Jurisdictional Challenge Based on Condition Precedent Interpretation
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA party challenged the jurisdiction of a tribunal based on the argument that a specific condition precedent for the tribunal's authority had not been met, asserting that the situation giving rise to the dispute did not fall within the scope of a governing agreement. The court reasoned that the jurisdictional grant was sufficiently broad to encompass the present circumstances, interpreting the relevant clause as conferring authority based on the general nature of the disagreement rather than requiring strict adherence to a narrowly defined prerequisite, thus upholding the tribunal's jurisdiction.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Jurisdictional Challenge Based on Condition Precedent Interpretation: The court reasoned that the jurisdictional grant was sufficiently broad to encompass the present circumstances, interpreting the relevant clause as conferring authority based on the general nature of the disagreement rather than requiring strict adherence to a narrowly defined prerequisite, thus upholding the tribunal's jurisdiction.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAApplied to rule on the costs of the federal proceedings.
Applied to rule on the request for legal aid.
Testo completo
!"#$ %%%%%%%%%% !!"#"$%#
#
& ' () ) ' &
&'()*&
) !#" //////////$ #0""" //$ 10" //////////$ )'// //////////(2%$ 3 1" #00 //////////$ 45$//////////'--+6
'6 . #7 '--+$ !0 !//////////$ #0""" //$ 10" //////////$#" 2#" 5%#"# "# "089: ;6 %" % " 1"# !6 //////////< 0$ = 4>0 # #$ 4"6 0 0$3"0 " 0"# "5"5#1 #5">6 #" " " #5 2%" 6
+6 :" ? #" "#$: 3 0"2@#" A#7 '--+6
3>< # >1"# #"0#" " # $B #" 46C%" #>"3 " 4 > 1" #%" # "6 3C %" " " 4"6 3>< %" 8"> ? !6 //////////>3"@" 1"$"# " #>"&"@"" # "6 #" "3 " 0# 2 5"@ %" #>3" " 1D" >3"@"" >3"%#" 6
: @@ ## B'.#7 '--+6"1%" " # 0"#63"0 " 1?1E+02 #56 " 2%"@63>< # >!6 //////////%" @" @@# > " "#04" < 4""6
*6 '.0"'--*$!0!//////////"5?: 6 %" 00 # > ////////// " 1 " #" # 0"#5%"0 "=>3#"=>3?''16 3 " =0" #0" 16
!0!//////////3 " 0"@ 2: $ " #5$" "#3C 152%"" 3>< 6
.6 +="'--*$">## #"3 # #0""" 10" ////////// # "5 #00 ? 3#@@" % "" #9"&2F ;6
