Indemnity Clause Enforceability for Self-Negligence
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case addresses whether a party could enforce a contractual indemnity provision against another party concerning liability arising from the other party's own actions, even when the first party's conduct was also deemed negligent or a proximate cause of the loss. The court reasoned that an indemnity agreement, even if broad, generally will not be construed to cover the indemnitee's sole negligence unless the contract expressly and unequivocally states that intent, as enforcing such a clause to cover one's own fault would contradict public policy favoring responsible conduct.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 LTF; Indemnity Clause Enforceability for Self-Negligence: The court reasoned that an indemnity agreement, even if broad, generally will not be construed to cover the indemnitee's sole negligence unless the contract expressly and unequivocally states that intent, as enforcing such a clause to cover one's own fault would contradict public policy favoring responsible conduct.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAApplied for the allocation of costs following the outcome of the appeal.
Applied for the decision regarding the distribution of costs.
Testo completo
!"
#$ #%# & ! ""#$%#
#
'! ( )*!+,# '!-).(!# '! + # /) !"(0 # /) !"".# '!1*" !((#2 1 /) !"3 !'#2 1 '! ( "2 /) !" " .2
.+. -# 1 4 $ #-# ! "!#"$%#
$# #$ # $# 5 $# $ #
6- #
&'()*&+,,- .'&(,.
(/ 0#" "#12#3 45".670#" "#89#" :"; < 6#"$=>+-+$?" -+ #;; ##@."%$ " + A;" #". $ #" !#" .
!"A :B/
+/ :".?# #;#0?" -6;C## "# 0 C# :#" ?#3 $ D" #; : E#9 =>+-($#" !"F:"@@$%" G:$" <0 ##:#"(-9+,;6 "#. /
'/ ## #.G"# #" " "%; %#""=H,,'$H,,)$H,,-$H,,> >I)-/
)/ %" ?#3 $ # "# B@ ; 5".67%"8$?" #$#=>+-+$ % ""6 ?#3 $ #% +- #%;: +,,' 0" # ?#3 5".67 0" 8/ J : E#9 =>+-( #"#;;?#3 /
-/ (' # #: +,,)$ 0#" "# # D3 #" "# # "5)->&(8# #% "#:K "; " =>+-+ 09 "#L"@/
>/ +I # #: +,,)$ D3 #" "# :" 2"0%"#??""5".672 8/
I/ (H#%;:+,,)$!;G" ; <0" # < :" "# D3 # "# ?# "6 "%<=>+-+/
H/ D3 # "# ?# "6 2 ' ;:+,,)/
*/ #"',;:+,,)$!;G"# ";" "# ""6?#3 #%+-#%;:+,,'0" $." ## $< C#:#" ?#3 / ;<0" #"#" "#/
(,/ #IE%"+,,-$0" %D1# "; 9 ??"; "# M!; G"N$ %@ "# :# MN #" $ " :# M=>+-+N$ 0 A" #;# 0
&'()*&+,,- .)&(,.
""@6/ %@ "# ;3;D#;# "?# "6$ ;"" $";"#$3 ";"< ?# "64/
((/ ""# ;3; E#$ ; " #" 5".67 8$ "; $ # ?# "6 " =>+-+$ #@ # +- #%;: +,,' 0" #%""6?#3 / 9?#3 ##:#" (- 9 +, ;6 $ " C# :#" ?#3 $ #. D "#/?#3 " #;#0""@65A3 ?""%8 K@-, 0 @" ;""0:/J#@#% " I, O #.:#" " / @; " 3 6 ";# P@" B@6 ; #" "@"?" "?#" %1 B@4/
(+/ ' ?%" +,,-$ ## #.G" # " E # < 0# ""# 6 #;;""# # ; "6 # "# 5".67 ! 8$ "; D0 "# #:E "%E "?"" 0 ";" C#:#" ?#3 /
('/ I?%"+,,-$# 6%#<0# ""#" $# "" <D # " ? =>+-+" C#:#" ?#3 $#" # D?#3 /
()/ H ; +,,-$ 0#" "# ;" #:% "# < ! E 9#/ #" <#?"; "#""# D/ 0 $ # "# ?# "6 %" D" 0#E ;"#?#;" 9#;";#0 #" :K "; 9#" 0 $ # #"%" "D; " 3 "%$# D""# " :"?#/
(-/ "#; "## ! "(+;" +,,-/ "% # # " #"#$ # 6% ";D;#Q# "#?? $B :# "< ""#D$##" <0;"C#:#" ?#3 $ ?"A; %" "; #/ ##$ 0%" # 0 " < 0 ?# "6$ ;3; D #" " %#"" # %#" # " 1?"A; " ; "?4/
(>/ (>E"+,,-$ ! ?? # / # ""D 10##:#"R # # " @:$""D " $# "" #% ?" 4/ 0" ;" D " #; #;; ?#3 ## :#"D "#1M0 " N9$;" # ?#"#"1D00 $ M%" N3 4/
&'()*&+,,- .-&(,.
