Appellate Review of Summary Judgment on Contractual Interpretation
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe appellate court considered whether the lower court erred in granting summary judgment, affirming the lower court's decision based on the established contractual interpretation that the relevant provisions unequivocally granted a specific right to one party, leading to the conclusion that no genuine issue of material fact existed regarding the scope of that right and thus the moving party was entitled to judgment as a matter of law.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 al. 2 LTF; Appellate Review of Summary Judgment on Contractual Interpretation: The appellate court considered whether the lower court erred in granting summary judgment, affirming the lower court's decision based on the established contractual interpretation that the relevant provisions unequivocally granted a specific right to one party, leading to the conclusion that no genuine issue of material fact existed regarding the scope of that right and thus the moving party was entitled to judgment as a matter of law.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAApplied for the apportionment of costs in the event of an appeal being dismissed.
Applied for the allocation of costs to the respondent who did not prevail.
Testo completo
!
"#$%&''''' !"## $%& & &((& ( &( )(& * + (& )(&
'()*+'
*1 (2 %# (+++$ !&# 344444$ 444444 */2*$ ## #$&67#3#1
(1 ##&(8#(+++$7&99#995#:#';<= 8 6$ &# > 5 #& !1 344444 > 5&&?@ # %#6AA16B6##&$ 7&&%# 3###6 # # *C 8# (+++$ & # 9&6 $ & ># # &# &9 #&1 &;% # "57D #&%
& 7 # 8 & ##& ># % 9## #%1
-1 (. 6A (+++$ 85 7# #& & ;% &&E7& !1344444&&&6 #&&%&# % D A& &F E &D#&6 # 7 &6 & #9 #&E7 #*/"#99*	 9# -& &A */.*:3 '32*(1*(*=E#,.8&76#&6 & # # œ &&&D#&96 # &# &9 #&& #>1 && # %9## #%9 7&&# #&1
,1 856 (.8# (++*$ #A&#&!1344444 &A7#9 #&5%E3 &7B #%%D&6E 9# & ,++ 566 &F # E (.+ 566 & 7# #&$ & > !1 344444 &6 E # -0 6&# 76#&6 $E%& #&# # ED#&8### # &# &9 #&& 1
.1 856 &9#6 "6A & 8 #B /& &A(++*$# # -0E-+6
01 &7 #(+&%6A(++(%9& #&99# & & #& :#'; < =$ !1 344444 ##> >7# %# 66 8& 65 &G # %# & 6 7# & &613%# A# # # & 9�&>7# %# ># 7 65&%#3#$#7 # #EH8&98H #%5 %# A # # 1 %# &66# 6 D &# 61 ## B E &A& E *++ I & & 3# & & &%6#?&% #%&? &6 7# # 1
