Contract Interpretation as Matter of Law
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case involves a dispute over the validity of a contract or legal obligation where the lower court made a finding based on undisputed facts. The appellate court reasoned that where the facts are not in dispute, the interpretation and legal effect of those facts are questions of law for the court to decide, not issues of fact reserved for a jury or fact-finder; therefore, the lower court's conclusion, if based on an incorrect application or understanding of the law to those established facts, must be reversed.
Regesto Legislator
UfficialePOUVOIR D'APPRECIATION; OPPORTUNITE; RETROACTIVITE; CONSTRUCTION ET INSTALLATION; AMENAGEMENT DU TERRITOIRE; DROIT PUBLIC DES CONSTRUCTIONS; AUTORISATION DE CONSTRUIRE; ZONE AGRICOLE; CONFORMITE A LA ZONE; DEROGATION; EGALITE DE TRAITEMENT; PROPORTIONNALITE | Recours du DAEL contre l'octroi d'une autorisation pour la construction d'un abri pour chevaux en zone agricole. Construction non conforme à la zone agricole. L'administré n'exerçant aucune activité agricole et élevant des chevaux pour son seul loisir, l'implantation d'une telle installation en zone agricole n'est pas imposée par sa destination (confirmation de la jurisprudence). Par voie de conséquence, l'abri pour chevaux ne peut bénéficier d'une autorisation dérogatoire. | LAT.16; LAT.16a; LAT.22; LAT.24; LALAT.27; LPA.61 al.2
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive regarding the apportionment of court costs.
Testo completo
! " # ! $ %"
&%%& % &% &% & %
'()*+,-, !! "#"$##%&
'()*+'
*0 "# 0 10 #!# 2 &## # 334%0053#406 7(/(8$#00%9$ ,:,-*3;!%&3#<"0103###!0% 7 *=*= $# 00 9 $ +:+8/ 3; !% #! > ?##*@#$!!93!?3## (( A# *-8- B C 6 8..D (. # 9 ## # $!! 93!?3##,A#*-=8B C*/.D0
(0 9&## 7*=*=*=E(...%# ##!F"010&####E# G5&23 !#E2&2#!G9 ?3!# !92#!9H0E#%I &##% 3#*(3;=3;2&# # #G #&#;F#0
/0 (8E(...%! 393!?3%9!F# 3 ?3 B#' ;J D #$#! G "0 10 !## #33!#3 2!#E%!3##9E#3#! #!##2A0K%33###& 1L*:...0'#!!#$#?! !##3M3A0
,0 *.&3E(...%000 #!! #60 0B#' ;J 9 #D! !3$39###B-@-/-'
/D ; % 3 "010%F9!3##9 $#9EA90 A#3 #F#!3?9E#2# ## 7*=*= #2#3#G #&#;0# A!&#M!#$#!?!5E!0
+0 #3M3A%"010##! #!# !3##AF9#339##0 !#!F9# # 930 ## $&E3 FM #*8&3E(...0
