Contractual Interpretation and Enforceability of Ambiguous Clauses
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case involves a dispute over the validity of various contractual or legal clauses or stipulations, with the court focusing on interpreting ambiguous language and determining the enforceability of specific terms based on the established facts and applicable legal principles. The court reasoned that because certain provisions were vague, unduly broad, or contradicted the clear intent evidenced elsewhere in the operative agreements or by established precedent, those specific provisions could not be enforced as written, leading to a decision that either upheld or modified the enforcement of the underlying rights and obligations.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contractual Interpretation and Enforceability of Ambiguous Clauses: The court reasoned that because certain provisions were vague, unduly broad, or contradicted the clear intent evidenced elsewhere in the operative agreements or by established precedent, those specific provisions could not be enforced as written, leading to a decision that either upheld or modified the enforcement of the underlying rights and obligations.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive regarding the allocation of costs.
Testo completo
!
"#$$$$$$$$$$$$$ !"#$%&$'$$( )$ &
%& & % & '''%&' (') *+
, ''-' (,' &$ &*$ +&)$&&,,
-./01-
'
05 657777777777778$-9:&$ && ; & $ < ,= 0>.?5 @& = $ &$ A& $& B *$ C,$D & $& & ( &$ B*$) B&= $BE, )F5
.5 .0,$0>>2%&$ B $,=E&$$ $ )&$9EGH$C5
B$$ $& I $* E$ &,, H$C $ < '$ 0>>>5
15 $& & + &)$& &,, 8$-9: ; $ 9* & B 0>>J% &$ , $& , $* :
0>>< 0>>2
$,= B-*$ 2??K30>K1<3 ?>.K10<B<10
&I 0K<34K444 0K04.B.44
)) $)& .3? .14
$ $ E E& &)$& 00= A E % + $$ :=;/$,= B &$ F5
?5 .2 &*,= 0>>J% *$ & $)$ G &$ =& + $&)$$ $*0>>J%L.,=0>>J% ,&I, $,&=&= 0>>< 0>>25
,& M&B0>>J$ G N#?>4K1>45-5
35 =& + $& &$ & B 0>>> ,& N#?>4K1>45- & $)$.<'*$0>>>5
<5 &$ .3 )*$ 0>>> $) G $9 + $&% & $== $)&, *$ $$& ) $9E &$($*$ $&B,=E$ 5A&$)) $& C$(F , )&, *$ & 0 '*$ 0>>>5 $,$ O &,$G & $*$ &$ )) $*, GH$C5 *$ ,&$&, N#0..K4445- &)$, $&&))$$5
/2.3/.44. -1/01-
