Breach of Contract and Tortious Interference Claims Rejected
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case involves a dispute over whether certain actions constituted a breach of contract and/or tortious interference. The court determined that the evidence did not support a finding that the defendant breached a contractual obligation, as the terms of the agreement were not violated by the challenged conduct. Furthermore, the court reasoned that for a claim of tortious interference to stand, there must be a showing of improper means or a wrongful purpose, and the defendant's actions were found to be within the permissible scope of business competition or otherwise lawful under the circumstances presented, leading to the rejection of all claims.
Regesto Legislator
Ufficiale; AMÉNAGEMENT DU TERRITOIRE ; ZONE AGRICOLE ; CONSTRUCTION ET INSTALLATION ; CONFORMITÉ À LA ZONE ; ORDRE DE DÉMOLITION | Rejet d'un recours contre un ordre de démolition d'un cabanon sur pilotis d'une surface de plancher de 16 m2 avec terrasse de 10 m2 édifié sans autorisation en zone agricole. L'ordre de démolition de la construction non autorisée est conforme au principe de proportionnalité. | LCI.129.let4 ; LAT.16a ; LaLAT.20
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAProvision cited for the decision on court costs.
Testo completo
!
"#$! %!&"$#'( )* !"#$ "
!
+* ,, , ' ', , , )''( , , - ' '
%&'(%
,
,- ./!""01!"!/!2/$ !" " ,3&3#0",4!$$1""- "&&.+3*$& " 5! 2"! " ,* !" 0 .$2$ " !"&&6",(4(7 %84++9 &+!"." "!!" 0 .$2$ " !" ) 6" ,(:4 7 % , 3+9- ;"%0! <!" 1!"%!"!2/$#2" #$$; ./!""#="> "?! $$ ?"20,&.&+)$&-
&- &&0?"&++*#!.! @00 " !" ! "! $ ! "! /!!2" ."0!$ "!7"%AB 9#" ! =.;!;!""! "# . 0 / ,* $& ? ,+ $&# ?" "0" #? ;!= #=. !" "!! " ." ="- 8! !" /! !2/"=# ;! "! < ! %0C !? ""=. " 0C " ! !" -
! ."0 "! 7'3*(+9 ?!> 3 $ &++* D 1$ /AE# $$;./!""-
3- &4$&++*#1-!2/$0" ?"#." $"". " " ;? .?! $!> .!" "! !"# $" "! 6 ."0 "!-
$" " "0" "AF+ #$" " ;$ ="" " "";-;!" "2"< ?" !; $ 0".> !$ "<"D ?"2 " .""# D " !? ?2# ==2!" ?"!2 "!- ! ;!0!"#"?" =. !" "! ; " " ! ! "! < "$"! " $! - ; " !0!$ D 00 "! 2"! ?" !G EH&+.+++-%#!$ 0"." "!-
)- ""! ) ?" &++*# !! D 1- !2/$ =" !" "!! "-
3+ ?"&++*#1- !2/$! $. !" "! !!! "!.;!D "" "!2"!-
F- &3$"&++*#?"0!C # >2?" !;? "!- &( $" &++*# !$$ 1"" ?" 0?!; D =C - : !G &++*# ?" .2"
')*+,'&++* %3'(%
?" 0?!;# .$2$ . " < ;!" .<!" "!2"!= -?"" "!.$2$ " !",&! !;&++* " 2$ 0?!;#"!."$ 2 "0>2 .;" -
*- * !?$; &++*# 0 . !" "! !""