@0 9##3% !&#!!F#0
0 ## #3# # ## F &# H 9##3 33 0000 !&# $&E% G #$$! ## 93!?3 ! 3 9#!#% 9?# 9 B#' ;J D0 # &! ##&J 7*=*=!#!$93% # A#$## 9 # & ?# 93 3
),(-)(../ '/)*+'
	!# #3 ! ##0 ##% A9!# $322#?&93!?3##0
E0 3 ## # "0 10 !! E#! = A&# (..*L#9 &#$$##B#' ;JL0 00DEA#9 !!&!0
80 *,A&#(..(% $! FM"010% $## !&# !$&E !3# 2 3#$ #&J 9E# 5&2 9! #! G #&#! ?# F! 9! ?#% A9!# $3G9$$#>?#0 %#&##G #$#F 3#$9?!3%F#3 #G# 9!#93#;#3 ! ##0
=0 0 "0 10 ; 33## 3#; #B#' ;J33##D=$!&#(..(0G9# !##G9#9##F#&#$#! 0 F ## 9# 9 ## !?# !# 3 #0 9#3 # 9 E# G 5&2 5 > G EN# !# #3 ! ###!M ! !9 #G A0
E0 9#(,E(..(% #33!3F# #033####$&E33 (+E(..(0
0 # 9## I !! F# #% & # !! #! - A&# (../0 # #! #0
#&F! &## ## ##! 9 ## 9# (, &## ## 9!?#! #30 # 3;?% #!# 92O# $# 9?#%&#!!#>?#B 23 3;?"#"3500G00003;?"3"0' 00 G 00D0 5?! #; !! &! G !% 33 5? 5#3;? 7*=,(0
3# G # F9# !# #$$## 9&#? #E2 5&2>#02##$# 3;? F 5&2 &# M !0 # ?3 &# !!F#$#!P#GQ 0 9#9# !!?!GA?0
0 *8 $!&# (../% 33## !## $# #;3 #2#"010!9#9### E# 5&2 7*=*=0
),(-)(../ ',)*+'
# A! &# 3#$ 9?!3% 3# #!##3 ! ##0 %9!#$##3;?> ?#!?#!3#F#EN#35> G EN# !# #3 ! ##0 !F% !## &## ## 9!?#!#3 ##!0
-0 ! !(.3(../% !## 33## ; #E3###$%#&F&## &# 9 !##&##9#(@#!( 0
*.0 "010 #!?#$#&F! !!33&33##0
0 # */ A&# (..,% ##! $# F !##(8E(...&## ## 9!?#!#3 ##!0 $$% 9#&#! ! 2 0 ##?# G $# 9!&? 5&2 #F! G # ## #3 2 ## 9 3;?%3<#!#!I $#&#&##!?3 9!&??5&2%# 9!F##0 9!# # # ##; F &# I! 9## # &% !# F !## 9##&# ##F ?#>?#0
69?##93;?G00%9##-@:.=8&# !! I! 3#$ F F! 2O# $# 9?# G # ## ##9#&#&#! #5&20 G9#####-89*,+'/%&#!!3! 3% 9#&#! !# ?#0 % 2 # % !&# &# 9?# &# !! ##$% F9&# !! "0100
*(0 $$! "0 10 A? !!?! G 9## ! / 3# (..,% # $# !! !J
0 "0 10 !# #!# F 5&2 2 5&2 0 9E# !# #3 3 ! E# !3E% 2#% 3 #E2F#;3 R #0&# E #33!# 6I3> F & E# # #3 ! G /. 3;90"010##F!F&##33&#! A F 9 !3## &# !! AF9G !###?0
E0 9H!6I3>%#3 #&#!!!#?! E!!$# 9 ## !?# G > ?#0 6 #2% ## F3#F#3 #EN#3
),(-)(../ '+)*+'
$#% 3 ! 9 9 # E2% 9 !# 3# !? $# $$# E& 9 3;? &0 "3 0 !# #!# #2% 3# 9!# !I; 92O# $# $3G>?#0
0 ## #3;?#! 7(@(=%$#/-,.3300B#! !## *. A# (...% -@:.=8D0 ! F9# 9?## 9 # ?# #&#!% F &# &##0 3 # 9 3#3K%9A#9?!3##FEN##!G9#&#! ?#G9#&#!!F%33E2035&#!!!#$#! 7..%$#/,/=3300%#G9#9 ##((A#(..*B-89*,+'/D0 9!#EN###3 E2! ! #2#!3#3!#F%3!2 0
0 "010##!9 G !#3;? ! 200
*/0 ;'&E! !!&I!2 #+ 3# (..,0 !! #&#! G $# E&# AF9 (. 3# (..,0