25 .,0>>>%*$ &(&'$ & % &$ &I, $ ' $ G '(BG $ $& E$ &,,5&$ &'&$$ E$ &,, 9*0'*$0>>>% ,$ ($&$ $ $& &B+$0>>>%=&& $&0>>>*$ O E5
J5 10 , 0>>>% & $== & , $& G B& =&+ 0>>J 0>>> 9 &,,$$& , $&5
= %657777777 $ &$ &I,&$ $$$ E$ &,,5@&$9E $ $ G9*5 & $, + , , $&=&.<'*$0>>>%B)) $)& $ 022 0>>< 04. 0>>2% &$ ,&I 0?4 ,&I5 B,= E &$ *$ $ .0 ,$ 0>>2 ) $ $& $9E&$ GH$C5 ) & B,= & )$ & B% &$ & & $*$ &,,$% *$ = & B 0>>25 $ &=& &,,$*$ )GH$C0>,0>>J59 %$ =$ $ G9*(21&B& (B$)&, $($ 5 &II0>>J $ G N#2J0K2.J5-5
*$ & B+ & $*$ $$ G 9* 9 ($)$ $) ( ( $ $)5 $ ( )$ % CE, % ) $ $& B $*$ G&, *$ )) = 0>>>% $ &&,$( *$ *&$ B$$ $& )&,% -$ I & B ,& $)5 $$% B $ 104 $ ? &$ E & $= $& =$( > &*,= JJ2 8 - 1 43; B$($ % ) $9E B,= & $*$ &,,$ *$ O &$ &,, $&B $*$ &E*&$5
+&B0>>JB*$ G N#0.3K<>45-5 & ,=&, N# 1<?K2445-% &, $, )) N#?>4K1>45-5
& B 0>>>% + $ N# ?K?<45-5 & ,=&, N#002K3?45-%*,& * N#0..K4445-%&$ & &+&,,G,=& N#?J.K.?45-5
>5 $$& 04 , .444% &,,$$& , $& B $*=& ($ &$ =& 0>>J5 $-$ $ * )$$ $) B&, $ 14 '& )$+ &$5 @BE$ =& 0>>>%B' 5$(, $& $ $*% )$ G&$.3)*$0>>>%($&*$ O &$&,,*
/2.3/.44. -?/01-
, $&5 &$$ I 9, + $& $ ,$$5 B $ 104 $ ? *&I$ + $& * O $ ,$9 $,$ $* & & $== ($ , $ )$ G $*$ $$5%&$ B*$ ,$) , & $*$ &,$5)$ (&$ B&$ G9*(21 & )) B$)&, $( $ $E$)$$ (B *$ & G & , $ B & &,,$$ $& $)&, $(5
045 B& $$&%&$ & , $9 &,,$$& & & , $9 B$,P 8$-9: "; E, *& , $&5 % B $*$ , &$&I*$$)&, $($ & $ $ =$, = )$ ,% $ ,O, $*$ &$ 5,&Q $&B+&$ $& B =$, = $ &$ E*&$ *$ O % *$ G & ,&$ =)$$ + $& $ ,$$ * B $ 104 $1 %&CE, & B $*$ % O &,$G +& E&&)$&0348&$ *$;5
& G B $& =&+ 0>>J 0>>> G & $)$ $&&*+($ $ &, ) B $*$ GH$C%G &, 0> , 0>>J% $ * 0>>< 0>>2% &)&,, GB $104 $? 5
005 .J ,=.444*$ &&& G &)$, $&$$&&,,$$&, $&5 = % & $== *$ *$ G ,$ $ +$ $&5 .3 )*$ 0>>>% *$ $)&, *$ ( & $*$ *$ )GH$C5,&$ % , $&%$$($ ( 21 ,&I $ G 9* ,$ G =)$$ B $
104 $? 5* "%&$$ (B&$ B =$, = G 9* $*&($ % G $ =$$$% CE, & B $*$ , &Q ,$ &$ *$5@&$ %& $==,$ &'& $*&,$ *$ C,$5 $& .444%&$ *$ &G& &' $, G G9* *$ )&$GB &$ + $& = $ $&$ & 9* H$C5
0.5 .2'$.44.% " 9 $, ,$&5
5 *$ *$ & $)$=&0>>JG& $==02 ,=0>>J5 B (.3)*$0>>>(-$B*$ & %&$ =$ G $ $, $) 14 '&5 )& ,'
/2.3/.44. -3/01-
$=, 9)$$ $) &=$E &$$$& B*$ $*&(5=& $ &( )&GB+$ $& $, $&5BI*$ &=$,&$ $&& $GB $
141 9&( ) $9EGH$CB $ $ *& B0>>J5& $ ' &$ 5
