Contract Dispute Over Liquidated Damages Enforceability
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case involves a dispute over a contract that included liquidated damages clauses, with the court first addressing the enforceability of these clauses by examining the intent of the parties and the reasonableness of the stipulated amounts relative to the actual or probable harm caused by a breach. The court reasoned that the clauses would be enforced if they represented a genuine pre-estimate of damages, but would be struck down as an unenforceable penalty if they were grossly disproportionate to the loss, ultimately determining that certain specified amounts were penal given the lack of actual resulting damages or any reasonable basis for the specified sums, while upholding others that were deemed a reasonable attempt to compensate for anticipated losses.
Regesto Legislator
UfficialePROCÉDURE ADMINISTRATIVE; COMPÉTENCE; INTERPRÉTATION(SENS GÉNÉRAL) ; SUBVENTION | Examen de la recevabilité d'un recours contre une décision de subventionnement d'un établissement médico-social. L'exception prévue par l'article 53B ch.3 let a LOJ n'est pas remplie en l'espèce, la LEMS reconnaissant un droit aux subventions aux établissements d'utilité publique. Le calcul de la subvention a été jugé contraire aux termes de l'article 27 LEMS, l'un des critères prévu par cette disposition - l'intensité de l'encadrement médico-social - n'ayant pas été pris en compte. | LOJ.56B.ch.3.let.a ; LEMS.26 ; LEMS.27
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive section regarding the allocation of court costs.
Testo completo
!"
#$ %%
&' ( & ) '(
!"#$
#( )+,-./0+ ,12 3/%4+ !$$'56++)/7+88/+ +9 :890+ ,12 ;<35 '5 :8+ 87= 6 >5 .// , +// =8 9 :8 <( (95 /++ , 74+ )>,++ ?+ !$$' !$$@( + + 7++/ A?) !$$@ 6 :8!$$'(
74+ *+>/ /+ BC !)DD&)E$$( 5 ,=7 , 48 8 BC !#F)!$$( 5 !$ !# :? 8+( 74+ ,+ 6 ,5 , )/7+85 4/ !$$D , ;<5+F5#!G BC&@)#D#)&'!( (
/++ ++?+ ?) 4++ 74+ /+ ,+7 +?8*+)4++87+5,+48> ),+(/+,/+/?8+4,147., +(
