Contractor Substantial Performance and Damages for Minor Defects
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA contractor sued a client for non-payment of the final installment for construction work, arguing substantial performance despite minor, uncorrected defects related to the aesthetic application of materials, while the client counterclaimed for damages based on the cost to correct the defects. The court held that the contractor substantially performed the contract, thus entitling them to the contract price less the reasonable cost of remedying the minor defects, reasoning that the defects did not impair the building's essential use or purpose, and the contract's purpose was substantially fulfilled.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Contractor Substantial Performance and Damages for Minor Defects: The court held that the contractor substantially performed the contract, thus entitling them to the contract price less the reasonable cost of remedying the minor defects, reasoning that the defects did not impair the building's essential use or purpose, and the contract's purpose was substantially fulfilled.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThis article governs the imposition of court costs, as cited in the dispositive orders.
This article concerns the allocation of costs concerning legal aid, as cited in the dispositive orders.
Testo completo
!"# $$$$$$ ! ""#$%# #
%& '%()) %
&'()*&
). ')/%"'--0$ #" #1%# #" 2" "3#" 4 # #5"# # 3#6 %#" #3#7"& 2"&8)*-9. #" %":)03" '--0.
'. . !#" ;;;;;; 75" < #" "# <2 #33 =55" 3" "#3 3#6 <"#"%" 2"',3)>>>4? 9.
7. )- 3" '--,$ " #"" @ #" "# <2#" 2" %" 7"A" <" $ 2".?AB / B 3 @##3" 4"&1C 3 9 ) /" '--,$ #5"3 "7 3"" "5 4 (0->('--, )> 37 '--,9 " "7 5 4B "7 5 '.'D)('--,),3'--+9.
*. . "" '' 3 '--,$ %" #" "# 4"&1C ? 9 2 2#" < %" 2" "%$ "3 #33 2"#" "#3 A 2"%" # 55 3#"5" A<" " 3 #5#3" E #"<"")03"'--,.
1 $%="#" # <":3" %3 "#F 2"G.A $#3 5#7$3# F 2"G #"$ %" B # 3"1 %""7 E <% E <"1 %=". 3#"3"2%" B " E<" " 2"# B %""7<2 " ""A" 2" " "7## " "5 # " %". 3#" %" "3 #%#" :3 ""A"=55%" " 32"3/#"1 %".
2#" %" #? $% )03"'--,$AB ##%3 < #" "#<2#" 2"%""%$# #% #" "#. 2 A" @55 " 3= "$%" "< #" "#<2#" .
7. #% "" 2 =55 2" %""%H/" '--,.
?" E < %": 2"$ =55 2" %" "% " 3# <":3"47#7#795"2 #" %="$ # ## F 2"G E #2"3" A 3"#:"A 3 E"#" "#" 1 5"= F"5#3 "#
(+,('--+ &*()*&
2 :G. %" :3 # E <" "# 3#" 3"2E<" "%="<""*)#I '--,.
H. #@# J55 '' 37'--,@" # ? $" # A !. ;;;;;; #" " "# 2" E @## .<":3" " #/#5"2 #" #%="$ ## F 2"G@%" # 3#"3"2< " #" .
0. ""#))37'--,$ 1"%#"##"7"" <2"A5" #=$? "5":E!.;;;;;;3 8K H--.& # "5 "# 2 " *D " * H 2" ,' 1:3 <2 "# 2"H3"'--04 2"&8)*-.-)9.
,. !.;;;;;;" / #1 "73"" "5# ""#)-/%"'--+.# E# "#.
# " "3# " *D " * H 2" ,' 2"%" ##AA 2"%""%" ":" $ " "#$ %=" A 1 # #55"" ## 3" 3 " #5"##" A" 5"" E %". " # " E @ " '+ # " "#5 #5 "#")D%")>>>4 .&?)-)9 %" "7 2" #5"#. #% :3 "# @3B=" "A#3 "#" "##3 #5" 2 2"%"7" #"%"1:$A" L" " #"#%" "%#.$@" " "#5" 2=55 2" %" "% @ "" %#" 7( 2" %#" #M " "# " " "" A =: " @6 #33 "3 2" ":" 7"%3 "7 @ " / "5" " B 7".
+. *%"'--+$ 3 @ ###.
