Contract Interpretation and Summary Judgment on Purchase Price Calculation
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA party challenged the trial court's decision to grant summary judgment in favor of the opposing party regarding an alleged breach of a contract for the sale of assets, asserting that genuine issues of material fact remained concerning the interpretation of a contractual provision governing the purchase price, which depended on the calculation of certain net assets. The court reasoned that the contract language regarding the net asset calculation was clear and unambiguous, establishing a definitive formula that led to the undisputed final purchase price, and thus, there was no factual dispute requiring a trial, affirming the summary judgment.
Regesto Legislator
UfficialeINTERNEMENT(DROIT PENAL); EXPERTISE; PLACEMENT PSYCHIATRIQUE; EXECUTION DES PEINES ET DES MESURES | Refus par le Conseil de surveillance psychiatrique d'ordonner une nouvelle expertise et de prononcer la levée de l'internement d'une personne condamnée pour viol. Confirmation de la décision. Le TA a considéré qu'une nouvelle expertise ne se justifiait pas au vu des rapports médicaux concordants et a jugé que le recourant, qui s'était toujours montré réfractaire à tout traitement, présentait encore un danger pour la sécurité du public. | CP.43 al.1 ch.4
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACosts are imposed on the appellant based on this provision.
Testo completo
!"#$ %%%%%%%%%% ! "#$%&
&
&' ( ( )( &( * +&, -(
'()'
(
*. *(/0*11-$!.!2222222222 &/ &3 " 4"+"&&%"&56//.*7/*118$ & "&9 &%&" "&" 9 & 3: & 3 ".!.!2222222222#/ 6" 3&09 3/35"&4%" " &" ". % $ " %" 94 &/ ;" <$ &%"& "&&/""$"&&&"/ "%%"&$""= & 3& 5 % /". 3 " 6" /= &/& / 5>"0" "&" .
(. ? &%/0 *11+$ & 3 " &/ !. !2222222222 4 ""="&& "%%"&% 0. " $ & @ && 3" / &/ " "& A " -? >"66 * " ( & " (* /0 *1?7 B C ; ?.,D. #/ && " / @>" "=. !.!2222222222 / " 4"& >/'&&.
;& 35 " &"E ! >F$ (* 9%" *11+$ !.!2222222222 " >&&#" #% %&/ &" C &0 0&" C % &G. " / /"&'@>" "=" &66 3 C/"&3"/"C# %&" 3" &// 3 "0. "& & / $ " &/&/ " #%/ " 0"=. " / /"" >&" " 3 " ""=. " ># @>& > "= )& &"& > "= & & 9& 0"/ " "" " " /" " # " %&& 35 ". " / 0"/ &" C " "" C &" % "6"%"/"#3 ".
?. *H%"*111$ & "&9 &%&" "&" 9 4 3& 3: &3 ". *?&I *111$ "06 9 &%&"" &&" 0"" 9 & 3: & "&. : *7 9%" (,,?$ & "& 9 / %""& & !. !2222222222 & 3: & 3 "?&%/0*11+.
-. ;& & @>&&#"= (? & &0 *11+$ 0" !. >"" 66$ @>&&#'@>& > 4 3 " "%" " /" #$ !.!2222222222 " "%" @>&&#"= %" /"4 >/'&&. " 3"/& &0//&"$& & // ="" " &>.%" %" "/305
)(+*)(,,- '?)'
3 6//$ '&. ;& !. 66$ !. !2222222222 ##" 43"% " " / 4&# /.
8. *- 6%" (,,,$ !. !2222222222 & " & 65 /&"## & ! >F. "'" " 3%&" & 4 = "$ &=3" "" %=36&".?/(,,,$" !"" J0" $-/"(,,,$ >/03 "&&6"/ / . *- /" (,,($ = 6 &%" &$ 6 3/ &%5. ""& &6"/ >/03 "& 89"(,,(.
H. " (* %" (,,,$ !. 66 "6&/ &" %" @>" "=B"'JK ;D=!.!2222222222 " "%""(& &0 *11+ """ /"J""# & > "=. >"%"" /" /4 &%"6&/ "& "%4 &//&". !. !2222222222 " %" "/ 3 "9 ". & " " " &" & 3" &"& >" L= . "%" > "= /" " " .