!( F 8+ !$$'5 + ,7 8+++* ) ;< /,/ A+8 /8+ /++ % 4+ !$$' ,1 /,8 ++/ )8,+ 0+ ,1 2 < 3 8 ,/78?)+,+),+*,++,8? 74++/(
/++ /++ ) + A+ + ) :./ < /,8 )/8+ / 0+ ,1 2 <3/F$8!$$'5/6 ;<74+/,) 14( + ) 4+ ,// , 8 + 88 +8,+*++ 1. 74+8 4+*++1 ;<5+8,+?,.8+.+ + ++ /7+8( 74+8 ?+ +++8,./)1.8+8,,/ =+4( 74+ *+8 ;< + 7++/ 1 )>+ !$$' A?)!$$@6:8!$$'(!$$'5+/,+ ;< ,,+8 > 8 4/ !$$D ,=/ , H+18 6 *+ :? 8+( 4++ ?) *+ > ),+( ,+> ,+ + > + +:./( /7+8 + 88 ,+7++/ ) ,/+ ?+5,)>+)/>/+ /*+++(
"!%&#"!$$' F"#$
/+*+6,+74+.7!$$'7.//?+/+ +*/+)4+&G6!$$D(
/++4+6)+!%++4>/7+8 8/+ +>+,-./F7#@@%0 ;< % !$3 ?+ ,/4=+ ? 8 74+ *+>/ 8, 88 )++/ )8 8/+ +5 +1 ?+ /+ 7 >,+8,,/++(
+74+*+>/8+1+.+,?5 /++,8+,),, ;<8+*++ ++ + ,+?/ *+ ,7+? ?+ /+ + ++8++ ++7 /+ + 6 4+ +4 4+ !! 8 !$$E ,,+7 > ;< 0+ ,1 2 3 ,,4/ , + ) /87 !$$E( + < #! */4+!$$E++?+?/4/++48,/ +5 + ) )..+ 6 8 :. ?+ /+ ,, /++ 8+1 + ++ 4+5 , ?) + . ( )5 7.874+6>+*/+6+!$$D ,/+ ? 8,I:+ ,+ 8/+8 +> ?+ + I ,,+?/ *+ ,7+?5 ?+ /+ + 6 )..8,+, +) (
F( /++!&A+!$$'5 +) :.< A/ /8+(
/8+ /+ 47 /++ ) ++ 8 ++4+ 1 ,+ , )+/ ),15 */ +,7+?+4+,7A/58+*+) +7+.+)+E+/#+ ,/8+++4#!,87#@&D0 D#$3(
) ,+* /+ +/ 6 /8+( < * ).8+ /4,,/,) ;<,4+I(
)++/ )8 + )4+ , +, +1 ,+ 8, 8/: 74+8 ?+( ,+ )/4+. ;<5)/4++1*++8=) .+ ++/ 9,+*++ +*8+/ + +*+8+ ?+95 7/./ <( 8/:4+//++/!$$D,74+ ? *+ + , 74+8 ?+( + + 8, +1 8+/ 6 )+ !% ;<( 74+8 +4+ , + ,+4+ +/I ,7+/8++,7+(
"!%&#"!$$' E"#$
;< >+.+ ? ;< 6 ,+ :. ,++ ,5 + 87 ?+*++5 /8// *8/8>4++456/*5>8/?+4 4+. ;<(8J/?*++1/+ ,+,,/,) 5/,88,/4++8/? +,++ = ++ *++1 4+ I ,/ 6 + )+/ , ,,7+5 8+ ) )/+ , *88,+6 (
7+ / 74+ ,/+ 8+ !G K )>,++) ;<( /8++/+8++5) ;< +8)778+?+/,+ ,..8/ (
74+ )>,++ ;< )++4+ 7. ) 4+ 8,/ +( < )+ !D +/ # + +8+/ + *++1 #D /87!$$D0 C ###35+8+/+*++1=/ ,+5/+++,7+)/+47?)6 ++ 8 )++ /, =/ , + +) 547.( ++ /.874+)>,++,/4, ;<(
/++8++?),,++)+D'+/F + ).++ A+++ !! 487 #@E# 0 ! $D35 ,4+*+)7A)(
E( ,/ !% A+ !$$'5 ) ;< ,1 +7 8+++*/++/8+!&A+!$$',< ( ,/7 6 ? +7 ) ,+* 5 8,+ , ,+ + /4 + 8,//+L,++,8+6)+/++(
/+ 475 ;< + > /7+8 /+674+(
< *5 ) ;< ,+ .8 /A6 /4,,/ /8+,/+?,+74+!$$'6!$$@ !$$D , ? )8 8/+ + )/,? 4+ // ,+ 8,,+I?):=,:1J+4+?+ ,/+++4+75?+)/+6)/4+,/.6 )/4+)//),+,+6)+4/,8 4>/+0!D6F$G,3(
"!%&#"!$$' D"#$
