Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATA/633/2005 • CJ GE ATA/633/2005 Generato dall'IA

Statute's Equal Protection Challenge Based on Classification of Governmental Entities

Numero d'incarto ATA/633/2005
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Accolto (Allowed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The dispute concerned the validity of a specific section of a statute, with the central issue being whether that section was facially unconstitutional because it applied only to certain governmental entities, thereby failing to provide equal protection under the law. The court reasoned that the classification created by the statute, distinguishing between governmental entities, was not rationally related to a legitimate state interest, as the statutory distinction served no discernible purpose beyond the differential treatment of similarly situated entities, and thus the law violated the equal protection guarantees of the state constitution.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Statute's Equal Protection Challenge Based on Classification of Governmental Entities: The court reasoned that the classification created by the statute, distinguishing between governmental entities, was not rationally related to a legitimate state interest, as the statutory distinction served no discernible purpose beyond the differential treatment of similarly situated entities, and thus the law violated the equal protection guarantees of the state constitution.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
uguaglianza di trattamento costituzione protezione dello Stato statuto in diritto internazionale privato uguaglianza in materia di diritto di voto discriminazione razziale

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied to determine the costs of the federal procedure.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

        

       

  

   

 !"#





 $$! %%%%%%%%%%  !"#$$$$$$$$$$%"&#  " 

   





     '()*'

& 

-/   0    -1 2#  (,,.% 3# 3  #  + "4  (,,.%  #5 6##  #&  2   " # 2   !6 $$$$$$$$$$%    !"# $$$$$$$$$$ 7#'89 !6 $$$$$$$$$$ "  6 :# #;""  #8< =#>  /

  6"6  ?@.,,/' 6#<=;!6$$$$$$$$$$/

(/      (1 "4  (,,.% 6#  606 2" <    > #  " % !6 $$$$$$$$$$  A  6 #" "  >6"6  B# # A#    #&#;/  C A"#   A#" #"   #  #"  #& 3 "#  #A#   "# #B 7 D E ,/-,+/(:%  A#;"E#-F 65-11(%##B #F%1  +* " #  #"& "& #"#-FA#-1117  /' E-,-:/ &#%# #B;6 8;6 &#%6"6   #6#   6 #8 6##  #A  +, 2#  -1FG B#  " #   >3 #"## 8"3"6 #8"#  "# #B/

   # 5###%6 &# "A"#B> 3" A   #"  ";66  A##"    #"D  #  #" &##8# ##&"# /

+/   -1  65 (,,.%  6     #&"6 B    #  ;<2;/

&  

-/   > #FH#*"#"6##  #A -(  65 -1F. 7  '  . -,:%  #5 6##  #&      6 #"C  # 3&#"%6"6  #6# 0   2## #"/ 6 #""# 0 "+,2"8 " #&# #""" #/

   >8%  6  " #  A"#  #  # "    3# #">0 # ; A#(12# (,,.%"B# "   >0   -1 2#  (,,.    3#  #6 % "#   + "4  (,,.%< "#/

  6 #" A5/

)+,-.)(,,. '+)*'

(/  ## B  6   "8 '606% #   % #  " #  #" & >#6"  3  "  ; #   6 #8  " I 2###" #" "/

   5 ; "  8A6  > 6"6    " #   > #FH # /E"0 "6 #6 % #B>#  #  #'606  # <  # "%   8 "3  "2< "##" 7&/" / )((.)(,,. -1A#(,,.  )-(-)(,,((G&A#(,,(:/

+/  E>;#    &#3 #"      #6# %  2## #" ## #" > 8 ; "A"# ># #"% B# >  #6#  B  ># # #">5# #7 ).H1)(,,+(+2# (,,+  )--*)(,,( (G&A#(,,(:/

  8;6 # #B6 %#>C>3 #" ##  #6   &#   "    # B# "65  6 #8  "#  "# #B/  #% > # (   8;6  &#3  63#66  >6"6  < ?@-,J,,,/'% A"# < ?@-.J,,,/'   "   #" ##"  #&&#  ##8/

 ># A #  #"&##8#"6  #">6"6 / "< ;"#> B##   6#  >"; # >#6   A   #"  ";66  #"    A##"% " B    3" #  A< #-2A#(,,*/  #8> &&# "  5#  6    6 / '# >3"   #  #"  6#8&&#66 "68 "B>#0 #"# #"  #5  /  #  #" &##8 > 2 ##5 >     # 8&#3 #">6"6 / 6"6;#  #   ## B  >65   2## #" < >#  #" > "#    2;6 " #   # 8/

 %  >8% >&&# A#  " 66  " # <  #  "6 #"" #/" &"A# " " #8""A; #"%B>#& 36#A"#B> B# / 8 "%  "" > 6"6  0  < ?@.,,/' "#  <  A#; #86  63#66  #&  ?@-,J,,,/'   <   #86  63#66 5" ?@-.J,,,/'  86"  =< " # #B">;  >5# #/ &#% #  >C  #   #6 &"%  6  #   B#5&#># 2##B/

*/  "B% 6 #"2 /E" %B#"65%  " &"#  "6 <  6"6  "    "

7 ).F()(,,.+,"4 (,,.:/

)+,-.)(,,. '*)*'

KKKKK

  &  &   

'($)*#!+

 A5  6 #"  (1 "4  (,,.  !6 $$$$$$$$$$ "  >0  #56##  #&-12# (,,.D

$)*,9

2 D

# BJ#J LJ6"6 D

"66#B    0  < !6 $$$$$$$$$$    !"# $$$$$$$$$$%"&#  #5&"#&"6 #"7/.11)(,,.:/

E#; 9 !6"AC%# %!/C=8%!6?#%!/ =#%!6"% 2;/

"6 #56##  #&9

;&&#8'2# 2/9  A#'# 9     !/ ""# /"AC  

"#"&"6 0  "66#B3 #/

 8A%  ;&&#89         

)+,-.)(,,.