),-./)(++0 '-)*+'
C1 . 6 (++-$ &# 5# & A# # %&?5 &%#&#&!1344444&7# # 44444$444444*/2+$%A 
21 *- 6# (++-$ !1 44444$ # 344444$ 7 && E & %&# E # #& &J? #$ %# D$ # >7# %# # %# B & #9 #& E 3 1 8& & %&#$ !1 44444 7 A & >7# &%# E & 7%#& # # >7# %&# %&1 %# ##> >7# %# ##K'# &# 1
3#!1 444447%# 86#& &6 &"&&# # E ;%$ # %# & 9&# # #9# &# 6 &66 & # 5#1
/1 (+ 6# (++-$ !1 44444 9& E # #& &J? & & &##;1
*+1 *( 6A(++.$# # #&7 # &## && E 7& !1 44444 & # 6#$ 7# ##A#&&&6& 6 &6& #97& # A#1 # # #&7 7B & #9#E7# > *-&L (++0 #># *(*-&L (++0$&66 44444 # > # M># ; %&# && &FE >#7 %B &###%#1!1 44444 # &#&5& &F 7&66 NO*7+C,$-+>7###> %&# &% &7&M>#1!1 44444 # &#& 7A&6 & A#%&#$7 7 # 7 A&6 6#' #9 &6 44444$ &6 >7# 99#6 %&# &% & '6&# & A 5 &%#1
$!1 44444 6#%&# D&?7# 6# (++- 65 7# # #& 7 # E & & %&# # %#3#5ME75 &A % 6#&96# #1%# 7 # #%# 3#6 A1## %&#&66#7 # 1 9#$#7& B & %#&#&99##D 9# 1
1 !1 44444 7&99##&#*-&L (++0 % 7#9 #&E3 $ A 7#9 #&E7 #(-&# 98& @ A#6 5(06*/-*:3 '3 *,(1(+=&B %3#65D#&8###&&/ & &A(++* &8 # %A8>7*/&%6A(++/1
),-./)(++0 ',)*+'
*(1 #& 9# #' *( *- &L (++0$ !1 44444 &6 & 7# # 344444 && 85 7# #& *0 &L (++0 & %&$ 9D # $ A #9 #&E3 E#,6L#&6 1 && &6 #& %9## #%1
*-1 C&%6A(++0$ &# &##& #% # %&?5&%#&#%A8>76#(++CE!1 44444$444444*/2+$ #&# 5#$&6###E &J?1
*,1 ##& *2 & &A (++0$ !1 344444 A9## 7 #A #& &# #&%#7%71!1 44444 #A&*+ &%6A(++01
6B68&$# # #&A#5>B 6## #% E > # %&&# & #1 & & # %&# 6# (++- & & &##;$ # %# #& ; & #%E7&& &J?137# # ##A E;%$#&6 # ># 3#A9#& # #1
*.1 *+&%6A(++0E*-",+$&66##&##& 6# #&6## #%&D6&## #& # *-A # * A 3 $ 7# 9## 7&A8 7 ##& %&# & #9# ## & 9## # >7# & #9&6 $ #>7%& # 7& 8E%& *0&%6AE*/"..1
6B68&&66##&#$!1 44444 %&&# 	# &556 &# #> #>#%# D#; #&$##5# &%#1 # 6#$>#%# 6## &66# #$%# 6#&& #& &# #>1 3 %# A # # # 344444$ 444444 */2*1
*01 *- &%6A (++0$ !1 44444 &66##& & & &# 5 :#'; < =1 ##> &P >7#7%# &# #3#1## %&&#># ?6#& &#&G#%# 6#&E&#% (++-1&%# #&G### 13&%#&6 # 3444441 &## B & ># %# 9# 7&A8 &6 #& # (.&L (+++$(.8# (++* *0&L (++0 %&# &D #(++-1
&9#6 #&7&6# #&6## #%&D6
),-./)(++0 '.)*+'
*C1 ##&*-&%6A(++0$ &9#67&6# #& 6## #% & $ &# 8>7 *+ 8%# (++C$ 7# ? 6& &&6& 6 # D # &# # >7# # #A 6 5%6 5 %# 7 #1 9# #' 6 # >7# # & # E & 9&6 1
