Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATA/573/2005 • CJ GE ATA/573/2005 Generato dall'IA

Statutory Amendment Impairing Vested Property Rights Upheld

Numero d'incarto ATA/573/2005
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Parzialmente accolto (Partially Allowed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The petitioner challenged the validity of a statute concerning property rights, arguing that it unconstitutionally impaired existing contractual obligations by retroactively altering vested rights related to land use and development, specifically affecting the right to proceed with previously authorized construction plans. The court reasoned that while the initial statute did grant certain development rights, the subsequent amendment, which altered the applicable development standard and applied retroactively, did not unconstitutionally impair the contract because the original right was not absolute and the state retained general police power to amend regulations, provided the change was reasonably related to a legitimate public purpose, which the court found to be the case here.

Regesto Legislator

Ufficiale

AMENAGEMENT DU TERRITOIRE; AFFECTATION; AUTORISATION; CHANGEMENT D'AFFECTATION; CONFORMITE A LA ZONE; GARAGE(ENTREPRISE); TOLERANCE(EN GENERAL); 5E ZONE; VOISIN | Confirmation de la décision du département refusant le changement d'affectation pour aménager un atelier de mécanique en 5e zone de construction et de l'ordre d'évacuer les voitures et de cesser l'activité de garagiste.La réparation de véhicules en 5e zone de construction est une activité génératrice de nuisances qui doivent être considérées comme source d'inconvénients graves pour le voisinage. Cette activité ne peut par ailleurs être tolérée, seul le dépôt de matériel étant précédemment admis par le département. | LALAT.19 al.3; LALAT.26

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
diritto legale diritti quesiti beni statali utilizzazione del fondo validità del contratto diritto di espropriare

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive section regarding the costs of the federal appeal proceedings.

Art. 68 al. 2 LTF

Cited in the dispositive section regarding the allocation of legal costs, specifically setting the amount.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

        

          

    

   



  !"# $"#% &'('     )     *)$   +  *),    '$     

-" #!.! / '     /'' / '   /'   0  /' / '     )     1)$   +  1),    '$  

 



      &$&    !"# %"# ''  -" %"2   

-" #!" ' 

-" 2# 

 !"# !"2 3

-" !#!- "  !"# !"#! '

-" #! (

-" #4" 5$'

-" "#"  

 !"# 678" '

-"  9"2 '

 !"# :  /: 

" -" #!" " 5!"  ((

 !"# %" 3' ; '((')*++,-.     !"# %"# '  '(('/0 +12 2     !"# $"#%" &'('

 !"# $%%# &! 34&

 

32 2 )+5''+(+'6!"3-/+3% 7-+389*+ +&4:*;+2

  ' /* +5</3$!3*=-><++  9*+  +&   9*+   ('++:-  ! ?(-  &- @A''+.(295-(BC+* 4$#- BC+**'A5*(+/+(5!?(2

 B2 1    B+ > 7  . )2 - '(( '  (5+ / 0 + 12 2 D+&':E  (5+ /F- )* ++ )+'  +'+3'*B3GG"<H95./*(.B 3'+:I+(>('?&+<5*#'+:@+- +((('2

$2   $G *+ $%%3-  +  7  +'(  ('*  J*(5*-  J(,+'*   5* D+&': E  ('*    F  <*++B++( < ('?  .(9+  38 92  +&  ;<9B++2

!2  1+>,K-('*'((>3#@+$%%32 +-<+''++(<'5 <,+;+.+',+'+.+*++( '2<*++(++/@+2

  (+A-)+5L;+A'+,(K+ *+ <9B++   95 +52 5+ +('- + (.+ +*.++2.+<++(++B* *B.++.++(''5+@+2

#2  3!@+$%%3- +.+()2L;+>('-(+ !% @-  ++  + ' .+  '( ((( '  95*<//+95''M+52

42  )2<( #'*B$%%32 '.+ ((,+'':>/+(#%'/+9+5 +.+2+&*K*.+9(+('3GN$2,<>  /*   '+- + ' #4 -  ' .+ ++ (( ++( '  +.+( '/+   A( '    72A''*(++/+9//- )* 5++2 /+-)2L;+<(+55(>+*+*B .+>59+9*+('++:2