" *D " * H 2" ,' 2" " " " " " "# %""7 " 2 :#" 2"$ E %#" %"7" %""%.5"" # "3# :3 "#:%#" 2"A""3" " #373" "#3 . "#" "# < " #A # " E "7 ##3"A. <" " "# 7#7# 7 %" # 7 # : " 1 # #5"# 2" %" 7"$ %" "% "3#". #7/ "5#" "" 73 E" B 7". @" " "# 7#7# 7$ 3#" 3"2 %" "3 #% E <" " %=". 3#" <%" " # 3 3" # J$ =55 2&
(+,('--+ &H()*&
3B3 A #". 7 #"%" " " 7"A A" # " " %"33 " B 7". #" "# / "5" "# " "#"7 ##3"A" B 7" " """.
"$ <" " "# ": " " "5 7#7# 7 <#7": "# <# 2 ## #3# 3 "# F 2"G 3 " 55 "%3 <%" #5"# 2" %" "%$ 2 %" 7" "3#". <6 %2 #" 2"$ ? " <%" A "55 #7#7#< " 55" #"55"2 :#" 2". 2" %" "% #% =: " " "#$" #% "#3" #A#""&" <B #A@" =1. %" :3 #%#" " ": 3"1 "<" """ ## 2"A"%" #" < ""%#"%2 # 7" =: "# 2".
E" "#<" 3#"3"2$"@:"" 3#6 3 # J " 55" 32"33 %"#" " .# J =6:=" 7# #3"A "3"" 3"1 "7 #37 # J.
5"$ 7 #"%" " *D " * H 2" ,' 2"$E%#"" 7"A # "#" 1# 7 " " #" 2#" 2" %" "% #%#" 5"2 7#7# 3#" 3"2 #" %=". "#" "#" ":" " #""## "#" . 5"$ 2"<" " " 3###.<6%" 1#%"# "# "7 ##3"A.
E <3 8K H--.& "5":$ " #3 #33""# " "# "5 "# " 5" 3 #5#3 "" ## "#" . !. ;;;;;; @"%#A "55" 5""1 ""1$%" B #5"3.
D. I3 #%#A )*%" )/"'--+$!.;;;;;; @ E@"#3 "##5"2D/"'--+N ##"@ #3".
>. ?A#"$ "7:E/:.
(+,('--+ &0()*&
)
). / 3 "% /"" "##3 $# $E :$ %7 4 . 0, #" @#:" "# /""" '' #%37 )>H)&& '-0N .,*.) .#"#3"" "% )' 37)>D0& & 0)-9.
'. @ " > " ) #" 2" "3#" 4 # #5"##3#6%#" #3#7"& 2"&8)*-9 %#" "55 6 @ #" "# @2#" %" # ## @2#" $A" @" $ 2"%""% 4 .9 @2#" 2"%"7"4 .79.#=6"A #" #2#" "##E@ ")- 2"#E@ ")) 2"$ ##%#"%#""% #" "#@2#" 2"%""%$ "%3 %"7"$ A@" .
" "#" "# " #"$ @ " 0* 2" %#" A =55 2"A"$#@ %":#"$2 3"1 55 "% #5"# A" @" $ # #" E #"% "%" 4.'9. @="$@2#" #" %#" "5" 2#" "#@ ")-$")$#@ "))$")$ #"" 3 "% @ #% #" "# @2#" " ".?" 3 # A@2#" 3" #" "##%3 @ #" "#$"""3 " "3"# "5"E&" @% " A@E5 E@=" "$@ #" "# @2#" %#A4.H9.
@1$ !. ;;;;;; @ " 75" @ #" "# @2#" @ " )- # )) 2" # ## ""# " E # # 3: @= " @ . $ " " " < #" "# <2 #33 =55 " 3" "#3 3#6 <" #" %" 2" ', 3 )>>> 4? 9 " " ""# " ":"$ A" ##"1#3" #.
*. # 3 # " "#" 2". ""$ "1:A "*D"* H 2" ,'1:3 <2 "# 2"H3"'--04 2"&8)*-.-)9%"# "7 ##3"A # # """@:" " 3 .
H. . " 7$ " A$ #5#33 E /" # $ "7 3"" "5 #3 # 2 # J # " "#" #" #A<""AE5% "". <:" <2":A"#"""3 #" 5 #" #< "H>") # " "#5
(+,('--+ &,()*&
#5 "# " )D %" )>>> 4 .& ? )-)N (*')('--, )* /"'--, B " N.O!! ! $<%# "# # J /"" # " "#" #" #" :%#"$ K )>DD$ .)9. # 5#"$@# J# $""#@" "# #3 %"" @#7/ #$ B 4.!$#" 3"" "5$#.)$)>>H$.)-'P'.'.H.'9.