=5 ) $9E&$ GH$C*$ $$ = '$ 0>>>, E$ &,, *$5&0>>> .444% =$ $ G 9* <J &=& B& B$)&, $( $ 5&$ *$ &G& &' $, G *$ + G $& = $ $& $ & + *$ ( $&5 * , % &$ B*$ ,$) , B$ E$ & $*$ G9* B0>>> &*$ & *&$B $104 $? 5
5 &$ B*$ ,& (B*$ CEB $*$ G9* B0>>> (B $ *&$ *$B$ E E&&)$&0345 + $& 0>>>*$ &O =$ ,&I, & $&$ $& B $104$. = 5B)) $)&*$ & )&$O ,.?.G0?45
015 10 '$ .44.% &$ & & 9 $=,$$ $)& $$&$ 5
5 *$ &*&$ =)$$ B $ 104 $ ? 9 ,0>>J%*$ B+& $*$ &,,$ & 9*% = B))$ I ) G H$C $$& B,=E.0,$0>>25 $& #0>>>,& $ (B&$ B =$, =G9*5@=$ $ )& $+ & $ $,,= $ G 9* ($ )$$ B&=' B + $& $$95@&= &$$$( )$$ $ & $*$ $$%(B $ &IG9*%&Q &$*$ $*$ &$%&$%&$ & $)&, $( ($ &*$ O ($)$ A=R &))$F% &&$ $& G A)& &))$F+GH$C5
@&'$%B$$ $&E$ &,,B&$ & $ $ (B &, $& )E= $ B $*$ $,&= & BE 5 *$ $)&, *$ ) $9E & &$ .3 )*$ 0>>> &, $& $ &,=5
=5 =&+ $ $E$+ E$ $ $& &= $,&$ $& $ $ B $ 141 5 $$% & *$ &=9,% =&+
/2.3/.44. -</01-
0>>J 0>>>*$ ,& $*, G&,, N#04JK0245- N#?K?<45-5
& GB $&$$& "%GB $& =&+ 0>>J 0>>>% GB =$, &*+=&+ &, ,&$)$ $&=90J,0>>JGB+$& C$))B))$,, $,&=E&005
0?5 &$3,=.44.%'EEG , *$ 5 , $9 % $$ B' $, $$& + $& )$ G&$ $&& B,$$ $&)$ &8$-9: # ;5%&$ B*$ &$ =& #0>>>%$-$I & 53&*,= .44?%*$ &$$ $B$ %B))$ & 9B # 5 $=,$$ $)$&& &I$ & )$ &=* $& & & + P &$ 5
035 *$ & 04 ,= .44?% & $$, G B$*=$$ , $& & + =&+ $ $E$+% =$$$, G&)$, $&$$& " (B$ $*=, $&& =& 0>>J% & )& + $&0>>>5&$$ E, B& &$B$,$ 5
& G B& =& 0>>J $ $*= & $&*&($ 5, $&)&,& 10,0>>>GB& + $&0>>>%& $)$.<'*$0>>>% $ E, $*C&$E14 '&5 &$.3 )*$ 0>>> &*$ 9 & O $,$ G , $&5 &$ B*$ B$',$, $&,,&$=( 5
)&& $9 + $&%B $*$ &I&$ $ ($ $*, $,& % $(B $*$ $)&, $( $$=G=&,CB*$,$$ $) (% $ $+ $*$ , &,,$& $==*$ ,$ G9*5&,=$,& &=& & ,& $ (B $*$ $ E, ( $ $*, $,& 5 &$ *$ $,, &I B $*$ & $& B *$C,$ &H$C% & &* =$, = G 9*5 &$ $& # 0>>>($*$ ,& (&$ &$ B =$, = G 9*% &$ *$ C& G & * B CE, & B $*$ 5
0<5 $& 2'*$.4435
/2.3/.44. -2/01-
&$ (B$I*$ )) $*, $ ) $*$ 9* G H$C G $ $$& 0>>25 ) B $ &$ $)) 9& $ ,0>>2'(BG)$ '*$0>>J5& B $*$ %G*&$&%$I*$ $E $) + ) & *$ 9* H$C5 +,$ $ $( &$ 5
AE*&$F*$ $)&, ) $9E (BG $B $ 8)$0>>2;& $ E$H$C &Q$ &*$ && E)L$5
B-*$% , $,& $ *$ $5 *$ )GH$C 0>>< 0>>J5
$= ,$$ $) & &$$ $& )L$ $ $9 * , &$% & $& &, &,, $% $$&, @ &$, & *, $0>>J5
025 $& $)&,0?'$.443( $ E G'E5
' &