# # 0%" " 0 > !6 ////////// "@"5" "00 ? # 1"6 "&" %" >" 3"0 '--+ 0%" " 0 %" #00 # > 1"# 3 " G5 > >>0#"6#%"# &4G ##"&" " 6
(+,'('--. &+()*&
3"0 " 1E> # =# # 0# #"$#"5 " "3 " #06
0"@ " 4#C 13@@" ">0 # #" ),1+- ')1+-$0#0 #H#" " " ?3" " 0"#6
"5 " 0" ? 3 3" %" @00 #0 @"?" "#6
A6 3 3 ')="'--*6# >1" " 1?4"21E3%"#.02 $ ""## "# # ?3"0$ ## #0 32?"16 " 50 3 " ? "#" "#$ 0" #%" < # 0 % 1E6 1" %" " #" "# #0""# # 2>>$"%" "#@" "%" @" I@< J6
K6 ''="'--*$3 @@ #%%"" 6# > 1" " 1 =" >3" =#" #05" @ #" "6 "&" "8$ 3 " # @" %" " ""> > #" "# "# 3 " 46!6 //////////0"0> 8">>3" 1" #1"#4>"3 " "#5"@> $3"0 @5" 5"50%" #" 6" @"6 # $ " # %#" %"# % # 1"6 " %" 3#@" %#""56 " 0%"" "5# 00 %!06!66
0<0=#$3 3 1D##0"""//$10" //////////$ # "5 " " 6 &" @@"0 3%#" =0" % !6 ////////// 0 " # "06 " 8 > 1" 4#C" 4# #>3" " ? 3 1$ 0" " >> 0 " "# 3 " 0 0"#6
3>< 0 ? !6 ////////// 0" ? " "# 3 1$ "0 @4 > #" # " # ? 3#04 #H 1" #" < ">0 #4#0E 6
,6 "# @" " $ 3 $ ) =" '--*$ ? !6 ////////// %2 % "0 6 " ). 04 '--* " " "0 " # " "# 3 # )- 0' ),- 0 1 $ > %" < "3"1%#1 35036 " # ? !6 ////////// > 1" %" #%#" 34 1> =# "4 # #"10""006 @"$5" "# " 0 "2" "" " 1"% 8"%6
(+,'('--. &*()*&
L6 !0!//////////3 ?3 #"A#7 '--*6
: @ ? # #" + =" '--+ = > 3%" M#%$#@"0" >3# " >3"0 " 1E #"% 0"#5%"4"$#>#" " #%" ? ##0""61"4#C" 0 6#>"&" " G1 ="$"4#C" 51>" #6 "#%" 1 >#" "3" %"6 "&"@" 3>#1" > 45 3>" >3? " ). 0#"6 !6 ////////// %" @@"B #="$# >3"031" 6 @"$ 0>#4"" "%"#" "%#"0 % #" #C#%" < #56
"0 !6 ////////// " ">" !0 6 !6 3 #" >303" "?=#?3# "&?6
)-6 A 04'--*$!0!//////////#@"0?3 0 ##" 6
))6 , 04'--*$3 M 1#">#4 : 6:" ?#%" $ " #"8 %" # > " "# " "15$ 1" " 1 ? # 1E "3%" "4""#6
)'6 '.$ ', 'L 04 '--*$ 3 3 6 # 0"2%"" $1"3 " ="6# 54" ### "#3#6
##5$ >#$1"3 " "%""4""46
0"$"3%" 156#5"5 " # ="6
)+6 L # #4 '--*$ 3 " 1#"> % !0!//////////6 &" 8# > " 8 0" %"#$ 1" " ?3" " 0$>3"3 " 1?38 " @#"G1=".?)-0" 63#3 " 0"6# $!06!6#@"0# "# "6
)*6 '-# #4'--*$!0!//////////3 $1" " #% 1=#$#" % #"20"#6 4#C" @#"6 3#3 " # " 6
)'#%04'--*$!0!//////////3 ##@"0 >" "#3%" 156 #">5&02 " @#"1"%4G ##@" "16
(+,'('--. &.()*&
).6 )K #%04 '--*$ 3 3 1D !6 ////////// % >" "$@")+ 026
3 # > 1" " 1 % 0"# ? 1E 3%"# ' 02 $ 0" #" > #" # 1 0" % "16 B " @ " #" !6 //////////3%" "). 04'--*>""%" "0 "## "3#6
