Appeal of Denial of Motion for New Trial Based on Evidentiary Sufficiency and Jury Instructions
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case concerns an appeal regarding the denial of a request for a new trial or an altered judgment based on claims that the evidence presented at trial was insufficient and that the instructions given to the jury were flawed, particularly regarding the application of specific legal standards in a complex matter involving commercial relationships and contractual obligations. The court reasoned that the trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying the motion for a new trial because the appellant failed to demonstrate that the jury's verdict was against the manifest weight of the evidence or that any alleged error in the jury instructions prejudiced the outcome of the case, concluding that the record supported the jury's factual findings based on the evidence presented.
Regesto Legislator
UfficialeEXAMEN; AVOCAT; VICE DE PROCEDURE; STAGE | L'absence de distribution des textes légaux nécessaires à la résolution de l'épreuve écrite lors des examens de barreau constitue un vice de procédure tel qu'il a eu des conséquences sur le déroulement de l'épreuve écrite du candidat. Annulation de l'épreuve écrite, le candidat étant admis à se représenter à l'épreuve écrite.En revanche, les notes des épreuves orales sont maintenues étant donné que celles-ci n'ont été affectées par aucune irrégularité, et que l'examen n'a pas un caractère "insécable". | LPAv.32; aRLPAV.21 al.2; aRLPAV.31 al.2
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive regarding the allocation of costs.
Testo completo
!
""#!$%&&&&&&&& !"#$ %&'
'
'(()*+**,('
()*++(
*
+0 1 &'2 '3 2 '2 % !4055555555 62(17 2 ' ' 8 99 : ;&' 1 ; ;&' +'< )..)=+>2 )..,0
92 ;'3 2 3& ;&' ' 1&% ; 4219'2?2';@4'&43)..,0A2 ? 42B%; '&9'2?2';@442 )../0
)0 2 2'24'2 ;@492@? '924 2';22 2'C22 '4422';@4 &' 62(17'4422'8D&2)../0
(2' 92@2 2&'4422'+>&2)..=% 4'292+E4)../%2'2 2':2 ;@492 ' 9'2 2B:0 @' C;F2 ;:2 ; @4 '92'0 ; '2C'3> '2 B'2C2 %42 2 ' '4 '92' 4 21 2C 30'2 ''%2 ' '2&2 ? 2 2' 'G 2 '&2 ;2 2 &2 H0
&'2 C2 42 2 2'' ' 9@ 6A "I* 7 ' J K * * A ! 7 ' J *L ALK*A KK 7' 8 27 F2 ' 2' C 2' ' 242C ' ? 2'2 2' : C 32 '&: 2 % @ 2' 42@2 3 2';@4H0
=0 ;&2 2=42)../0
;' (2 '4' 2 2 @ '2 '2 6'9'4; 2 '2 ?;'32892 2'; 2 %'4;>'2 '444 2:0 2 4 @ 2 ;:2 >2224 92 &2 ? 2 '> ;2: 2'' 239'44 2C ?B1 4 '3 '2 C ;&' 2 & 4 '22 '0