<).+ 5 7. 8 74+ 6 > +*/+ 6 + !$$D ,/+ ? 8,I:+ ,+ 8/+8 +>5 ?+ /+ + 6 )..8 *8/, +) (
98++/9+8+++4?/,< ,+ = 7A+4 ++ 8/+ )/7+8 /+ 8I8 + > ,/4++ 7./+( 8,+ 4 ++ )8+++ .4+ )/+ , ,+75 + ,4 6 +8++*/?+)/+.1,+7,+(
+8++/,/++,/++48!G :. .//( 4:5 ,/+ &5%G *+ : + :.+@$G> +/:,,+64/8,+ K( /+/4+?7..++8++ +*(
D( ' ,87 !$$'5 < /,/ 74+( /+ 8+*8 +47( +5 /+ +7 4+ + I+8,+*+8,//+*(
( /++ +4 > 74+ ++ 8+ , >),,/++/46)8+++,4+,++? ,+/+>6+A+++()+D' +/ F ++ ,++ ?+ +/ )+ @@ :+*//).++A+++#'/87#@EF0C < #%F(##$3 ?+ ,/4=+ 8I8 8+* )+47++/ , + 8+++*(
;< +,+ ? ) ,4+ 74+ )>,++5 6 + ++( ) 8+ +7 ) ,,/+ ),,+/( ++ /+ /+ 8+ +( 74+4+8,7,++,*+8 ;< *++18(+,/++,8,++,+5 ?++/.8+7/),,/++) (
*+>+ +1 7A+* )+ !% ;< ,8+ +?8))/.+/+8++(
),+ ;< 4+ 88 , 7 8, )+ ++4+ =/ ?I > ,++ ) ;< , 74+ )>,++ / 6 )/7+8 + 8I8( )4+ A8+ //?++8+4+,,+8,4+),,/++5?+ + 8 , , ?+ + 6 ++
"!%&#"!$$' '"#$
8++8)>+ /+A6)+/8,/,+ 8+1)+,7+?(
C+85 M + *8 ++ ) 74+ 4++6+8,/,4+/.++*8+17./+ ?+,4+4+)A++?+(
7( <*5/++/+*86)+!% ;<,+?+1 )++/)88/+ +/+A,,+?/8+4 /. 8,( + + ,/++ +4 6 ,/+++/)/4++1?+=*+.+(
+ , )/+ , +8,/ > ;< , ) ( + ,8+6) ;<),8,++,*+ , > 7+ )8 4+75 *+ )/ / /+(
)>++ //8 ,8 : + ,7+ +88+17./+4+ +(
(
#( < )+ D' 5 +7 8+++* )+/ ,/+ ++8+18+++4()+D'++,/4+ J ) , 47( ).+ ,++ /++ ,74+5/+5.+5+8+/4. ,+ ,/++ + ,7+ >? + *1 , + 0(D':(F(3(
!( ).+)>8++,/,187, )>,++/.++*1+674+ )>,++> ;<(
F( C/4+.#A4+!$$'( /*++,++, ,,+7 8+1 /.++ *+> ,+,+ +8 ,,+7>+8+/>+*++14/,0(#( ! C3(
<*>,++,/+5++6 +*++10(D(F C3( ++?/.8? +,++ /. ?+ ++ 4 ,/ + / 4+.5 +4 I ,/ )++ # A4+ !$$& 0( FE ( ! C3(
"!%&#"!$$' %"#$
4+ /8+ + ;< M + > 74+5? +/:,,+6),,++ C5+? ;<+4I+//88++4 C5+ ?)+>,+)+D+/! C(
E( < A+, +5 /.++ *1 + + )8++++8,+/8+/+/ 4*)9;4:+*9?+>+7/),,/++( )+45 )+++ 8 9,9 ++? .// )>+ ) +7/ 09N4:+*93( /8+5 ++ 8 9,95 + 7+.,*+)+/6.+5,>8,?)/++4 ,/++?+,:+7)>+)+7/),,/++(0 C@@7E!# +(!7L (< 5 +/+8+++*5:-5#@&E5,(FF! /*/+/3(
D( ( )+ !' ;< *+> ++ , )7+ 74+ )>,++ , ;<( ) , 74+ )>,++ , ? )/7+8 /, > ++ /. +4 6 )++ )>,++ 0( 3L > ++ /. 74+8 0(73L>++,/,/.++.4+0(3(
7( ;< 88 , 7 /*++ ++ /+4 )++)>,+)+74+)+4+8 )>,++ ;<0(F( ;<3(
)++ , ;< ) =18 74+8 ;< 4+ 6 8, ,+ )+ ,7+? ++4+ ,++A./:+?:8++0; #@@%#D"!#@' !#@&3( ),?+5*+)6,-./++)+ ?+/ 6 ++ *++18 ,,75 + ) +7,+)/4+. ;<5,74+5 7*+8/7+80(D( ;<3(
