Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATA/639/2005 • CJ GE ATA/639/2005 Generato dall'IA

Improper Summary Judgment in Regulatory Lien Perfection Case

Numero d'incarto ATA/639/2005
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Accolto (Allowed)
Spese processuali a carico del ricorrente / reclamante

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

A lower court improperly granted summary judgment against a party challenging the validity of a regulatory lien imposed on property, as the challenging party presented sufficient evidence to raise a genuine issue of material fact regarding whether the lien was perfected according to statutory requirements by the proper notice procedures. The reviewing court found that the record indicated conflicting evidence about whether all necessary parties received actual or constructive notice, which is a prerequisite for the lien's enforcement, necessitating a trial to resolve the factual disputes.

Regesto Legislator

Ufficiale

CIRCULATION ROUTIERE; RETRAIT DE PERMIS; RECIDIVE; CONDUCTEUR INCORRIGIBLE; PROPORTIONNALITE; RETRAIT DE SECURITE | Le qualificatif d'incorrigible est réservé au conducteur qui ne souffre d'aucune maladie mentale et ne présente pas de troubles caractériels mais qui ne parvient pas à se défaire d'un défaut entachant sa manière de conduire pour se comporter d'une façon sûre dans le trafic. En l'espèce, le recourant a dépassé 11 fois en une année la vitesse prescrite, il a fait l'objet de deux mesures de retrait et n'a pas suivi le cours d'éducation routière : c'est donc à juste titre qu'il a été qualifié de conducteur incorrigible. | LCR.16; LCR.17 al.2; LCR.27 al.1

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
enforcement requisito legale pegno immobiliare procedura per direttissima esistenza e validità sostanziale azione di accertamento

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive regarding the allocation of court costs (costs of appeal proceedings).

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

        

        

  

    

 !"

# $%&'







&'%"()*)

 







+ , ++ (( ++ + ,- ( 





     !"#$ 

+ 

#(  )*(+++++++,(+++++++++++-.#/&0-1***.+++++++-#!$& 23-**451**.*3.5*.3* #1*#/60(

!(  ,  *  5*  *7 1***8-    8* 479 4 1  *  *: 1*- 5. 5  *. 3*!!3*!$$!-**:;23*11*6 <!$317!$$#(

      8* 479 4 .**  *  ; 1* 5. 53*17*3*=*>* 52?, @'.17 !$$!-*:;23*11*5*3108.3*-## 1*  #! 1* A ; 5* !$$!(  1  .. 8*1. 5 B  *71***8#C93*!$$'> "%!"!$$'#C93*!$$'@(  *- *71***8*.4*)(,(+++++++++++   8* :4   3 *8* A  * 8..   ** *2  #/ .17 #/%6 >  D , 0'#($#@ * 5* B *.. 11**=*74*#0*.! (

      * :  ' < !$$!- )( ,(+++++++++++ 3* 11*;23*AE.53**. #& F1"G- 1=  .*. .*-  :4A  *  .* *1*. A %$F1"G(, 3*.A531( 8*- *8* **  .. :* * 5*  *.*    3*8*A (

C(   6 9* !$$C A #%G#C- )( ,(+++++++++++ **  3 4 3*:* =E-**.H-A3*6CF1"G- 1=.*..*-:I*1*.A*A&$F1"G(

  .513*..**!CF1"G(

'(  .**#&8.3*!$$'-, *.51* * )(,(+++++++++++A*.8***8-1**11!'1*-5.=*-  .=*  .=* 5.*- A 15   .5*   5. .**-7-55***#&*.C7#0  (     ** A )( ,(+++++++++++  *  3.G* A 1 5 :  51*  * 4.* 5 .*- 7 (

  

"%%&"!$$' C"#$ 



   8*=  3 8*  *   ** *2- 52  5..**'.17!$$!-)(,(+++++++++++3*.1. :4* 8** 8*  1 5. A    :4 5. 1***3.*53 *71***8(

%(  )(,(+++++++++++** *71***84-5 #%1!$$'(

   .** .* 1521 ;*3   5.**  *3 58*(   3* 81 *9(  88-  * **  51* 5;1*5:;23*.8***315;2 3*-A4*45G**:.1:4*3*J52 3* 11* * *8*(  43* 5 8* 8*  .**  4*. 5*:4*3*15.**#C93*!$$'-33* 5**13.G**(

  A:9**8*1*5AG;*3(

&(  5*..3:. *15*5 !/3*!$$'(

  *-)(,(+++++++++++1.?