0 3#(..,%"0109 !GF#?!GA?& F##$#>?# ! 20 #&!G !0
E0 #*(3#(..,% #!!3##(. 3(../3##3;?! 200
*,0 &#! #EG!3# #;&!G ! % "0 10 ##F!% (( A# (..,% F 95##F # -*:=8@ 3# 9# &## ## 9!?#! #3 F9&# !$# 0 %#&#!3!F 3;? ! 2 0 9!# #!% #F F 3;?% #!! "3 0% 9!# !& ! ## #3##0 !## F ##?;9#!M E#3##$#G9?#'
F9#9?##9###!F2 #!G$# 33#0
!?3##!9##"3"00##F! 200
*+0 3#;#9###7-*:=8@% #E3###$!!!3#&0
),(-)(../ '@)*+'
0 #!## 7*=,(%*+@/==($#,8 33 00000 *--(% "3 "0 0 &# I! 3# $ 9## # & ?# 2 ## !F0 #3#$&#$!!## J!#93;?!# #3 #E & 9$$# ?# >% ## 9# 9 !?#9!# !#!9##!#G#?&3 # 2# B$0 $ 9## *@ !3E *--( %F#!#! 3&2 E#9!?#D0
E0 6! 20%33##&#$#3!*--/!?#! !##0 $$%&9!#3#!G9#&#!?#%$ 92 ## $# E 9$$?30 9?## E# #9### !#! '?#!#2#$# # & 0#%&###2!3'
#F# A!##&?##E #F9##GF#!#2#B$0!#'
# 33##% 0 ,'+D0 @ A&# *--,% ! 2 0 &# ; #E3###$0
0 !&!##I!#&!9####! *,A#*--,%&#!!I!H #E3###$0"3 "0 0 !# !I $#0 &#&# 9!&? ? 5&2%# F#&#!##?#9!&? #F!G# ##% 3# !?3 92 ## 9 3;?% 3 < # # # 9!F##0 9!&#A# #E $!! 3#; 9!&? ##$ 9#32 > ?# $# F9 #3 # G 9#!# 9 > G EN# ## &#?E A#$####!?#0 !##9##&# ##F ?#>?# B$0# #9 5?! ! 3&2 E#9!?#!3#33 0000D0
0 *--+%! 20&#! !39### & BE% $ID% !# B(( E2D !3# 9!# 2#0 9## &# !! ! &# *--@% 3?! 9&# !$&E ! 3 9?#0 6 #% "3 "0 0 92O# $# 9?#% #&#! &# M #!! 33 ##!$O ! !G9###&? A! 9!# $3 G 9$$# 0 !&#% ! 3 9?# !#$##F A &#M!#!3< 3#$##!?#3>!# !E3$$!%#!# 3;?9 &3323 B$0 !&#*.S*--+D0
0 &39###&#!!! !*--@0 &##9?#3& ! $##,,T !#'
),(-)(../ '8)*+'
A ###0 9!# 3#$ F &# $! 9## ##!/.A&#*--80
*@0 (,A#(..,% #E!#$3! #F !# ?!GA?0
%
*0 # F#! # !## *8 $!&# 33##%9#@.# ! 3###&*( 3E*-=+B ' +*.D0A!3 #& A### 3 !% &E B0 +@ # :?## A### (( &3E *-,* ' ' ( .+U 0 @/ 0 * #0 D0
(0 0 # :M ?# ## ; $3 B L*(.E/8-#0/E 0/=/U-*/@#0(E 0*/=M#!D0 F ?# :# (- #! ( ## $!! $!!##*=&#*---B 0$!0'6*.*D%#3 # :#!! :$$# & #% # #% :E# F:# # ! # G $$ & #% ## G :3### & # % G 3#% :2 #3 !%FG#$!##GB )=8-)(../ (!3E(../%#0(!$!#!D0
#$#3## &:3 M5 A? G :3### # & $$ ! G !## ## ! #;% ## :# F# # F '# #:3G3#$# ###$#G!E#! !AG # # B M #E $!! 0 8 E (../% (0(..)(../% #0 /0*U )*8()(.., ( 3 (..,U )/-)(..,*/A&#(..,#0(D0
E0 : ;%9##3!F#:##! 200% #!# 3;?09#!A###!##2! ## 9 G ! # P0Q0 3 9## 3#9!E# $# # !# 0 ##% #E3###$!G3 # !3###! "0100
/0 0 ;? F 33## &#! 9# @* #! ( 9 #! !##0 !! ? # & ! 3 !3 F# # &# E! &# 9 !##0
),(-)(../ '=)*+'
E0 #A# A# &#: !'