' ' 23 ;&'2 :2 24 2' 2&% 2 2 2 ? 92 ;' ;& 2 % C; &2 )../ '2 >'&2 B '2 %'4222?
*),--*)../ (=*++(
4M4?1&%&2 ' 29 29 4210 ? >'2 $ 2: ; 2% 22 KJ ;'41 2 22C ' 0
,0 ' &%'4422'2 23@2 @ '22& 7
('2N':2 2'>222))'&43+O,+6( )./8
('2'2&2+.&2+OE-6 P =./8
('299'4 212&2),4)...6K'PA)-)8
'2&2 22C@2 C;2'&2 234 2'@42' * ' %2 2'+OOO').., B'2@2 %C'4422'420
/0 &B%;' 2 23@ @ :@2& 7
( '& 2' +D 43 +OEE ' '4 >222 ;@ 2'22'4 212&2 '4426 PA.0)-)0++8
('29=' '3)..=92'%22'% 9'4 2' 9 24'2=' '3)..=6KPA))+0=.+80
2 C2 &2 B'22 42 ;2 2' ).., * ' 2'2 2 @ %2(292 2@0
D0 ;222CB%2 42'20
-0 2 32@&'++ +E42)../0
E0 2 - >2 )../% '4422' '442C ? 2 ' @40 &2 '3 ' 2& 7 & 2 6'9922 )87 =%)/J & ' +7 ,%/.J & ' )7 =%..J 4'$ &' ' '':27/%'2 ' +O0A'; 2 =. 2 ) 1:4 ;2 2' '2 '92' ;&' / >2)..)6 &P D+.0.+8%;@492 22 ' '2 :'2?).0;$ '3 4'$C2%2 &2 B'0
22' 22C2 &'2 ' '& 0 92% ' 2'' 2& 2 '0
O0 +/ >2 )../ ; ' ' 2' ' 2&0 A' '4422'%? '2'%:' @'%'&2 '% ' 2 22 C 314 2C0
*),--*)../ (,*++(
'2 ; 23@2 C2'22 44'2 C2' 2:>'2 ;2&'C 0
A'2 %' %' ' 22CC ;3 @ '2 2 '32'; 2 2 C;22: ''4222K%2C;2 ' '2 C >'2 ' 4 40 4M4% ' C2 &2 2 ? 2' 24'2;'2 '$4?; %29922 4 2' ; 2+E+ %'4422'; @ 4 210
+.0 , >2 )../% 42 2 '42 > 3 62( 17 '42 8% N 2 '4422' ' N29'4 '2 2' '42 ' N@4 92 :0 @'C%&B 2&'4 2 %2 2 :2 24 N C N@4 ' '2 2' 2'B3 '9'( 4 @ @2: :0 :4 '2 C 'C N@4 2 BN'314C2 32 ''4 4212:292 2&%2 2 '2'@2 '2322 N&0
2&2 2 'C'4422'?':2'&& 2 &2 92''2322 ?;432 $ B''212';@4'&'20
++0 ++>2 )../%2 2 > '' 22' ->2)../0 ' 224 ?; 2'22'2 ';@42 C'@4'@ ?C2'2 ' '$ ; '2 2' ?; 2;@4920A32224 ' 2C4 ?; 2';@42 ?C;'2 '2? ?;&2 0
22 92 CN &2 % 9Q' ' 4 2 2 2> 2923% 4 '23 ? ' 244 C '422''4422'N&2 ':0 2 2' 2 N 2 '3 CN 2 @ 2' 2 ? N> C 2 1 @4 C2 ' 2 2 @214 2&0 AN$ >2 9 ' 4 21% 92 &'2C92 ;&'2'424 @2 C K 2 ' 2 29 N &2 ' :& 2:230 :4 24 C ;2 2' 2' 2 &2 32 20 92% ; & 22 ;2322 ;@4 92 ' '3 2 ;@4 20
+)0 '2 +D 43)../%'4422'' :29 &' 0
*),--*)../ (/*++(
A;2 2 &2C;&2 4 ?2'2 2' @ 2%;'32: 2' '4422''&2 2&2 ; ? ' @ C2'2 '& & 2 2' '0 '4422' ;&2 C ;'32: 2' 4 ? 2'2 2' 2 @ 4 '&' 2''0
22%;1%2> 2922 4 @2 C;2 9922 C 2 22: ;2: 2' ' @ '2 0'&2 @2C C; 2'' (2% '&3 9922 4 2 &: '2 2 C;2 ; 2 2 ;:2 ' >'2 0 % B'2@ 2 &2433 > 2922 %@42;' 2 2'''2'&322 2 9230
;@4'2' &2 2C;3 @ ;&2 ;24 : 29 ;2 2' ' &2% C; 2 '32 2% C;'C;&2 32 >20
92%'4 ;2 2';&2 &2 ' ' 0 'C% ; 2' (2% 2 C;'2 ''%9922 ? 32:2 0
'4 ;434 %'4422'' > '0
*(
+0 > 4 2 & >22 2' '4 % ' &36 0/D '2N':2 2'>222))'&43+O,+( ( )./J 0D=0+2 0'2'422 2&+) 43+OE/( ( /+.J 0=+2+ &80
