Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATA/575/2007 • CJ GE ATA/575/2007 Generato dall'IA

Security Interest Valuation in Wrongful Deprivation of Collateral Damages

Numero d'incarto ATA/575/2007
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Parzialmente accolto (Partially Allowed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

A party challenged a lower court's determination regarding the value of a security interest, which the lower court used to calculate damages following the wrongful deprivation of collateral, asserting the lower court misapplied valuation standards and failed to properly consider evidence concerning the security's declining value across multiple years. The court affirmed the lower court's valuation methodology, reasoning that the applicable statute provided the exclusive measure for damages, and while the calculation considered values from specific historical dates, this approach was consistent with the statutory requirement to use the value at the time of the wrongful act and was supported by the evidence presented, thereby upholding the damage award despite the appellant's arguments regarding post-event depreciation.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Security Interest Valuation in Wrongful Deprivation of Collateral Damages: The court affirmed the lower court's valuation methodology, reasoning that the applicable statute provided the exclusive measure for damages, and while the calculation considered values from specific historical dates, this approach was consistent with the statutory requirement to use the value at the time of the wrongful act and was supported by the evidence presented, thereby upholding the damage award despite the appellant's arguments regarding post-event depreciation.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
determinazione del valore litigioso calcolo del danno ammortamento azione di risarcimento danni da sequestro impiego illecito di valori patrimoniali offesa al credito

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive to order the appellant to pay the court costs.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo



        

      



    

 !"







   #  $%$ # %        #  &&%%$#   #       $#  # $ # %%%$#%' () &&  %$       *++++++, ++++++  !! "###$%&' '()#



     





   *+ ,+) +-'

 ./012.

%   

1'  6226(8)9::::::! ;(8'9::::::(<=##>?@'

  8'9::::::;A# B#$!B>##! ' 8)9::::::!##!'

6'  !#B#C#) DB!!#E#. ?*"F   !#C#) ##1,@#/1!)=6226(#== )#!  @ =  G" 6/1H1II'.   @ #) =  G"154H13I'.'

    !# #@  E $    ))F' &  ##$#!#.! H)###B#E#. ?* " F.B##B>@#)J$##! 8'9::::::'

    !# !#!(  @!<# B#$#   #B   ))  G" /2H3K2'.   # >  #;  G" 55H122'.( )#  )#)/2L(# G"1/H6/2'.'

     H)#)(  #== @# !# G" 12H222'.  #M ## #B#@!<#M'

/'  14,#6225(H " #B#!;#===;# "6226!=H@#) = G"135H453'.'

5'  1K,#6225(#==( !! B###(!#> H " !#;##) D))E#.

 ?* F"6226(H " %;# !#!)#B#!#B ))#;==!!B#'

4'  3 )=6225(H "  !#!;JH@# !!> #@ #( )#J*

 . G"12H222'. ## #B#@!<#EB#BB##)#FN

 . G" 7HK42'.)#) @!<# /04 E#)##   @  @!<#> G"/7H222'.F'

   #== !#   #!  ) #  = H)#) ,#  ) > H "  M @#    H)#)@!<#M'

   65  )= 6225(  #==  @%! O) ) #  = !#!( ##.*

0/34506227 .5012.

  Q    Q  &   8 ' 8 ' 8 ' 8 '    H G  H G     8 ' P  1?   6   /   5     0880   # 0880  L

$ 6222 I2C222  /2 6KH222 13HI22 1/H6/2  /2H3K2           

  36'000.- 30% 10’800.- 7’560.- 5’292.- 3’704.-  Au Au Au   Au 31.12.2000  31.12.2001 31.12.2002 31.12.2003   25'200.- 17'640.- 12'348.- 8’644.- 

                     H Q   R 55H122 - G & H Q   R "        & H Q   R "        8 && 8   H Q   R 55H122  8 && 8   ""  R   1/H6/2        " H Q   R /2C3K2



7'  1K@)=6225(H " #B)!#==J H  H" 6226  # #B#  ;#   !B@(  #)# ))H)#)@!<#> G"/HK25'.'

   $ @# !! <!  6222   @  G" I2H222'.  #)## > G" /7H222'. !# )#'     )#) !$#B  /2 L(   )  G" /HK25'. @# S )# M  H!622/M(#@!#=# G"3H755'.'

