Breach of Service Contract and Damages Award
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court addressed a dispute involving an alleged breach of an agreement where one party was to perform certain services for the other, resulting in financial damages claimed by the complaining party. The central issue revolved around interpreting the terms of the contract, particularly concerning the scope of the required performance and the resulting compensation. The court reasoned that the language of the contract, when read in its entirety and in context with the parties' conduct, clearly defined the obligations and demonstrated that the party being sued had failed to fulfill the requisite performance standards, thereby justifying the award of damages to the aggrieved party for the established loss.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Breach of Service Contract and Damages Award: The central issue revolved around interpreting the terms of the contract, particularly concerning the scope of the required performance and the resulting compensation. The court reasoned that the language of the contract, when read in its entirety and in context with the parties' conduct, clearly defined the obligations and demonstrated that the party being sued had failed to fulfill the requisite performance standards, thereby justifying the award of damages to the aggrieved party for the established loss.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive to allocate court costs.
Testo completo
!"
#$ $%$# & !"#$%!&'()*$
$
$' $(( !+$ %)*$
))*")+),-""./-"!)!", #
))*"0/-).""./-"!.!1#%
))*" )+"!-."
))*"%1!.-2) 3 #
))*"%),1!-"#%
2-2 ))*"$/"!"./-"!!).$#
))*"-"4 3
))*"#"" $ 5$
./-"! .)- $ &$
./-"!".16$$
))*""#$
))*"7,8-"$ ! $%3%)*$
# # #$ $$ #$ 9$ $ # #
:6 $$ $ # #$ $ $ 3##5 $ $ ; # #
,-./0,-//1 2.,4.2
$
45 & 3%% %* -4 *% -//6) 7% 7% 75 5 8%2 9: ; $%% < $% %$ <%3% % %$ $&&% %$=14.>?% 3$%$&& $%@ 8%29: $&&; % ($ 3$*%% < % 40 %A$%<% %$$%3<&?& % $% 6B%40C>8 2 4./;)$% D&%33@5$B *% <% %$ < &E < D ./ &9 $&$ % <&%%$ %% F <% %$ D%F G $ %5 <&& * % $?*$% ""G$@%&% ?5
-5 %%$ -1 &% -//A) & $ %$ D$$?% <%3$& %$ 8%29: & ; $ $H < $% %$ &? *% ? %3 $&&5 $ *% %% $<% %$$ 3%& $% %3$$'* %$5
.5 ./ B% -//A) $&& $ 9 $&&%%$ $$& %9$ %$8%29:$&&%%$;$ < $% %$ %*) $ G $ %$ @ &$ %3 F D < % $ ?) F< &$ $% % %$ D$% &$'% *% *$ $% &%% 3% * %$ ? %*%*%5
65 $ 3$&4 B% -//A)!&$% !$%! $'% $$ 8%29:!5 !& $'% $$ ;$ %% $&&%%$$$G< %$< $% %$%*5$ $ $3$&% <% %$ * ($ F % I %3%) $ <@% %F % @ H$& $% G F < $% %$ *%$% < % 46 $% $ %$ % %$ %* 46 *% 40CC 8 2 A /A;) * $ F $&& *% %* *% 3*$' $B F *% *% $ $ %$ $ '% H$& $ %$% 8%29: 7; $ % $&%%$J $B % 3% $ % @ $&& %$& %9<&?& % $%5