 #@ 53**3.G*A4.=K

 !@  53* *  3.G* 5 :  51*  * 4.*5.*K

 C@ .*.*A!'1*(

  5., 1*:)(,(+++++++++++53** 3.G*5:51**4.*5.* :G*88#7.**:..*.(

  )(,(+++++++++++**:.:4*3*** *78..> L@4 4B *71***8#C93*!$$'(

  ,*A.**:.-*3*5'$M3(3** 35**7*,*:4A 4.=*3*7*3.G*53***(3*.5. 51**'1!$$'(

   43* 5 5 *3   4.* *2 5  * 1.*(

"%%&"!$$' '"#$ 

   4*  4*- 4**   5.  .. 5  89:4A*9=.5.53 L(

0(   #$ 1* !$$'-  L  ..    )( ,(+++++++++++ *37>& (#$"!$$'@(

6(  3*.!&9*!$$%*AA5.3  *71***8-)(,(+++++++++++..1**(

+ ( 

#(  9.  15 * 3  9*** 15.-    37>(%& *I=**9***!!317#/'#    !$%K(&C(#*(*5.1***3#! 517#/6%    %#$@(

!(   # 93* !$$%-  3 *5**      .  3*=>!$$!5(!0&0@( 8*-*5****  3-  *2  455*: :4; *8*   ** *211*52.3*=-1.3 4* * 1 .=* 5  *- 8 ;5*  .*.  452( 4 C#.17!$$':*455*: > "#0"!$$%##93*!$$%@(

C(  G*5*=;1:5***=; 8*;3*1;*1>(!0(# K(#&!!4 *=***2%517#/0/D,D,0'#(!#K L#$6 &!@(

'(   *1**  3*-  :I .   *    *=** *2- 3-   9*5- 11  *1*  A :.*.151*( **:;- :*  3   5* A 5 371  3* ; *- 11 ; 5**.  3.G*   G=1- ** :I;**-**3**7**.-*A5* :9.5*=>(C!(# @(

  I*#&*.! 5*:51**5B*. :*-5*8*;2=**-151* .*.     *11.  57* >#2 5G@(  *15 3*1 5 B .     5  =3*. >!21 5G@( ,I*#&*.C -51***5B *.*151*=31.*.(

"%%&"!$$' %"#$ 

  *.7******?

  5=3*.>*#&*.!-!215G @K

  1E1=3>*#&*.!-#25G @K

  =3>*#&*.C @(

  *2.=*-3**=3I2= **-I*/$G*88! -*N  ..  .*; = 5  .*. I*    5*  *: > L#!C#$&- #//00!%-*(!7-55(0!0 0!6.8(*(@(

  O*.-3*1;*1=..3.G*5* 6$F1"G-:**-**3**7**. 837  I* ' *. #    I   2=   ** *2  #C 317 #/&! >   , 0'#(##K L #!#  #!0-  #//%&&'@(,I*.%1B1*5**-*=;53 **: I 3* 1;*1-  * . 55*7  *  5 *1**=..3*(

  ,  9*5  *7 8..  1*2 I;2  3* A I;.*I*.-***:*I5G..5.- .513*1;*1*.%A!%F1"G* 5=3*.:*9*8**153*1I*#&*. !!215G > L#!C#$&-#//00!%-*(!7-55(0!6 0!/ .8(*(@(

  :.51*!&!/F1"G-8=3*. 1E > L #!'  !%/@(  3G-  .51  C$ F1"G  5 P5**5 81*8;5*539*8*I;23*  ;  8  I17**   * 7*=*  51*  *-3=3*.1*=:I*53:(*- 9*5*2:11*3**=*2I 2=81>(#&(C*((/$G(! K L#!C#$&- #//00!%-*(!-5(0C$.8(*(@(

  *5**555*7:***** 837    :  ..   8*8 * 7  13*(  I=*-  88-   1*2- I  .*.  *   83*:5*7I.=*.*19**7> L##/7 #%&K,#//C5(%C%K L##6#/$K#$67&0K#$'7%#@(

%(  **.*G*88C5*8* 5.B-3*.*5**.=5.*.(*   8G :* < 51* A 4*.  8* 55**  4* #&

"%%&"!$$' &"#$ 

*.!-51*25G -***.*83747 4..(



&(   452-  ,   *.. :   3* B :*8*.  **=*7*..(

 ***=*7I*#0*.!  -:51**..8***31A(

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

"%%&"!$$' 0"#$ 

.*;23*> "#$!"!$$C!%8.3*!$$C@(B!/ 3*!$$C- *71***8.=18*1.*51* *.8***85.AI.=I**=*7;1*8: I*.. 3* 8* I79  : 1 1***3  < #///  1* !$$!-  15  1  **=* >  .*  3 I3.G*17*:I*.*5I*51** 3*.I**8*1EI51**:*I.*5*@ > "!&0"!$$C  !/ 3* !$$C@(  1B1 9-  *7 1***8  .=1 8*1.  *  51*  * .8***8 *8*=. A  **=*7-E8*I79*1* 3*#//0517!$$!53*88.I55*=  B 15=.- 151  : * 3* 5*.  :* 3* .*A.**:.> "!%&"!$$C!/3*!$$C@(