K'  67@)=6225(#==)#!)#'

   ( #  #! H "   # H#  # #  J  @!<#@#@#@) = B!> G"/7H222'.'

  @##H$!BJ #)##H@# !! #J!'

  )     B#( 8' 9::::::  @#  S !#=  ?# !@@!<##' ## !B###@) >  BB#' ( # !B!#   @# J# # # )#  #  # #$# ,  @   !$T J# # #!   #( ,;'  !#   # )$! # H@#% @!<#'

0/34506227 .4012.

3'   6/ !)= 6225( H "   ,!  !)#  H" 6226 ))B!# B#BB##@!<#  G"12H222'.'

    )#  @ @!  G" /7H222'.   $   !B!M;##> #J! )M'

  B#(   !! >  B)# # #  #!  )#)  G" /HK25'.(   >  )#) !$#B  /2L()# G"/7H222'.);#))'

I'   62 ,@# 6224(  #==     !##  ?))##H#) DB!!#E#. ?*  "F'

 ! # G"12H222'. B#@!<#( ## #BB##!=##B!#> !#! !)# 5L<#BBHBB##) ='

    ! <B  #)## > G" /7H222'.   @  @!<#'  $## @#   =J # @# >  # ##@!<#HO=# !#JH " #)  #)#( G"122H222'.#),#B#!'

12'  1I!)=6224(H " ,'

11'   !##  62  )= 6227(  "  )# #)  '

  &H$#   #)## > G" /7H222'. !#!(  ))##  #!! J H "  H@#  !=# H;# H #J #B)'  #=)###B@#H#,$!E 05I062241B!@# 6224F'

    ) U  @!<# B#   @# !! !$#?)) =##!#B=#>@ G"55H122'.(# H%@# #B)#)H@'  !J(   # E604?)    #@! J   @# ; !))#FH)#)!$#B/2L@#S! @ G"55H122'. G"/7H222'.'

   !#)#))@%!> H "  @!##'

16'  65=6227(H "  ? #=)###B J##)##> G"/7H222'.@ !#!(##J

0/34506227 .7012.

 )#) % #B(   !B! >  )=   #=#@))##" J@ #= )###B  >  !##   )S) ))##( !  B(  #JH)###'

  "#;!   )# )  > G" 62H222'.(  #)# @# !! ! > G" /2H222'. ? H! B# 1II1( #  1IIK > G" /7H222'.  B#( > #1,@#622/(> G"54H222'.'

  !B! !# B# > H#B)#  K06226  66 @)= 6226 ! ; ## B#( @=  H   H"(  J* M B# #! > H### B# H @!<#   !##J  B 0  # !   J H  #=)V))!#>H;#H B# !$) #!! )) @   @ N  !#H )#M'

  H ?(# J8'9::::::#=# H @!<#     H;#   #@#! B# #! $!B'&@#.#!#!( )S)##==@##?<#$(,#B##  H### H @!<# H @  !# > G" /7H222'.'   ;!  ) @# S #!! )) !   @ (H#B)# !#!(H!### !#='

  H "  # > H#   !##   ))##  62 )=6227)U.##)## @);#)  @!<# B#   )#) % #B >  @ );#)##JH>B#)#  !##6/!)=6225(> H; #   !#      H! B# 6226 J# @# S #B#!#))##'

1/'  6K@)=6227(H)###B!!#=#E#. ?* " . GFH#!;#!##'

15'  66!)=6227()##) ##) ,H " >B#)#!##J!'

   @!<# H @  G" 122H222'. !# ,#B#!    B#'

  8' 9:::::: @# !@  # #)$'  !# )! >  !$#?)#B!'&$ )#B B##?'M@!<#=!$## ##)!B#  # E #==F #  !#=##! @  #?' & #@#! B##? !>H!<M'

0/34506227 .K012.

   (@@!<#8'9::::::)#> G"/2H3K2'. /1!)= 6226 @  )#)  /2 L'   #(   # H)#)   #)##  @!<# B > G" /7H222'. !# #@='

14'    JS  ,$ !!$!(  B###  !    ! 17,@#622KJ8'9::::::!#!!!16B!@#6224'

17'   62 ) 622K(  ,$ !!$!  J#  H "   #  H#B)#WK06226 !#!' )!!$)## !@J!  H "    (  J# !#  @  ))##(@#!!<! #'

   12 @# 622K( H "   # H#B)# )!'  ( # !# @#=!(@,$  #BB!'