##G:3###:#!?#B L*-8@ 0*(,U0V % !# # 3###$% N L$'''"#% *--*% 7 *@.'*@-U 0 "% # 3###$% $3 ?!!2% 3 % *--,% 7 ,0*0/0/0% 0 /*-'/(,D0 #E! 9 !## 9 #3#! F 2; E B )+@.)(.., (( A# (..,U )+-)(.., (. A&# (..,U )@,@)*--8 (/ E *--8U 06 % #! # 3###$% 5N%*-=,% 0//('///U0V % 0#0 0/,'/@D0
F9 #! # #!% # $ F9 E!!$## 9#E!9 !##0 #;F#$###F 3 # G 93### 5#2 # #% F# ## !?3!?B0"% 0#0%7,0/0(0*% /8,'/8-D0
A### 3###& & K F &## #% I 3 # :2; :E &# : !## # #2 #3 ; $# #0 &5% 3 ! !#: #!!##F!%$2 # !& #B0@*0*( D0
9 ;% 33## ?# # & A##F 033###3!F#&#E! 	 !'
## #! F 9E# 9!# #3 ! ##% 3 3#$ 3F! ##F !3#F &# ## ##!9!?#!#30 $$%#!!F$#3M3 F # #3 G ? 3;? &# !! !#$#! > ?#!3#F#EN#35>GEN#!# #3 ! ##0 33## 9 ! 9 #!!## 3#E#E#$!#; ?##3#9#@*#!( 0
,0 0 9! $# 9! !#! ; /* S (...% & #E0
E0 69#*#!* % $!!#%33 &#G###3!0
9$$# ;? 3 9### !#3# >GEN#%>?#>G !?B0*, D0
0 >?#&G ?#E9 &##3 I G ? 3% G &? I? !3 G 9!F##E !?#FU 9 F#% &# M 3# F #E#E#0 >3 %9 %# F# M G 92 ## ?# G 95# #
),(-)(../ '-)*+'
!# G 93 #3 #$$! N5 !& G 9?# % 9 % # F#% 9#!M ?!!% #& M 2 #! 9?#B0*@0* D0
!# $3# 9 # 9 ## > ?# 3# G ## B0 (( 0 * D0 #; !#&! # # 9## $3 G 9$$# > B0 (( 0 ( #0 D0 > ?#% # $ F9 # $3 G 9$$# > ?#0 9 3% # M !# G 92 ##?#G95# #&#G!& 3 #B0*@#!*( D0
+0 0 !! 3#$#! &2 # (( #! *% (@% (8 G (8 !&#?(,3#(../0 & ## '!#&#!% : #F% 5?3 ;? #% # ## &#? !##:!$#F##M !#!A##F3F# !FA##FBM #E$!! =-).**-3(..(U L *(@ *@@ #0 ,E% *(/ */+ #0 (E% *(* *.. #0 * A# #!U 0 "% 0 #0% 0 *8=U 0 V % 0 #0% 0 @D0 $#% 3#; 9##% A# 3 F9 9E # ##!?%9#! #F3&#?A< 09 ###33!#&# ## A#$#! #!M E# ! !B0"% 0 #0% 0*8,'*8+U0 V % 0#0% 0 =U M #E $!! *0/+,)(..( /* E (..(% #0 +0(U L -E*88D0!#!93!?3##5!3## >?#A#$# ###33!#& # #0
E0 # F $# # !! & (, 3# (../% ! A?!# ##�
@0 0 69#*#!*#### #& *, &# *-== B ' + .+D% !& ## #####0
9##3!$##E#G5&23## ##!>?##*@*@ ##F #(.#& 0
E0 69#(.#!* %>?##!G92 ## ?#5#%F####& #!JF##!E3G#&#!2 '
92OG# ## %F# I?% F# ##$#2! #/,#&9 93!?3##(=A#(...B '68..0*D0
),(-)(../ '*.)*+'
0 :### M!#&!F:G##F'
##$3G>B0((0(#0 DF: #E!!$## :!?#B0(, U(8 .,#$3G > ?# F: !# G :2 ## ?# F9 & !& 3 # : #&#! $3 B0 *@ U 0 (. D0
6A# %9!&?5&2 #F!33#3 ##9 ; ?# BM #E $!! * 0(@)(../ (( &# (../% #0 / !$! #!U M #E $!! * 0(*.)(... *0,/@)(... * 3# (..*% #0 ,U L *(( *@. #0 /E 0 *@( A# #!D0 9 ;%#9 !F9E# 5&29 #$3G9$$#>?#0 A##?#2 M #! F &# !?# :# (, (8 ,
80 0 #; F 33## $# 3&# ### ## !#!9#9##!'