     5 .-  *7  .  8*1.  * .8***8-31**11;-A:*3*11*G* ;23*-*;*;.5..-E.*A :*51*A*3*1> "/'0"!$$C#&.17 !$$C8*1.5 L!!1!$$'@(

  8*-   B  #& < !$$%-  *7 1***8  8*1. :4-G88;*-E11**:;23**: 3*8*A >.85**.@3*B*.. 11**=*7> "%%6"!$$%@(

  :*8**84**=*7.3.:*88 41*15.57.*1*:* 53* 5 A  .8* 4 .8 G  1*2  * 5  1548J<8*(

  455.**4**=*7**.4**3**5 8* (  3*  GG 4* ;*  ..1 88* 5  : 4*.. 4 5 *7 A 488 5.3*8 **1 . GH   E 8* 479  1 177 > "'%%"!$$#&<!$$#@(5.AE-*.*   8   ..- ** :   8.:  .**3-  .G.455.**9=5.1B18*(

  452-G1*8*A4*=*.**:.- 11**:;23*6<!$317!$$#-*:;2 3*#&8.3*#!1*!$$!3;23*'< !$$!( 41-.5.H8*.3* 5*(8*479;1*-51*25*. 3*    5  *. =3*   .1 4 5 .G55.*7.(45*3*4.**2:

"%%&"!$$' 6"#$ 

* 4.* **   * 1.* :4*  *3:. 5 9*8*  713..(

  

  3:*5.2-*7.5::  5* A 8*  2= ..1*   ** *2- 715*A54*.(55P**7 A4881****1.GHE7* 1177( 4A9*:, :*8*.  **=*7( 4  3* :   ;5*: : 43*1:**..*8*.5 *71***8B #C 93* !$$' .* 5.* A 4*8* :*  . * A  .** :.( 88-4**=*7**.5.5555.4 3*1(

0(  5**555**.=3*.*:(** A 4*.  5  1   . 4 5 9*8*. 5  *(

  *15.*4.53;-4*.**1. 5*.**:*.G55A**:( 3*8*53 .3.*.-8;..-451.*1.7* 58*-  .=*=7 A 4.5: N   5*  .**( 4B. :.8*1.5*(

  4*15*5!/3*!$$'-,  5.1.4***8**3.G*A 1 5 :  51*  * 4 5 .*(  *   .1-5*11*(

6(   I*  **=-  .11  OL #%$(   1* A  G=   :* 7* 5*1 =*   >( 60  @(  ,  E 5.1 1*8*.  .** :.-  .11   1* A  G=( RRRRR

.  +(  +    

/012&" 3

"%%&"!$$' /"#$ 

. 37   *9.  #& 1 !$$' 5 )* (+++++++ ,(+++++++++++.**3*17*3*=*#& 8.3*!$$'**51**A*.8***8-1**11!'1*K

12&'3

415*1K

8*1  .**  3*  17*    3*=*   :4 5  *  51*  * A * .8***8  )* (+++++++ ,(+++++++++++-1**11!'1*K

   3*  17*    3*=* :  : )* (+++++++ ,(+++++++++++  *. A *-   .* 4.53-  3.G*.=*-L)3.G*5:51*45 .*K

1AG=.11 OL#%$( K

* :- 81.1 ; * /0  *3   * 8.. I=** 9***-5.B5B5.-53**1***8-   9 2  *8**- 5 3  *7 8..K  1.1*  ***:*-1*81E535*= 1*K**B.*;15*1* *7 8..- #$$$  #'K  5. B   5*2  5*  -*3:.111E53-*3B9*AI3*K

11*:  5. B A )* (+++++++ ,(+++++++++++-  3*  17*3*=***:4AI88*8..A(

,*.=? )13E-5.*-))(EG2- G.*-9=(

1 *71***8?

=88*2 9*9(?  3* 5.*?     )( * (3E   

"%%&"!$$' #$"#$ 

5*81B..11*:.;5*(

 23-  =88*2?    

"%%&"!$$'