*21 & 599((&%6A(++0$ !1344444$# 44444 :#'; < !1 44444= & & ##& ; #A 6## #9 & E& #& E 6# #A #66# 1 ## ># 3#6#%&&# &#$? > # 9## 7&A8 7 6 7B #% *+ 8# (++0 & A#& & 5#6 #% *+ 8# (++0 ># 66A7#&9&6& #>#1 9# 6& # E *//01 8# #& &5# #& *- &%6A (++01 &6 # &%"& &7# # 1
3 9&$ !1 44444 ;5 > &# #& ## E 6# #&7 #*-A#* 3 9# 9 <7 $ ##&7# # #&7 3# (++.9## &99# ##&%&#&7D#&17 $##&%&#E&5 (+++ D#& 8### && (+++ (++* %# D 6# (++- &>7# %# 9& #1 ##$ ##& %&# & 7D#& 6#; # # %# & #9# # & & 3#1 & #&$ 6# #A %# B &B# 6 1
# &" ##E&%3 1 $ 9# 7 7# # 7 & # # 7 # ## & 9# # 9 7 9&6 1 &6& 6 %# # # & & A%# E A&# 6#; &%#&# & 7%# 7 A# A6 3#1 # &# >7#%# ># ? ## B E9#1 %# # 57# # %&?#1&%# B "A5"KQ$ &6###E #755# E&E & &%& #&%&?E 7 '#1 ## & #%&> 7 &# 9## ## 9 1
#$& & # 65%6 %#&7# 5# && #1 %# D& 6# 9## 9E##&#A #&&# #&&& *2& &A(++0# 6 %%#9%&A #& "6'&& && # 9%&A # 6 > &6& 6 & #A 1 ##&7%# 9# 7&A8 7 &1
),-./)(++0 '0)*+'
& ## &6 &66 $65#A ##&#A #&&# #&6 6B6 6 $ &# %# & & ##& &A #K' ; 7 #& 5# C &%6A (++0 &6 44444 && 6# #& 6## #% *+ &%6A (++0 & 6& #99# 9E&6 #&1
9# $&66##&#? #7&6# #& 6## #% # 7 # A # E @ &# #A #& &# #&1 &6 6& #%##&&# $ %# #%#&&&A#5 #&1
7 # 6& > & & # 6 # & 5% 6# 5 #$ & > 6# #A #66# %# B &&1
3# #A %# 6 > 6& #9 #& # 99# $& 6%# ##&& #&# ># 7 # $#5 #& # &#&&A#5 #&7&D &# E 5 99# 1 $ ##& #A #& &# #& # & #7#7%7>#&%# B %&> & 6#&&6& 6 &# #E6 #&1 ##A ""$E%D #&%&#$&%# B # >& &# #6 16 #&%#&# &## && #&# 1
*/1 (- &%6A (++0$ 6# & &# ##> 7%&A% #&E9&61
(+1 E7&99##&#$# 6#&A% #&(C&%6A (++01
& #6 D 5 & $ !1 44444 9## 7&A8 7 D#& 8### 9& 7 ##& 7# # #& 7 3# # *( 6A (++. & # 6#1 D# # & ##&78 %A1
# % > & %&# & # E & 9&6 #>7#%# &6 &# 8 %# A# # 1 $&&# #& $!1 44444%# # &9@ #1
9#$& %# &66 & 9#&5 & > 7& &%# 6# 5 # %# 7# 5# &&7 #$&# #& &&5#>7 #*- 3 1 66 && #6##A #&
),-./)(++0 'C)*+'
&# #&>#& # D#;#9 #&&66#&L (++0$ & 6## &# #& #*- *-A#* A 3 6&G# # #9 9#&5 %# &6&6& #9% &9&6 (+6#(++-#&L (++0 E> 6&##&1
#& 7 # & # ## && #&# # > &A&&6 %
&A% #& @# #6 9&## ## #& #&&>& @ # #*0&%6A(++0&66 %$ > 6 % 6 # % @ %&# #1
(*1 3>&#$ 5E851
(
*1 *1 8 6 # % 8## #& &6 $ & %A : 1 .0 R 1 C 1 . *+ 1 &# @# #& &# 98& @ A#6 5*08#*/22'3 O(*+' 10-1*# A =1
(1 # #& @ # *+ # ( 3 $ #A 6## #9 #D8&>##% ##1
*6A(++0$ #A ###$ >#%# ED# #&(6A(++01
