Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATA/578/2005 • CJ GE ATA/578/2005 Generato dall'IA

Improper Electronic Service Vitiates Personal Jurisdiction

Numero d'incarto ATA/578/2005
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Accolto (Allowed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The decision addressed a dispute concerning whether certain business communications transmitted electronically constituted valid service of process under relevant statutes, where the underlying issue involved interpreting service requirements and whether electronic means met the required formality and jurisdictional basis for personal jurisdiction. The court reasoned that the electronic transmission method, in this context, failed to satisfy the statutory requirements for effective service, leading to a finding that service was improper and consequently that the court lacked personal jurisdiction over the party sought to be served, thus affirming the dismissal of the action against that party.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Improper Electronic Service Vitiates Personal Jurisdiction: The court reasoned that the electronic transmission method, in this context, failed to satisfy the statutory requirements for effective service, leading to a finding that service was improper and consequently that the court lacked personal jurisdiction over the party sought to be served, thus affirming the dismissal of the action against that party.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
notificazione valida incompetenza per materia scambio di atti giuridici per via elettronica competenza in materia di contratti conclusi dai consumatori abuso di impianti di telecomunicazioni relazioni personali

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This article regulates the allocation of costs, as cited in the final order regarding costs.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

        

        

 

      









 !""""""""""



#$  $ # $ %%%#$%& '( ))  %# 





   $ ))%%#$   $ 







      %#%   



   $  #%# $ % 



 !" #""$   %! &"%

%  

&'   #$ ( #""#) *( +,,,,,,,,,, -. /  *012  *0,,,,,,,,,,-(3002(0003/4.-0%546 0772  (50  30 80    9 #""&%'   00:3 (( 5 / ;1 *0 *,,,,,,,,,,) 84  *(,,,,,,,,,,) (0003 ;< ='  0  30)  077  00:3  80  35(  >9 ?@"'% -70: !&'A 92)  5  >9 !B"""'% -70: !&'? 92 00 :C 30 10C35= >9$B!!D'%-70:!&'D 92'

#'   0  ? E0 #""#)  077  (3 / C(000 80  -0%546 9 2  507003  80 04(  30 80 (03)  31   ((058000)50(805 35()5305308(

!'  383/((00C 9 )0775303)#? E0#""#)50:.05(0800;03'

  00)  80  35( .0 F 3  80 C 35(  $" G( 5 E  (H) 0   &!B#"" G( 5 ' C0(03  5 /   >9 !B"""'% .0 31( F 307 5 C '  /  30 530   70: !&'D)  .0F53/ >9AB"""'%'

   077 (0 / C 9  C0 30 507  5  030 C0 8004 :C0 0 = 5  *(,,,,,,,,,,(0003 :'

@'   I 3(7 #""#) C 9   0803 = 077  7  =09#""&( >9!#@'%)83.0(57 >9$&B"""'%).550074(53.5C0#&@03#0 833B0(5J8330&@3(7&DD"-9%KI@#'&&2'

  (0800(3)530530 70:!&'D)30(053/ >9AB"""'%'

$'  0773.33(05#@3(7#""#'

  KC10  C9) 0  3  (  5 C 9  5  50(C)0 >9!B&""'%):C0.000:3( >9!BI""'%'

!" #""$ %@ &"%

  31(3.)F35C 9 / >9$&B"#&'%) :3000:0 >9@?B@!&'%'

I'  #&L#""!)*',,,,,,,,,,0/C 9 '

    80(3 :  7%84 .0 .3 ;< 0   C3 #""&  :)  0%:0) 0%0 C.0 113 : >9 !B@@@'% 5  3 /'   (3 31( : 0 .  80 580) =50: :C0 .00 .  .3;0     4.'