7. ""# " $E@# # $"A3 ##3" # %=" 2 " "# " *D " * H 2" ,' 2". " ": % "7 "" "#" E A "#.
0. . ?# @ " '+ " ) .$ "7 ##3"A : ". #3# 33 "7=#"2#5"#$"71E "%" ##3"A "%"% #"72"4 .'+.' .9. "7 # 1: # "%" ##3"A"%$2E " #5"# E # "# @ :" # @ % 4 K )'D )> #". H. . '>N !: #" 5 '- #%37 )>>, "5 E #% # " "#5$"KK)>>+).)+,9.
7. "75#2=55 2"" #" %#""7 ##3"A$3B3" "%" "3"A: #3"7"4B "75'.),+()>>>'03"'--- "C ? '--) . ,0N K )') )'> #". *7 . )*)N )-D )*0 #". * .)*,9. : #3" 7" B :3 @ N :" # "" "3" #37 "#3 %2 2" 3"75""" 33 . 33 @: #3" 7"$ @ #3 @2" #5"# =55 2" E @#7 "# @ #" "# # " 3 @2 # J 55" 7= @ "%" ##3"A A"$ 5# "# # "3# $ #= @ %"7". 2":%"#@ "'+ .3"# " 3 / "5" @" B 7" 4B "7 5 '.0,('--' )D /"'--'#".*.)NB "75'.),+()>>>" $#".'.9. #3E 5" 3"Q%#"% "" ## "#" 45. .0.' *,.* .9.
. # " "#@#" 5#3 #" B 5#7: 4 .*,.) .9$B / "5"" B 7"## "#@ #" 5#3 @ " 4 . *, . ' .9 L ## "# 7 %"4 .*,.* .9.@#" 5#3 2 "%"#74 .*, .H .9.
" @" B 7" #% / "5" " "# E "7 ##3"A$# #"" "# #" 3
(+,('--+ &+()*&
#"$3#" "A#"#3" " "# @ " B 7" 4 K )'0 *'' #". * . *',N B "7 5 '.>-('--0 )D %" '--,N (0->('--, )> 37 '--,N . (. ! (!. 8 $ #" # " "# "$ %#3 $ '--,$ P >+, $ . H0+9. ?# %= #="7 3#" "A##3"A## "#@#5"#A" % "7 # % 5%#" " 7= #5"# # " 5#3 @2#" "# 4 B "7 5 '.D*('--0 ', /%"'--,$#".'.* /"" 9.
. ?#""@:" " 3 # E 3B3 7= ##3"A # @ " '+ .$ # " " 3 A" " #"# #3 " "# # " $ @ &E&"A"# #4 K)*- ', #". ,.*.*.) . 0*9. # " 337 3B3 7= A" @ % 3B3 #55 3B3 7" # "5"3B37#".?# # " $ 2"%# ""#"#4.&K. $.! 8$ " #33 " # " "# 5 #5 "#")D%")>>>$.'--*$ .'+$.'*H$ P)+9. @:" " 3 # @ 7# #" "55$ E #" "# A &" # 7 :$ A@# E" 1#7/ "5 6 13"&3B3N" 3 2": A ":" "" " #" " 3""33 "# "7 @" B 7"#"%"4 K)'0H*)#". H7(.H*0&H*, /"" 9.
,. . 2 3@ "*D"* 2"$ 2"%"7"# " "5"7# 2 %="% # #5"# # # "A ": " " "5 : 3 . %="% # #5"## % # #"":" " "5.
7. @ " *D " H 2" %#" A 2" %" "% # A" 3 @ #3 =##R"#3 "A @ ": "# #3 3 F 2"G3"1E%" # #5"#7"% 2"%"7" "3#".#3# :3 3#" 3"2#55 3B35# "#A":3" 2" %"7"$%""7@2 "%=".A"3 # : 3 .
. @ ",' 2" " @": 3#"3"2# #"% B A" 2"%""%. "% C
S) 2"%""%# 3 "#F TGE@% E @"1%=".