)0 & N 2 =+ 2 ) &% ' M 9'4 ' 4' 29N2:2 'N32 20' '1&2:29?N' 22' C% 42 2 &2' 2' 2'2 2' : 42 4'2 N@40
=0 N 2=) &&'2 CN@492 : 32& '4422' N@4 2 &'2 & ' N':2 2' '4422' 4'2 N@40N 2)+2) &'? '4422''4 92@4'2 N@40
*),--*)../ (D*++(
+ >&2 )..=% '4422' ' 2 2& : ' 44 4'2 N@492C;4'292+E4)../0 N:2 N @4 '92' C2 N ' 2C '3> '2 B'2C 2 % 42 2 ' '4 '92'02 ' '2&2 ?2 2''G 2 '&2 N22 &2 0
2 2& ' 2 '&: ' 2 '2& 42 2 C2' 2'C 2''242C'? 2'2 2' : C 32 '&: 4 2'% @ 2' 42@2 3 2'N@40
N1%2N:2 422' 2'C 2''?N@( 4=42)../242C2 '? ?K% 'C '(42'2@2 0
,0 A' ;&2 ; '2 2 24% 2 2 2 '> ;2: 2' ' 922 29 ' ' 2' @B 2& > 02 &2 :4 B'2@% ;'4:4 &? 99 0
B'2C4 %2 &2 B'2@;:2' >'2 %' '2 '2 2 >' 4'4 92 '2 0 2C4 % ' '4422'% 2 &2 22: ' '> ;2: 2' ' @ '2 @2C C; 2' ' (2%'&3% 2 992 '&:'2 ' 2 0 4 C2 > 2922 '2' 2 ; 4F2'24 H% 29?;>'2 C24 2 C 29'4 2' ; 2 ' 4 923 ;3 C2 4MB2 2 42 9'0 C 2' '&322 >'2 '2 :4 :'2 0
%2 '2 ?92;'22 2' 12C ? 2 '2 '2 2 ; '422 >'2 ; %; 2 24 42'34 2C:2 24 2' 2&0 22 4 ? '4 'C'2 '4422' ;@4 2 '2 4 ;@ 2 6 '422 >'2 ? ; :8 2 ; 2 ' 2'4 0@2 2''4422'? : ' '&2 0 ;3;4 2'CC;'2 C ? ;2'&322 >'2 ;' ;@4% 2 ;&2 4' 29&3''?;2:0&2 ? ' 4'2& 2' 2 C;2 2 '23 ;2: 421 '>'2 & '2 '2&2 2&'C 'C 2'' @ 0
*),--*)../ (-*++(
4M4 K0 2 ; &2: '2% ; 2 +E+ 2 , $ &'2 ' C2 ' 2' ; 24'2 ' ; 2 ? '2 '4420 ;2 C'> 292;2: 2'@'2 %2'&2 2 K 22 ; 2 -/ 2 + K &'$ C 2 32 '224 '32: '2&'&32 ;@ 2' & 9 24'20?'% ' 2 2'2 @ '2 2C; ;&2 2 23 C '4422' &2 42 C 2 42 ;@42 * ' +OOO C2 '4' 2 @ '20
/0 '442 2 2&+>&2)..=%3 N@4 '2 ? '2 B'2CC'4 '9( 2' 9 &' % C2 '2& 'C 2: @4 R'44N22 &2 R0 99 %2 2&1& C @ :@2?' 2''314'' 42? 2'2 2'2 0
'' 23 422 29 >? ;'2' 2 C; 2 2' % &' & ' 4 ' ' '2 CN2 >: 20 ' CN 2 @ :@ 2% '4422' N'3> N@4 '2 B'2C 2 3 CN (4M4 2: ? 2(2
6 *D*)..,D>&2)..,'20/80
2'4 ; 9';1C%;& 4M4 '4422'% ; 22 C2% ' % &2 2 2 ;2:>'2 2 ;342?2'2 2' @ 0%2 %;3 @ '2 ' 2 9'4 ;2'4 >22C0
'C%'4 9'2@2 K% '4422' &2' 2 2& C; (4M4 42 ' : 4'2 ;@4 92 :0 :29 &2' 2' '2 ' 9'0
D0 A'>2%' ?C 2'' ' :29 C2 ' 9Q' ' N@4 ' ' & 2' ' '
6 K +.D +% +OE) ))-80 &2 ' > 292 N422'N' N 2''9'422' CC N2@2 22C&22 @299&'3 N@40&24 '3> 292 %9 N2 M 2: ' 2'2C2N& %' 2 4' 29'6 *D*)..,
*),--*)../ (E*++(
D>&2)..,'20D22' '29)-4+OO+%2 /D*%+OO)%0+=+80
;1% &2 ' 2& 'C ;@40 ;3' ;24'2322 ; 2 >'2 9Q2 & >22 2' :&'2 '4 22 C 92 ;M 42 2'2 2':C 9' :2 24 2'2& @ '2 '2 2 >'0 2 % '3> 2&4 ' ' 2 % 24' 4 ? 4 2 '422' '4422' 2 ' ' &'' 2% '2 ;2 92 ' ' $ &'2 2: C @ @42 'C 4 2 ' ' C 2' ;@40 92% ' ' 2 % ' 44 '' C2 2 '@2149'2?;@4% 2' 4 2 '2 ? ' 2' 4'$0