:,+5++/9C+8,++,74+895 + ,/4+ ? /7+8 ?+ /, > ++ 74+8 /8// 6 )+ !$ +/ # 6 ;< )++/,7+?0(!$(! ;<3(
:. *++1 /7+8 )++/ ,7+? 4,,+>,+*/>,++,) 5 ,8+,74+0(#% ;<3(
/ ?+ ,/1 ?) /7+8 7//*+ ) ++)>,++/,>++74+8++ ?)> ++ ,/ , /.++ .4+ )++/
"!%&#"!$$' &"#$
,7+?(<74+8,)+,-./,8 ++8,,+:.++4++6)+,7+? /+( C ? ;< + +7/ ),,/++6)+/?6)+74+>/7+8 )++/,7+?(
/?5/7+8/7//*+)+6 74+)>,+)+D':+F),/+/ ),1(5,++A/8,+5470(D' L('F(#+( 3(
'( ?+8*+,< ,4+)>,+8 *++.47++/5+7/+8?)+ )=,+)=4/+< ,8,//+(
58./85< )/A6>,+8/*O/+/ ?+ ++.+ ?+ >8+/ + ,1( >,/ .8+ ++ ? )+,/+ ?)+ *+ +,++ /. ,+ , ,++18 )+ !% ;<5 /++ /8+ ? 74+ /,/ 4 +7 8+++*(
%( + ? 8 74+ / =/!$$D8++8+/)+,.),*8> >+. ,/ , ;<( )/4+ )/ / ) ,+ ,+ )+4/ ,8 4> /+ + , ,+ 8,(
( <).+74+577.8, ,// , )/7+85 + ) ++ 7. ) 14 74+ )>,++ 8 *+>/ 8, 87 , )+5 > ),+ )++/ )88/+ +0(!% ;<3(
7( )++/ )8 8/+ + 8/ 8= ) .+0 <3,8/8+++4+8+6,,6 :?/+(</++/5874+!$$D5 */88)/4+*+4.+8+///,+ +8+/)+>,*+>74+?+?+, I8+*+/?)*+)4++87+,/(
5 )++/ )8 8/+ + 4+ , 8 *+ 87 + > ),+ 8+ /.8 )/ /:?/+( //,+78+*+ 8,5 ?)+ ).+ 4> +4 ++ , ?+
"!%&#"!$$' @"#$
/+/A6) ;<(,,M?)++/)88/+ +,+8,/++,+?+,/8I /8+/,/!$$'6!$$@8++?8+?+//8/ !$$D(
( ).84/,)++8/5+/)7,/+++? 6 ,/+++/ )/4+ +15 + I ( ;< ,/4+?)/7+8886)8+++ *+,4+7//*++74+8().+8,7++/ ++? 88 ,+ *8 > >+. /.++ *// ) 8+ > ++4 )+/0(!$(#(+ ;<3( 8+4I/7+ 70)8+5(@(D) K 8 ,+ , :P,+> /7+88/+ +>) 8+ <&F!(#$E3(
)++,,+7+588*+/,8++8/5 ?74+5*+>/7)8)++/*+!$$D*O ++?,?64+5+8,+1,/4, )+ !% ;<5 ,+? ) +?8 4++ ) +1 087+,/3?+,88+*+874+56 )>+ ) +1 *+>/ +5 + )++/ )8 8/+ +(
4?+,/15*+>+74+5?,/4, /++ ++.+5 + > 8 8I8 )+ !% ;< ,+?)+,8,)++/)88/+ + 8+,8+*/A65?)++/+)>8+ .+*4/6)/++(
&( )+++.5/88 BC#)$$$( 8+6:. /,8 ++8/( +8+/ ,/ / 6 5 + )/ , ,// , 4 )/. , 4+ *+,++0(&% 3(
QQQQQ
"!%&#"!$$' #$"#$
'# (
*+,-" .
/ 47 +A/ !% A+ !$$' , +// =8 9 :8<( (9/++/,8++/)8,+!& A+!$$'L
,-.
)8L
4++/,8++/)8,+,4/++ +/L
8 6 :. /,8 ++/ )8,+ /88 BC#)$$$( L
+?)+),/)+8+/L
88+? ,/ I 6 +// =8 9 :8 <( (9 ++ ?) /,8++/)8,+(
<+/.2 ;(=:15,/+5;84=B+5;( :/+5;85 A.(
8 +78+++*2
.+1 A+2 ,/+2 (+ <+.+ C(=:1
,+*8I//88+?/>,+(
145 .+12
"!%&#"!$$'