7. 35/ !. !2222222222 "= . ;" " C //0 ;C *+ /0 (,,,$ % = " &%" 3 " 3"/# & /& "&$%"&&5" $""=/&/ &M" %" "96//%&" 3& &/". !.!2222222222"" %&" "/"=5%"&&="%" &/ " %&" /"&4 & . " "%# &" .3@%" ""&4&3" .
+. ;&& @>&&#"=86%"(,,*!.66$0& & > "=3 " " %!.!2222222222. "'""" 6" 3 "/" %&" "9 / &/$ / !"" J 0"$ 35 $ %" "/ & @>&&#"= & " &# &" 4 &". 3& "& 3 " & 3" &"& >" L= " &% .
1. 5 / 3 & @>&&#"= !. 66 *? 9" (,,*$ &'
"# . . "%$ /" &" &0 @>" "$ !.!22222222223 "/" &%" "/3"9 " " " %&"9"""N"3" &#" &#"&3" "&4= "" 46"6.3& "&3" &3" &"& >" L= /" &% .
*,. &5/"&"=(- /0(,,*$;" "5"= = %"& 6" !. !2222222222 3%" "%# " 3 .
)(+*)(,,- '-)'
. *1 %" (,,($ !. 66 = "%" > "= !.!2222222222 " " &/ " 6" &%/0 (,,*. "'" 3 " && 4 "%" > "=$ /" " /" &9& & "&$ "&&="># > "=%" " "$&% /"4 " "&.
*(. +/"(,,($&6. .'O.P"#$/">6%"4"%""& /"" ""$ ;& @>&&#"=*1%"(,,(. !.!2222222222 " " 4 " 6" & = " %" &/ 3@ &" 4 " / . 6" 3 / "J " >#@>& > "=="%"" =&=&0J/"45" . 3&&" %>4"%"& &0J/5" " &66"4&" "&$&"$""=.
*?. && 35/*?&%/0(,,($. " $//0 ;$ & =& ""=$ && !. !2222222222 / " "=45 &35/ .
*-. *+ /0 (,,?$ !. !2222222222 &"" ; 3 &%5 "4&#." =: (+ /0"% .
*8. "(,& &0(,,?$!.!2222222222=" ;&& % / 3" / $ & = 0 / %" " .
*H. 3J & ; (? & &0 (,,?$ "& !.!2222222222 & "" 4 : " " &9 "%" . & " #&" N " 6" & " / $ " %"" 4 / 6" =" " " &>. !.!2222222222 " 3& 3 >"%& Q"&5N >"&"" &// 6#"$ " 6" 3" 3 >&" " "&. ;& &"& & $3%& "&" "&!.!2222222222/" 6"0N% / %" : 6N & &% 5 " %" 9 "6".
*7. ""& *( 9%" (,,-$ ; 6 3&& &% 5 " !. !2222222222 && % 4 3" / 3" / & .
3@ %" " 3&& &% 5 " J & = !.!2222222222 " >=5@>" /&" = &"&&&" .;& @>"=3 " /"&" 0 &" / C"" " 4"6" 6" " / %" 4 & &0/ "=. /" &9 "6 #&" 3%"
)(+*)(,,- '8)'
"/". " 4"=3"&// &%"6 "&$&% &R / "0&"4#43 .
*+. *( 6%" (,,-$ !. !2222222222 " 9 & J "0/"" "643& ""& ;BS )(+*)(,,-D. & 4 3 "& ""& ; *( 9%" (,,- 4 =3" &" &&&%5 ".
;3 " /& &09 "6& "#& "&G$" %" 4 & & #"6 =3" %" 6&/ & . ! >F$ &/:/= & &9"""3 " &&. ; %" & "#& " /" / "& 6" = & & " %&" %& &// #"& 3& 5. ; " I "&/ 3%"&6.P"#6" "66" "'" >"= ""=@ #"$" & "&& & 35 .& 6" %&"0 =35 "=3 " 6& ; " &". @%" &= "3&& &%.
