Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATA/715/2005 • CJ GE ATA/715/2005 Generato dall'IA

Government Boundary Modification and Constitutional Challenge

Numero d'incarto ATA/715/2005
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Parzialmente accolto (Partially Allowed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The case addresses a dispute concerning whether a governmental entity's actions regarding the modification of certain real property boundaries constituted an unconstitutional taking without just compensation or a violation of procedural due process. The court reasoned that the governmental action, which involved a necessary adjustment to existing rights to facilitate a public project, fell within the scope of the government's police power to regulate property use for public benefit, and since the modification did not deprive the owner of all economically beneficial use of the property nor significantly interfere with clearly established rights, it did not amount to a per se physical taking; furthermore, because the property owner was afforded several opportunities to participate in the administrative process, including hearings and submissions, the court found that sufficient procedural due process was afforded.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Government Boundary Modification and Constitutional Challenge: The court reasoned that the governmental action, which involved a necessary adjustment to existing rights to facilitate a public project, fell within the scope of the government's police power to regulate property use for public benefit, and since the modification did not deprive the owner of all economically beneficial use of the property nor significantly interfere with clearly established rights, it did not amount to a per se physical taking; furthermore, because the property owner was afforded several opportunities to participate in the administrative process, including hearings and submissions, the court found that sufficient procedural due process was afforded.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
confine particellare diritto di proprietà violazione dei diritti procedurali modificazione della servitù diritto di espropriare appropriazione indebita di beni demaniali

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The court decided on the allocation of court costs.

Art. 64 LTF

The court decided on the granting of legal aid.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

        

        

  

   

 







!"#  $$%  &''  !"!#$%$" 

" 

(     )(*   + )(,     -*   



.--. -   .-   /   .- . - 





     &'()&

 

./  !0   !"1 /2222222 "  ""1 1 1  3 " "4 .555226122"002227222(8$/

   %76'9.-:0'% 1 ;"#1"/    4"  "   "  222 7    " 2222   < 7"    =0/  41   1 60%  0  01" 7=41  1" > "".:3?,-0'%@  %A %1  :+0' $1"% $  ## < 7 #/ B  A  "    01" 7=41  1" "$"  1"'-0'$1"%0" 7#1/ 7#1 71##/6" .:+0'%"1  " ')+0' "C1$C/

  !0 /2222222+ 1  "61"% C "  1$1   71 ##1 /1.55,% 1 "1 7 #8$   $1"/ !/ /2222222% 1 1 7  161  6  1  7D%  6" 1"1" /

'/  "7" A66 :$1'+++%  "1 "  1" 0 90#0 %9@10  "#0  >1&8 E   0 ?  "   @7 1 " =$C $1    00  161  ""# 1"  4F 10  .:3% A  /     1C% !/ /2222222   $"1 " 1    1  D  G 7 "1 1"$4"002222 1 H <"@H  4" 6"08 0 /

:/   "1  .+ $1 '+++%   0   "610 < !/ /2222222 @7 161  71 1 %  H   461 7  "1 1"  " 1% 1 $1  " $ < 7 1 .   "1   "  1"    1  1"1$.3$1.5> &-+-?/1  I"1  1  10 1 " "  @H  611 1$   "1 1"  " 1 "  7"4I 1 1#1C/

3/   .+ 01 '+++%  "C /2222222 "  " 8   0  @H  "1 1"" 1611 1$D ""4I %" 00 %  "$  " =$C >?% 6  '. "$04 '++'%  1 1"  7 1 '3 4   "1 6  70#0   1 "1  '' I1 .5,5 > &B,++?/

-/  80 % 0 ""0"1 1""$ " 1   "1 1"%1"1C I"/

('*+,('++- &:()&

)/  B117"" 7 7 C11"% 14 011  16   01%  H   5 "$04 '++3 > (*,+('++3   (*,.('++3?/  14  @"I   1  "14 #  7 1 '3   /  "@% 7"  0"1 1" 7 1   6"/

,/  B     "   0 %  14 6 > J?    11"  "   $"D    14   " "$ 11"%7#1  117"0"1 1"/

  "0    6"0 1"  1%  "$  < =$C% 7 6-'0'%C1 *0'0C100.++0' "17 1 3' 1 :   4  7""  70#0   1 "1  '* I1 '+++> KB,++/.? '-L"  17#10 <7C 1 $"0C1  <1"1 1""1 1"7 13'1:   /  0 %  C 1 8 $1  H    " "4 1  "# 1"/