-0 ? 42 2 &2 ' M % ' 44 '2 2''' 2' &@N3 K0
'4422'; 4 9N''4232C% ( N3% ' N @4% 4 2 2 ? ' 2' '314 '42% '2 CN2 N 2 '23 42 C 2' 2 9'2 2 4 2 2 &2 2 230 'C%N@4&2 M &%4M4& 314% N 2 &2 '&'292622''4422'; +,42+OOD%2 D+*%+OO-%0==D80
:4 2' :4 23 ;10 2' %2 C K 2 2?' 2' 0%2 24'23 42C'' 2 &'2N&2 ' 4 4'$?N3 2 '20 2 ' ' N@4 992 0 22% 92 23 '2 4 2 ' 2 C2 '22 S ' ;&2 '2 ''2 2'92 CN43 2' 2 % N (?(2 N3' 2' 2'4 >22C ' 2 % T 22' CN 'N@40
42'4422'4 ' &2 ' ' 0 ' 4M4 2'% 2 ; '23 23; 23?' ' CC292@ '4422'% C ' % 4 % '22 0 41'23'2 ?92 ' ;@42 0
*),--*)../ (O*++(
E0 & C2 1% 2 ; 2 ;@42 :29 ;32 2'&' 0
O0 ' ' 2 ' C ;@4 1 23 C; 'C% '2 '&'2 ; 2 ;@4 92% ;&2 C@&'0
0 ; 222C' '1&:29C '4 ?' 2'&'0
30 239>? ?''24220 '2'2 24CF' 24 ?C' 2 ' % @&' 2 ' 22&223%42' 2 % 92 C :2 2' ' 91 24 ? F;@4H% 2:2% ; ? : 42 H 6 M 23 9 )0+D+*+OOE++'< +OOE'20=3 80
% 2 2' M & B: 2C 2'2 2' :2 @492 :' &2: +>&2)..=0 2'43&:4 & 2%' 2';@4 2 2C0;$' 2'; 2'4 2390
0 '>' 4M4 >2% 23 9 '2 C F ' $ 14% ' ; '2 2 24% ' C ;& &22 '2 M ' ;& :21 42 93% 4'G2;@2 2'24 2&92 & '2 '9'40 % 4 B' 2:' 2 ' '& 4&2%42& :2(2 3'0%4M4421 B$' B1% '& 2 > 292 2' ' ;: 22 ;:2 2 4 % 2C 2 ' @4 ; &22 ;' '2 ? 2&4 20 22%2 &2C42 2 ' = 2' ;& ' 2 ' ? 2 / ? ;& 2 ' '3 2 4'$ C2J % 2 2 ' 2 3 ;'32: ? ;& ' 2 (2 &2 992 0 92%2$ 14;''?2 2':'32 % 2(2 @42'@2'2 2 '('4422' '& M 299 % 4 992 ? 22' C 2' 2 2'% ; C;2 ; 32 C;2 '2 9&'3 ' H6 M 239)0+D+*+OOE++'< +OOE'20= 29280
2C C2 2&2421' 23 422 29:4 22'' 2?214'292 2' &6 *,*).., */*)..,D>&2)..,80 421
*),--*)../ (+.*++(
'2 2' C2 1 % 23 &'2 2' 4'292 >20 ;2 C B1 ' ;2322 ;@492 :'2 M > 0
+.0 ' 22 24 420 22' '4422' N@4&' 0@4'@N ' 2 '4 %2 %2N$4' 29> 292 N '2 ' ? 0 21 ' '2 ? N&2 N@492 :'N'B22'0 ' '3 3@4'@ ?2'42)../ N@4 2 C2 92 2 ? N422' ' '2 '44 ' 2& 2 N 2 =. 2, &0
++0 242 ' #K+;...0(%?B:;2 24% '?' C2'3 2 2:26 0E- 80
;2 2 2:% 4'4 #K =..0( 42 ? B: ;422 2'0 B:4 2C 'C':2C ' B'&'2; 1&C29 '& ' 2'0 :4 'B &22; ''42 '&'2>222 '4 2 2 '&'2@ 29; '&'2>222; 0 92'9'4? %C ' 2 ;: ? ;@' 2' $ 4 2C ; 1& ' 4'4 '6 *,)=*)../+,>2)../80
'*( *
-."/ #!0
&3'2 > ++>2 )../!4055555555' 22''4422'N@4&' ->2)../J
"/10
;4 24 J
22' '4422' ;@4 &' - >2 )../ C;' ;&2 ;@492 :J
'2' ? ?;&2 ;@492 :J
*),--*)../ (++*++(
' ? ' 242 ' #K +;...0( ? B: ;2 24J
4 ?B:;2 244'4 #K=..0(J
'442C M ? ! " #$ % &' ' 22 CN? '4422'N@4&' 0
A2: 7 !0$B1%2 %!4'&$ #2%!0 B2%>:%!0'% >: 0
'4 23422 297
2(>2 7 2 7 0U992 22 K0$B1
'2'9'4 M '442C@ 20
1&% :99217
*),--*)../