Contractual Limitation of Liability Enforceability
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe dispute concerned the enforceability of a provision in a governing document that purported to limit the liability of a party for certain types of damages arising from a contract, despite a claim that the limitation was unconscionable and unenforceable. The court reasoned that the specific provision was not unconscionable because it was a bargained-for allocation of risk between sophisticated parties, there was no procedural unconscionability based on fine print or fine print, and the substantive terms, while excluding certain damages, were not so one-sided as to shock the conscience, thus upholding the contractual limitation of liability.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Contractual Limitation of Liability Enforceability: The court reasoned that the specific provision was not unconscionable because it was a bargained-for allocation of risk between sophisticated parties, there was no procedural unconscionability based on fine print or fine print, and the substantive terms, while excluding certain damages, were not so one-sided as to shock the conscience, thus upholding the contractual limitation of liability.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in order 3) to regulate the costs of the proceedings.
Cited in order 4) concerning the allocation of costs, related to the legal aid request.
Testo completo
!"
#$!%!&"'(
'(%!)*++++++++++
, -- - .-/ 0.-- ,. ,
!"#
-
+ 05+ ( 64 47+ 48) (9 /+ (::'.+;47+<77=+!>+(::%. ++?=4+3+=+34/++/)
47+<77+04@?+;!!3/;!&&()
$) 3+ /;+ 3+5+ 6+ 42A B 8
) (&3/;!&&&.B ++04/++4 0 ? /+ 1 + ? 3++ +5++ /+ C D0++ 43+?+)
;) !# 4/; !&&$. + 4/+ ? 0 += /+ 00
?0;+006(.9:5)"8)
) !$ >3+ !&&'. B +0 4/+ + *)
3=?(.E$5)"3+3+0+5++/+)
) E F !&&'. + 4/+ + 00 40 4 0 +0/+0) 44 ?=4+ ?+0 /0+ 4C<5+3+3+1+4+1+?30<+1 /)
') 94/;!&&'.04/>+.4+0+06+ 42A
?++ ?=4+ 3+ =+ 3 4/+ +/) 0+00+/4+1?+0040/+)
0/+0 4 4/ ? 3) + + 4/+ +.+0+1?+4;+@)3+4++53+0 +40+@4/+++++0/+ @+ +3) /+ @? +2 < + + 0) 3+ 00 /04+2+7+14>0+4 /+);3+4)
"!#$%"!&&' $"#
?++ ?=4+ 3+ =+ 3 4/+ +/ ++ @47+<77+043/4C0+0+ ++)?+0040+44/++05+(. 0+1+?=+)
?.$&0/;!&&')3++00++++5+1 !0/;!&&')4++4/+.+;3+4?. .37/+.+0++04?G4+500)
++4=+4+4?)*H/71404+ + 0. 43+ ?+ 1 + =+) /43++;)
?++40 00<5?0+) ?++ +3++ /0+ 05 3+ 44 ++@ @ *)
+0 4/+ + 4 0 (9 /+. +@ /+ (: > + 1 45) / +0+ 3+ 00 7/0 B )
B 3+/+7+00++.0+C007+=01(!/++
?/0+.!#4/; !&&$) 3+4/+ +0;/+>+!&&E)
(&) (( 3+ !&&E. 04/ /+ 0++) *H/ +
0+0+ +7+ ? 0+ 4 /+7+0) ++ ?<;++0 0+ 1 ?;+ ? 47+ <77 +04 3 /4C0 1 ?++ ?=4+ 3+ =+34/++/?0+4/4+)
-0
() >0 /4 + 3 >+++ /40. 3; 6) E# + I5++ >+++ !! 3/; (:'( !&EJ)#$)(+)+40/+++3(! 4/;(:9E E(&8)
"!#$%"!&&' '"#
!) ) !(>3+!&&E. +53+403+ =++/+6447+4/C3+ /;+8 0 3+5 (E /+ !&&E 6 =+ K G ( $&8) 3 =;50+3+=+!#/(:::6 =+8)
2/.25/?=0++3+=+ 90/;(:::00;50425/?=0+ =+.'/+ !&&E6 =+KG($&)&(8)
;) /+7++ 05++3 + . + 0++ 4 ;> 0@ >++@ I /4/ I 030/ 40.I++44+;)@I+I5+07++05+/>++@ 7.05++;A4=/4.I+I ++4+.4;2/+770)>+4. ?; +4++ 05. I+0 44+@ / 3+5>L6 !&&&4)$9$)J "%(9"!&&$$& 4/; !&&$J "%9'"!&&! (& 0/; !&&!J "#'&"!&&& !' ;!&&& J ) M. 0 /+++3. !&&&. 4) (:# J ) *.+/+++7.(::'.3)4)(%'1(%#8)
) B?5++4++4+;?0+0 4;+. 3 + +/ 44+;. C /4+ 4 7+ 0+103+56 "'&$"!&&'(9/+!&&'8)
?42. 3 +4++ 05++3 05/+ +4+4++++03+?+ + ?=4+ 3+ =+ 3 4/+ +/ + ?47+<77+043/4C0)
0++ ++5+ 0 70 +4++ 05 ?<;++0. ; ? 0+0 4;+. +; /+++7 44+@ +/ 3 +. ++ @ 25/ ?44++)
$) ) B?+#+0! =+.47+<7 7=+4H0+30@@@0775+ /+0/4/77+)
;) ?+ $ =+. ++0 N=/ @H 0+3 47+O ++@. 1 +0 $. @ 04/ 4 // +0 @ 5+ /+0 /4/ 77+ 4 77 4 4 @+. + 400 04P @H.+0?0;+00@+7+0?+EE+0# +700+++2(:0/;(:E96 B%'()&(J )$)$); =+8
"!#$%"!&&' E"#
) 4 7/+. +4++ + 1 ?/+++ 5 43+ ?440++ 4 7+ ?;> @ ? P >+++ +/+0)
+4004040H)2.?1> +@04/0@++0+1?;+ ?0+4/4+@?+40+6)$( =+8)
') ?++?=4+3+=+34/++/ 0+?H4?47+<77=++04 6) # (E =+J ) 9 ) ! ) =+8) 2 . + 47+ + +/40+3/ D + ?++ ?=4+3+=+)
E) 3@+402.>0)0//40.
8)
.-0 -
1 23')$!4
0++04/>+.4+0+0!$3/;!&&'J
23'(4
>J
/1<50// G,$&&) J
>+.4+0+0)
B+05A */3C.40+.)C<2. <0+.>5)
"!#$%"!&&' #"#
/ +;/+++7A
577+2 >+>)A 3+ 40+A *) + )3C
4+7/H00//+@0=4+)
23. 577+2A
"!#$%"!&&'