    33 . : *' ,,,,,,,,,, 800 / C 9   E08008 08/80580'

A'   #? 7 #""!)  077  3 / C 9   8 C%(0*'*,,,,,,,,,,)530:0%03004( /;1'

  503((08005 08 = 50(C00:C=8035('

?'  300&&3(7#""!)C 9 E33(0'

D'   077  00  ((00     C0(5J 8330-0%546((002#E.0#""@'

  5035330)/.0:30 50(C053/ >9!B?""'%:8035( 0(08038(3(/10M5.0=0 C0 (03' 80) 0 C010   0 :0 .0 53 C 9  / 550(  (0%;1  8(0 :C .0 %(F( 553/C35:'

&"'  C 9 C3(03!"E0#""@'

   C30 5 370 :  7%84   7=%5  *',,,,,,,,,, 30 .307(  5 30    C0 #&! 9    3)  077 C.0 5 370 .0 883.(C(0 >9$BI""'%#""&'

  C0(03  .0  3:05  5 .0 33 3 5 C9 / ;(=0(((007'

   50( C%(0 .0 33 (0 /   ( (=0(( 53. 5 C0 #&# 9) 0 >9 !B&""'%'  30 30 (E3  >9 A""'% 5 ;: 8  5 ;: 5 30) (0  C54  ;1  8(0 C.0 33

!" #""$ %$ &"%

(0)   :  (  (0  30) 0 >9 !B&""'%)  5.05F1(3/ >9!B?""'%'

  =8035()C7E080085( 3(0  (7  E  C3 #""& 5 :  077.0L.0(7G0(4 5 ;: E / 0 580)  30  >9 #BD""'%) 5  50=  C7(  99) .0 33 3  077'

&&'  K?3(7#""@)((00E3'

   077 C.0 5 3(3 :C0 .0 80 / *'*,,,,,,,,,,) 5 : 0 000 C0 C ;1  8(0)  50C3./ >9$BI""'%C3#""&' =7=%5 (0003 :)077C.0805043(  03 80 3:0 5(  N   880.=%/050'077.050E08008 C.( >9@B@""'%883@.0#""#)505 C380#""&'

   50( C%(0  0 .0 33 30) 8(3(/C0#&#03&9)C.05/F1(3 C0#&!03&794:C;18(0 C30(0'

   = 80  35() 8 C000 530  077) C30 / 7 0 : C 9   .0 80=3)  5500  C0 #I 03 &   9   5 (( 383  50=  C7(133=04( 99'

&#'  *' ,,,,,,,,,,  00  07 (0008 C    3005303)5@E.0#""$'

  K 7%84 30 / C35: 50( /  ;1  0    C30 ) 5)  C0(507003 C=  0.03 880((0.05(7.0/70'KC0C30 5 30=) 0 ) 0 C (0 5 (0 :C0 30 1( 35'

   010 0 C0(03 5  5  >9 !B"""'% .0 33 50  (50(5J833=='

   30 5  00 C%(0  0 .0F53/ >9!B#""'%)5500C0#&#03&9'

!" #""$ %I &"%

  KC10   80  35() 0 .0 00:3 / C 9  :C0 50.0&!B#""G(5.55.3;0' ((0C30 50(03)0C.05/50E08008'

  80)C305500C 9 :C0.007=%5 30:03(0;1.((.35='

  000.=(0080'

&!'  35#83.0#""$)C 9 C5535 (083.5535((00'

&@'  50330(505D (#""$'

  *' ,,,,,,,,,,  =53 : C 9   0 .0 E(0 (3  E080088035('0308800  >9 #BD""'%)  0 5.0 5. :  80 8808 30 1( 530'

   ;1  8(0 .0 F 03  = .) 0   7=%5C5)08435C5'  5(0)( >9@B@""'%.0335H3#""#:0 30314' )0.0.3C3#""& 55('C.0550E08008.3035 0 5 C3 #""&'  .;) 0 .0 (0 :: E08008  50(C%(0(('

  C 9 )01(805*',,,,,,,,,,0800 5=00C0#&!9'

  *',,,,,,,,,,80(3:505::0   ;1  8(0 0. /  7%84) 00 :   80  35(5C3#""&'

&$'   #! ( #""$) *' ,,,,,,,,,,  50  E08008 5  80 113  #""& 5 C0   7%84 00 : = 08 /  8035('

&I'  .03/3(0)C 9 (05008 ;18(05*'*,,,,,,,,,,' 0%0C307(5  00 C 5 057 C=  0.03 0.'   005;18(05077C0 #&!03&79'