A5 $. $K -//A) $ B @$) < $% %$$ $3$&G$%5
15 C &' -//A) $&&%%$) $&$ !$% !%D) % ) !& D$ !$% L') &&') %%$& %$$5
,-./0,-//1 26,4.2
>5 %%$ 1 *% -//1) $&&%%$) $&$ !5 !%D) % )!%L' 3)&&')B $)9*$% B$% @5
C5 -- B% -//1) $&& % B $ 9 %' &%% %3$ G< %$%%$$&&%%$5
7$ $% <I *% *%$ %% F $ $% G $&$% %$$ < $% $5
$% %$ $ < % -1 G <$ $% < $? %$ < % &% <95 <% D %F $ %$ %% F ? % @ H$& $ %$% % $ G $%$ %$*% ?**$%%?5
05 -6B% -//1) & 3% $'* %$5$ B $5
4/5 $ .4 B% -//1) $ G $3%& %$ < $% %$$ %-1&%-//A5
445 6$K -//1)$($ &%9$$ 3% $'* %$5$ G< %$%%$$&&%%$ 1*%-//1 < $% %$$ %5
4-5 46 &'-//1) %$ %3$&F % ? GB?5
$ #
45 B & % * B%% %$ $& ) $ $&&$%@ *'8 5A1 $%<$?% %$B%%% --$*&'406422 -/AJ 51.54% 5$%$ &%% %*4- &'40CA2 2 A4/;5
*D) $%$ $ !5 !& $'% $$ $ %*') %*) $% $ %% 8 5 1. 5 4 5 J ,>.,-//6 -/ B*% -//6J ,A./,400>- &'400>;5
-5 $ % %F$&$% %$$&&%%$)&&' %9< % &I& <%C&'-//A B?& 5 F$$% <I *%$3% D?& 5$&&%%$% K$*$F$*% $*$&$% %$5
,-./0,-//1 2A,4.2
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
'5 @ &< %./%4 ) $ $$ $% I B? $ B%%% $% G F $% $ * %' '%$%)$& )% %& %5$ %$% %$2$$ $% G< %AC 52$% G $&$% %$ $ < $% B%%% 8 " 4-> 4-C $%5 . 5 4./ J " 4-A 600 $%5 - 5 A/4 J " 44> 411 $%5 A 5 41C;5 < %./%4 5F<B?$% I &&' $ &$& B?& F $ F<% % %% G $ % * <33%$8 "44>4..$%54 54.AJ "01.-4$%5-5.-.;5&& B?)%% $& %'*? %$B%%%$< 5./ 5)$% %* % $%'%% <@ $% <I J%3 ?& F$% 9?$% $ <&%% %$ * 8 I %' 3 . *% -//. 45.A-,-//-$%5.;5
5 7$ < % 46. ) $&&%%$ $ $ & %9 $ %$$&@ %$ $%&&'5 %$* %?F$F<$ $& 5 DF %$ %B? %'&%9% J@ &&' % %$ D$%% D$<&%% %$57$ %?$ @B? F &&' 8 546.5- ;5
5 <$%$ < <% %$ $&& % $& %$ $) %$ % 3%? $92*') $ F<%
,-./0,-//1 21,4.2
% F% % 5 < && < B?) %2% %$ < $% $& ?E $92*'5 $% <I $ 5
<9) !% !%D) L' 3 %% F !& D$ $ $ &&' $&&%%$5 %%$ % $ '% % % $% $ & $&$5 $&&%%$ %$% $9 *' '% $ $& %$ $ C&'-//A$B?5MH*% 9$%M$$ $*$& %$$ %5
$F ?%3 %3$5
.5 $ $%9F$% %$$< %-1 G <$ $%<$? %$$ &%5
5 7$ < % -1 ) $F %$ B %3% <% < <%$*% ?*$*$%%?) & $? @%$% %$ %4C 40F G $ %$5
'5 $ %$ %$ %%9 < % -1 % 4 $ B%%F % &% % % % G < $% &%% %*5!%$? %$ I %$)%3 &%9 '% % 87 40C> .0>2.0CJ ,.>>,-//- -A B% -//- J ,-AA,400>--*%400>$%5>' 3% 5;5 $F%%$$% %$%$ '%$ %$%%' * 9? $% <F% 3$ & $* % $ ?%? 3 %%3 8 ,A4,-//1 .4 B*%-//1J ,.>>,-//--AB%-//-J ,6.0,4001->$K 4001;5
5 7<?% $% $)$%* @&%* %%$ F <&%% %$ $ $ 3 $? %$5 <% * %$ $% $ < &%%' F $N & < %?%$% %$$3$$'B %*& ) ?9 ' * $% $ $ % %$ * 8 5 $$ .4$K 40CC B%% ;5 $% $$ $ 3$% $ O%% %$@ %$) G P $? %$) % $ $ 8 ,A4,-//1 .4 B*% -//1J ,.>>,-//--AB%-//-$%5>;5
5 $3$&& @ %% %2) B? $% *%3% % <&%% %$ < ' $ $*$% <% %$5 ) %%$$ %$% &B5)%%%&$ % I &%% $ $ &8 ,A4,-//1.4 B*% -//1J 5 ) % I * B?