!6 ////////// 8"> > ////////// " 1 $ # "$"" 10"?#4!0!////////// >" #%" "> # #"6 #"#$ //////////%" @5=>310"////////// %" 1 5%0 %#" 6
1" " #08@#"=#1##" #" %"$ #" %@ 6# >02G5@" 1"6
3 ? !6 ////////// >3" %" 5 1" "" 1$ 305 "00" 0 #$ @ >#" 3"0" > 3 3""#6
)A6 'A#%04'--*$: " 1#">%3 6 " "#3%" 15 : $>"3 " =#0<0$%" # %" " 6
)K6 ) 04 '--*$ !0 !////////// #@"0 ? 3 > 0%" " 0 "@"5 ? //////////$ >" %" # 00 $" 63"0 " 11#"0 " 2 B =>3? #"6 "&"" #" 0#"@#"$#" ## #" "6
),6 ) 04 '--*$ 3 @" # > % "@ ////////// >" ? @#"2 #6 :# #4% "# @" #4 @#"2 #"5 # K 04 '--*$ 1" " " "%$ %" " # $ 3 "" ? 3#13#6 %" #0# 0 0@"$3"1"4" "# "@@" ?3 ?#%%"#0 6 5"" @# 0 80#%0 94;4>$>""" #>3%" 4 6 45 " # B #"6
)L6 , 04 '--*$ 3 " % !6 !0 //////////6 #8 ////////// " " >> 0#" @ " "%0 1D 02 1D 26 !0 //////////3#" //////////#>#0" " 4 6
(+,'('--. &A()*&
!0 ////////// #@"0 > 0# "% "# # 0" 3%#" 1" " #= "> " ## $# 00 % 1#""6 !6 ////////// %" " "#6 %" " %" 4 >" 30<1" %" 0 > # " %8?3"%" 6
!6 //////////35"?#4% "#6# #1 >"" " @" "">8>" " ?026# 01 @@" 0%" %#""56 #0" #6 %1$"3 1"?##6
'-6 #" # $ 0" M 3 )+ 04 '--*$ !6 ////////// #"" " "# //////////$ # @" G5 )- 2@@ 3"06 #"#$"355 @#00 #1#? 11"?1E$? "1# ?"% # #"5>3 "#" 6
')6 ""#'-=%"'--.$3 ##> @"" "@ ////////// " " ? !6 ////////// " "08 # " 0"6" 0 " 8 #"##4 #6
''6 !6 ////////// "" "4 0"" "@ 3 # # ""#" $ ),@%"'--.6
40 $"#"" " "#3@@ "@6
:@#$"# #1>"" " @" 63%" 4" > ////////// " @" 3#4= 0%" " 0 $ " 3 5"5 = "@" 0 " 3 6 3%" 0# > 3"0 " 5< @# "# ##$ " #@@ 3 "0 "# "#" > # 1C5"2 3" 6 # 0# " > //////////4@""" 3@@ "#4##0E #1 "%" "3##" " "#3"0? #0E 6
3"##$!6 //////////#" "#)- =%" '--. 4" % "" !#" N " 6 #0 0 "# ">80@@ '--+#%" "# " ?" "" >3 " 0 '--*6 % "" " 3%" =0" # #420#0# 0 8 //////////6
!6 ////////// 50 % 8 4 3 "# 3 # " #5 1D""0#"="'--+6! //////////C " #00 # 2 5 "$ # 00 % "086 3 #%" 05"0 %%#""5$"C3%" # @#0#%# "# %#""6
(+,'('--. &K()*&
:" 8 #" 3%$ !6 ////////// %" # " # )-0'?3#04$0"1"%#" C 6%" #%"&0<0 3#" ">""#%" $?%#"% 0"#$#" #"6 !6 ////////// 3%" =0" 0 " # 1"6 #>3" " 4 $ " 3 1" ? 1E 3%"# A0 4 30<1 @56 0$ # 5 "#""5?3# !6 ////////// " @$"3#" 1"#004#2@0"6
'+6 3 3 ##? " "#3@@ "@ $""#K 0 '--.$ " "4 0"" "@ = >< C "%6 " ""# #@"0 "4@< )=" '--. 9' 6),K('--.;6
