Indemnity for Pre-existing Liabilities under Contractual Covenant
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court addressed whether a party was entitled to indemnity for liabilities arising from a transaction, specifically focusing on the interpretation of a covenant within an agreement concerning the assumption and release of prior obligations. The court reasoned that the language of the covenant clearly indicated an obligation to indemnify against liabilities stemming from the predecessor's debts and obligations, as the agreement was intended to transfer such risks, thus rejecting the argument that the covenant only applied to future, not pre-existing, liabilities.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 al. 2 LTF; Indemnity for Pre-existing Liabilities under Contractual Covenant: The court reasoned that the language of the covenant clearly indicated an obligation to indemnify against liabilities stemming from the predecessor's debts and obligations, as the agreement was intended to transfer such risks, thus rejecting the argument that the covenant only applied to future, not pre-existing, liabilities.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the final order regarding the allocation of procedural costs.
Cited in the final order regarding the allocation of procedural costs for the second instance.
Testo completo
!
" # $$ %&'! ()*&"" **+! &*!))!", - ".- " **+!%%!!%&'! )*'%." %&'! +!%.- " **+! /&' /!!%&'! 0'! ! **+! *1! '%!2"-3 **+!')!!%&'! '1* " %&'! ! %* -# %&'! )4 ! .-"3 **+!)!5*% * .-"32"3 **+!6!*%%'%!7" "
%&'! 1 '&81!9" %&'! 0* ': -
&#& **+! )*'%!!%&'! /81*%! -" **+!* (* !1 "";
%&'! 01')'88! - **+!.1'&)*'%!- " ; '()*'+''))',-' - - -" "" -" <" " - - =0 "" " - -" " " #--. " " > - -
!!!" #$$% &. "!&
"
"/ 0 ) 1 #"2$, 3' 4 56& 7&'6, 8 9"4, -',('3'('--:9+:'''( ))'(()(;/
+ 0/ /, *' ; , *- *' ' ,*-('(*''*',*- +' <, *-'*''+'-,*'+,*' 3';-<,*- 7';-<&*=<*-' >' ?'&)5@ )-' ))'('A (' ) ))'(()(;))-=9'))- );-B'(97/))(!22-''5- ))'((/