,-./0,-//1 2>,4.2
&%% %3 % ?$' % I ) $% <*%$& <&?& % $%)4001)54C0 )$ && 40-,40.;5
5 <% %$ %$ B %3% $? %$) % $*% $% %$ 9$<*$ %$<F %)? % %$ $B F%) I %&&% & $& %' * $& ($)*9 &%%'$& %$ 8 ,A4,-//1 .4B*%-//1;5
35 7$ < % 40 % A ) ($ 3$*%% % @ % %$) *$% D&% 3) ? %*% % G <@$% %$ 3$*%%5 $ %$ 'E %& <% %$ F% $ % G <@$% %$3$*%%)$ && @% *$%D&% 3) '$$G<$ %$'<$%F % < %.$%<@ %$*$%$&&% %$ <&?& F %$$% )0&40-08 @ 246/;5 DH$ D9) $ % $& ?%& ($ %&% $D %&9 $% F %) % ) $ 3$%) $& $ %$ F<% *$% G<% %$< $&F%'G.($5
?5 ) % %$ D$% &$'% 9* <%3 ) &I& % F<&E <%?)F< 3$& %F)$% $ 3%) 5 $&%%')<?% % %$) <%&$ F($$ %')$?& ($3$*%%5
8 I %'34 5-C/,-//6->$ $'-//A)$%5.5>545;
<9)$B % %?%@$ $ %$)($3$*%%) < % %$ $ D$% &$'%5 -1 *% -//A) $&&%%$ <D% $ *% $% %3 @ &$ %3 F<% @% '$ <% %$3$*%% %'*$% H<$*?5 $ &D $ $* < && F % % %?%@ <$ '$ %5$F ) & *'& $ $H$? %$G <% %$ D$%&$'%F%$G<% I '%< '% $&&% %$F 5
65 $ G &% % <$ $% $? %$ $ G $%$*$%%?%$*% ?*< %-1%4 5
$ %*$F &% % ?& D %F % G D ?'% $%5
5 7$< %-1%4 )$ %$$%* ?'% %&% %?& %?* %3#$ D 3%%G< %->5D %?* %?'%
,-./0,-//1 2C,4.2
-4 &J $ 3$% * %$% %$ %4/ 44 $%F % @ $%?($*$& -0B%40A>8L2 4.AJ 5->5. ;5
'5 %' 3 $%9 F< D$% &$'% $&$ $% &E < F% $ %$ % 5 $F) $% $& $ %$ $&& D ?'% <%&&' 8 I %' 3 4 54C,-//6 4A &-//A)$%5154;5
<9) % -1 -> <%F G <% %$ % %?%5 < <H % %F < $ %$ % )D &@%&<?'% $5
A5 $ * %< %4A%4 - 5
5 @ &< %4A$%$ %$ % %$ %* 46 *% 40CC 8 2 A /A;) & % % $ < $% F $ * &$%3% %$) $ $ %$ F%) %&%$)% %$$$ @ %)%% 9$G<% I F %) < $ < D&%) < % $ $% * %''%854;5%%$ & 3$$ && *% $&&%%$ <D% $) $ $'B F% $ $ $ )%$&&%%$&$& % 5 % $& ?& ) D ) @ &% $&& $ *%$& & 85-;5
'5 %$% %$?3&M D %F)F%$ % $ %$ B%%F % &%) % % $*$% M% %$ G M&%% %$) 2% M %&% F M@9 $ M' $*$% M% %$8 ,A0,-//6-/B*%-//6J ,161,400>-.$ $' 400> J 5 7 ) % $% &%% %3) DE ) 40C6) 5 ..-2... J 5Q ) % $% &%% %3) E "3$ 222!%) 4004) 5.62.1) = 41/2410;5 H 9& ) *% $ *% $&&) & $?%& % <$ F< 9 $ %3) 3 %$% %$ $ % @ $%5 $F< *% $'%? $%) % $*% &%%&% 8 ,A4,-//1 .4 B*% -//1J ,-A.,400>--*%400>;5
5 DF 3$% F < $% &%% %* % *% $&&%%$ $ %*)< $% $$% <%&$ % )3$ %$ $ % G D % %? 8 ,4-0,-//. 44 & -//. J 5 ) % I * B? &%% %3 % 5 5! ) ?$' % I ) $% M*%$&
