4 4',A'4*00@&5 NC6 (4 B (4 E(4>>(6 (;)
4( ; '( & >4 (4' (> 4< C6 R(66N44 '4 R2 ;; &4 4'3' > C <C4B( 4((536(( 64B 4(4 4(4 2
(( 45 644 4; AB =(4( 4 >= 4 4( & '( ' ( 6 ( ( (4 >N4 A< 42 ( >N 4 C <C 4& (6644( N(5A NC6 (4 E(4> 4 5 >N )6M6 4< B 4)4
8 +.+*00-.A'4*00-(421:2
4(6 = ;(=3>&=' 6M6 (6644(& = 44 >4& ( & '4 4 4 =4<A(4 4 =564B4(4 4( C 2&4 &=5 C (4 ( 4 ;(6 =4(6 A44>2
(>&(6 ;(4C4 K& (6644( '4( 4 4' >= )6M6 64 ( < 6(4 =C6 ;4 <2 <4; '4( 4( (4 ( ;(2
.2 D(A4&( B> 4(( ( <4; >4 ( ;Q( ( NC6 ( ( ' 4( ( (
8 K ,0. ,& ,O?* /:2 '4 ( A 4;4 N644(N( N 4((;(644( >> N4C4 44>'44 C4;;'(5 NC62'46 (5A 4;4 &; N4 M 4< ( 4(4>4N' &( 4 6( 4;(8 +.+*00-
+*-./+*001 )?+,,)
.A'4*00-(42.44( (4;*/6,OO,&4 1.+&,OO*&2,@,:2
=3& '4 ( 4' (> =C62 =5( =46(4544 = 4 A(4 ;Q4 ' A44 4( <'(4 (6 44 > ;4 =M 64 4(4 4(<> ;( <4 46 4(4' C (4 (4 4 A(2 4 & (5A 4'6 ( ( 4 & 46( 6 B 6 4 (644( (6644( 4 ( ( '(( 4& (4 =4 ;4 ( ( % '(4 4< > C C64 (> 6 4 ( ( > 4( =C62 ;4& ( ( 4 & ( 66 (( >4 4 (C436;(4B=C6& 4( 6 4 (4 B ( 4( 6(%2
/2 B 64 4 '4 ( M & ( 66 (4 4((( 4( 'CN5 K2
(6644( ( 6 ;N((6454>& N5&(NC6&6 44B( 4( (536 (64& (4 >N4 N 4 (45 64 > 4( 4 ;(4 4 6 4 4 '4 4 452 (>&NC6'4 M '&6M6' 536& N 4 '4 ('(4 ;4 844( (6644( ( 6 ;N((6454>,-64,OO.&4 .,+&,OO/& 2@@.:2
<6 4( <6 45 =32 4( & 4 > K 4 4 B ( 4( 2 & 4 46(45 64 > ( ( 4 '(4N'4 ( 6 6(%B N5 4 (42 4 ( ( NC6 ;;4 2 44& ;4 45 (4 6 4(4 >4(44 S(='4 (4((4 4(;4 >N65 4(4 &N )B)4N5( 4(4(6 A44> ( 4 &T 44( >N (NC62
64(6644(6 ( '4 ( ( 2 ( 6M6 4(& 4 = (45 45= 45B( ( >>4;4C (6644(& > ( & 6 & (44 2 63(45(4 B;4 ( =C64 2
+*-./+*001 )O+,,)
?2 ' >4 3& 4 = 4 =C64 <4; =54 4('( 2
O2 ( ( 4 ( > =C6 3 45 >= (>& (4 ('(4 = 4 =C6 ;4& ='4 >C'(2
2 = 444>( (3'<4;> (6 B( 4('(2
52 45;AB B((46442 (4(4 46>F( 46 B>( 4 ( & C'( 4 ( 44'445&64( 4 & ;4 > <4 4( ( ;3 46 B F=C6H& 4<4& = B < 64 H 8 M 45 ; *2,.,+,OO?,,(U ,OO?(42@5 :2
& 4 4( M ' E< 4> 4(4 4( <4 C6;4 <( '4< ,A'4*00@2 4(65'<6 ' 4&( 4(=C6 4 4>2=%( 4(= 4(6 45;2
2 (A(6M6A4& 45;(4>
F ( % 36& ( = (4 4 46& ( > =' '44 (4 M ( ='<4364 ;5&6 (G4=C4 4(46 4';4 ' (4 (;(62 & 6 E( 4<( 4 ( (' 6'4& 64 ' )
<4)4 5(2&6M6643 E%( E3& (' 4A 4;4 4((=< 44=<4 4 6 &4>4 ( C6 = '44 =( (4 B 4' 6 42 44& 4 '4 > 64 4 ( @ 4( =' ( 4 ( B 4 1 B =' 4 ( (5 4 6(% >4J & 4 4 ( 4 5 =(54< B =' ( 4 )4 '4 ;;4 2 ;4& 4 % 36 =(( B 4 4(<(54 &4)4 C64( C 4( 4 4 ()(6644( (' M 4;; & 6 ;;4 B 44( > 4( 4 4(& = >=4 =
+*-./+*001 ),0+,,)
54 >=4 (4 ;'(5 ( H 8 M 45;*2,.,+,OO?,,(U ,OO?(42@ 4;4:2
4> >4 4'4643( 45 644 4;<6 44(( 4B436(4;4 4( '8 +-+*00- +1+*00-.A'4*00-:2 643 (4 4( >4 3 & 45 '(4 4( 6(4;4 A42 =4 > E3 ( =4544 =C6;4 <(4 M A 2
,02 ( 44 46 642 44( (6644( NC6'( 2C6(CN ( 4 (6 &4 &4N%6( 4;A 4;4 N (4 ( B 2 43 ( (4 B N'4 NC6;4 <(N(E44(2 ( (5 5C6(C B4(64*001 NC6 4 >4 ;4 4 B N644( ( (4 (66 ( 4' 4 N 4 @0 4- '2
,,2 464 ( $K ,=0002)& B E< = & (B( >4(5 4 4<48 2?/ :2
=4 4 4<& 6(6 $K @002) 64 B E< =644 4(2 E<6 4> (>(<4> ( E('(4= 3'>4; (' ( 4(2 <6 (E '44= ((64 ('(4A444 (6 4 4 ('(4C 4;= ('(4A444= 2 ;4(;(6B &> ( 4 =< B =C( 4( % 6 4> = 3' ( 6(6 (8 +-*@+*001,-A4*001:2
&)' )
,-#." /
'5 ( 4 A ,, A4 *001 !6 27777777777 ( 44((6644(NC6'( /A4*001J
+*-./+*001 ),,+,,)
#./
=6 46 J
44( (6644( =C6 '( / A4 *001 >=( ='4 =C6;4 <J
(4 ( B B=' 4 =C6;4 <
4 C436 4'J
(B( 464 ( $K,=0002)BE<= J
6 BE<=644 4(6(6 $K@002)J
(664> M B ! "# $% & '( ( 44 >NB (6644(NC6'( 2
D4< 9 !2%E3&4 &!6('% $4&!2 E4&A<&!2(& A< 2
(6 45644 4;9
<;;43)A4 9 4 9 24()D4<4 K2%E3
(4(;(6 M (664>C 42
3'& <;;439
+*-./+*001