*1. (1 6%" (,,-$ !. !2222222222$ #" &$ #/ & & "0 /"" "6 4 3& ""& ;. & 4%C% / 43"C&" / 3& " " "&" "&.
6" #"6 ;3%&"&4" "&0" "6" . 6" =& " " &/&@"#"6"" =3" " #&&" .6" /&"&& " " 6 &G= /" &" . " 0" " 6 % / 3" / % & 4 5 ". & 3 " J#6%$ ;3@ 0"= / !. !2222222222 9 "6"" & =3" 6I " . & 6" %&" =3" &/&/ " " 0"=. 06""" 3 & " @>&&#"= 6/". & &> ; 3%&" 0/ . ; %" && / "&& "& & 0 %". 6"$!.!2222222222"%&=&" &/ "&3"&N"35" " %66" 4&& .
(,. (/(,,-BS )-*8)(,,-D$& &0/ 4 3& & S )1,8,?)17 4 3" "& !. 66. " ""$"="3 "&""& ;*(9%"(,,-.
35 " ! >F & "" 5 5 " & $66 *177 *1+1$="%" & 5&"=& " / %" ".
)(+*)(,,- 'H)'
;&& $""& "%"&" ""3" " "& 30" ". " &#"= =3" 6L & " / & % &0J/3&5$ " / & 0 &" " 4&"# &0 / "4#"&= ;%&" "6"%&&//3&5. &&%#&" $ ;"&>" 6"%&"&" 9 "$ &/:/=& " & .
& =$ & & "$ &=3 " /& " 6 " 4 & " / /"$3" / %" : /" . ;$="%" & " >T& C=&"=6I " C " I$0&&#"=$&&%/.
(*. &*1/(,,-BS )(+*)(,,-D ?*/(,,- BS )-*8)(,,-D$ ;" ""&.
((. ?,/ *%"(,,-$ "0/"" "6"6&/ "= " #49#.
( '
*. . & *( (1 6%" " ( / (,,- & " 9 % 9"" "&&/ B .8H &"A&#" "&9"""(( &%/0 *1-* C C ( ,8 N . H? . * " . &" & /"" "%*( /0*1+8C C 8*,D.
0. ""& "/ "&5"&K""59& & &" & ""& 6 3&& 5 " " 9&&&"& 6 %3" / .
;& 9"$ ""& & 3&& " 3&& 5 " ""& "" . & =3 6 9""043" 3 "87" . $&3 &% & ""&B )?(H)*11H(1/"*11HD. 30 9" "0$ ""& "" &" : = % ""& 6"B : "06-.H)(,,,*H/(,,,N <1H(1(&". *.(18$. *17,8*?D.
3J$ !. !2222222222 = ""& & 6 3&& &% 5 "$ "" = 9 / % &" / " 9&BS )(+*)(,,-D.& *(6%"(,,- &= %0.
. 3" (16%"(,,-%>"%0& "% N"%/:/&(/(,,-BS )-*8)(,,-D.
)(+*)(,,- '7)'
. 3 "7,"* %&" =3 &" $3&66"&=: $ 9&"$ /:/ &$ 66" =" & 4 " "& " "=&49""=&//. 3J$ &= S )(+*)(,,- S )-*8)(,,- & & 5 & " 9 4 3& ""& ;*(9%"(,,-$& 9&" .
(. & 3 "$ && A" / & " "& A "-?>"66*"( . ; A &" &/ & // & / 6"4A" / && &""0 "&4A"B .*," . 0 &"A" "& & A &"6/ "J *-/*178C C -*,D.
;&/&H/"$& -@>" $BD"6"/"BJD @>" "$ /#" & " /#" &%&" 9"""$ ( %& $ ( %" &"5$ @>&&# & &6"& $ "" = ( /"'@>" &> #&" &B .*8.*&"#"/& " 366 "& / %" 0"/ @>" "=*9" *1+,C U*(8D. "0 /"" "6 A"/& " A#" = "& >"=&/"&=A &" " "/ &/&$&// AJ$ "" "& &/ =" B )((,)(,,? *8 %"(,,?N )--1)(,,?*,9"(,,?N )*(1()(,,,19%"(,,* 9"" D.