(I/ ""#+HE" +,,-$ ! ##E# "#/ ?"A; 0%" "/#D D "#D" " < # " %#""# "# ?# "6?? " #?#; < " 9 "" #"/ # " # "# ?? ! D ## :#" D "# 0%" %## "; : 0 "#; A# "#/ " #;#0:06""@6";"" <9D" #%" " #" #;; ?#3 ""# "/ : " "?? $ D" #"" ;"6 #"$ #" < #" / #D $ ""# D %" 3 "; # "; ;"/0 ?# "6 D";" <0 " #?"; ""# D %" 3 #; " #; C#?# "6##:#"$?+,9(-;6 $ " #. ."/
(H/ S ": (+ ;: +,,-$ 0#" "# # # ""# ! " / # " D "#D9: " " ###" #;; ?#3 ! / 0@"" 0 A3 ; D" " "; : / # %" # ; 0 #" "# # "/ 0 # 9 D0 %" #"" # # "# ?# "6/0" "# ! " # "9 "#" "# @ ": < C#/ # #" < #?"; "#""# /
(*/ () # #: +,,-$ !; !/ G"$ !; ;". # !/ T" #$!; ": A #$!; " !/! #$!; !/#T"@# #/# #E #%" ?" <0 "#""# / "6" <0# : ?"9 #"$ < %#" 0 #% "# ";#" ?# " # #"% ;" %/ ; 0: ## :#" " #;#06""@6";""<D" #%" " #" #;; ?#3 / " ?9 0??"; D 9 : " #09 "#?#3 /
+,/ # #:% "#(I# #:+,,-/ " @; %% ! # E #%" ?" /
+(/ ;3;E#$ ?" #:% "#/ # " D ""# ! " 0;"# "#?#3 $" 0 # " < 0" "# ": E :".?# #/
++/ JD#"$ @<E@/
&'()*&+,,- .>&(,.
#
(/ E ; " % E"" "# #; $ # %:5 /-> #"0#@" "#E"""++#%;:(*)(. . +,-U />'/(" /#"#;"" "%(+ ;:(*H-. . -(,8/
+/ ""%@ D"?" "#:#"; ##(-9+, ;6 ":#=>+-+ E#9 =>I)-/
'/ #" ? ?#3 $ ) # #: (( 5J *+(/, . 2#8 %" < #% "# ?#3 " "# @#@A"D$ < # @ D ;"" < @ " DP " ;"?# "#$# ;; # "$#" ##;"D <;" " #;#%#"P##;"?# "6/@" "#$# $# : # ":<# @# "# :"P%# :# %A$ @"; "$ P#"# A " 5 #A 8/
)/ / ?#3 # # ?#% P:#P: ?# "< ;3;P9?# "#?# "6/#"@"$;#P9#" "# ; "#@" ?#"# " 5 /+/(2#8/
# #" #;; ?#3 @# P: # P: "#$ A"$ $ E"$ % 5 / + / ' 2#8/
:/ ?"9 #" ?$ # % " @$? PK@;"";9D#" %#"; ? #D"?#3 ""D@ ?;"";D#" %#" ; # 3 #" #;; ?#3 5 / + / )$ (6 A/ 2#U / ( / ( P## ?#3 ', #%;: (+ V 2# V J *+(/,(8/
/ J" ; ;" ?# "# #" # # " ""6; ";# $" 6 #9# ;" " #" #;; ?#3 ";; ?$ @ # #K@5 /+/)$+A/2#U /(/+2#8/
/ " 6 D " "? D # % ?"9$ ";" P "("(2#$% <"?"# "#D" "%?#3 # #" ?/ J? "# ""6$ ?# "6 #" 3 ##D" 6D " "?# "?" $# D" # " ";"";9/ # ?#""D" ?#3 "; ?" D " # " / " 6 D " "? #"% # " # "# D" "% ?#3 $ # %" # 5 3
&'()*&+,,- .I&(,.
":?( /I(&+,,++>#W +,,+$/'/+U &)'>&+,,- 3 " 8/
-/ 6%$ #" ?#3 $ +, ;" (, 5! - (, . 2#3 8 #"6 #;; ?#3 ; :#" # " "D D" "% P ?#3 $ 9S ?# "# ?# "6 # 9" 6"% 7
83 $""$K@P;#"(-U
:8P ?P;#"-,,;X
8%#"@;"";(+;/$""6#"#;"5 /+ /(2#3 8/
@##"@; P:"# ""D " C#%# #"#;;?#3 5 /+/' / 2#3 8/
>/ 2# 2#3 P;6 " "D"# #%#"D"?"":#"?#3 /
J#P9#;# "? "?<P "+$"'$ 2#3 $# 9@";?# "; B@ ;D"% # @$ " ; ?# "5!;#". #"$(I$/>,>8/
2# P: # P: ?# " < ;3; P9 ?# "# ?# "6 ?"" D" ?# "/ # $ " #%" ?<P9*P### "#%@ 9 +H?%"+,,(5.J*(>/+,8D" ;" @ 9:?# "/ 9 B"D; ""@6PE# #B#B#"$#B ""&;""D"# #"#;; : : ?# "$D# DP"#" ?#3 /
I/ ?# "6 # P # ?#;/ #?#;; < P " ) 2#3 $ " " < P" ?#3 "":".?##" 3 ###"#;;?#3 /
# "# ?# "6 #" PB "D; "# ?" 5#"$ " $ K@$ ";"# ?# "# ; 8$# ?#3 D " #" ? $A $ " 6D#" #P9 "# ;":P " + " ) 2#/ PB # "# < ?" % " 3 "% D" " #A # P " 3 :" 5 (H -,($ #"/ '8/ ; ;" # P" "# # %@ "# ?? "%
&'()*&+,,- .H&(,.