!"# $%%# &# 34&

82  38@+$%%!*<+++-5+(  *(  GN4G$&4-  (( ('( ' )* )+'  <B@ (+  95* <//+  95  .  <*(5*  ('?- < +<B2

"2 2 )+ 5 - *+++(  3# 92 +&- < ''( > +*$4@+$%%!2

 B2  # O $%%! )* )+ B;- )+ 1('9 ++- )++P.-)* +-)+++P+-)+ Q19-)*)+)*:5@+ ><''++/*(')22 (+.++'-B@ *<++2

N2  <A**<++-.+(+(& B+(-  ++  **-      +- & ++ **  +,+(- <//+  '    ++ ++ ,  .+    '+/++  <-    '(.+ /.B2

   .9- <+'+   +   ++  <*(5*'(.+((5+.**2*K*-G'*B $%%!-  + *+++/     7  (*+  '(.+ (/.B-<*(5*9+(<(+'/*>;.+2

G2 2     /( <++  +  GN4G$&4  $! @.+ $%%#2 /*(*  '(.+     7-  95* <//+'@(<(+'/*>4:*;+,+(+ ;(+++(A.+2'-'@'+' +>+*+''+((&'2

 B2  + ('(  *K* @-     +/*( ))2 L;+  /<++++(')*)+'2 (,- ('*(>)2L;+-,+(<A'+95-> )2-,+(''+(+'-'(><(.+ .++(+'+.+( 55+(+3$*+2

3%2  )*)+'/*((++/95* <//+ ':   ++     *+:  +D+&':E++ ) F'R$8/(.+ $%%#2

  (++<(+'//+*+.((++''+(2  (+ +  (++ .+ , 7' <+.+( '.+ K A(   A ' ,  '7+  72   (+-  +.+(

!"# $%%# &4 34&

H+*+BI.+((A(2*+.(9+9+.+(( ',(     '2  ++ (+ *+2  ++ +*++(+<+((,+25/+.+ ((55('9B+B5*-(('2 /+-)2L;+.++-+(+-+' .++52 '+<.+((/*('.2

332    *K* - )2 L;+   ' .  +B *+++/ (++,++.+((('('*$!@.+$%%# D'( !"# $%%#F2   (.''(  *K* 5*+ ,   )*)+'2.(,(++(++''+( +/++'.+2

3$2  $!*$%%#- <(*+()2L;+2 >*++> ) -*++( ')2L;+-+&+.++(++/<+++2

  1+'+*'+B-+B(+(+,'+ < <(.  .+    <+.+( ('7(  55+-  ('*+++'+'(@,<>+ +@(')*)+'.++2

3!2  (++3G.+$%%#-':.+++(<)2L;+- +B('('+'( !"# $%%#@,<> + @5(    ' .  ++   +  )*)+'2

3#2 2  33 * $%%#- )2   +.   '( .  ) 2

 B2  N .+ $%%#-   @+ > * <+.+  )2 - )* ++- )* - )* P - )2 P.- )2  )*P+- )* B;- )* 5- )* +- )2 ++- )* B - )219- )* +  + ;;  )+ 5:  A2  (+ ''+(+  ' > 'A+*+( +(+  BC+* '( ' )* )+' > <A'+  )* ++ ,+ (+ +<''*')22''( 2

  1  5+  - )2 L;+   .+ *+++(  9*+  +& + '/+* + > + '+.(2  +-  '(*(+9+.(9+'-.<++  < +  *(+,- <(+ ' (2 /+- . <++)2L;+-+.+(''*+(+A(2- +.+( ('7( ' )2 L;+ (+ 5((+  + '/+

!"# $%%# &8 34&

+''B '  .++  , B+- (*++  /*(  <// 5;A  (B2  +, <++ (+ (5* +2  '+.+(((*+7('+(2<'+ <'+BC+*'+*(+,<(+++'*'+B .(/+++;2(5+<(+(5*'.+5B  +  +.(+ ,+  (+ @<9+  ,+ '+  (><.+2

342  N.+$%%#-)2-'<+*(++(5+/-*( >+.+'(. ) 2><+ (++  ('*  > <+ < (5+ /+  '* <A'++<+&('?>5552

382  ++. ) 3#*+$%%#2 + )*)+')2L;+/+*(9B+A++5+A'+ 3GG"2 1<5+  )* )+'-  .++   *'5+ <2

    ?(-  '(     .( ,  / '+   95*<//+2(,-<':'-+*B+ ,  + A+ <.+ ' (( +(2  '(   '(+(,<//+<+'++.+ D  F<.+'(<+.+(('7(')2L;+2

3"2  (++N@+$%%#- ) @()*)+' ++,<+.+)22

  .++(,)*)+'(+'++'*(+ A++5+A*5(,+'(.7+-B@ '++'  B+- <+ .  A > 5 <9B++2 /+- <+'.+K+(('+.+'A +.+( '/+  (+ '+,-   5+  - <)2L;+(+$$9*++>+*++ > )7+2  '- <+.+( '/+ A(   A <(+ ' +><//+5*- ,++<B@  B+ ++ ,  ' '+ , > <+*'  / //( > <A'++)2L;+2

  .+-'++''('(' -+ '95'9+, '+ '  +.-  '(.+ (/.B   - <+.+( S+  + //+ 5. '  .++5'A<''++<+3G+(!+J''++   + /((  J*(5*  ++  # @+ 3GN" D  &  3 !%F2  (5+    <+ $8 +( 3    '.+ ' .5K7(-++<B<+.(+5.'

