Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATA/636/2005 • CJ GE ATA/636/2005 Generato dall'IA

Failure to Timely File Notice of Claim Due to Mental Incapacity

Numero d'incarto ATA/636/2005
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Accolto (Allowed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The court addressed whether a statutory claim for damages could proceed when the plaintiff had failed to timely file a required notice of claim with the relevant public entity, despite the existence of mitigating circumstances such as the plaintiff's mental incapacity at the time of the injury. The court reasoned that while the relevant statute granted discretion to waive the filing deadline for good cause, a finding of good cause, such as mental incapacity, required more than merely excusing the delay; it demanded a specific finding that the failure to file was due to the incapacity itself, and the lower court's determination lacked the necessary specificity or supporting factual basis regarding the direct causal link between the incapacity and the late filing, thus warranting further review or clarification on the application of the good cause provision.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 93 LTF, Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Failure to Timely File Notice of Claim Due to Mental Incapacity: The court reasoned that while the relevant statute granted discretion to waive the filing deadline for good cause, a finding of good cause, such as mental incapacity, required more than merely excusing the delay; it demanded a specific finding that the failure to file was due to the incapacity itself, and the lower court's determination lacked the necessary specificity or supporting factual basis regarding the direct causal link between the incapacity and the late filing, thus warranting further review or clarification on the application of the good cause provision.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
insinuazione del credito atto tardivo incapacità di discernimento termine legale circostanza attenuante annunci pubblici

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 93 LTF

Used to dismiss the appeal because it concerned a decision on costs, which does not allow appeal to the Federal Supreme Court for lack of finality.

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Imposed the costs of the federal proceedings on the appellant for the dismissal of the appeal.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

        

        

  

    

 !

"!#$%&





%&$!''''''''''  ! "# #$% &'% 

% 

( ) (( ** (( ( )+ * 





     ()*+(

( 

.0  ##%)12#)//,&'# %2%3# '#4 #% 5#(67  $ 8   # %    9 2%#  2#  %# %   4%#   %( 4%# : !%#  !;;;;;;;;;;& %2### "< !2!;;;;;;;;;;&26&% ;;;;;;;;;;:6'0

)0  # ##%  (#4 =#>  # : %  '  >"  #  4& # '  - ?# )//,0  %=&  %%2:%9# 0

@0   ./?#)//,&$  2###%# :># & % # #2&   #  %   #%   A#  =  % #A# #%  #  # ':>"#4% 2#'%#0

+0   .+?# )//,&!0!;;;;;;;;;;%6 #3 2##  #A% ##%)12#)//,&% :% #%0

,0  %>#%2 #%% #., 23 )//,& >#    = %=  ##%  $  '#    % #A#&  26B"<=## #  %?%%2###B # '0  # ' A#2#*3 ?#0 #'# %>'# #  %# #   %$ =>## %#0

  >#>#& 4:?40

( * 

.0  #% @/?%6 #%##% =5 0 -@ 0 . # 0    %#   % 2##  #'  .)  23 .CD, (  ( ,./80

)0 0  '%#     % #A# :    : = %  # #  E%#  AA #'2 0 %=  #     F   #    => #'#  #% :  #>'%# %3%G 9 %% &   # >'%#  2# 0 % A%#&#>'%#>  # #41?%&#  '%# %22#=#?% # 5 H .)@  +C@& ..C  .+C %#0 )& ..C  C+ %#0 +3*    A80

30 #> HD,..,&64A# #%% #A# #%:>" #4 % 22 %A#2 #39A95 H .)@+C)I..CC+%#0+3&..1.@)%#0+ A# 80

*),-.*)//, (@*+(

    %    %2# :  #%& # >  4# >'#  => ? ##3 % : % 4  3  > #  %    %# = # # G  >    % 5A0 0    & >9# #%  #% %  ?##=&#$& -C*.C1@&0@+C80 ##&F  5 H.)1@.8& #3A  ?4 =># >J    A%2#2 9#A : %# =  A# #%   % #A# #%:>"#4 ?% 42 #3 %=% &%## # #'%# # %4 = K'%#K  #=#?%#5%#0)380

     >6&  ##% =      2#6 4#6%2##% 0A# =>#%'26&  %# >#    F  # #3 #  # : >%AA# %    #'  6 % =  ?# %  &   #   %3    % %2##%  %   & # 3# => %  %  A    9###&2F2# '%#%%=>#'3## >% %   A%#% 5 *)@*)//,  .D ?'# )//,    A # 80  J  % # >2  =  ##% =    '32  % #A#:>"#4% &%# -?#)//,0

@0 0 #2 #% %A#9%#% #%# #% #2 #'  %#  3#0   % &  ##&   #3 KF  %%45 0.-0..6" 8& # %&#K  4#  #(2F2 5$ .CDC 0 +.D80 ##& # =# K4#     # #  A%% ##%=# A%%3#4 %#5$)///))  A# 80

 30 A%2?  '5 0.-0.)62" 80    4& # J  #  # = %23  %   % #%  '2  9 %## #2'##3=#'# "%"6K #'#   K#    =# K#2%  : #  K9 #  AE% ## #3 5$ # 80

  > 2#A 2 >60

+0  %%#'3

   2%2   LH @//0(  2# :  "4  %  5 0 D1  80 MMMMM   

*),-.*)//, (+*+(

,  (*  (    

 #'3  % # ?   .+ ?#  )//,  !%# !;;;;;;;;;; %   ##%  '#   %2%3#     '#4 #%  )1 2# )//, #  #  %2# %# %  4%# % 4%#%  92%#I

2 :"4% 2%2  LH@//0(I

%22#=    F  : ! "# # $% & '%   %  ## =K '# %2%3# '#4 #% :K%AA#A% :0

$#4 7 !0J"6&# &!2L#&%&?40

%2 #32##  #A7

4AA#6(?# ?07  # 7     !0 %%# H0J"6   

%#%A%2 F  %22#=9 #0

 6'&  4AA#67           

*),-.*)//,