*' +')+ C, *' 'C ', *- & '*'0()+ ,*-*;+-D,*'+'& ')) ' *- +'' ED ?'&)5@ 67 )& )'('A +(, #$$#, ) ))'(( )( 4$" -''5-9-:/
#/ . B' #$$!, 67 ))'(' ()( - 9'' ? 22#"2A D ) :B 3-' (' 7))--:'--:,8)9))- ')'5,+-::;'7'/
0 ) 9( 7', -: 9'--: -'(=+-::"$8""-#+ 9 ))-, ( ) ()7 , = '( 9 (B 96' .$ 8 .4 -#, 9 '' 96' 4 8 % -# 9 +-: 96'"48#$-#/3)();',''= ))'5(--(F'G)9':'/
)567,-:')()7))-,' '7 )'5 ') "H# -# +:': = )'5 ""4 -# +:':/
./ 9'' =I, )(6' '6 (( ''@
/ 9')' +' (-' )(6' 36:, (6 '''68('(',9'')/
:/ 6'9+:':''(9)(-'9:B'/
!!!" #$$% &! "!&
/ ' 56 9 (( 36: )B, 8 '' = D 3 ) 7 )'5 ))- ))'-( () ) JE.9##4/&))'5)/
/ --''--,',&--'' +' ?'&)5@ *0A 6( = :K'- (' '( -:)(;((:#$5-'5/)B +K''6'I6/
-'3'' -( D (( ))( )B, *0 ''=(I36:)B,(6('97(' ',='6''I-'667/
/ 6'B''=+;(L3-'()B8' (-'', 3-' (6' -' 9+:'' #4 B6' "22% ? & 4 #$A (-' )(6' 36:/ D 6' -:')'5D JE!9#!$/&)'5 ( (',' )'5-'6,D('-)(8 JE.9##4/&)'5 (, ' )'5 -' 8 (, 6 D )3( JE%92$2/& )'5 (/ -) -- ((-, D -D, )5 67, ) )'5 ) ( (' 3'7( 8 JE !9M"2/& ) ( '= /';-7'-:6'I;(8 '3'/
!/ :6''6)6()-' +;'9'3-'?'&)5@()- A@
/ "4B'#$$!,'((9):'?'&)5@0 A';(= (' 7 ))- -: N' -')'' ';- :/ 9))' ) 8 9-(;- -:,-'+''(6''''/
:/ *-: 733'*' -?'&)5@ ()7A,';-'(-:,''=()B, =' 6'' 9' !. - O ' 96' ) (( '3-(''))'('/
/ P ))'(( "4, -', '' +:'&))'(& 'P, 9 ' ))( )B/ ()7 , ' 9))-'(-:,6'9:'9';(=' 6' (( '3'(/ ) ()( ' ''' = 8 9+'-(/
(;'-()67))'(';'')-'3 )('3/ 6'';'3'(;(7'&'+:'' 9'--: )' ) '= & ' 6 ) ))-
!!!" #$$% &4 "!&
=9' 6' 9=('/ *;( ('' 9-:( ;((, (;''')')'9'--:'/
)B)''7)'--9'--:,-- ) '' 9 6 :' =' ('' (' 9 ;' +'= - )/ 6 8 9(' ' )'- :(/ ' ' )'6'( ) )- B <('+7/ 9'-) 9(=')- '' )(6 67 ;-;(('37='7')6'))/ 9(' ) )':, 6 ), 6' ' ' ' ' 6(/ 3', -'3'' 95 8 ' '=' 96' (=))'--6'5)'%5-(;/
4/ (''".B6'#$$%,()-B())'' ('6( 9'' ''(/ 0 '' 1H, D ;- '7 )'5 6' ) () JE #M92"!/& ) ' = )'5 JE"29##4/&)))(''=5-''/ ' ;- 7' -: 6' I ;( 8 '3'/
%/ / "H 3(6' #$$%, ()7 )5 --'' -'5 ' ?'&)5@ A )((-3';))''/(;-6(= ('''';'''D='9(')3+ 7()7:')()())'/
:/ "H 3(6' #$$%, Q ) ' B ) , )-'))'('*/(;-)5 / (' ))'(' 9 ) ))'(( ) (;, (6 *//