*/   14011  16171  1"/

   "C /2222222 "  "1# @ 7"  0"1 1" 7 1   I 161#71 H 41 1"" 1"/

   0 1 "#0  1" 1/

5/  "   1  61 %  14 011  16  68 C 11"  " 61 /

 - 

./  1 1#" @7"0"1 1""$ <=$C/

'/   7H  J@"$ <=$C% 1<7#1   1@ < 1   "11% 7    "14  $   7 1 '' 1 '     /  %   0 "M 1  01    "1 1" 0 1$7 13'1:  4 %1 H  "1 $"1"# "1/

:/   0  ""%<7#"  1"%1  1" "7 ="01  % 1"%0"161 1"%1" "0"1 1"> /.'51 / ?/ 0$ H ""  0  "@ 7   7 "  1"% 7 1  1" " 7   =" 7   "6"0 C 1 1"     "1%  8#0  @7 $"1  "   "1 1" 1$  1 1"   1"1 1" # " #0 1 > / .:+  ?/ " H  $4%  "  01 

('*+,('++- &3()&

"6"01 % @1 "0"  1  10  1  1" 1 1#1% "1   "     "1 1" 1$ %  1 1"  11   "" 1"1      4" 6"1 > (--.('++-  .) "N  '++-    61 O J...4''."1/) I11 ?E

 / 7""1 H 11#"  4 > J.+,':?/

 4/  1  1"    "1$   $"1    "1  $   "1   $1#  0"0    1 1" > J .+3 4 :+3O  /  '-"N .55'?/

 / 1  "1 7H "17C 1"  $C1 1#1C> J.+,.'.P .5*:'55?/

 / 7 "1   "1   $"1  =; 7011  " K   "0%  16"0 1"%   "  "0" 0  K  C  1$%   "1 1"  @7 1  1   11   4" 6"1 >/ Q % 1  "1  011  16% 380 /% .55.% R -+5% /.+*O /':6$1.55:"610 J"41'.04 .55:O J..,'*,"1/'4 I11 ?/

    11%  1  1" 1 1#1  "1$   $"1   " 7 "1 76G"@11 " 1  1$7 "1 1" 1 "7 "1 1"<61 1"1 1" #> J.5*'/3-+O /':6$1.55:?/

3/ /  78%   @1   ""1 1   22 "C /2222222% @1 "  " <  "  1" 1 1#1% "   4   "0" 0 /

 4/  "  1""$ 7 C 0  01%01   1     3 " "4 .555 K   < @  "C /2222222 "  @1K :$1'+++% <@ 0 "   7C1 /

 /   0   1  "  "1  7""  0"1 1"  "$ % 1"0 14$;"6""1/

-/    %1"$1 7C0110 "0 14$71 H  41 11"" 1"1 /

 / B7#1   71 H  41      ;" #1"% 1 70"  016 0   1% 1$%  "C /2222222 < 01 1    ;"  "  1" @1 7D "    1 > H   14 6 . /*:(.55:'.04.55:%"1/'4O (3::('++-'.I1'++-O (:):('++-'301'++-?/

('*+,('++- &-()&

 4/  0"1 1" 7 "  1" "  "14 7   11  " 1  11   "" 1"1  > H   14 6 ./)',('++:'304'++:?/B17 "1   11"  " < ""  0"1 1"% 1 6  " 6"1 $ @7 8# #% "  1"1=";"<4F 1 ""6"0<766  1" ;"$1" 6"0 0 "1 670#0  1 "1  "1$  H  0"1 >/ S &JJ ( / T&   % 0#0   1 "1% "  1"   C"1 1"%  '++.% # 3')   1$ ?/ &0H0%0$1#  < 14 $1 7"$"1   @   0 0"1 111$ 710"1  @1  1  01C  1 H 1$" >6/E (-*-('++-:+"N '++-?/

 /  $   @1 8%  "  I    7"  0"1 1" "610/

)/  0"M17 10 1%"C/2222222""  " 8   0   @H    "1 1"  " 1  "$  < =$C @1 1 "0   "1 1" 0 1$  7 1 3' 1:  4 /

,/  71"%0"0  UJ-++/&01<=# "C/2222222@1"04 > /*, ?/

 VVVVV

 . -      

01$2% 3

 $4  " 1 I   '+ 04 '++'  !"1   !0 /2222222" 11" 0 90#0 %9@10   "#0 '."$04'++'O

$2!3

I O

"6107"0"1 1"O

0 <=#"C/22222220"0  UJ-++/&O

('*+,('++- &)()&

"001@    H  < ! " !#$% $"   " %   0   90#0 %  9@10     "#0 % 11 @7<  "0011" ""0 18"  1"/

B1# E !/ D=8% 1 % !0 "$D   U1% !/ =1% !0 "% I#/

"0 14011  16E

 1&I1 E  1 E     /W661 11 J/D=8  

"1"6"0 H  "001@C 1/

 8$%  #6618E           

('*+,('++-