?. 3" / 3 "-?>"66*"( %"5 @ "= .3 $5=3& "#""&"# ="&/&/ #%/ " 0"= C / 9 "6" & " & #&" #" "/6.3 $"= ="& 0&" &" =" % : " /" & & " = " / " &// " #% "6 "& 3" " / 366 " /0 &"/ &>Q" &&>&".3#" 43 ="$/:/3"& " &&"#$"= &// #%"6 "& & // %"&43" "3 0"/ &6" 4 35 "B <*(*(17&".(0.?,*V *117*,* 6 9" " & "" D.
-. A &" &/ / 6"4/&="B .-? >. - D. &" 6 %&" "&" "& & 4 3 " -8 B!.P $ .-? "!. .$P.OW P $U&// $ ; 6# T0>$ .*C,; $$6$!X>$(,,?$.H7HS(*HD.
3 "-?>.- %""&" "/ &M3" #"$ & & ".&" > "=% #/ : &"&// && J$ "/ 0"" "& 3 & &$ /#/"0$&=& "& : 6" =3"
)(+*)(,,- '+)'
# &0J/ 3& "& B!. P $ &. " . . H+,'H+* S (?7D. 3 &" &/ &" / && " "= = 3" & &// . & "/ 4 =" % /&/ &&9#/ $#&" 3 ""/$& =3"@ " 3& % # "% 30 #&" $ & && %/B!.P $&." ..H+*S(-,D. " / && 0 3 " -? &" : % " & 0 C % "& &% "6 "&C " &"C3&/"@>"=C"B <*(( +&".?.*HD.
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
3J$ & &"" 3: 4 &% 5 ". #"6 =3"6&/43& 3 /"J5 "$"" = '" &"& =&=%.& " #/ =/3" / &" : %C4 & /&"43"C/& "6=3" &/&/ " 0"=."&" "&$!.!2222222222 06"" 3 "%" /" #" "66 @>" 3 @>&&#. 6"$;" "$ " $P"# !.66C5 "6" " ;C& 0"& & &"%" > "=&& / $(?6%"*11+$(*%" *+ /0(,,,$ 86%"$*? (-9" (,,*$""=*1%"$+/" *?&%/0(,,(.
)(+*)(,,- '1)'
;6&""&0& /"5& 3 / & ="$ &$ && . 39& 6" = !.!2222222222 5/"" ""C& 5" ;C &#"&N"& " # "=""& ; 0 3/ &09 "6. 3 &" "6" " &= 6& 4 ""& 6& "J &"& " 3 " "=36R 5 "& .
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
8. ;%="J$&9 .
/&/ Z$&6&// 49" / "JB )(1H)(,,-H%"(,,-D.
[[[[[
* &( ' .
(
/ 0 1!$2 3
)(+*)(,,- '*,)'
"%0 & " 9 (1 6%" (,,- ( / (,,- B S )-*8)(,,-D !&"!2222222222$ & ""& &" %"@>" "=*(9%"(,,-N
%0 & " 9 *( 6%" (,,- !&" !2222222222$ & ""&&"%"@>" "=*(9%"(,,-BS )(+*)(,,-DN
0 1!" 3
9 N
" =A"A ZA/&/ N
" =$ &6&// 5 " 17 "% &" 6 A&#" "& 9"""$ : : & $%&"&&" /"" "6$ 9&J& "6" "&$% "06N//&"& &" ""= &"&$ /& "6 /&@ % & "# & & & / "N " &" : &" 5/" /&" "0 6$ *,,, *-N : "J &"& & $"%&=&///&@%$&"% : 9&" 4A%&"N
&//"= : 4! "#$%& & ""=A&" %"@>" "=.
450" # 3
!/&%@$" $!.@>J$!.;>"$!/P"$9#$!. &&$9# .
&/ "0 /"" "6K
#66"J'9" 9.K %"'" K !. &&" .&%@ &"&6&/ : &//"=5 ". #66"JK
)(+*)(,,- ')'
J%$K
)(+*)(,,-