7 &*)(*%,9 ! ?" 2 "0 " "! .$2$ " !" ?".2" -
$C$ "# ""! ""= ! !" &*)(* '3*(+ ! "0"D1-!2/$#= !!" $!" "!;!" "2"<"!"< 6!-
< ""! ""=" ?!" ! "?$ D !$$""! !!$ "A! "!7"%AB 1 9 ";$"" "0-
4- ! " "=#! F$;&++*#1-!2/$ !A 1 ""=.A ";$"" "0! I ""! * !?$; &++* 7!" &*)(* '3*(+9I ! D. "!" ""!I =.!!$!" "! ;!I-
.00 "! ;! " "" 2 "!" "! 2" 5!2"!-! "!" "2"?" C !"ID ! $!"I- ";?" ""! ! "" " "! -
! # " " ! $ "!! "! .!! $!" "! ;!#?"!?" $6=!"!" - ! "! .?" "">2-
:- ,, 6?" &++4# "; $"" "0 ." "! !. ."!" " 1 -
(- 1 ! D." "! ",+$"&++4- ! D ."?;"" ! =" . " ""2 = ! ""! !! $!" "! ! ! ""! 0- 1-!2/$ ""= = 2 2 ! "A ! ( /2 " "? D ""! 0- ?" ?" .2" .?" " !$ ?!! 0" ! D 2 "!$""=$ .00 "! =@ .! "2- ""! " 0!0" "!$ -
')*+,'&++* %)'(%
,+- ""!&)$"&++4# 1 . "!$ ! !J ! ! ""! * !?$; &++* ! $".!00" ";$"" "0-
8! 1 # ""! 0 . !" "! $C$ 6! 0"" .!;6 . !- !"! " ! ?"" "=$ .!$!" "!-
,,- ""! 3 6" &++4# "; $"" "0 6!" < !-
,&- &+6" &++4# !6 !-
;! % =" ?" C ="0" ;! KL% ? $2$ 00 #! $$ ?5!;;%?" "2 !" "!-.!$!" "! " 0!!""-
A !% !"; ;! ?" / $"A 0"" "? ""! * !?$; &++*- .! " 2$ ""!! "!" #." C ;" ;"$ . " "! !0!$ !" "$" ." C "? 1- !2/$ D !? "!;!" "2"<-
, '
,- - < ""! ! ! "0" !6!" $ D 1- !2/$ # . ! 0 . !" "! ! " . !$!" "!-
. !!A 1 ="!A "; $"" "0 .""= "$ ." ! . ! . ! ! < ""!- $ "! "=$ < ! ="2 # '&*)(* '3*(+-
! ! " ! !"! < 0"2 "A 2 =" ! "=$ .! $!" "!- $! "0"?!=! ""!. !" "!! "= $!" "!- H"$ # < ""! 0"2 /2 "A# . ! $! , 7! $!" "!9 . $! ( 70 . !" "!! "9-
0" #= "!?!""!! "=$ .! $!" "! ! 2$ ""! 0 . !" "! ! " !" C <$"-
')*+,'&++* %F'(%
1 !D!$ "!! " 62 =!! " =.!$!" "! . $" "; !"!!$ -
;- ! . ! ! ""! ."?;"" - ! 0!"# ! " > $" 1 # "; $"" "0<$".!00"!$ -
! !$! .$;"2M "D "! ! $$ D"";"""! -$!"# !$ !"!<"! 0" =." $ " !0"!$ ="0"# 0! ! =" "2!"=!;6 .!$!" "!-
- . " ,)F " , !" ! "! " "! "? ,) ?" ,(:: 7 % F +F9 ?!" = ! ""! " $ " "! " !" ! A2$ C ! ? !$$""! !- ! 0!"# . " ,F+ ?!" ! ";$"" "0 ?< " !" "!-
6 $ " ? "; $"" "0# ! ! .! $!" "! * !?$; &++* ?; 7 - F* !" .!2" "!6"""&&!?$;,(),%% &+FN -*3-," - !"!$"" "?,& $;,(:F% % F,+9-
&- 8! . " , " , # # ! " !" !# >?!" !"#? ! ! "! "!! " "!-
3- $ !!.? "!7 -,&( -; 9#$" # "!#$!"0" "!#"!!$!" "!7 -,&( - 9D.2! "!#" "!!. /!="! !0!$<" "! #A2$ ! !" "! "?" "!"!" "!2!2$ "7 -,3+ 9-
# ! C ?;# ! $" !0!$" !" # " "! "" !! "!" ;! 0!"# !" "! "? 7 H ,,, ; &&, !"- * 6" " N 'FF,'&++F,*!G &++F 0" 9B
• .!!" C ""2! ; 7 H,+4&39N
• " "!!"? ?!" !";? !" ?"2$!$ " "!7 H,+);3+)N '&34'&++4 ,F-+F-&++49N
')*+,'&++* %*'(%
• " !" .C ! " .< "! ?<" "2"<7 H,+4,&,O ,(:3&((9N
• . !" !" ?!"/5.$"" !%!$# "0!$ "!# ! !$! $ % < "?# !" "! =." """;!0!"7 H,,4 &:4 !"- &; 6" " N - &30?" ,((3 !0"$ H ! ;" &, $; ,((3N - P # " !" $"" "0#)A$-#,((,#QF+(#-,+:9N
• ." C ;" ;"$ . " "! !0!$ !" !" .$! ." C "? ." $" " " "! " "2"N