?# "#;#; ""#$# D; P" ";""@; 5Y/./ $#D:A ?#3 7 @"< %#%@" "#?#3 $"A"P%"#; $ =+(,$2 2()$ /(,$/)I8/
H/ J#P ">("( $# 3 ?#;#%"# "# #" B #;" P96 P: #%#" P" "# "" D # # "#"9 #"#;6 ?" " /
/ 0 #" ##" P";# " D" ?# "# <# " < A" "@5 &>)*&+,,+-#%;:+,,+8/ ""$ ! D"$ $;3;#%#"#@" "#D ":;"" "? $ # "; < E"" "#$ #;# # "" #9# R A"DD"."5 /(I# #: (,8/
P6$ ! $B "#%#"09;$# < # / %"?""# #PD "## ""#D%" "/
:/ ""# D $ B 9 ?#3 ## :#" " "@"9$ # ?# "6 " = >+-+/ "6 " #;# 0 ""@6 5A3 ?" "%8 K@-, 0 @" ;""0:/J#@#% " I, O #.:#" " / @; " 3 6 ";# P@" B@6 ; #" "@"?" "?#" %1 B@4/
/ %A "; 3 P ; ?# "6 ? " "@" +, 9 (- ;6 / 0" ;"$# # ! $D"#; D" ?#3 ## :#" D "# 1 0 " 9 4$ ;" # ?#" #" D0 0 $ 1 %" 3 4/ 9" "#0%" ;# "%""#/
/ # "; < 0@ # $ ! #" D0" 0B %" ?"A; ##:#"" "@"9/ # $"# # "# ! D0# #"D## D "# %## "; :0"#; A# "#/ #;# 0: 06 ""@6 ";"" < 9 D" #% "#"#;;?#3 ""# "/ ! @; # D : " ";"# "?? $ D" #" ;"6 #"$# < #" /
&'()*&+,,- .*&(,.
/ # $ ":#" "#0;: =>+-+"C#:#" ?#3 # ;""#" "# 0 "+"(?#3 # ;"/ 06$; 0: K@-,$##:#"" "@"9 0@(-;6 " =>+-+" C#:#" ?#3 0 ? -,,;+/
*/ % D" 6$ " Z D ## :#" " "@"9 %3 # " "D0?#3 / 9 ?# "6"."$ ;##%#"0" "#/
"# $ 0 <:##" D ! # D ##:#"D "# " ?# "6/""# " #D #?";/
(,/ "<# #$A $; ?"A; 0 " - " + 2#$ % #% "# :K "; 09 "#L"@"=>+-+/
((/ %D"6$#E ""# ! #?";/
(+/ ;#; Y2 (0-,,/. ;" < A@ # $ D" #;: 5 / HI 8/ #;" #$ !; !/ G"$ !; ;". # !/ T" #$ !; ": A #$ !; " !/ ! #$ !; !/ #T"@ 0# #" ";" / # #;$ < % < # 6% ";" #?"9< Y2-,,/.$;#Q0 :#< % ": #"#D"# ;"6" # D0#/ [[[[[
-$ #
7(8/"'!9
%: # " E * ;: +,,- P #" "# 1 2#3 4# ""##;;""# #; "6# "#+H E" +,,-U
&'()*&+,,- .(,&(,.
8/9
E U
; <A@# ;#; Y2(0-,,/.U
#";" Y2-,,/.<# 6%$<A@# U
" D$ #?#;; 9 " *I "% #" ? 0#@" "# E"""$ 3 3 # $%#"##" ;"" "?$ E# 6 # "?" "#$ % ": ?U ;;#" ##" ""D#"#$;# "? ;#B% # "@ # ##; "U"#" 3 #"9;";#" ": ?$ (,,, ()U 3 "6 #"# # $"%#D#;;;#B%$#"% 3 E#" <0%#"U
#;;"D 3 <! ""#$%# # $<!; ": A$ " #$ < !" T" ! #$ < !; :" !#"\";#T"@$<!; %" !#" "G"$< ! !#"$ %# # 6%$ ; " #"$ < #;;""# ##; "6# "#""D0<0??"? 0%"#; $?#3 B@/
J"@ 7 !/BA6$" $!;#%B Y"$!/ A"$!;#$ E@/
#; ":;"" "?7
@??"6.E" 7 " 7 /"#.J"@" 2/BA6
#"#?#; 3 #;;"D9 "/
6%$ @??"67
&'()*&+,,-