Contract Interpretation and Material Breach Regarding Payment Deadlines
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court addressed a dispute involving the interpretation of a contractual agreement concerning certain financial obligations and remedies for non-performance, specifically examining the application of a "time is of the essence" clause and whether delay in payment constituted a material breach justifying termination. The court reasoned that while the agreement contained language suggesting strict adherence to deadlines, the course of dealing and subsequent conduct of the parties indicated a mutual understanding or waiver that permitted reasonable latitude regarding the timing of payments, thus finding that the delay did not rise to the level of a material breach required to enforce the termination remedy.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contract Interpretation and Material Breach Regarding Payment Deadlines: The court reasoned that while the agreement contained language suggesting strict adherence to deadlines, the course of dealing and subsequent conduct of the parties indicated a mutual understanding or waiver that permitted reasonable latitude regarding the timing of payments, thus finding that the delay did not rise to the level of a material breach required to enforce the termination remedy.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive section concerning the allocation of costs.
Testo completo
!" !"# $%#$
$
# $ % $ #$ #
&'()&
-. '/0#1',,*%2$1 1$3$$415671& 8944 : 5 ; 1%$1 1 71&89 4: 5 2 $1 1$ $ $<1% -= 5 ',,* -'>,, ? -/>,,% 5@5 # 511$ 5 &1 2 51A% 1 $ <B --. @ 1 $555$ C185 1#1 @ < D 11 A 01 $E $@ 1$ #<A2#2$ 1$2D.
'. $2 1 >$1AF5',,*% 3$ 1$ 101 1$6 $1 10$5 44 $ #1 < 10 A ? 2$<1 1$ 2 510 1$. 00 % 510 1$ 2 1 51C@$511$1$5 1A$$1.
F. $1/5',,*%44 54111A A @ < $1 21 1 1$ 510 # 511$ 1$5 1A $ 1 A 1$1511#1 ;?1 # $ G $ $555$ 1$ 518 < 5$1A# 511$5 G 1$1$ < > >1.
/. $1 ) 5 ',,*% 4 0 2$ ? $1 1$ <#$1 $ < 71&89 $1 1$: 2 $1 1$ $11 $0$55 ? 2 1 '' . ' $# 1$ 1 1$ 1$5 1A -= #1 -)+-. 4 $ 0$1 1 H 1$ ? C51 $# 5 #1 1 A 1$.
*. --5',,*%44 $8 1@511 10$ 11$4)5',,*.
0 2 $1 510 1$ # 511$ 5 &12 51A#1$1 111@ 2C1$ 2$11$% $ 55 5 $I 1$ # #11 5@5 AA1J1$5 1 11<$ 511$ 511. 44 <5 1#$A ? 21 $ $ A2 510 1$ $ ? 01 1511% $<1 1$ @$1 44 -)5',,*# 25@ &12 51A?% #1 $1$1@$1.
(*+,(',,* &F()&
+. $@# 1$ K '* #1 ',,*% 4 1 A% 11$ -= 5 ',,*% 1 510 1$ $1 ? 1$ 2 $11 21J1$.
44 1$1 A1 $ $1 $ 0 4 1$$ 55 A1 55@ $1 1$ 11 ? 510 1$. 4 <5 C$ 0 1A $ 510 1$?$C151 511$1$5 1A$$1.$ ;$ A100 510 1$#$A$ 2#1 01 2$@; 252 $1 1$.
L. $21$5 1$$ 1-,;1',,*% !$1 $@1 4>@1% 44 % C$ A $#1 $$@; 5$%<?$1 1A <8 & 12 51A%1 8$@@5 5?5 $1 1$ $ 11A # 511$5 .<5 1#$1 1A # 2 511$ 1$5 1A $#1 A 510 1$#1 $1.
4 1 A B 510 1$ ;$1 M 1# 2 $1 1$. <5 # A2 8 <$5@ #1 1 1@# 11?1A .2 % 1 0015 A2 - #1 -))) F- ;1 ',,/% 510 1$ < 2#1 51% 1&5H5 $ $5 $1# $1 1$.
=. $1=;1 ',,*%4$015 1@2#$1 $# $1 1$ 510 # 511$ $ $ 1$5 1A.
). -*;1 ',,*% 1@511 1001 #$1C 1A 1 <?;<.
-. 0 4 2 $1 510 1$ $ 1 11$ 511 1# 2 1 / . - . $1 $ 511 1#-' 5@-)=*7 & *-,:.
11$ ; ?$8 1@511 10 1 ;$ ? $5 $ 101 1$ 7 . *+ $1 2$<1 1$;111''$#5@-)/-7N ',*: +F.- . ./ :.
(*+,(',,* &/()&
'. 4$ ;1% A1 $ $1 $ 11$ @$$?2C1 21 H 7 G-'F'=*$1./.'=+O --= /+ $1. F . *FO --- @ *= $1. ' . *' 0 1 O ('L,(',,- '/ #1 ',,-O (LF-(-))) * 5@ ',,,O (')*(-))L+51-))L:.