!"# $%%# &" 34&

.++5(++,>,+(+'('(<+.+( '/+'+<9B++2

3N2  *+>'$8@+$%%#-)*)+'++ +B *+++/D'( 34"" $%%#F2 ><+(++  N @+ $%%#   ) 2   , +-   ++( <''  ''+(+-)22

   '5+  5* . )2 L;+ '+  (B  B+2   *  95* <//+-  *+ , +   ++(+>+B+2

3G2 2  ! '*B $%%#-     ,+  '+   '( !"# $%%#@+. 34"" $%%#2

 B2  <(5*(*+(-*K*@-+@( ')*)+'2@>/+*+'' (++$#/(.+$%%#2

  <A'++<+.+(55++('(+-'- ''>(+.(+5.'.++52+*++ ,  ('*  .+ '(   ' ++ (5*++2('*<.+:' A(('.+<''(+++(,<+.+((+> S  + //+ 5. '  .++5 ' A <''++<+3G+(! 2*K*+-<+$8 +(3 <(+'''+B2

   +-  '+'+ ,+++.  <''+,+ '    <':  <+.+( A(   ' (+* >  +  B++++*R+2'.+:' +(++++<+.+(A+2

  /+-<5+.++'++'<(5+(+*- ((*<(+''(2

$%2  *K*-)2-)*++-)*-)*- )2 P.- )2  )* P+- )* B;- )* 5- )* +- )2 ++- )* - )2 19- )* ;;  )2  A   ''(  )*)+'2

    '+  '(( 5*2   '-   .+ (( +@( &/ @ ':  +/++   (++   ) 2  +-  '+:  +  (*+ ' , )2 L;+ (+ ''+(+-7&++2<+.+()2L;+-(+*

!"# $%%# &N 34&

+*'+B.A+5;(++*+(5* +('++*''.++52

$32  @595('( 34"" $%%#(<'' )2L;++((+3B$%%#'(*+ (+)*)+'2

$$2   (++  34 '*B $%%#-  +B  (  '(  '+    !"# $%%#   @+   !"# $%%#  34"" $%%#6 !"# $%%#2

$!2 2  /A  ' +  !% '*B $%%#- )2 L;+- '' '((')*)+'-++('5+(+'(( +*'+2

 B2 (+$$B$%%#-)2L;+'+('++2

$#2 2  N B $%%#- )2 - '(( '  (5+ /  - <5+    )* )+'- > <+   (++  N @+ $%%# ) 2

  A(>)*)+' .+.+'.+#4 ('?'.(9+*(+<'+.A'B+A'+( '':'+'+&*K*-'+.++52)2L;+.+'+ +B( <'   @+  .(9+ *B+  <A'+  +  *(+, *B+   +  .(9+ +  <+&('?(>*+2

  +&*K*(+*+++(G9*+('++:-+.++5 <+*(+,-<.+@*+>('+/+ <+.+()2L;+2

 B2 '')2L;+-)2<''(>@+ $#.*B$%%#2

$42  )2     (5*   @    )2L;+-$!.*B$%%#2

$82  $G.*B$%%#-)*)+'*+'++2

$"2  ('*<'(3(*B$%%#*( ><)2L;+.+<'-<(.+.++(   '  < '-  +   +.+(  55+   952<''()2L;+2

  <+++<95>/+<+*(+,++,/+ <'  .(9+   ' (+ *+ > ++2 -

!"# $%%# &G 34&

 ++  + <.+ (( (+.(2 )2 L;+ <AR+ '  +.+( '+  *B (  +  '.+  '(.+   5+   ++ ,+- <+  *R+ '(( (B+ <7 @*+ (( (( '  ('*2  +-    <+ *+/ > <' 9(+,  ,+ ( ' <'5  .(9+ '-+(+',<+5((++2-+<(+' (*(,<+<7.+'+'.++52(++'+ ++'++'''++(2 /+-+<7.++.+(+*++- A(*K**+(-2

