Contractual Enforceability and Severability of Liability Clauses
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case concerns a dispute over the enforceability of various contractual provisions, with the court ultimately addressing the meaning and scope of several specific clauses concerning liability limitations, indemnification, and representations in the context of the agreement's governing law and severability. The court reasoned that the plain language and context of the relevant sections dictated that certain disclaimers were enforceable as written, while others were deemed void as contrary to public policy or the governing statutory framework; furthermore, the court determined that the entire agreement was not invalidated by the unenforceability of isolated provisions due to an effective severability clause, leading to a determination regarding the appropriate scope of relief for the parties.
Regesto Legislator
UfficialeBOURSE D'ETUDES; ALLOCATION D'ETUDE; ETUDIANT; ETAT; ETRANGER; FORMATION; REVENU DETERMINANT; ETUDES UNIVERSITAIRES | L'interprétation littérale de l'art. 19 al.1 litt.b LEE aboutit dans le cas d'espèce à un résultat choquant et arbitraire et ne peut être maintenue. Dès lors que la recourante s'est révélée être économiquement indépendante pendant plus de 2 ans, cette disposition doit être comprise comme exigeant que les revenus perçus immédiatement au cours de 2 années consécutives, avant que l'étudiant n'entreprenne la formation pour laquelle il demande une aide, soient supérieurs au barême fixé par la loi. | LEE.1; LEE.19 al.1; LEE.46
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay the costs of the appeal proceedings.
Testo completo
!""
#$ %##&% &'# ## ' # (#
!"#
#
() *+ ,) )- ./ 01. 2 (# 1. (3))- 2.4. +...2 +5+ 1.- 4 .67+ . .8.+.- . 0229-2.126:2;<=1(33>)
!) :.22 62 6. +6. ?.2 :.8.+.= @?: : !&&&)
1. 9. 6. 6 *+ )- A. 22 < :+...8.14 BC!&D#'() (33$- BC>>D''3) (33#- BC>#D3>() (333 BC!#D$E3) :!&&&)
% +.:4!&&&+.6+4!&&(-*+ )882 +.. F+.. + 6 *2. * ;.) 62.- 0.+ F+.. . 12 6.+ BC E&&) 6 +..2<1.8.1.6 ..?:.+.2 + BC(:&&&) 12+64.;.)
') = ;.- 22 1.2 9 B76.9 .1.. =1G. 6=HBI?.2:.8.+.=6:.+2...22 ,/+2.1.)
E) *+ ) .. 22 < :+... 8. 1 4 BC($D%E!) 6 :2 !&&( 1 4 BC $>D'3!) 6 :2 !&&!)
>) ;F. 6 2- *+ ) : .++.2 3 6+4 !&&%<82.2+.?.:.1.2=1 ?.2 :2. 20.= 6 + :F.1 24 !& 4 !&&%) =+<2-1..<!&J?.2:.8.+.=)
$) #4!&&%-*+ )..2:.:.:26 :2 2+.? !&&% !&&' 6= 1. . :2 :66.0G. 6=H1.I)
#) (%@1.!&&'-1.@2+-+.8??2 61. 5 .22 ++ 2. 2+.?+ .26 .D0+92'4(3#3G (!&I-= ?92.8.8..62 BC!(DE'&) 4 +..++) - 6= 1. 2 1 2+. 6068+..:.22-. .2.62.9+4=+)
3) $ 821. !&&'- *+ ) 212 2+.) ; 2. 8. !&&(:.0.6+ BC!(DE'&) 4) 1.882
"$#%"!&&' %"#
2.=<88+..F+..1.6*2. *;.+-?.96.?.8.412.22 <) 662?:1.-?:2..26.(33>?- 2-1.22162.< BC!(DE'&) )
(&) !! + !&&'- 1. @2 2+. 8.+2 2..(%@1.!&&')..1?26:.22.. 22+ 66 < .1.2 .. 4. ..1.- +. 6+.6209.=8..626 )
2. 12 96 20. ?: 1 4 +..++ 2..F2:.26G*2+.2 .-- (3#3 6) EE33I) < + . :.26 6 . +6 .. ..1. 4. 6 +. 0 6- .4 +...8 1. @02 ?- F+. < 8. 6.. ? . 1. 621 :4. . G) (3 ) ( 4 F.88 ! I- :9.0 .. :20.2 .+ :/ 66. G "%#E"!&&% ((+.(33%I)
(() 262(>1.!&&'-*+ ) .4+...8 2..) 6 0+. 21662 2+.-<+.<2)
(!) (%+.!&&'-1.6.2+2..K. @)
(%) + .4+...8-:.226.. < *2.*;...?1.9.62(33$ < !&&&)
(') ;?.2202<@0)
#&
() @2 +6 . 1 @... +62- 14G)E> .D0..@...!!1+4(3'( !&EK)>%)(.).62+...1(!6+4 (3#E E(&I)
!) D 0 @ ?. 6 2 6 1+:.G)( I-+/2...1.. 8.926.D0+92=0+D66..%( @.(33(G (!&)&(I)
"$#%"!&&' '"#
%) D. (3 .2 ( 28.. ++ 2+.?+ .26 D2.2.4.?.2..?..229< .6..) 9 . 62.8. 962+ ? .. +.1) 2?- .1 5 2.2 8. ?D 2. 2.4.6.5?.8.2LD2+.?+.26L ) 6..-D.(3.2(4621.?:2..-1?D. D6 8+.- 1. 41 < . 6 9 - 0M<.1.22+2292.6.+.<+. +6G) I-1.2626=D+...01..4.64.? 92.8.2.18.2D14+..++ BC!&D>E&) FD.68+.6=DM0!E21 G)4I)
') 66..:.'> +62< BC!(DE'&) 6. ( 6+4!&&!)