!" #""$ %A &"%

  KC108035()C 9 (0:880 >9#BD""'%C30555503/005004077'  533 /  .   80 8808 / 50   0   (00  077  C   (5H) 3 5303 :   .0 C88  = 35) (5   = (5H 0883C3#""&'K7C30 >9")I$5 G()80H08C3.0/ >9$B"#&'%5C3#""&'C 9  50080=07('

&A'  0$(0#""$)*',,,,,,,,,,835500' .=308=505/303'

  5030'

&?'  30:7 #""&31(3335  077'  53  (   .  ((00 (04C0(5J'

% $ 

&'  E3  (5 0 .  E000 (53)    .7-'$I 0B100E000##.(7&D@&% % #"$O'I!'&0'053(000.&# 5(7&D?$% % $&"2'

#'  &E.0#""#)3.0190:041/0 $!  0.  53 5 .  07 (0008' C0 ?I 9005:4153C550:4C3.01  53 0 =   5'  . 0500  5507   C54' C0 # 03 # 90 53.0 :     55075:90CH315'

!'  C7E   5   30 03 = 80 580 C 5)  /  30 0 C 5) 5  530 80 #""& C0(5J8330-92'

  = (  C0 #I 9)  80 580 :0 5. F 30   80  35( 30   (00   0  .0-'&'72-P2'

  K C03 #   0500)  80 580 (03 / C03 &)   / )  0(3 8800(O     C03 & )0775E0808053.3'

!" #""$ %? &"%

   0(0 00) C 9   (0 : C0(0 8800  50 5 /  303   C54'   533 /   8808  5 (( 5(4  0   (00  077  0   (5H     ;1(   0 0.    C3#""&'K7)C 9 (308035( 5( >9$B"#&'%5C3#""&'

  0(:.=8=)CC  (5H 3 0=)  (F( :  (7  G0(4 3 (000.0'

   07(00087.:0800505 .3080#""&37059,,,,,,,,,,K' ')041/ 4.)  (5  5300 C'  #& L #""!) *',,,,,,,,,,C113/805.0/C 9 E0800880 580)  :C0 C 5 80'   C0  (50 5D(#""$)33:C05.05.: 80880835(301(530 >9#BD""'% 5 C 9 '  C 5 .1 50  E08008 313)  7 / (041333(53705C 9 ')0%0 833530)070508G0(4: 5  0 35  (00   / 0   (5H 508'  CH   5 0  C 3   07 (0008   / C 9    0800   =0 53) 5  70: Q8035(R >9#BD""'%/ >9$B"#&'%'

  50((050'

@'  C0 !$ 9  5 7E  30 0' K C03 & 7)30. >9@B!""'%5;:5(  50( 057 C=  0.03 0.) / C0  :  077 5.0) / 00 :  0 01  (0  (30'-P2'

   504 50 5 C 9  370 :  C3 #""&) *',,,,,,,,,,=30.030. :C/0030(0/ C0(5J /  '  C0 :  00 5(04 5 (  3008038'

  E350'

$'    7 50( 10  )  3((  >9$""'%(0/;1-'?A 2' SSSSS

!" #""$ %D &"%

'#%$  %      

*+,!- .

3.70E3$E.0#""$5*0,,,,,,,,, 300((00(04B0(5J?3(7 #""@O

,.

C(50(O

  / C(000 80    11( / (  30  0  80  35(  >9 $B"#&'%  0  5   30 >9#BD""'%O

80(  300  ? 3(7 #""@   ((00     C0(5J833055O

(/;13(( >9$""'%O

0 :) 8(3( = 0 DA  0.   0 833 B100 E000)53F5F53)5.00(0008)   E 4  0800) 5 .  07 833O  (3(0  000:0)(08(H5.501 (0O00F30=(50(0 07 833) &"""  &@O  53 F   504  50  )0.:3(((H5.)0.FE0/B.0O

((0:53F/*0,,,,,,,,,,)/((00   C0(5J 833 0) / B(000 80   / C(000833070'

K0316 *(.H)530)*'H;4)*(>0)*' ;30)*() E1'





!" #""$ %&" &"%

( 07(00086

18804%E0E'6  .0%5306     *' 0 '.H   

508(F33((0:3=50'

 4.)  188046           

!" #""$