9'--: 3'' )' 9 -: "25- (: #$5- '5,9'(+':''=6'I-'/)B )' ' 7 ) 9'--:, ;' +'= 6' I (( - )/ (' (' -''(/ 5 '-) ' 6' I (( 9))- = )'5 8 '-:,6)9'/ ((-, =' -'3'' ;:' ', ' R - ()- 8 39''''(/
),D)')7:')()( ))'/ ' JE !9M"2/& ) )'5 ) (, ' ;- )(' -7'-- )(6, JE .9##4/& ) )'5 ) (/ */ , ',6'I;(,='9(')/
!!!" #$$% &% "!&
H/ #!-#$$%,67))'(',--()*/', ))(/('9;'96''<'-5 6'; )' ) ' 8 9'--:, =9 ' 9+' -( 3'-'/ )) '3 7 6' (( --(/958'3')')'--,) )))-8(/ 7D,'6'((3'7(3-(- 8 /
M/ -)' ) ." - #$$%, )' -)()''/
7)(=D 6' (( 3'7( D JE .9..4/& ) )'5 ) ) 7 ' )'5 -' 7'/6'-)9D667 JE"#9#H$/&/ */)('(=D(' JE""94#$/&+;/
2/ #M 6' #$$%, 67 ))'(' )('( =, '- 8 =' 6' (( (;(, (' 9 ;' +'= (' )3,'97',(;'3('89)-: :'8(,6:9'-')'-)/ ), )) 9';(' 6' 3'-( = (' 9 ;' 9''-)(''=-/ 8'-'' ' '6 -:, 9' ) 9'' 9(' 7 '( '3('/ 3', 9'3-' )(6 8 9'!. 6''='9'--:7 -:,='6'(6')'/
"$/ #M6'#$$%,()7-'',) (6))((-3';/
'#$B'#$$%,-(8)6'() 7:6'67))'('/
""/ (''"#:#$$%, B(/
()76'6(8B'=9'!. 96' )(())'=(/ 3',9')()-'3' '))'(,)'=9-')3''';=9'33'' ('6 6 '' ' )5 6' ( ' / 3' ) ) 3'7 D (' 3- 8 B'), ' ' -) ' )'5 -' 7')'7 JE.9##4/&))'5)(')'5-'8 (,)'7 JE%92$2/&))'5)(/
!!!" #$$% &H "!&
*06')(6'(36:-)B/;'3 (39';-:'' )')'8((-';)'/
"#/ "H6-:#$$%,)-'))'('*/'' ':-'''39,);-'('/
"./ / ""B6'#$$H,67))'('))(/ 6'6(-I-;-6 ,' -) )'5 6( 8 )( &-)/ 9D 6' ) -'3'' ' ' 9' 7 )/ 3'7' D)'77'; /
:/ L(,()-B"4B6'#$$H/ 9'' ('6( (' 3- 8 ' ' '''6"!6'"2MM? &4$4A=98 /;'3 '6958''''6'/ *096')(-' (6B'-''3/
"!/ ))'#"-'#$$H/
', */ ' ';( = *' + 6' 6))'(()(;/
%5-(;,'(((=5'7''' 9( 9))- */ / ' 7)'=( = 95 6' (( 3-( ) 6', -3 9(' '' ))- ) 6 8 )' )'/ ;' -",.$-5 L('('-''()67/)) )-958'))-)''(()'/) )(6 ) ;' +'=, 97' (' '( (; '3(',(()((/9+')('(=9'9('))': 7', ); ) ;' +'= (' 6';:/';(=9-,'D6'):5- 9'-'9,9+')('(=9''689' 67/
"4/ ' "! R #$$H, ''-( '3-( ': = ()76'((;(,:')33")-:#$$H/
0=',933'((;(8B;/
!!!" #$$% &M "!&
" -
"/ B( -) ' 6 B''' -)(, 6:?/4% '9;''B'''##6-:"2!"& & #$4S/%./"'/')(-'''6"# )-:"2M4& & 4"$A/
#/ / 9'%$: ,)'8)(=' :' 8 ('' =( ) +( '- ) (''=''(I)';)'8=9'( -'3'(,''='()'/ ':-'''3 (B8 B;( = : ')'' )('( '6 ' )5@'',)''=')3'6''(I';)' ' I -' -- )' , -I- 9' (' )' 8 )()-'5'? 4## #$$#.)-:#$$#,'/#: (3('(A/