?# A##?#20
E0 !&# !?#3 !?# # % 33 F # A#$# F !?# ! :#&!#?& &##?0 %:#3 #9# 9 ## 5 > G EN# M #! F # #3 ! ## # #!M ! ! ' 3## $# :2 ##?# ##' :I B0(,0* U0(8 D%2##!3#& BM #E$!!* 0(@)(../((&#(../%#0+D0
6 A# % 9#3 # 9 # #3 ! ## # A#$#! 3#$ EA#$% 33 # 9 5#F% #! G 9!3# 9 # ! $#?# U 3#$ $## $$# 0 !E#3 $$# & & & #>GEN#% # ?!! E!!$##9!?# > ?#0 % !?# # M !&3 &#?!% G #2 #% ###F# M G3 3 > G EN#0 9#3 # > ?# # #'
##!G9!&?5&2%3;?% #F!G### '?# 9 #3 ! ## BM #E $!! * 0(@)(../((&#(../%#0+UM #E$!! E#!#W*--+ 0 *8= U M #E $!! * 0(*.)(... *0,/@)(... * 3# (..*% #0+!$!#!D0
),(-)(../ ')*+'
9 ;%9##3!9 ?#0 A## 9 E# F 5&2 % # #!# F# 5E#33! $#09# F#32 #! 2#&3 2 ## $3#0 % # #!! F #E $!! &# 3# F # 9 !#% & ? 5& >?#%!##3 ! ##%33F9 ! # 2 E# 92 #% G $# #& BM #E$!! E#!#W*--+ 0*8=D0 #E!;& F9 ;#$$;##! 9##3!0 $$% #E$!! 3#F9#3 #>?# I #!##3 ! ##< #!#5& !#?# F9!E#39!#!# !&2 ##?#0
0 & A# #E $!!% 9#3 # 9E###?#2>?#9 #3 ! ##0$#F ####!!#!$$# !3##9E###?#2#!#3M#3 !>?# ##0
33##!#!F9#3 #E2 !& 9##3!&# 3#$9?!3%3#F9!## #3 ! ##0
=0 0 6 % !## $ 9## !?# G 9##3! &# ## 9!?#!#30
E0 3#; !?#% & :3 # !?# 3 X X% ! 3 # : # &# : !##0 9#! !3# 9!?#<2!?9IE#?2 !3 #3 ##3% F !?# A#$# # ##;% F 33 ! 2 E ?!!2 #&# #% F933! 9#!M E#9#!M #&! ! !% F9 2#?! ## 9!?#! #3% M # G #!M E# B0 "% 0 #0% 7 ,0/0(0/0% 0 /8@'/8-U ),)(.., / $!&# (..,U L 8 *,@'*,8% #0 , 8 E */,% #0@D0
0 !##&# ## 9!?#!#3F9!E# ###A##FF#A#$# 3#$#E? ## $# G !?3 F9 3 $# ### F# 9#3 & #% 9'G'# F F# 3EE 9 #! 3#; ##F F F# #3EE 9 3#; #$$! B 0 % 0 " % "0 1 % # ## #% # $32% 3 % (...% 7 *.*,'
),(-)(../ '*()*+'
*./*% 0 ,-8'+.@U L */. *= #0 +0(U *(8 (++ #0 /EU *(@ +( #0/ED0
39###F##9##3! 9 3EEGF##G9#9### 353#F #!!"30B-89*,+'/D0 #E ! E&% 3;? 00% F9# I &# # ?# #&#!0 #% &# I! ## ##%F9##3!%9 ;%#!#3E!!$## !?#3!?#0##9#9#### 3M3 F ## G 3 # FM !?#0 ##% ##$#9#9##-89*,+'/#$$; 9 ;0
&# #E3 ## 2 ## $# ##$$!33 #F#A##F##&# ## 9!?#!#30