'*6 # @# ') 0 '--.$ 3 3 ## #6 5 "# !6 ////////// " " ? 3C6 #0# 0 ////////// >3" %" #4% 3 " % " 0 >3 %" 4"6 !6 ////////// %" 3" ##"# $0" "#)+04'--*$>3" %" 0 5" ? 35 # 1" " 355" ? 0" ? # #0# 0 6 # 0# " > 4# " "# 3%" ># 6
'.6 ' 'L =" '--.$ "4 0"" "@ 0#" "6
6 !6 O//////////$ # " !6 ////////// " @" 0#" 0"'--+$#@"0 < 3 3 "#.@%"'--. 9"2).# ;6 3%" =0"%!6 //////////0 " # 1"$ 804 6%" # >!6 //////////#" " "# ? # 1" #00 80 I"J$ I%"J$ 6 %" 50 0>>!6 //////////%" 4#1 #B 6 #>3"0 " "%$"C%" #="61"4#C" 0"@ &? >3" 3"0" C 6 !6 ////////// %" %"5 3 # ""#" $0"" C %" @"0 #$ > //////////@" "# # " #"6
46 !0://////////$%#""!6 //////////$ 6 %" "5A@%"'--. "#>!6 //////////"%" #0" %# > " 3#9"2)A# ;6 %" 2 #>1"#" #" $3%" =0"" # 0 % "06 %" 0<0 % > "&" # "" #=#"2!6 //////////>" " 00 16
6 !0////////// #@"0 "# ? 3 ,04'--*6#$%" # >#0"%"
(+,'('--. &,()*&
4## %1"5$ ""% //////////$ 3%" =0" 0> > # 0" " 5"@6 " > 3 " "#"@@" >3"# " #>#0" %" "?5 "#% //////////6
6 !6////////// 6 " "##@"# %!6 ////////// "3%" =0"# >"" %"# 6 #"" //////////#3%#"%1D!6 ////////// %> "3 " #063%" # >3"0" " "@# 4"> !6 ////////// " %"# % "6 %" % ////////// %"5 " @#"6
6 !0P////////// 6
" " : >< " # 0 " $ #@"0 # >3 %" 4" A '. #7 '--+$ "" > , 04'--*6
">1" " ?: $##0# 0 %" # 0 156 3 " $0"06 " #$>"3 " #>3 " "%6 """ 8#0 1"6 %" "?01"$>3%" @"?#"%6
@6 !0 !//////////$ %#"" !6 ////////// 6 #@"0 %#" : ? 8 " "5 " #" ? 3" "#3 $#" %3 #$#" 6 %" 50 >> " 1#">%3 6 #@"0 "@@ 059"2)$'$*$K$,$))?)+ ;6
3'--+$%" # ?"">1"# " 0 " 6 %" %!6 //////////3"0 " #04 " #6 %" 50 # >1" " 1 # 0 # =#6 $ %" C 3" %"2!6 //////////$0"3%" ##> "= 3# 86 %" 50 # > !6 ////////// " # 1" % 4G #$ %#" ? #"# % >> 1# 04 ??<16 8 ##Q'--+$# "#%" " 50"0 1" %" # % > !6 ////////// #0"0" 0 1" # 0 0"#6 " "# 3%" 15 '--*6 !6 ////////// " %" #"'="'--*# #%50 $0"013%" 4# "%#" # >3##" 1" " ? 3 "6 #>3 %" 0 ? !6 ////////// #>#"1" " #=# 1$"&""%" #>345 3>" >3? ").0#"60"25$%" # >
(+,'('--. &L()*&
1" " 3"#0 >3" 4#C" 0"2 6 @" $%" 50"?8"$0"?3"%&" 3"0 " 16
%" 8@< >"#" #" !6 ////////// $ 05 %5 "#$ #%" %#" >" 3C " $ # 00 % 3 0"#"6
56 !0 //////////$ 0" 3 %#"" !6 //////////$ " > ""@#"0#"6 #@"0< 3 3#" ?: '.0"'--*9"2+ ; %#""5 # "% +="'--*9"2* ;6 31"%'--+&'--*$3%" " >1" " # 0 1?# "$4"$"1$ 503# 00"# # 06 %" : " 0'--*>""%" " < =?# 6 04'--*$ " # 0 " "#0 " " 1" 3 " ?3 6