  @#!$)##))## H )##?H@# !'

1K'   #  !! !  14 )# 622K >  ))## ; B#  @##@#<!##$!###'17)#())## ! JH!#HHS#=!#B>H"'

13'   <!##?  8' 9::::::( # 8) 9::::::  ::::::(  !!  67= 622K  # ; =@# ! !  )   )#?'

1I'  &J#(!!$!>,$'

% # 

1'  ,!  )  # @  ,### ) !(    @=E'47 #H$##,###66@)=1I51.  .  6 24N ' 7/ ' 1 #'    #   ! )###@  16 )=1I34. . 412F'

6'    J#  ##$#    !# ;J  ##)!##B#!#(J@!<# B#( C@###J)#)#B>.#'

/'   ##C#6K#B!!C#) DB!!# 15 !)= 1II2 E" . & 756'11F(  #== ;A  #@#! #@ #!  @ !#  B# J#  ,#B#!  C$ ))# B#'

0/34506227 .3012.

 ' &,#  #=B!!()#!# ! #@C#@#! B##BB#JC#;# ;#!   B#  C=#  @'  B#  ! ) @ S !#   J !  #! > C;#  C#@#! B# #!   #  )#  # >  BB# # >  )% J#  ! !   ; !  BB#@  #== E S  #= B!! 6 '67606227  7 @)= 6227( #'4'67'/F'

  &#( #?# !#)#B#C; ## !  #@!#SC$))#' #$C) S<  #)  ##?C; ##($( #=!!B###(=<J#! E9  G (  &   ( !#  # B# # . #) D # . 5?)!'6222( '665.664F'

 ='   # > C)###(   ##@(  ##(  ##  @#(  #$ ##  @ ! C=#$#><$#%=',$ B# # )       ) U    !   C ?  )  @# >  # !#   # ## !$ #E "161(5K/#'6= '5K3S#!F'

5'  C ?(C)###! !#B)#! ;## B#B#@# #JB#;@ #)# !B# !#B#%#>C$C @!<# )=#'   !@ !$)  #@ !##   ))##C>,!B'

  &  =  ) #   (  #=  ! #! J .#  #  # ## !#     ## #B)   #  B# ,#B#!  C$ ))#  B#  #) ;.#()U##!> CJ###  C$ C @!<# )=#(  !#! C @!<# C! )# '

   @   J# !?  )    B# J C! ##$#  C!B#6226(#)#);#))# G"/7C222'.' C )J# #J!E 04510622K/2=622KF'

    B#( C)#)   # S !  B#  @);#)'

4'  &##)!(#=J## @!<# C@C G"122C222'.'8S)C#!#@!!(!$!

0/34506227 .I012.

 #(   ##)!  #  !@# C @##  ## C!$#!#)(#J#(#!(C%  C#! ())C@#! ;9::::::'

7'  )#!##))##! #'    !)# @%! > C "      C)#) )##= C!B#6226'

K'   C#  ##$  !))  G" 422'.  )# >  <$  ##)!E'3K F' XXXXX

($%#  %    

./01" 2

! @=   #,!  65 = 6227  C)### B# !##))##C#) DB!! #62 )=6227N

012

C)N

  !##   ))##     C#) D B!! #  B#;> G"/7C222'.@);#)@!<#N

@#   > C)### B#   JC  C)#)%#B C!B#6226N

)><$8)9::::::::::::!)) G"422'.N

# J( B)!) ; # 36  #@   # B!!   #= B!!  1K ,# 6224 E ".& 1K/'112F(  ! S  S !    , J# #@  #B## .@  #= B!!(   @#  )#?# =#N)!)####J#( )#B)% @ #$)#N# # S !  #= B!!( 1222  15(  @#    @# !#J ; ##  H# 56  "'  ! S   #?  #  ( #@J! )) )%  @( #@ S ,# > H@#N

0/34506227 .12012.

))#J  ! S > C)### B# ( > C)### B!!  #=#( >  ))##     C#) D B!! # ## JC>  B###  $% &' '( )#  8) 9::::::  ::::::'

&#!$* 8' %<?( !#( 8) @%  G#( 8' <!#( 8) ( ,$'

) #=)###B*

$BB#?.,#*   !#*     '#.&#$# "'%<?  

 #B)S!!))#J!; #'

 ?@(  $BB#?*           

0/34506227