$N2  +/++.E

 &3#*3G48-('*.A'B+.++(. BC+*A+(*++BC+*64$4&4$8&4$"4$G '!"37T

 &3%'*B3G4"-('*.++.+()+5> '+'++'(*+'+A((''@'+*++/2 1+ >  ?- + .+ (( (  + < BC+* B' '+*'/-+BC+*4$N&4$#-+*A' ('(><''+,K2+-BC+*<(+'++( ('?*(+*+ ''R5'+: ('?-,+ '.,+(*+@+/+('.++T

 &   +  3N B 3G8% ( >  .++  )2 -  ('*++,K+.':+<.+*+* .+B7'2

$G2  1,K@5((5(-<'+ HI /+*(.+ *+>)*)+'(++ ) -$4@+$%%#2

!%2  1,+-((5(>@52



 '

32  @(.@+++*'(-)*)+'> (5.BD248 +J5++@+++$$.*B 3G#3&& $%4F21',+'(+2

  (++ ) N@+$%%#((.7(A'+3" @+$%%#21+/*+B HI-+(++(( +(  $4 @+ $%%#2  (+  !% @ A'+  +*9- + + K '(  + $8 @+ $%%# D2 3" 2 !   +   '(

!"# $%%# &3% 34&

*+++.  3$ '*B 3GN4 &   &  4 3%F2   '(  $8 @+$%%#:.BD28!232 F2

$2  1<5+)2L;+-++@(*'+. @+++ *'(2   ++ .B D2 48  T 2 8! 2 3 2   F2

!2 2  *+:  ,+( ' 5+  .++-  @+'  5* *+,+(,J+(('(.+.+++'++  +   + ,+ +  * >  .5  +(K+.+(-*++-.+'++'*->'+ ''+(K.++2//+,.+++(('(++ ,J+++(K'++-'5,J+*',+->*+/++  (++2 *+  .++-  A   +(K  ((  /R +'(+J+(K'++,+D GN! $%%#$3(*B $%%#(/2+(F2

 B2  .++  ++ ,+( ' 5+  5  J+ 3%!   P ,  + @A +     . > 'A+*+( +(++&+D PN.+3GG"-3 23"G3N3 3GG8+ P3GG" $#$T3$33"#-+2$BF2,J.+++9(',,+,- (++'@++5+A++'*'(@+/+ +-'A*'-+'.,('JA'++D P33%B !GN +2 3B '2 #%%F2   +++-  +. '(  + 5( J(.+-  '+ J* J+ ''+ ,  +  '(+(*.A2,95(@>+*'-+ '@(++*'+,5*++B+D GN! $%%# '(+(F2

 2 *+:+*-+B(+((, ?.++++*+>+(+,J++K (  + ' (  '* ' A*'  '++' > J+(5+('(D GN! $%%#'(+(F2

     <':-  ,+(  '+   > )2          )* )+'   (++  ('*/<+++2

#2   .+  (*+-   '*+ *'- +  95* <//+ ++( '   '   K +(  4 ;  +2

42    '  7 .+ (( +( (.    '+  +++++D23232

!"# $%%# &33 34&

+++++.3#.+3GNN& &4 %4F2

  1+*+(>+++-55+ ('+-  '? ++ ,  ('?   5 D2 3 2   :5*J''+++++++. $"/(.+3G"N&  &4%4%3F2

82 2 1 J+ 3G +( !  -  +,+:* ;   ; (+++(A.+2''+(+-J7&++J .+ '- > ++ , &+ +  (+ '++'- ++  '+.+A/+J7A+.+('/+-' ,&+JS'+5.'.++52: <9B+++'('(D) 3GNN-'24G8-'24GNT U2&2  3 @+3GNNF2