28% $ 2 21 H 1A ? A1 2 1$2 A%1A 510 1$ .
% 1 $ ? 01 2 1 H $1 1$ #@11 $ $A C1< 01 $@ $ M $ 1 1$1 2 A1 $1 $ 5 A1>1 $;$ ? 7 H 1@ 0 L $P ',,-% .L,(',,- $1.'O G -'/ 'F- $1. -@ . 'FF H 1 O ('L,(',,- 1 :.
44 C$$1 1$$555$@ < D A&1.5H51 1$$1 $1-=5 ',,+ 5 $I 1 1 < 01 $>1 <. 2# 02 $1 1$1 #11 8 15 ? A1 1 ?$#15$1@$ M$ 1 1$1 # 510 1$ $ A $1 1$ 21 H ;51 51.
1$ %A1 $<1$ $1 H 51.
; 5 1# ;11 1$$5 %$ $ #@.
F. $ 1 2 #1$ 1$ 1@ 2C1$ 2$11$.
4$2 1-+1- $ 1 1$0 $0 1$ 1 -= #1 -))) 7 .& 4 -,-:% 1@ 2$11$ 1@ 210$5 1$$ < 1. 1$1 1$$$1 $ $ 0$5%2C15 1@5 $$11$7 .-+.' .:% #$11@5 10$5 1$%$C$<5 1@ 100 7 . -+ . F .:. $1 $# 1$% < 1$2 1-,Q- RA11$A $ $$1 ? 1@ 2C1$. $1 $5 1@ 2$11$ 1@ #$1 $ $551A 10$5 1$ $ 1 A21 1 B #$11<2 $1 @1A $1 1$0$ 18.
/. 2 1+)1- % 1@2 15$ 10 A 1 1#$A O 2 $A$1 1 B <5 1 2C51 1 02 $1 1$ $ 1?1@ 1$.
(*+,(',,* &*()&
1A2 $5$%44 #$11@ 1$ 21 % $55 28% $<1 1$ @1A
7 . (.! (!.R % $1 $ 1 1$ 1% ',,,%./,LS=--:. 5 %A1 $<1$ 2 $ 21 15.
4$ 2 1 '' 1 ' .% $ $ $1 2$<1 1$. 1@ $$1 $ $5@# 2 % $ 55 # 2>< 1 $551A ? 17 . (.! (!.R %$.1 .%./,FS=,,:. <5 < 12 1--Q- R%A11$A $ $ $1 ?1@ 1$101A ?1@ 2$1 1$.
$1 ? 1@ 1$ $1 0$5 $1 5$ 1A %?21 $1 ?1@ 2C1$%20$5 1 $1 . 8 $% 1 $1 01 2$@; 2 1 1$ 1 1#7 G-,FF-,$1.*.F-*O5@5 ;1 1 ;1.41%11$ $5511$-,$ $@-)L)%S=-)-(L=% -L% . )FO 1 . $B5&1% 11$ $5511$ + #1-))*%S'''()/%=-&%.-/+:. $55 %$1 $#?0$1 1$ 1# #$1 @1A% 11 A 1$ 1A 01 @1 7 > 1 $ 15 015 . $B5&1%11$ $5511$-+;1 -)=,%S=//,(L=%'-% .-F=%Q-+' O R;#1 . A1',0#1',,F%1 H 11$71&891:%Q*+.:.
4$;1% $1# $5 $ <$1 1$101A51<5 2@ 12$ 1 1$11 @1#?$1 7 R;#1 1 %Q*LO > 1$ 15 0151 %.-+':.
*. !< $ M $$5 1011 >8 21 1$% 1@ 1$ $1 2C51 ? 518 1@ 2C1$% $ 1$ $11$ 1@ C15 $ 1 2 $@; 10 51 1@ 7 G---F''$1.+.F''O R4 D$# <1 1$ 5$1 1 1 . <1 ' $ $@ ',,-% 1 ',,-&T%Q=*.%;#1 1 %QF):.
$ 0$1%$A11$ A 101A5 $1 $1%12B1$1A 1$5 $ 2< 1@ 2C1$ 7 R ! 1 . 1 -L 0#1 ',,/% $@1%Q'F%;#1 1 %QF):.
28%11$ A044 2$<11A AA 1J1 $ # 511$ 5 &1
(*+,(',,* &+()&
2 51A. % C51 < 1@ 1$ 1A5 .
+. $0$55 ?;1% 0$1 2C51$55 1 1$?1@ 1$ $1 1$$2 1F+ .%?#$12C1 2@<%21 H @1 $$ 1$1 7 G-,L''+$1./@.'')O ('==(',,/+#1 ',,/:.