-1 3###&%&#&@D#&6#;# & #9#$ @ &# & &6 $ D 9# @ @D #&$ 6 & #&&>##& 9& #>@ & # 9&6 $ & 66 # & &6& 6 8>@& 6; E & >@ 9 E &A 6 D # #& &# : 1 *-A 1* 1 3 R ).-/)(++0 0 & &A (++0R )02-)(++. *, & &A (++.R )0+()(++. C 6A (++.R ).,.)(++, *0 8# (++,R )(C.)(++,-+6(++, ),,*)(++-(26#(++-=1
3& @ #*-A#* 3 $ %#5 * %# (++,$ 6# #& ## &> ## & 9& # > & & & # 9&6 1 ## &#% B &# &66 & &> @ 5 #9# D "5 @ # *- 3 ## &>@# 9 & #; 5# #6 #& & &A& E @>## #& #;
),-./)(++0 '2)*+'
&# : 1 *-9 1 3 =1 3& @ # *- 3 $ #A %&# @ # *-A # * A 3 $ #& 6## #% 56 &#A&>&&6#6 # &6 5%6 5%#&# 5# && >$& 6& #9$9# @&A8 @&# & &61
,1 85 #& &# ##& 5# #&$##>@> #&7 61& S5# #5#9# & @A&>@#&# %#9## #&&& &6 #A%  ##$ #% #& #A $ # 9 6# # 6& #9 5 #&D# $#'# A 5# #6$#@&A#5 #&# $#9&6 D A #$&$6 && #& > 1
7;$ 7 &# 6#; # &# >7# D# # ## & & > & # & # E & 9&6 # %# &6 &# 8 %# A # # $ 9#9# &6 E & # # # 9# 
.1 !1 44444 &&@D#&8###9&$@ $%A8>@(++2#>@ && #A &#(.8# (++* &9#6 &8 #B /& &A (++*1 D##&8###& & #9#& $&@# # 344444 $6#@# 6#&&# #& *-&%6A(++0>@ # A##>#%# 9# @&A8 &6 #& (.&L (+++$(.8# (++* *0&L (++01$6&6 && /& &A(++*$# # & >@#56 T@B # 1
@# >@ % 3#8#(++0$!1 44444#66 %#& 6$>#$ & 6>7-*6A(++0$& #&# #& 9# 6	# #& *- 6A (++( & #># %#5*8%#&"#1
A# 56 > !1 44444 9# @&A8 *( 6A (++. @# # #&7 @# 6#>## & #9#> *-&L (++01
& & ' &66 @;5 & ' > &# #&##E6# #&@ #*-A#*3 9# 9 1
01 &  & # #& ' ' 6& #% #& ##&#A #&&# #& @&6# #&$@ @ 6 6B6 6 1
),-./)(++0 '/)*+'
> #&@ EB "$%@## #51
C1 @& 6# #& &9#6 8>@ *+ 8%# (++C1 $ # &# 6 %&# &>&# & @ # &66%*0&%6A(++0#6B6# #%%&##E 1 6B6$ &# &6& ## #& > D 6">## #&D& &"# %& %## # %&?5&%#
&# #&$#9 6 > #& #&& #& #> $ @&A#5 #& # > &# &#% &A% @ $ >@# &# # @D6# # ## & &9&##&&5 5 & @# # %&?&?1
21 &>$ & 6# 6# #A #66# !1 44444&&1
@# # #5$ # T @6&6 1 #6# & NO*@+++1'&& $E"5@ ;%$ 6B6##'##A9#@# 8##>: 12C =1
UUUUU
)& (
,-./" 0
%A&# 8 ((&%6A(++0!&# 44444& ##& &66##& & & &# 5 *- &%6A(++0R
./"#0
76 R
&&6##A #66# !&# 44444R
# >@#@ T@6&6 R
),-./)(++0 '*+)*+'
&& #6# & NO*7+++1'E"57 R
# >$ &9&66 D # /C #% &# 9 @&5# #& 8###$ B B & $%&#&&# 6## #9$ 8& ; & #9# #&$ '% #A 9R 66&# &&# ##>&#&$6& #9 6&?% & #5 & &&6 #R#&# B &#D6#6&# #A 9$ *+++ *,R B #; &#& & $#%&>&666&?%$&#% B 8&# E@%&#R
&66#> B E!"## $%& & $E&66##& & & &# 5 ## >7E 7&99## &# &#$ O6A&#	&6 #&1
3#5 < !6N#$# $!1 "# !6&$851
&6 #A6## #9<
599#;'8# < # < 1#&'3#5# 1N#
&#&9&6 B &66#>D #1
;%$ 599#;<
),-./)(++0