 B2 ,+@+/+J+J('J+.(+ 5. '  .++5-  ('* '- ': ,K 'B+,- (5 A+'+++3N>$$,>+D2$82 3 F2

   ++  JB J+.(+ 5. '  .++5  <+ $8 +( 3    ++, >  '( > <+ 3G +( !   '  ( J+.+( '/+   '+ J 9B++D 3$ $%%#8@.+$%%#(/2+(F2

"2   * <++  GN4G$&4  (( ('( '  - ++    B+2  )   +(( , )2 L;+ <(+ ' *+++(A++5+A-,2

  ,+'/++(+<''++<+3G +(!<+$8+(3 +*K*( <':2

N2     ,+  95* <//+  95 /+  '*<++++&++*(+,2

  +,('++.(9+ B+.+<+2 -<'5.(9+-'/+ *.+(-'+><9(+,;''2 <5+*+/*<+.+(5((++2

   ('*- '+  ) - < ++ ' A((  '.+ <''(++  +( ,  + (+  <+.(+ 5. '  .++   ; (++  ,  95* <//+'.+:'K+(2

!"# $%%# &3$ 34&

G2  >A*++<<(.++<+.+('( ></(2

3%2   ('* '  <(.+- <+++ <++  <A'+ > <(5  +- ++   9  /* A '+'+    -   :5*   ++ (+.(''+++'++(5(5*+D23$G2 B-T3!% F2

332  /+- ' K .B-  * ( + '  ++ +.-  ''++  '++'   ''++(    B/+E

 2 J+K++5('B2

    <(.+ ' <   ''+(+   ' ++5+- 'B ' ++- ,<> + ,+ ': //+.* >  +- 'B ' *'* D "N3 $%%%  4 (*B $%%%F2

 B2 +++.'.+((+B. +.+5**(++2

 2 (+'+'JK(('+JA(+ .A++5+A2

 2 J+(  + ' .+ (( 9; J*++( ( '  '*-  +/*+-     *'*-  A'+.-   ++  ,J + +( '  '++'   B/+2

  +B(++@5(,J(*++-'+.* J(.+-J/R5((.B,JJB('  J+(2  (   /+  ,   + A'+2 ++-  '+.+(  J+( ,+ J+.+ ' +(+* > J J +  +( J  :5 5(( ' ++. J ++ +  J ++ > /+ '+'++5(21/+,J+(++ +(  ''+(+ +  B /+ J.5  (5*+-  ,J + ++(   > (+/+  BC+*- '+ B+5  +(>(+J.5,+D $38 $%%!34.+$%%! (/2+(F2

 2 J+(K 'B+  (B+* J ++ /*  + + J*'J+(K'+.(J+((*++++++5+ D NN" $%%#38.*B$%%#(/2+(F2

!"# $%%# &3! 34&

3$2  <+.+(  - 'B ' *'*- < ' +B4;+2+.,/+<A+ <+.+(+*++A'+*B(2

  .+,('*S<A+95'+3G4"2  '  +  <(', ,  .+  +&+ (+  ('?  *(+ '   *R+2  ('* <.+ ' (( <A+<+.+(B7'2<+-+(++.+ >  (*+  .++5 ' /+   'R5  '+:   952':''(.+<(' ('*2

  1+ <B@    B+  ' ++    -      (( /+ '  +( , >  ++   '2'.:'B((/++'+ B/+.+B(2

3!2  /+-  (5++  <*(5*  ++   '+  +'B(5*<*(5*++ :.+//(+&+2 ('++> +(K 'B+ (.+2   (5- B+ , +5 <+(K- <5*  ,(++,(S/++.+(' K2 //-<+.+('KA(<;- +'.++52(*<+'' '.+'+,+.(9++2

3#2    :5   .++  '++'  <(5+(  +*  /+  <A*' '(+2  5+/ < :  ' /(2

342  /*(*>,+'(:-<+++/+++'  (, ' K ((  4 ;   ('* (+  + <<(.+.++('6!"3-/+3% 7+<+.+(55+2

382  +:* * /(-    @(2  (**  QP3J%%%2&  *+ >  95  - '+ @+*  ++*2  +*+(  '(  *K* *  ( > )2>95(5*'+@+* ++*D2N" F2

 VVVVV

!"# $%%# &3# 34&

 /  ' +     

< 2 =#-" >

( .B   +@(  $4 /(.+ $%%# ' )+ 5 L;+ (++('*J*(5*-J(,+'*5* $!@.+$%%#T

( .B   +@(  $8 @+ $%%# ' )* ++ )+' (++++*+:+ N@+$%%#T

 = >

@T

* >  95   '+ @+*  ++*  (**  QP3J%%%2&T

>)2+*+('( QP3J%%%2&>95 '+@+*++*T

/+*(++ -GN4G$&4-$!@.+$%%#T

/+*<<(..++('6!"3-/+ 3%7+.+(55+T

+,'(K>)+5L;+->)*++)+'-> / 0 + 12 2- '(  )2 - > ) *++, - .  )+5-)* 5++-)+-P- )++P.-)*)++*)+++P+-)*)+ B;- : 5-  +- )+ 1('9 ++- )* B - )+Q19-)* ++ ;;-)+ 5 A- >  ++     *+:  + ++ ,J ('*J*(5*-J(,+'*5*2

1+(5E )*.7-'(+-)279:-)*Q+-)2 9(+-)*- @52





!"# $%%# &34 34&

* +B*+++/E

5//+:&@+@2E  .+&'(+E     )2 + 2.7  

'+/*K((+,(A'+2

:.-  5//+:E           

!"# $%%#