%" # ?"">1" " @$#" % 4G #$ #" % # # >3" %" # "6 %" 50 %>"1 " # 0"2>1"#%" C 6 %" " "0#00#@@&## 14" 0"#6 " "%>0"$=#%"" @ !6 //////////$8&"=# =" >1"#" 16 $ %" # >@ =#" ""#>1" " 1 4#C" 6
16 !0R//////////3#1 ##0 : 3 # 8 >3 0 ? @> > " //////////6
%" # > 1" #% #" !6 ////////// " #=# 1"#"$503 6 %" """5 # "%+="'--*9* ;6 3%" =0"%#" "1"$05 "%>3%" @" 6 #>3 3#" 1 > " 3C " " @#"0"$ 0<0@#""@#"=#$%#"" 6
"6 !0 S//////////$ %#"" " !6 //////////$ 6 #@"0%#""5 # "%+="'--* < 3#% ## 9"2* ;6
%" # > " >3 " "%$ ////////// " #=# 1 % 0"#6 3C 3%" 50 3$ " "16 1" 4#C" #00 $ >" 5" ">
(+,'('--. &)-()*&
#@"# 1 6 %" # > @ !6 //////////$ >" 00 %"%" 0"#$ =#" % 1"6 " 0'--*$%" ""#%!6 ////////// = //////////6!6 //////////%" %#>@" >3" " 1" %45 $>3"%" #"@"6!6 //////////%" @" @@# #4#1 #B $0"1"@"" #%8 31" #%"1D# 00 6
3 #?3" "# 0#"T//////////6
'A6 3" "# #$ "4?5?=56
&
)6 = 0 " % ="" "# #0 $ # %49 6.A #"U#5" "#="""''#%04)L*)& & '-.V 6A+6)" 6#" #0"" "%)' 04)L,.& & .)-;6
'6 "08#"% < " 0"2>" "0"8#0 4#" # # >" 3# 3"08 #" $ > "# 0 $ %" ? 4"&< 9 6 ' 6 ) ' #" @# "#"08L0)LK,WX W:*..;6
+6 " >" " "0 # 0 5 #" #" #"5#%40 $3"@ $"@#"5E 9 6+6)X ;6 # 00 " " 0 " "08$5"55%0 # 0" "0 9 6''6)X ;6"4 0#%0 "? 3"0#" < %0"24#" "" # "#$08##0056
*6 3 #" #" " %" "00" 0 #>3" 4" > "08# 5%0 5"5# @M##02 0 #V > % "%0 #5#" #"$@" 9 6 '. 6 ) X ;6 " " 0#"0 # # " 0" "# #003"088#>"# "#%#"@" ?""#5%0 "#" "# X "">38#>"$#0"0 $@"4 3" $ 3##"0 # # 3 "#$ # "4 " "06
3 #" " %" "00" 0 #>3" 4">"08# 5%0 5"5 # @M# #02 0 #6 > % "%0 #5 #" #"$ @" 9 6'. ;6
(+,'('--. &))()*&
.6 2%$ 3 15 38 "# 5" "# # "#"089 6+16)250 3" "##"@ # "# "08 )* =" )L,' W X W ! + .-6-';6 #@@" # B 50 "# #" # 8 "08 #0 ">63>5" "#@# "#"08 #0 "> 9 6')X ;6
A6 32$#"# " #04" #=#?"# 0<0 C #0# 0 $ ? %#" #" "# "# //////////@" 0 " ?3# 3"06
"5 # #@"0 # "# % "4 6
#" > " # >"" "# =>3? # # @5: $ ////////// " >"0 1?" # $ %#" ? 1E$ 4"$ @#" $ # 0 # "#6 2 3 " % "# 3 $ # "1$#>&"$# 0#"$3 " @#0 "4 3"06 >>),0#"$# 3 0# " #$ # >3" #2 #" +U---0' %"#$ > 0 1"#%" < ""4 $ #>B " 4E0"#" >3"0@5" 6
: 0$ ////////// 4#C" @@"00 @# #5 0#> "%#""30% =>3?#"6
# # %" 40 #" "# "#>" " = "@"#"@" >31"453> % ). 0#"6 > "# 4"&@# @@"0 "# #@@ ""$ # $2).# #4'--*$# " # 7 3 "##"0$>3"300 @" $ " "# "5#0 0<0=>3)04'--*6
8 %"# & # 4G #$ 45 $ " &"# # #"#0#"6# # %#"#?4G ##?45 $0<03"@3%#" 0"2 "00#6 5$ "4 0"" "@ "$ #00 0" $ # "# @" @#"2 #$ #> //////////" 0"04'--*$"% #00 1" " "%$ #0# 0 0@" 5" @# 0 8 0#%0 # 00 4$>""" #>3%" 4 6