• ;"$ . " !" ! " "!!% "!!" !" ! -
)- 0. !" "!! ". " "2"<# ""! ? 0"" "?- $!"# .; A !"; ! "! <$" "%!# .2" . !" "! .!$!" "!-
- 5!2"!? D2 ";.!?""!$ > D!2 $#D?2>2 $ D .="";!!2"=N. !=!"#?" C $" = !";"; ! ! "!-
8! !0!$ D .00 "! 5! 2"! ! "! " "!="! "D.<!" "!2"!7 -,*-, 9- ! "! " "! =" ? ?!$ " . <!" "! 2"! !0!$ D .00 "! 5! 7 - ,* - & 9-
. "&+ #! !"5!2"!= ! "! " "!="! ";$ D "?" < !.<R D " "" =" >2"" = !" "! 0"< " 3) "? .!! .$2$ " !"&:6"&+++7 %84++-,9-
. " 3) " = ? C !" ! "! " "!="? D? !" 2"!"! "D .<!" "!#"" C ! .>!! ." ?"";= .<!" "!!;" D!2 $7 -3)-3 ) 9-
;- ;!" "2"<#<"! #!;?! "!-!" C ""! !$ "! ?"2 #
')*+,'&++* %4'(%
?2#?"D!2"2 "!!2!" ?"-8! ! "! 0" # ! 2 " @ "0# !?." "!;;-
.A# " ! "! ;! ! .<!" "! 2"! ! . $! - ! .2" ; D ! "#. "&)( A2$ ! "! " "!"? &40?",(4:7 %F+F-+,9?!" =? C !D;" " = ; D ! " $!?";# 0C "$"! A $! "<"?$ 2$ .! "- D. "" "! ;!!!2"2 "! "!?2# !<<"2$ "!"%-!="A= ;!. !0!$D.00 "!5!2"!-
- ?!"!2 !" !. "&) # !" "!? C "? ! !? ! "! ! " "! ! ! ! /2$ .00 "! " ."$ "! ! "! ! " "! /!5!D;S " "$! " "!7 -9 "" C ! .> !! 7 - ;9- !" "! ! $ "? 7 C ";0, -&*'&++3&&?"&++3#!"-F9-
8! 6"# ! =. ! "! !" "$! " "!#"0 !6!="!!;6 "? /"=#!!$"=! ! !0"2 "!!#6 "0" " "!.!?2!6 D .$$ ?- .> " !$ "! ;6 "?!!" "!!?!! 7 H ,&3)((-3;'-F+:N '(4+'&++),)$;&++)N ')F&'&++& &4!G &++&9-
.A#. "" "!! ;!!!$!?!"!% "!?" "!! =.2. !$ ";?<"2 2# ! $$ ? ."$ "! /! 5! D ;S " =" !" C "$! " "!- 0" # = "! ?!" " "?" A! " "0 !? -
?="A#;!. !";#. D;!!" = . !" 0! ?" ?" .2" " "!.$2$ " !"-
F- ! .!! D .! $!" "!# =." "$ "!! "!- !G ;! ?# $!" "! J" 0""A"$! -
- ! "!"/!5!D;S " !!0!$D.00 "! 5! ?"! 0!$ $ !" 0 .$2$
')*+,'&++* %:'(%
" !" !"? C $!" 7- T %HH ' - U% # $2$ " !"# ! "! <!" "!# &++,# -)&* 9- "! 5! D ;S " 5! "! "; "" " .$2$ ="# /! < "! ? !"# !" $." "! " 7 H,,,;&,3!"-*;-&&F9-
;- 8! 6"# .! $!" ! "! ! !?2 "0"$" != !" "!!?" C !. ""! """!! "!" - "=". !" ? 0" !$"!" . D=%"!? 2 ;" " "! !0!$ !" = "!?" =" ! !! 7 H,+:&,*!"-)-&,:9-
- .! $!" "! ! D " ; ?" $ $!""""?$ . "; -
?="A#." C ;"D ;"" "!!0!$ !" .$! $"0 $ ." C "? $ !!$"= ! -
*- - !=#!6 ""! !0"$-
;- $!$ EH ,.+++-% $" D /2 ! 7 - :4 9- VVVVV
* ,' ,
./&0 1!2
?; ! " 6 F $; &++* 1!" %!" !2/$! ""! $ ! "! /!!2" ."0!$ "!*!?$;&++*N
&0"2
6 N
$ D/2! $!$ EH,.+++-%N
" =# !0!$$ < " :& "? !" 0 "; 0 ,4 6" &++F 7 H%8 ,43-,,+9# C C ! 6! =" "? ! "0" "! %? "; 0# ?!"
')*+,'&++* %('(%
!$ "A!" ;"N$$!"!!" ""=!"!# $! "0 $!>? ! "2 ! !!$ "N" !" C "; 0# ,+++ ,)# ?!" ! ! ?!" !"= < !" "! . " )& H- C "A !"! ! # "?!= !$$ $!> ?# !"? C 6!" D .?!"N
!$$"= C D !"#$ "1-%!"!2/$ ""=. $ ! "! /!!2"."0!$ "!-
8"2 B 1->/A#" #1$!?> E"#1- /"#1$!# 62-
!$ ";$"" "0B
200"A%6" B " B -"!%8"2" H->/A
!"!0!$ C !$$"=< "-
A?# 200"AB
')*+,'&++*