F#9##!F!E# #!!! 20% !! #! 3#$ F "# 0 !# !I 3!# !&# 5&2 $#30 339##3!9&!%9!&?5&2 ;?#B 0((A#*--/D0 9 F#%! 2 0%9#3 ##>?#!##3 ! ##0 #%##!F##?93;?% #F9 9I # !0 9##3! 9 !I # !;& 5&2 ##% 29#&#!?#0
&% &# &E3 !E# ### A##F 2$#?%&# ## 9!?#!#30
0 69##3!%3#$ 9#9##$; !#!0! 20&#&# ## 39!&?5&2% F #!#&!## #93;? > ?#% F# # G A# 0 A F #!#3;?009 ?##%3#&%F#!3 F9#!#$#$#!#!;?#9#&#!2! 0
F#3;?! 20% &##E3 #F9##2'#!#9!&5&2% #F"00!I% F# 3 F9#392?9#&#!U9# !!9#&#!!#06# 9!#3 !9##9!& 5&2 G # $#% 9## # #!?0 ## % # 9I 9!?#! #3 9#!?#!% !F #E ! # #?30
),(-)(../ '*/)*+'
69?# "3 0% 9?3 &! 9##3! 9 #3<9#&#!2! 9 ###'
E3#!G9#&#! $# #!#'#0!3## 9#3 # > ?# ## 9!&? 5&2 #3 ! ##%9#&#!?#$$#&32!E#'
$&% #!#0 9%2 ## ?#$$#&3#&#! #!!"300
-0 0 &33##%"010&!F &#&#! ## ##!0E#$!?#$!!3# 33##UF &#E!0
E0 ## ##! $# ## #9? #E! 9 !##0 ##% F # # G 9#! 5#2 #& 3% !# #! 92#? 9 !F# G $# 9#!M E# F# #� ## #3# 2# &# !#F%3#;F3IF9#3Y&! 9?#F9$#3E#%3# ##!# 93E #% I 3 # #!M 3 3##!0!3 #;?J9 #%!#! ##! # 0 ##% # !##% 9#! # 5##3I G#E&#!F# 9#3#?& 2#!M #&!0 $#%#3E?&#!$$ 35####9##3!!3 ! #& 9#!M E#B0"% 0#0%7+0(% 0,*@',(@D0
3#; #% ## 9 #F 2 # 3##'
#&F9#!#$#?G93##!F#&#!;?#%33 ###0 $$%# 3H5#2 9#! # 3 B3% !3## #D F9$#? 	 !##0
9 ;% "0 10 $ 9# # 9 E# 5&2>?#0 ## ##!9 #F 3#; # 3###&% 3# 3#; 9## !?#% 3M3 # !## !F ## !3###%#33###&0 9##3!9I 9 !3##% #E ! H !## 9? ##!0
33## 93 F !## &## ## ##!0
*.0 &F# !;%3#0&###9 !##33##*8$!&#(../%F9
),(-)(../ '*,)*+'
!#& 9## # 9E# 5&2% $#3 $ 9###$#!*,A&#(..( 0
!33 1L*:+..0'3#G5?9##3!0
& % #
/01+2*3
! &E #A! (. 3 (../ ! 3 :3!?3%:!F# 3?3!##33## 3#;#*8$!&#(../U
1'3
3U
!##33##3#;#*8 $!&#(../U
$#3!##! 393!?3%9!F# 3?3 *,A&#(..(%A39###E# 5&2U
3G5?9##3!!33 1L*9+..0'U
# F% $3!3 2 # -8 #& # $!! :?## A###% !M M !% &##3###$% A;#$##% & #E$!!U3!3# # ##F #% 3#$ 3I & #? 3#U # # M ! # 23 # 3# #E $!!% *... *,U ! M #; # %#&F!333I &%#&MA#G:&#U
33#F !M! 393!?3%9!F# 3 ?3%##F9G33##3#;# G"#'#"$##%&9##3!0
)45*' (3
"3 &I% !#% ""0 I5;% 65#% 5!#% A?% "0 % A? !0
),(-)(../ '*+)*+'
3 #E 3###$J
?$$#;'A#A0J &#' !#J "0 # 0&I
#$3M!!33#F!2 #0
;&% ?$$#;J
),(-)(../