(+,('--+ &D()*& '
3 "# # A $ 5"2 # # 3"1#" 3 $# 5#3 "% C
9 A @ "3"# '- 2 )- "31 $ #7=$7#N
79 E@" "$3# F TG "" #" @= + "31 . * A # # E #2"3" A 3"#:"A$#" "# 3 . H 2"%""%# A" 3#"3"2$5"2E @" " 2" # B %""7 @2 ". 3#" 3 @""A "5 "A $ # ""# 3 $" 3 %"32"3/#" " $# ""@ ",)$"'$ 7 . # 3 "# A " 2 " ' * " " . %7"" #"% @ ",,. , @55"=:F TG#" # 33 %""7 B "%="$3B3#A@"@ %". + 3#1 3#" 3"2 33 # : 3 .? "#3# ::%" #3#7" %": "# # #" E 3# (# 3#" 3"2N 33 3# "A@2#" %S.
+. . 2"##7/ @2"#5"# # # 3#6 %#" #3#7" 2#" "# %" 2"#5#3$# 33 22":" 7"A$ @%"#3 #6 "##33"""A@2 1: "%E@ "" "##3"7"4 .).) 2"9.
#"3#"%" 2"',3)>>>4? 9$ # 7 " @""#5"# 2"$1"#$)>>'$ 3 #373" "#3 $" E@ "# @"" " "% S# 2" :2S$ A" %" 3" #"3 "3# @2#" .
# #3"E: "#A" %" 2"$ A" %" # 33 # #"3 #37 2" #" "#3 4! '--*('--H$$.*)0H$*)++9.?##7/ "5 "" " "#@:3 "#" 2"3"
(+,('--+ &>()*&
"#3 $ 3" "%" "$#55 3" 1 2 2" % 3" "#3 5"" " 3#"3""522#" 3" "#3 4! $#." .$.*)>>9.
7. 2"#1" " "# 2"%""%$ 2" %"7"4 .*.* 2"9 "3#"4 .*.H 2"9.
2" %" 7" "# @ #" @: #3" 7" # "#3 "" A # @ "" "# %#" % 2 # 7" %#"E" "# " 4 .)>.' 2"9. #37 "3" 4 .'- 2"9.3"%"7" "%# "3 @ 2 "A " E 3"# #" "# #" #5"# =55 2" E : #37 3" 4 . ')$ '' 2"9.# #"% "" # #4 .*> .) 2"9 # #3"EU# "5""A4 .H'.) 2" ,D ,> 2"9.
#37 2"%""%@ "3" . " 2#37E 2"A 2"%"7". %=$" # #" E 5" : #3" 7" 4 . )> . ) 2"9. ## "75""" E :#@"#")>>> 7#" 4 2# 3# "5 E @" #/ #"$ . D)9$ # % @2 "# #" #"@ 4 .)>.0 2"9. @"% 2"%"7"$"@# @#7": "#@ # #$3" # "#3"EU# "5""A E "5" "AE2 2"%"7"4 .H' 2" ,D ,> 2"9.
. ?# ? $ 2" % 3" "#3 " 3" @ 7#7#/ 2A"@%" 3" "#3 %" 7#7# 7 4 . H) 1:3 @2 "# ? D 37 )>>>9. # #33 " @ " *D 2" !3#" #" A 2" % 3" "#3 A" " "#S7#7#S3".# $" " #" 6 13 3#"3"2A"#3 ""A "5# 2"5" :4 A"3 # JE" #"93""" 2" "7# #$ # "=55#A# @= %"% @##,3")>D) %" ## #5"#%=":55 # # %#" #"3#4 '&?D''.'''9.VWX" # "# 3#" 3"2#" :3 3 7"3"2 3"$#A 2" =$""&" "7##.3#M 2"3" "#3 % 5":"%#"7"3= #" #$"# @#" @:#3"7"$" " # : " 1 # #5"# #"7 % 2"
(+,('--+ &)-()*&
%3" "#3 $3""%"3#".VWX "$ 2" 3" "#3 # "# E B ": #33 2"$ 3" " " #" @ 3" 3"1 # " ":# #33 2"$ A@ #5"# #" #"7 % 2" % 3" "#3 . "55 # S7#7#S L /#@=" "55" E 3B= #5"#. 2" 3" "#3 %# # 5#" 2 " #3# 3B3 3#" 3"2$ 7 # J # "# 7" 4! '--*& '--H$$.*)H0$*'*+&*'*D9.
"" 2 : 7 #"%"#"A " *D"* H 2" ,' 2"%" E" " # # 7#7# #" 2"%""%.