L. 4$ 2 1 -F $1 $51 @1 7 N - ,*:% $ 11 1$$51@1C 2<$55 @$$?2$ $1 2511$.
$A2<$51@1#1?5 2C12 1@ % ;1 $ A 0 51 A <15 2 $1 1$ $0$5 ? $ 1 1$ ? R 1$ 1#1 1 H 1 $% ? # 1$ ? $@; 1# 7U$DD1D1 . 8% 11$ $5511$ '* 51 -))F% $ @1% Q F-&FFO ('==(',,/ + #1 ',,/:.
1$1 1$$ 1 @<#@%1 001 $ 0 $1 1$.
=. 5$1$# ; 101 1 1$?1@ 1$ $ A1#1 ? $ <2$@1% $1 1 % A11 % 5$1 @1A%11A@$0$10017 G--, ))%$1*%.-,'O G-,=F,,$1.F.F,'O G-,L''+$1. *@ . 'F,:. $1 $# 1$% 1 H @1 $# ; 101 1 1$?1@ 1$$ 1 1$%P @1A% 0 2$ # 1$ 15% $ 1$ $ 5$7 .--Q' R:.
28%45$ 1#$0$$@1< 1$1 $ 5 $1 01 25H> A $C 511$ $1 #>1 $ $55<% 1C 511$ $@ $ 1<1 5$11$0$55 ?2 1''1' $# 1$1 1$1$5 1A-=#1-)+-7 N4,.-)-.,-:.
E 11A5$ 101#$A4$ 1 11@5 1 H @151&.
#>% 5$ 10 < 5 31A 6 #1 0$5 #@ 0 2$ $1 511$. %1 .
(*+,(',,* &L()&
). $0$55 11$$ 1$1 %2 $1 $1 5$? 1@ #1 $ #< %5 $1@% 2C1 1@ 7 G -,F F-, $1. * . F-*:. $1 $# 1$%11 C15?2 1--Q' R%A11$A 2C1 1@ 1$ 01 2$@; 2 1 1$ A A1%#$1$ 1 51%$1 5$ 1A%?1 1$%?P @1A%?02$ ? # 1$ 15% ? $ 1$ $ 5$% $ ? $ 1$$1 1@ 2 1.
2; 10 316% 1$1 1$% 2 $ 5 A23511@6%3$56%31$@6$3$$ 6O 31 6 151A $;$ 2C1 2 3@$1 $1 151C6 7V$D . $1 + 5 ',,F% 11$ $% -8 1$% $ @1% Q -,=O R $< . 5< '+ 5@ -))*% 1 S','%Q*':.
-,. 2 $1 % $ $#$1 < $1% $1 01 $$ 1 $5 1$ 01 51 1 5 1 5 2$@1$1 A21; 10121 1$151 .
28% 44 15 01 $E 4 1$ #1< # 511$ 5 511. 00 % 101AAA1J1$# C AA 1 $ 1 $11 . 1$ 8 5 44 $510 1$-=5',,*%A1 $1 ? 1$. &1 2 1 A2 1J1 $ 2 $ 11 . 2B 11 5 2$@1.
42<1 A41$1 C511$ <8%1E 10011 #$1 A$1 510 1$ 101A AA 1J1 $ 5 $ 1 % 2 A 2 $1 1 15 1$1 2 #1< 1 ;$ $ 1 % 1 $>1 1 % $<1 01C$1 1$$><%> .
$E % $ C$ 2#$1 ;51 $ @$5 510 1$A21$<1 A21#1 $ #% $1$-=5',,*%#12$$5$L$.
01% 1 #1 A2 510 1$ # 511$ 5 51125H515 A2510 1$# 1$% $ $A21 2<1 A 2 1$ AA 1J1$.$#1 11 1A44 1$2 1 H ?$#$1510 # 511$5 511 $
(*+,(',,* &=()&
1 1A #$1 510 1$ $ 8 B5@$1A.
4 $#1 #@5 0 2 $1 1$ 510 44 #1$1@ 1$.
--. # A1 8 $ 51% 11$ A $ 1 #1$ 1$<#1@ 1$44 .
21 1 1<% 5$5 RG *,,.& 51 ? >< 4%A1$5@7 .=L :.
151 $%$ 2B 5.
$
& ' ()*+ ,
#@$1 ; --5',,*2$1 1$$$ 41 5 744 : $ 11$ 5 ; 1% $1 1 )5',,*O
(- ,
25 O
5 ? >< 5 ; 1% $1 1 5$5 RG*,,.&O
$551A H ? ! "# $% #$ $ 11 AW 5 ; 1%$1 1 .
41< 9 !.B>8%1 %!. >1%!5$%;<%!!. $$ <%;<
(*+,(',,* &)()&
$5 1@511 109
<0018&;1 9 1 9 .1$&41<1 G.B>8
$1$0$5 H $551AC 1.
8#% <00189
(*+,(',,*