97' 9 '(I 9))(' - -- ()L , -' ' )( ('' S 9' 9('))(,((:B? E"#.#M4 '/ ! )/ #M% /S ""M !% '/ . )/4.S """ : 4M '/ # (3( '(S 2"4 #$$! #. 6-: #$$!S #H$ #$$" #! 6'#$$"S H." #$$$4(-:#$$$S #24 "22H%-'"22HS // "4 B6' "22HS / 0 , '( ' -'''3, +K,"2M!,)/2$$A/
:/ )( 33', ' (:' = ()7 ='( 9))-'-:9'--:")-:#$$H/), */ + , )(, 6 ) ))'(( ) (;/ 5((:B/
./ / 0 9' M2 '( " , 9'( +' :''= -: "25- '5 (: #$5- '5 '( + )('-5 )' ''&' ' 3'3'',''=6'7 ;,'I)(6(/
0'((---:;)7'--:) ';, 9+' ''= ;, '' = '--: ()( 9-)-, ;:' D (( Q 9-)''9-:='?/M2/# A/
-:9'(+' :''=-)5 -'?/2$/")-'5)+ A/
!!!" #$$% &2 "!&
-9'',''=67(3'3Q ''--:6'(89'M2-'))(6' 8--''--,'?/2./" A/
:/ 0B'):'(:', ':-'''3:6 ' ) (6' :' )) ))('' 8 --'')(6')=9'('3(''696'& '? !!$ #$$%."R#$$%I'(A/
/ 9)5, )B '';'7 (( )(6'( 36:- ) -- = ) *0, )5 6' (( )( 6T7 '5/ ()-, )' * '6' )(6'/ ;'3 6(),='='('(6 9;'+'=))-9''9:'9 ))-8(,9:')'9(' =' 95 8 ' -'3' ))('', '' = 9 6( /
' ''= , =' )'6'' (6',''6')-)( ':-'''3/
6=')(5, ':-'''3=)B 3-77'; ,;'33-()8 (;((/
!/ / 09'2'(" ,''(') 3-'(6'9'--:-'8''/ (, -- = 67 )- ('' ;- ))(-'/,()-''-)@
"/ ;,D);'='(;-7'S
#/ )'7 6' ;- 3-( 6- ((, ---:S
./ ;9'--:S
!/ -:)'5 3))-,''= 3;-6-((S
4/ 7';'(89:B'3)(6')'-'?3//2 +/# A/
9'(.-I-')('=,):')()( ))', ' 3 D ': 8 -B'( ))',
!!!" #$$% &"$ "!&
', " B6' "222, 7 -)' JE #9!$$/& JE .9##4/& ) )'5)(/3+D)7)'-I()(' 3:'6)'5'-)?/2+/! A/ :/ ': -'''3 (B8 6( = ((- )(' )(( ) '5 )(6 8 9' 2 '( # )-' -)( )( '(I )(/ (;, ' ))' ()-933))('';:3'9(6'-: +(-'- = (;' 7)(- 6 (6'/ 9()= (6'' , ' 9 6' (;- ''( 9: ('( 9 ))'' ': ', )' 6' -:7 )B B-' I ('( )'6 )+(-5 6'''-(('')'3;6'?*(-'( '"224))/!4%4&!4%%S 4!! "222"!)-:"222A/
'(',(6))(9'2 ,)6 I )' 9;' 9' % =' )(6' (;- )' -))''5)'(-'' '/
/ 3-', ': ( B;( = =9 ))-()7:')()())'); ) D (' -)( ) ))- )7 '(; -:, 97'; D () 7 :' )()( ))'('-')9-:9))-6-((/ '', D )(' ) )'5 6- (( 9(' ) ):? #H! "22H#26'"22HA/
': ( 3' -' 9 3-' 9'--:,)-('67;-)) ; D 7 :' )()( ))', =9)6 )' 9 7 D )' ) D, =9))('';:)-'('69''/ ,-I- ' D 3'7( ) ' ))- () 7 ) 7:')()())'? ""$ "22223(6'"222A/
': -'''3 -' -- 3- 7 7'; D3'7(8 JE.94$$/&)'5)9))- = )'5 9 3 "$$ -# ') 7 ; +-:6L6? 4!! "222"!)-:"222A/