05 ' , $ * '$$ $& &, % & *=8 53< &$K&E$ $&'$$$..&*,=0>?0- - .43D 5<150$ 5&$&,$$ $*0. ,=0>J3- - 304;5
5& 0>>J
.5 5 & $)$ $&=&+ 8 510451$ 5 &$E& $= $&=$(>&*,=JJ28 -143;5
=5 & & $== , $& ' + $& $14'&G&, $&=&+ & $)&$&8 510?50 . ;5
5 $, $& &)$+&$& $&$ $& $, $* &$ =$% $ & % $$% $= BO %&&E& $ (E$ 5 $($BE$ $$ )&& $$&&($ )&&=$E &$8 50< 5009C D /0>/.4430J'*$.443;5
/2.3/.44. -J/01-
5 )& ,' * 8 5 0< 5 0 .9, C ;5 @& )&,'%*, + &$$ $,*$$=($ *$ C&C9B $*$ ($B$,& G$B+ $ B)L&$$ $=8 /0>/.4430J'*$.443;5
5 $&,, G&$,$&,,$ $&& B*, ($C8 50250 ;5$%&($ '& $ ,$% $,C & '& E, )$% $ +$,$'& $8 50251 ;5
% , $& & =& 0>>J% & $)$ .2 &*,=0>>J L.,=0>>JB &(10,0>>>% &$ C& $5 & B )$ *&$ )& ,' ' $)$ & 5&( %=& )&5
&' &$ 5
5& 0>>>
15 5 @BE$ =& 0>>>% , $& $ E, $* $ =& & $)$ .< '*$ 0>>>5 % )$ )G&$.3)*$0>>>& , $&A, $&& 5 10? $*, 5 1<4F% ( & & $ 'G O &,$G 0>>>$& ) &$9EGH$C5&$- &.,0>>>%*$ , $9' & $& +$E 9E, =& & $&5 $$&04,.444%&,,$$&, $&( G&$ , $& 10 , 0>>> &,, &,, $ G )*$ 0>>>5
=5 $ $& $<1 $* %&$$ O )) $*, $,$G, $&5B$ ( $=,$$ $) +,$)&$ $E&($ =&5
?5 5 + ( &,, & 9* * *9&$ &I,($& &$9E & =$, =8 514050$ 5 ;5BE$ B*$ =$,P &B +&BCE),$$ $ $ B$,P C$))B))$8 /12./.443.?,$.443 )$ ;5
=5 +=&))$$ ($B$( C$)) ))$& $==%G&I&)$& GB)) $) &&8 514. ;5
&))$$ $=+&I GB)) $)&& ,O,& && $==%($B &&))$$
/2.3/.44. ->/01-
C$))))$($E&&)$&(& $== 8 5142 ;5
35 + $& =$: , B & ,&I+ (= 8 510450 ;5
$& + $&%&$ ( + $& )$ $& )$% &$ & ( B$,P M% &S$ % & ( $&%&$ & * =B$,P % 95 B$,&$ $& )$ & &,, & I 9, ,&8 5.0'$0>>? )$ ;5
<5 & $&*$ & B $ $& & $ $$ + $& ,& $$% E$ & B $104 5@&$19EBCI& C9CE, & I B $*$ $$( ( =$ &,, = B' $, %&$ &I 9,B$,&$ $&B9* 5
GB$?%$ $* :
A $&B $*$ % + $& $* :
5 & $== ($ , )$ G $*$ $* $$ & + &,, % = )$$ G B $ 104 $ 0% ,$ && $& , ($B& +D
=5 %)) & && $==*$ GB $140$0 %B$ $*$ B,O, $&&&$(($$* F5
25 $&$ $& $ $=,$$ $)5
, C& $ % C$ &$( &&E$(% $ EE *$ = & (B , $ & $== BO $,&% &I 9, + $&,&%(B&& $& , ($*$ +& $*$ $*$$5
B $ G*&$GB $104 $0 &G
8 0<& &=0>>0D .J'$0>J>;5
J5 %,O,$, )$G $*$ $*$$% &$ *$GB $140$0 %& ,, &$ &I,% ' $ G '(BG $ $& E$ &,,8" 0>J??./?><2;5
/2.3/.44. -04/01-
&&GB&=' $)B($ &$*$&$%B$ B$,P &$ O *% )$ BI E&= ( $*$ $ )) $*, &I$9*8 0<& &=0>>0D .J '$ 0>J>;% + $& B& % & I 9, & ,&% , ($, )& $&, B + $&5