,-./0,-//1 20,4.2
&?& % $%) E "3$ 222!%) 4001) 5 -/4;5 $% $%&% G@&%% & < &$ %3 $ K& '% *% < $% D%F $ %*)$&$%% 'M& B?& $* 'B %*%& $% %$ ?9@' $ %$3%@ $%8 ,161,400>-.$ $'400>;57M?% $&&%%$$ & %9 $ %$) 2% $&$ $ H $& % & %9 $ %$) M'%& MDH?%9 '%F 8 5 46. 5 4 6 ;5 "$& $ % %% ) $&&%%$ %% @ $ O D%F F %' &%% %38 ,A4,-//1.4B*%-//1J ,1/0,-//6A$K -//6 $%5A';5
5 $F $&&%%$ $ < *%) %' &%% %3 *$% %'& <% %$ $ %$ B%%F % &% $ O$<?<@9 <'$*$%)<@% %' <% %$8 ,A4,-//1.4B*%-//1J ,1/0,-//6 A$K -//6J ,4>>,400C.4&400CJ ,-AA,4001>&%4001;5
<9) $&&%%$ <D% *% 3*$'& <% %$< 5 $&&%%$3$&%% )$R$ $ $ <%& %$ <% %$ F $B ) 9 ?) %& F % F% $&$ % BG '$ <% %$ 3$*%% $*% ( %& *$% H <$*?5R $&&%%$) $&$ %%% )$%FR%D$%%$&$ % $&' & %FD $% %$ && G<@$% %$3$*%% $ F<%%% $ %%F$*$% H F%R5
$F ) & <'$$*$%<% %$ F<% %$% %?%< % % D %F5 $ )*% $&&) <H F< 9 $ %3) % < $% %%$ 8 5.5. ;5
15 $ %*$F ?& ? $ % @ H$& $%$% 5
5 M$$ $ %$ $ H$& $ %$% -. &'40008 27C465>4/;$' $ ?MD$&& $ H$& $ %$% %%' $ %$&&$ 8 5 4 ;5 ?% %&% %$&%%$D& %F &? %F? % %$ %$%?&&3F /+(G.//+( 8H$& ;) &% %$ M* %$ %&&%%$ H$& ) %%F@%?$G3%% %$($G'E %8 5-;5
,-./0,-//1 24/,4.2
*%&% M% %$ %&% %$&%%$$ H$& &% % %$ $ 8 5 . 5 1 ;5 7M?% %$ & % $ D$% &$'% $& D$%F 3%)*%&% M% %$$*33%M% % D& %F 65/ *$ ,& $ % %$ F% & @%*& ?&&3F0//!+(*%$)15/*$ ,&$ % %$F%& @%*& ?&&3F4C// !+(*%$$?&&3F* A5/*$ ,&$ % %$F%& G3$%?&&3F$ ?&&3F$ '8 D%3316 @;5
* %&% M%&&%%$ M@ - $%* I $ $N?* B$8 54.54;5
'5 B%) %'3 &G$$ F %$M%& %$MHOM D$%&$'%8 "4-0 6-/J "4-1.00S -//4>/6;5
$ M 3$ M ) $ %) $% %* G M33 H$& $ %$% D&%5733 D&%F% I % %3%F& '%J *D)%M@% $%% %3%F$3%&T&%%F& % @% $ F% $ 33 $ D&%F 8'%$$?%F;5 $ %$ $ 33 D&%F *%&% M%&&%%$)3%@GM@5 *$ %3%@ $&&%%$% %$$ %$$ % %$ $ %$% 8 ;5 % M$$) $% 3M #F& %&& *%&% ) % $ $F F $ %$ $ H$& $%$% $*% I %F%$33 $ D&%F5 M $F$%)%$P % *%&% M&%%$* %*) 3%@ G M % 6 5 * %&% %$ & %) M % $& %%* %$)@ %4%- 44%- $%3$ %$M*%$& >$ $'40C.8 27 C465/4;8%'%&)$%5.'556/-;5
M 9? @D %*& %&% %$ * %* &%%$ J $% M@ %$ * @%? %&% %$ $ % %* $ %%3$ M %4-%- 8%'%&)$%5 .56/.;5
M$%M* % 33 $ D&%FH$& $ %$% * * %&% M% %$ 8%'%&) $%5 . 56/6;5
,-./0,-//1 244,4.2