E) ) ; @.6 .4 822- . D.6= 6+..);.920D64+.-.6. .62.6.4.8FF12.462+- 200 . 1 D .6.. 20- 9 G.62. /2+.?I- 4 6.1.- .0.=+ D.25 6202- G.62.220.?I..?1220.?D ++ 19 626. G.62. F..? C (!( '(% .)'4K(!(>&.)%4II) 8.-.6..62.+..4- .8F..?.8+< ..G C((3!'#K($$%%( 5.2I)
4. ? D.62. .2 D .6.. 4. < 2 2.4.+-?D./+.86? 9 62 6 12.4 =0 ? .62.4.<2?20.61.1-<2 4..-<1...822 ..822-@0 .2<D29.-<66.?=0D.62. 21662 6 @.6 G C (($ (K ) , - 2. . +...8-M-(33(-N'(3@.6.2K O)!$1.(33%I)
>. ) ?. :. (3 .2 ( 4 .6.. 62.2- .4 +...8 D. D..? ?:. 1. 5 .622 .2 +-+P92.8.6.1.F 8.2D14+..++?D.D2.66.48. +/92.G "!>&"(33$!!1.(33$I)
4) .- .4+...8D22D.62..2 662. -.=Q2F?4.. 2)1.2.2?+L1248+.L1.-
"$#%"!&&' E"#
62.- 5 .622 ++ L1 + D. 8..=L) D0.. D 2. ?. D1. 6 ..2 D. 6 6+.= 2 8+. ?. 1. 4 1 88. 6 . 2 6 +6. 9.0 ) 2. 8. 262 912428+.2..88.6.< .8..=) .88.2.8.<F.9@..98.6 D2.?.-1D20-1.6282288062+22 ?D.1.2.2.8.6??+.?.- 9 2. D.+67 . 22 88. 6 6+ D. D.D2G ">'$"(33#(%4(33#I)
$) ..20D.262+.?648.9 .=4@.86+.882.2./?..26 +.= 4 9 ?.- D 6. 1 2+.?- D 6 ?.21.+8+..G "!$'"!&&%!&+.!&&%I)
# ) D9.0 26 9 2. 8. 8. 2 D + 2+.2 62 .. 28... F.882 D.26 2 +.? 96.. D. (3 .2 ? D2. 2.4. .1.L41<.69L)
4) *2+.8.96..-D0..6? 9 2. 8. 2.1 D + 2+.2 .1 5 26 2- . D ? D 1 6 < 21. L.+ 9 8. D2L G*2+.-(3#3-6)EE33I)
) /=+ D. 4 D2 82 6..6 022?D888...+46+..96G)()% I);D0.6+@/924+.1.22+ 22 .26 2+.?- D4.0. 8.+ 6 1.4...)
) 61. 62 < .26 2+.? 6 66 < D4.
0.D.6-.8@.8.16-?-+.< 6 . D 8 6. .- 61 61.?D.1.2.1).D.262+.? .+6.? 4..2 1 1 24 8+. 1- 4..2 2 D ..2- 1. D 6+ D.1.2 .1) 20. 01. .+2 ? 6. 9 2. 8.2.18.2D1+..++6+..2? D.26 2+.? 1. 22 2.2 .++2.+ 1 24 18+.G "!>&"(33$62.2I)
3) ) :6=- :.62. .2 :. (3 4 . < 2 .4) :4- . / . 1 ? 6. +
"$#%"!&&' >"#
8+.:.8.+.=-1.2+.=.66 .?68.?122/2+.?+62. . 621 6 .) .. 2+2 5 1 4+ 2+.?+.266)
4) .-:2?R126*2. *;.-61+.=+<.0M S6.+ +T BCE&&) 6/2 6 .. ?: + BC(:&&&) - 12;.6:0.++.2).?22 <:+...8.-8.2@+-+++ 6U +. @1. +. 6+4 !&&( GS6.+T .+.2 + . BC (%DE&&) I ..2 1 22 !&&( G. BC ($D%E!) I-260+.+..++8.926 2+?*+ ):62:52+.?+.26)...= .10 .. 8++ ? 20. . 9- . 6?.8.S.+98.:2.0 +6.+.216..1.22+226+6 G69)H1/0ITG*2+.(3#3-6)EE33I)
(&) 209+??.62=- .4+...8.=? :.62. .2 :. (3 .2 ( 4 4.- :6=<2F?4..?:65+.)
= ? : 2122 5 2+.?+ .26 669-.6...5+6. ++9.0? 16U.++2.+922.11? :2. :6 8+. 6 ? . + .- . 62.4=+8.926.)
(() - +.) . 1/2 1. 6 ?:. 2+..9.06216.+6.?- F/6F=-.<*+ ).9?.)
(!) :...02++6U) .+.2 2-:/69628.62G)#$ I)
"$#%"!&&' $"#
%#& ) #
*+,- .
2 14 .@2 (> 1. !&&' 6 *+ ,) ) 2..1..D2D66.0!!+!&&'K
,/.
+K
1. 1. . :2 :66.0 .2K
.?D.D66UD2++-.2:.+.2K
++.? 62 5 < *+ ,) ) .. ?D 1. . D2D66.0)
012 /3.
*)/F=-62.-*+1/-*);F.-*+B.-*) F2.-@0)
+ .4 +...8H
088.= @.@) 62.H *) . C)/F=
"$#%"!&&' #"#
6.8+522++.?296.)
=1-H 088.=H
"$#%"!&&'