9 H%4 #$$4 "4 6-: #$$4 ?0 #$$% )/ ..4, '( ) * A, ': -'''3 ( '' (-'' ' '( = )'7 6 '( ) ,' JE!9%$$/& JE!9H$$/&-#('3(D3''3 JE%9$$$/& )'5 ) / 3 -D )'5 96' '
!!!" #$$% &"" "!&
97)'/ - '' 5 ;- & 7 )7:')()())'/
/ 9)5, ()- =9' D 6', -:667,')'5-'6,-)(8 JE.9##4/& )'5 ) ( ))- ' )'5, D (( -)( 8 JE"#9H#$/&, ;: ) +; 9))-, ' JE"9#$$/&)(/
) 3' )( = 3'; +'=P)(6'B''=& P)3'')(( )''-(-)7@
& '-),PD)'57'DP +;=*/6'8:'S
& 9),)(6''.)'5-':'=PD )'5 7' 6 -)( 8 . ##4/&P, . )'5 -' 6-(/ ('(,' D=+-::6, =')(==.)'5-((/
'3' , D )5 67 ' R )(-'5'6@
)'5 D D)'568 JE%92$2/& . JE#$UH#H/& D)'57'D8 JE.9M!$/& . JE""U4#$/& D)'57'6-)(8 JE.9##4/& ! JE"#U2$$/& D;: "$ JE!4U"!H/& D-D )'5 JE!U4"4/&
)5 67, -: 9'--: )( ) '7 )'5/ B 3 )'5, 9))- ()7 -) ""4-#,=3;-)567'.$$-#, =' ) 8 3 -D ) )'5 '-''/ ), -- 96(()7)(,))-9) 5:(,=;-8(3/
)( 8 ))('' ;: '', 6 ) (;', )5 '3'' -'( '&, D:))N 3-77'; /),9)('
!!!" #$$% &"# "!&
)-;'))(':3+:':)()8'(I):' '/
4/ 6=')(5,)'--',''1 H 9'' '(-'3'( 3-(-3'; '&/
6',(--)(, JE"9$$$/&-' 8+;,)'B'-''-?/MH A/ 9 33 = 5 )'- -' ) -'3 =9' 96' 6( =U''-/ '-'( ( 7 ''-(,=''=-8='-(7 ()/ VVVVV
0 "- "
8 /*)*)!+!%@
- + *- : 733' , *' - *'+S
?)*4 +!@
(6:'B(#!6-:#$$%) +0/ /,*' ; , *- : 733' , *- *' ' ,*' -,*-('(*''*',*- +' <, *- ' *' '+ '-, *' 3 ';-<, *- 7 ';-<&*=< *- ' >' (''--''--'' -'5'"#:#$$%S
*4%@
9-)'-S
' = '' 1 H 9'' ' 22#"2&# '6@
F 7;- -(;( -:'( 8' D 97( ) 7 ) 3'' 6'(, ' JE #H9$MM/& ) ;-'7)'5 JE"M9$42/&);-=)'5,') )(''=8-''GS
!!!" #$$% &". "!&
B)S
- 8 +; , )' B'- ''-, (-- JE"9$$$/&
'=9'9)(9'-'(S
' =, 3-(- 7 ' M# '6 ' 3(( ': 3(( "H B' #$$4 ? E&0 "H./""$A, )( I ) I )( B =' '6 '3'' )&6 ': 3((, ) 6' -'5'):'S-(-''''=', -'3-D)6)';-'S' ' I ( ': 3((, "$$$ "!, ) 6' ) ) 6' ('= 7 '' U' !# E/ )( I )'5 )' , '6=( -- -D )6, '6 I B' 8 U6'S
--'=)(I8 +0/ /,*';,*- *' ' , *- ('( *' ' *', *- +' <, *- ' *' '+ '-, *' 3 ';-<,*- 7';-<&*=<*-'>', ()-'+;'9'3-',8--'' -'5 ' 8 *' +'')) ', -' ))'((''=98*-: 733'8*' -/
0'(;@ */D+5,)(',*-6DJ',*/ +(',*-, B;/
- ':-'''3@
;33'5&B'@ )('@ /'&0';' E/D+5
!!!" #$$% &"! "!&
)'3-I((--'=(7)'/
56, ;33'5@
!!!" #$$%