D. 3#M " "#"3#2%="%""% 5": E @ " *D 2"$ @2": 7 : "5" . E @ ",' 2"$"@2":#%E@: 2" %" "%3""A"3 %#". 1#: "##3 # E@ "*D 2". #" "#7: #"$A# @" # .
>. #%" 3""$5 #" 2 2"%""% @# 7#7# 3" #" 2": 2&" @" "# 3#" 3"2 E @" " %="$ 2" # 1:3 @2 "## E" B 7".
)-. :" "# 2" $ " "#3 "$==E "A 2"%""%$#"%" #7 #" "A ##3"A#="7 .
@#$ " # 2" A 2" %" 7" # #: "% $ ""$#" @:#3" 7"3"# #3"E% :# " . #=" A 2" %"7" 2%""%" B " ": " "5" 7 # "#7"$ 2"#E" B 7".3B3$ 2": A 2" %" "% #" A" 3#" 3"2$ 2"#7 3 3"# J#5"#. #" ""7 @" B 7". E23""3$#" @" " "# #7#7# #" @" "# 3#"3"2E@" " %="$# ## "#.
)). ""## "#" 2":A<3 " "%#" E #" #3 A 2&" " B " 33#""""%N# $"" " # "3" "# &E7
(+,('--+ &))()*&
%" " 2": # "#7 "&" " B 7" # "%#3#3"4 K)',')>#".'.''' 5" 9.
)'. 7#7## #" # " ":" " "5$ " "A %=" ""#33 2".
@" " "#$ " " " *D " * H 2" ,' 2"$ @# 7#7# #" 2" %" "% 3 A" 3 @# " " "# %=" 3 @ "7 ==.
# 5#"$#5#33 2 "*D"* 2" ,* 2"$ 2"%"7"#"% %#"#"#/ " # "1 #"% B 3" @ 7 3". # "A #7": #" # @"33 " "# %=" 2" 5 1 @ %":#"$ "A$#%="/E"33 "#%=" 5% B "33 "1@ %":#"$3"6 5" @#7/ @#3353 5"" "%% # %":$# "A #7": #"1""A4 .0>.' 2"9. E 23"# " "#" @ "*D"* 2"$ "75 /: @2": # " "A #5#3 E @ " '+ . 4B "75'.D*('--0',/%"'--,9.
@ "55 # 7#7#$ 2" %" 7" %# @" "5"$ @"" '-)-$ # / 7 3" " # "1. # "" #"7 " A"## "3 " ": 2"%""%.@#7": "# # "A 3 #$ E $ @%" #5"# :#"%=".3#2 2"%""%3# : 7#7## #" 1#2"5 %&EA" "# "7 %".
#A $@" " "#7#7#3" #" # 2"%""%#" B #"#33"## "#.
)*. @" " "#@# 7#7# #" "## "#$ A "# @" "# 3#" 3"2 E @" " %=" @ "@B $2&"#% B "E7#7#.
)H. %A"1$#3" ""#? )) 37'--,.3#3 8K)@---.&3"E =: 3 $ A" #37 "3" # 8K ,--.& ## E=:@ 1%4 .D+ 9. YYYYY
(+,('--+ &)'()*&
&( )
*+,-. /
%7#" / )-/%"'--+!#";;;;;;# ""# %" #" "# $ 3 @##3" ))37'--,N
,-!/
@3 N
""#%" #" "# N
3 E=: 3 3#3 8K)@---.&N
## "3" # 8K,--.&E=:@ 1%N
" A$ #5#33 2 " D' "% #" 5 "7 5 )+ /" '--0 4 K&? )+*.))-9$ B B # /# A" "% # "5" "# &% "7 5$ %#" #3 "1#" 7"N33#"##" ""A#"#$ 3# "5 3#6% # ": # ##3 "N" #" B "7 5$ )--- )H$ %#" # # %#" #"A 2 #" "# @ " H' K. B "1 #"# # $ "%#A #33 3#6 %$ #"% B /#" E @%#"N
#33"A B E ! " "#$ %# # "" A@ 3 @##3" .
?": C !3#%6$" $!.6=1$!. ="$!3#$/:$ !.#R"$/:
#3 "73"" "5C
"&/" C %"&" C .#" .#%6
(+,('--+ &)*()*&
#"#5#3 B #33"A2 ".
1%$ :55"1C
(+,('--+