>5 $=,$$ $)B&$&)$$(B$)$ A $*$ $* $$F5 BE$ B & ($ $) ( ( $ $)5 @ ($ $)% B $*$ $$ B&& G B $*$ &$ $E B $*$ ( & $== &$ ,' $))& &E& ,5@ ( $ $)% B $*$ $$ &Q & $== $ ,' $ & C$)) B))$5 + & $& &)& & % ,O,$&E$(*&$ (B&$I , $(, ,' $ &C$))B))$ ($ $*, $,& DC$)) B))$ $$ * , $$ & ,$ B $*$ $* ($ $*, $$ 8 .J '$ 0>J> )$ ;5
045 G +,$ $ &$ )) $*, & $*$ $* $$&B0>>J5
005 @BE$ B &$ & = $ & & $& B *$C,$% & C$))))$% $, % && $, B = % $ T $&= &, &,E$ , B $$-G $*&$&($-$% I $ $ &$E*&$& $ $E$5
0.5 $ $( B*& $& & ,$ & B$ &, $& & ,& ( &,= &=& & G 9* &$=, $,$ $ & ( B& ($)$ 0 '*$ 0>>2 10 ,= 0>>J )* H$C5 (&$ C$)) %&& $& G9,O,5
BE$ G & ,&$( B $*$ $$&$ %G*&$A* F%A*$-& $*F%A*$-$$*$F% A $ F5
@BE$ $ & % & B$ &)$, & $,& &B$&, $&&5
0'*$0>>2%022&=& J0 *$$ $$ , % &$ ?3U ,&I5 & 0>>J% 2
/2.3/.44. -00/01-
& 21 $ )) G % &$ ( >U5 *, GH$C&,O,$&%&,=B,&I *$ $ *$ E, <J G 04>5 10 '*$ 0>>>% 1 &=& <J *$$ G 9* $$+% & (B$ $ 04.($0??%&$ 24U%GH$C5
& && + +$ $& & $ ) $*$ 9**H$C%&B$&, $& &5
B$)&, $(G9*%$ G9 = ,& ,O,$&%& 0>>214U,$- BV*& (24U0>>J5
I I C9 & & ( $ ) B,= & )$ & B G H$C && G & & $*$ &,,$% E G 9* $*$ &$%&)&, $B& $)&, $(5
$= ,$$ $) $ $* &$ $)$ &(B $, ( ,$ $ $)&, $( $ &$ E*&$))$$ G,& B $*$ $*$$ &$ 5 )) %$-$ O &$&,,)$ $ B $*$ &Q& $==&$,' $))& I& E& ,%$(B$& $ &$ $&$(&G &$& GE $&& B5
$ $*, % $ T $&$ &$ ( =C $)&, $( B &,E$B ($ ,$ ,' $C$))B))$&$ %*&$B$ & & 5
015 B $*$ &$ $ &$ E*&$ 0>>> $, &$E, )&*$**H$C5*$ $ $)&, ) $ 9 = 0>>>5 B $ ,C 9 &$ & *$)$ *$ E $&% & G & ,&$ ($ &, $) ) B $*$ $$5$(B$BE$B + $&&$ % , ' $)$$ B= B$* $E $& ) &$( G A'$& F&,$ $ + $&$&B$$ $& & E$ &,,E*&$5BI$ ,& ( B$ $&'$ , $ $)$ 5
0?5 & & $, ,$5 $$& " &)$, ($ & =& 0>>J & ($ )9=& 0>>>5&$*&I*$ 5$
/2.3/.44. -0./01-
$ ,$+ , B$ B$,P )$BIE&= ( $*$ $ )) $*, &I $ 9* B + $& $ 5
035 B$$ $E%,&, N#1B4445-,$GCE $9*8 /?.1/.4430?'$.443;5
$,$ & G & 9 & (B B $&$&8 5J2 ;5
WWWWW
*%'& '
./012!3
*= & $ ' 10 '$ .44. 657777777 & $$&&,,$$& &&, $9K$,P .2'$.44.D
01243
B, $, D
$$& &,,$$& & & (B & =& + $& 0>>>D
&)$,&D
*&$ &$ G $ 9* & &* + $& &$ D
, GCE$9*,&, N#1B4445-D
$ (B$B &B$,$ D
&,,$( O G !" #$ &$ '$$( )$% , $ B657777777%$$(KG&,,$$& &&, $9K$,P G $9*%*$ +&)$&&,,5
@$E : ",&*I%$ %"5IC9%",N$%"5 C$%",&% 'E5
/2.3/.44. -01/01-
&, $=,$$ $):
E))$9-'$ '5: *$-$ : "5 &&$ 5&*I
&$&)&, O &,,$(+ $5
9*% E))$9:
/2.3/.44.