MH%$% %$33 $ D&%F$ 3%@ %$ * %&% M%&&%%$) M M $% & %&% % %%' % %%?%3% )M )F&?&U* 33%&& ? $ % $& % * %&% %$ * %* &%%$ ' M % 44 % - 5 $ M $3$& $% 38%'%&)$%56'56/A;5
% % M % 44 % - F $ $D M% %$ M% %% G $ M % 5 * %$M3$& $33 %& % )&% * $ G %&% 3$ & $N * %&% M%&&%%$ $ 835 " 4-6 A4> $%5 6 5 A-/ S 4000 A1C;5 *%&% M% %$*$% 3$ %'& 'F*%&% M%&&%%$8%'%&)$%5656/1;5
<9)44&%-//6)7$*%3*$'$ $ %$ % %?% * FF *5 $% = A 3%D $%3%F% $ %$'$ D$%&$'% $& 3%) * %&% <% %$ $ % G C/V @ $% = 6 = 0 <* %$5 $ *%) 7 < & %$F$% 0<* %$5
>5 5 7$$&& %$$% =-545C<@ %$<)% *% F<* &%*%<% %$)H$& $%$% 8%29:; & I ) $&5 < $F$% D? $$< $% %$5<% %$< $%F%*%&% <% %$< 5 *%%$ $& $ %$? %$ H$& :$$9?G& %$9 &%*%<% %$%)$*%%$)H$& '% % C/V*%&% <% %$5
'5 9? ?) % %$) %% % %* &%% %* 2 $) < &) $$ &%% %* 2 <$ ) $B% $ %)3$$% $ % $% 3 < % 60 $% 3 $ &%% %*-/&'401C8 274>-5/-4J "4-46>C$%5 -'J ,C.0,-00.4C$*&'-//.$%5. 3% ;5
<9)$&& %$<@ %$<<$ 3$ $'%? $%$ $% 5 ? % ?&<?% * $% % $% 57% $% <@ %$ % $& ) * % %% F< $3$& $% 35 <
,-./0,-//1 24-,4.2
$ %$ $ @J $ B%) % 3 $* F<$ $3$&$% 5
$'* %$ .4 B% -//1) <?? G 33 & $% = 6 <* %$5 $F ) F %$ < % %?%5
$%$) & *'& $$? %$)2% %$*% ?*$*$%%?5
C5 %'&%% %3$3%&$%%$$&&%%$ 1*%-//1 B %%$5&$& +"-<///52&%G D? $ 8 5 C> ;) F% $&'5 &$& +"-<///52 &% G D? !5 !& $'% $$ ) % $B$% & $%%& 5
$&&$%@%%F!5 !& $'% $$ $ $& *& < %&% +"-<///52 3* 7% 75 5 WWWWW
6 $# $
<,)=!*">
*'$% B --B%-//1$&&$%@$ %%$$&&%%$ $& %9$ %$1*%-//1J
%*'$%$$!& D% !$%! $'% $$ J
)=.>
B $J
& GD?$ &$& +"-<///52J
& G D? !& D% !$% ! $'% $$ % $B$% & $%%& )&$& +"-<///525
% F<% $%&% +"-<///52G7% 7%75 5GD? $&&$%@%%F<G!& D% !$%! $'% $$ )%$B$% & $%%& 5
,-./0,-//1 24.,4.2
% F) $3$&& @ % 0> %* $% 3 <$?% %$ B%%%) I I $ )*$%$$% &%% %3) B$ 9 $ %3% %$) 2* %' 3J &&$% $$% %%F$%$)&$ %3 &$H* $ %? $ $$& %J%$% I $%@&%&$% %' 3) 4/// 46J I %9 $%$ $ )%*$F$&&&$H*)$%* I B$% G<*$%J
$&&%F I G!"#$%!&'()*$ $ %%F<G ! $% 3%) *$ !& D% !$% ! $'% $$ %% F<G ! +$ %) *$ 7% 7% 75 5) G $&&%%$ $ $ & %9 $ %$ %% F< & $ %$ D$$?%<%3$& %$5
7%? : !5HD9)% )!&$*H +%)!5 D%)!&$) B?5
$& %'&%% %3:
?33%92B% : % : 5%$27%?% "5HD9
$%$3$& I $&&%F@ %5
9*) ?33%9:
,-./0,-//1