$ #" 0#" "4 "0 >#" "# "#1" ////////// " "@" 3# =0"%
(+,'('--. &)'()*&
# 0 " #"06:35" 0#"O//////////3 $ :////////// 3 $ "# C#51" % 23"0"0"" ">$" ?>30 0<0 #6 "2 #00 #@"0 "4 > 8 " %" #0" !6 ////////// >3 3%" "5$ 3# % # # 6 0" #00$ " # " # $ 0 >" 0 0 # # #4= "%" 6:35" !6//////////$" %#"% //////////%"5 "@#"$ #0 # >3" @"" # " ? %#6 3 %"00 "# >3"#0 #" "# "#3"0$ "#0# 0 #0E ?35 //////////6
K6 #" 4" "@M# 2"># 3 #0 "=# "#"%3 >" " %? "2"6 ="'--*$3 0# # " # %#C > >< " " $"""0 "" ). 04 '--* # 0" ? " "#6 $ 0 > # 04 %#" " 4#1 # B #" $>"30<1" 1"# 3#%8#316
,6 X?3"" " % "#$3 " @#? 01 """%6 @ > #%"#" # > # # ?0 > "####0# 0 $ # 00 # 0 ?0<0#"8"$%#" 0>0 "23 "#"6 $ 0##$ @" 5 "# @ 8 #1 >" " # $ # " "5"20 ## "6
L6 38" #0 $ 3 #" $ #00 # #" 0"" "%$ "" ## "#" 6 " #0# " "#0 #" F 34#$ 0#C 1#"" #" < # ? "4 @"86$ "0#C $##" 1#""" >"# 3 " 0#"5%8" < "%V@"$3##" 0 4 @@ 0 1#"" " "# 30"" % #0 #" %3" < 4"9 X)'+))'#"6* 6)') < " V ('A('--.),=%"'--.V (K-*('--')* #%04'---;6
:" ?3" "#?>"#$ "40"" "@>" #%" "#># " //////////0"2"#" " #"5" 3 "# 3 "# "6 3" > ""# > E # 0 = "@" # "" >3 5""## "#" 6 " # ? " < 4" # 6 #" < #@"06 # "0 ? 3 # "4 ? #E $ " 3C " 3%"5
(+,'('--. &)+()*&
32 " "# //////////?##" "$0#C # B 30 >"" #"$# C 00 0# >3" @"" @" " "% >" " " # 9 (.)-('--' + 04'--' @" ;6
)-6 ?3" " "#@" # ""0# " 0"$ #@"0 # ""$ 0" " ? . 6 "4 @@ =5 ? " " >3 " " "# 3 " 0" " 8"% 9 ()-+('--. ) 0 '--. @" ;6
))6 #>$#0" 2 "0 6
3" " "5$ 0#0 YX K.-6& 0" ? 15 # 9 6,K ;$>"#3"0" #$% >3"#048> "#""#0" "46
ZZZZZ
*' & +
,-.!$/0
%4 # " = ') @%" '--. !#" ////////// # ""#U#@@"% "" #')=%"'--.V
-.!"0
30 "0 V
" 3" " "# ""0?.V
#@"0""# >#V
0 ?15# 0#0 YXK.-6&V
" >3"3 #3"0" V
" >$ #@#00 8 " LK "% #" @ U#5" "# ="""$ < < # $%#"##" 0"" "@$ =#2# "@" "#$% "4@V00#"# #" ""> #"#$ 0# "@ 0#C % # "5 # # # 0 "V " #" < #" 80" 0#"
(+,'('--. &)*()*&
"4 @$ )--- )*V < "2 #"# # $"%#>#000#C%$#"% < =#" ?U%#"V
#00"> < ? ! ! "#"$ %# # $ ? U#@@" % "" #, ? 3#@@" % "" @ "" >3 !"" 2 4" #@ "#6
:"5 F !0#%C$" $!6C12$!0Y"$!6 1"$=5$ !6#$=5 6
#0 "40"" "@F
5@@"2&=" =6F %"&" F !6 ##" 6#%C
#"#@#0 < #00">8 "6
2%$ 5@@"2F
(+,'('--.