Stay Denial Upheld on Likelihood of Success on Merits
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA litigant challenged the denial of their application for a stay pending appeal, which was sought after a lower court ruling interpreting a statute regarding the validity of certain organizational instruments, asserting the denial was an abuse of discretion because they demonstrated the requisite likelihood of success on the merits and the balance of hardships tipped in their favor. The court reasoned that the denial was proper because the appellant failed to meet the threshold burden of demonstrating a substantial likelihood of success on the merits, as the lower court's interpretation of the controlling statute was reasonable and unlikely to be reversed on appeal, rendering the required showing of irreparable harm from continued enforcement insufficient to warrant appellate intervention via a stay.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Stay Denial Upheld on Likelihood of Success on Merits: The court reasoned that the denial was proper because the appellant failed to meet the threshold burden of demonstrating a substantial likelihood of success on the merits, as the lower court's interpretation of the controlling statute was reasonable and unlikely to be reversed on appeal, rendering the required showing of irreparable harm from continued enforcement insufficient to warrant appellate intervention via a stay.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay the costs of the federal proceedings.
Testo completo
!!" #$$$$$$ !"#$%"&'#
#
%& '' ' ( (' ' ' )((# ' ' * ( (
()*+(
'
/0 ""# /1 2" )--.& 3 # "# 4##$" 5"6#3 "# 7"(89 : 6 ; !3 <<<<<< 5 #" "# # " " %#" .- 3 "" # 4 5'"#)3&"3" #" &#<<<<<<6"/, #33 '& # #" "0 " " =#+&#" " " ">'"7 0/?0,#"@" "# #"6@3$3 " #"A2"/?1B( (/,-:0
)0 ""#)#C )--.& &' D" "'" "$ #" "#&D"'" # E/-#C )--+"3 #3#" "#. 3%)--+ #;!3<<<<<<" ,-2##6"8 "#" ""#0"# "6"$ 33"" "' FG)@+--0(0
,0 /B#C )--.&!3<<<<<<#8#33""# # 3 "8 # "# 7"(89 ! : # 6 5 #" "#/12" )--. # 533"" "')#C )--.0
A0 #" + #C )--.& H "% 3"" "6 . 3%)--.& ! 3";2"" "#&#"# #3  "#& D5"'"" 533"" "'0
+0 )- 3%)--.& "%3"" "65" "# 5 ""# ! 2 6 5 #" "#0
.0 ""#/)6'")--B&'6"" "'& ! 3" #!3<<<<<< ## "'5 #" "##"" & ; "#" "#0
B0 /-2" )--B& "%3"" "6'" "" 5" "# 3 5" 3" " 53 3"" "'&'""# ! 0
10 /?2" )--B& "6#3 "%D5"#H" ; 5# 3#" "# 3" #"" D 53 3"" "' 3" 6# # ""& "D '> '" " #" "# # "0 # 6#"& D# " " 3 ; FG /@---0(& ! I "3 '> #"%& 3#I " #" "#0
*,)+,*)--. (,*+(
?0 '" ; 3"#" "# &!3<<<<<<""D& #" // 2" )--B& 5'#" #%' "# ; 6#3& 6 ; #D53"#" "3#0
' (
/0 2 3" 3 " ' 2"" "# #3 & # '% 7 0 +. #" @#$" "# 2""" ))#'3%/?A/( ( )-+J 0.,0/ 0#"# 3"" "'/) 3%/?1+( ( +/-:0
)0 K # " #" #& &I'#" #"&' # # " # "# # " "#& # 33 E 7 0/ 0 / 0 #" # "# " "# "' /A'"/?11( (+-+:0
" D5 #"% 6"3 #"& " ' !3 <<<<<< 5 "" "3 D5 3 5 #" "# # " #" #0 D "#" "# 3 "# '"#0
,0 K# 5 " /,B " / & "% 5 3 3"" "' FG/--0(; FG.-@---0( # #D"# '" ; #"&> 8$3 L 5"D >## 3 "3" #"&8$3 L 0
A0 0 3 3"" "' # & " 8 3 " "$ "3 3 #"" # D #3 3"" "'3"8" 3 ">" 0 @ " D D# " "# 3"" "' #" L 6"> #3 ""$>$" #" 7 */?1*)--B)A'" )--B 6 " J 0 !& #" 3"" "6 9 3"" "6 # E&'#0)&)--)&40/0A0+0+&0/,?:0
%0 """D# ' " #33"6 &6C (# 6#3 @ "3 $"$ 70 FMG *0 !N *G0 F! & $3" O $4 & +83 0& PQ"4(R(8' )--.& 0 )+)& 0//B?:0K#""D"@# 3"&@3"" "##" 6" ' '" 6" @ #" 7 *+A,*)--. /-# #%)--.J *A+/*)--.,/#C )--.J 0K & " #" 3"" "6& '#0 )& 4R & /?1A& 0 .A.(.A1: 2#" @ $ #'#" @" "# # "6"$ 3 7 *A/+*)--. ). 2" )--. L " :0 2"" "# D@ @>8
*,)+,*)--. (A*+(
7 *)1/*)--.),3")--.:0 6"&@3#" "" ## "#" 7 0 ,. 0 , # " "# 6 #6 "# "/1'"/???( 0(K/-/J *),A*)--.)3")--.:0
0 53"" "# 2#" 5 $ #'#" 5" "# # "6"$ 302"" "#D55>87 *,.-*)--. )B2")--. 6" :0
0 58&53 2 "6"#"" 53 ; FG/@---0(##0
"% 33 #6"3 3 3"" "' FG )@---0( # '> " #" "#& #" 6 "# #" ' # '>& "# '"$ $" "# 5 ## "' 8 7 *BA*)--B )- 6'" )--B:0 & '" "6"$ 3 3"" "' FG)@---0(& $3 # 6#3 "# 66 #" "# > 3 7 *B?*)--B)-6'")--B:033 & 33"" "' FG+@---0(# '>"3# &66 #" "# " # #"% # "# " & " "%3"" "67 *+-)*)--B?# #%)--B:0
'53%"# & "" 53 '> " "$">& 8 #"%& 5% 5 # #3 "D #6"3 3 "8& 33"" "' FG/@---0(4; # " "D& " "D# 5$5L 3I0
+0 ' D" 8& " # 5'#" 3 533"" "'; FG/@---0(0#2 #0 3#3 FG+--0(3";4$# 7 01B :0
SSSSS
& '( '
+,!-" .
'%#" 2 1 3%)--.!3<<<<<<# ""# 3 # "# 4##$"@"6#3 "#) #C )--.J
*,)+,*)--. (+*+(
!-/.
# 3 # "# 4##$"5"6#3 "# D533"" "')#C )--. 3; FG/@---0(J
2 ##J
3 ;4$# 3#3 FG+--0(J
" D& #6#33 > " 1) "' #" 6 "% 6 /B 2" )--+ 7 G(K /B,0//-:& L L # 2# D" "' # "6" "# (' "% 6& '#" #3 "8#" %"J33#"##" ""D#"#& 3# "6 3#I' # "$ # ##3 "J" #" L "% 6& /--- /A& '#" # # '#" #"D > #" "# @ " A) G0 L "8 #"# # & "'#D #33 3#I '& #"' L 2#" ; @'#"J
#33"D L ;!"#$%"&'# # ""D@ 3 # "# 4##$"@"6#3 "#0
K"$ 9 !0I48&" &!3#'I F"&!0 4"&!3#& 2$0
#3 "%3"" "69
$66"8(2" 9 " 9 0"#(K"$" G0I48
#"#6#3 L #33"D> "0
8'& $66"89
*,)+,*)--.